In a town that is all pizza this one is too expensive but enjoyed a meatball pizza, it was good…read more Services and presentation was not so good.

Had the German pizza and I loved it. First time I've ever had sauerkraut on pizza but it was great!…read moreAlso had the super deluxe pizza and wow was it loaded. Crust was delicious and crispy. Also had 2 salads and lettuce was shredded and crispy. The restaurant doesn't look like much from the outside, but the inside is welcoming and clean. I was impressed that they brought my order out to my rv when it was ready, so it was nice and hot and I didn't have to guess when it was done. Would definitely eat here again.

Love everything about this place, great food, great service and plenty of room for the entire…read morefamily with a play area for the kids. Clean with large tables. Stay awesome!

Literally traveled to Valley City just to go here, and yeah the pizza is worth the hype! I…read morerecommend the Gourmet style pizza, they do not skimp on the toppings at all!

Pizza was ok, just wanted to try them out and they where one of a handful of place still open for…read moredelivery.

Ate there once. All of their pizza from their buffet should've been thrown in the garbage was dried…read moreout and awful.

Delicious! Four of us descended on Sunday afternoon. Great service right off the bat on this lazy…read moreday. Ordered the pizza, a buffalo chicken wrap, Caesar salad with grilled chicken and the spicy hot Italian sub with fries. Everything was delicious! Grilled chicken was plentiful and perfectly seasoned on the salad. The wrap was stuffed with well seasoned chicken breast meat. The pizza is a super thin crust that was a great bite. The Italian sandwich was a wonderful surprise with toasted meats and the delicious dressing, and hot, crispy fries. Outstanding experience and meal and we would come again if we weren't just passing through!

We stopped in for dinner on our one night in town. Nice downtown location and we found street…read moreparking easily. We got a choose your own pepperoni and black olive hand tossed pizza. The pizza came out nice and hot. Lots of ingredients and cheese. Thought it was good. My wine tasted like the bottle had been opened for awhile. Service was excellent, especially since it looked like one person taking care of all the tables. Good stop.

I stopped here to fuel up when traveling between North Dakota and Minnesota…read more The store is on the smaller side and not very welcoming. I couldn't bring myself to go inside, but the pumps are always open & the prices are fair. Easy to access for a regular vehicle, I'd skip it if you're hauling a trailer, camper or driving an rv. This location doesn't have individual hoses for each type of fuel, which I prefer. Tho they did offer winter grade diesel, nice.

I am writing to let people know to never work at Caseys in Valley City ND. I was told that they…read morewere able to fire me without cause. I have 2 kids to support and I was basically thrown out for personal reasons. I had worked 3 days when I was told that I wasn't doing a good enough job and that you only get 40 hours of training. I had received 16 out of 40 when I got fired. The individaul training left me to stand there doing nothing for over 1/4 of my shift. He spent the time talking to the manager instead. My self esteem was ripped apart by this place. please don't make the same mistake that I did. I intend to continue talking about this everywhere I can including the news and the internet. Thank you for listening to my experience.

great pizza but way to much money $8.79 the price has gone up a lot in the past 3 or 4 years like…read moreover 2 bucks they would sell so many more if the price was more reasonable they are crazy.

Being from Chicago, I have rather high standards for pizza. I went in here with absolutely no…read moreexpectations. I was going to take things for what they were worth. The decor in this place was not as cheesy as I expected. It had a western look to it but not to the point of being ridiculous. We went here on a Friday night and they an AYCE pizza buffet going on. SCORE!!!!!!! I knew right away that I was going to get more than my money's worth!. The cool thing about this buffet, was that if you wanted something special, just let them know and they will put any pizza out on the buffet that you would like! The staff here did a good job of keeping our dirty plates cleared and the six of us rapidly piled up dirty plates! As far as the pizza is concerned, I was pleasantly surprised. I think I tried every pizza that they put out and all were very good. My favorites were the taco pizza and the BBQ bacon cheeseburger pizza. The crust was a good thickness and the toppings were applied liberally. They next time we are out here, I know that this is a solid place to grab some pretty good pizza.

Garrett, a worker there, is the most kind and helpful employee. I truly felt like I was with family…read morewhile I was there, also, the pizza is amazing!! Keep up the good work!

Hundreds of Hops 2026 Amazing Brewery Race Stop 2, ND 2 of 2... that's a state win for 2026!…read more Roughly 7pm arrival as a party of 2 on a Thur - Thur special is a pizza & 2 beers for $20, plus the Hop Passport BOGO = 2 more beers for $7... not too shabby, if i must say so myself. 4 blank spots & 2 seltzers -plus- Forgotten West Coast IPA / Evolution Juicy IPA / Vaxine Raspberry Sour / Adelaide Pale Ale / Onset Smoked Stout / Caffeine Coffee Infused Brown / NuHr1 Klosch on tap Johnny B's pizza we opted for was the Bacon Cheeseburger Slider. It was served with ranch, parmesan, mule sauce hot sauce & pepper flakes. Vaxine 3.5, Evolution 4, Onset 4.75 (x2... oops) for beer tonight. Onset being our favorite, clearly. The company this evening was good. There was lots of casual comfortable conversations strangers about beer, bikes, food, art &... beer... That's a wrap for ND!

3.5hrs from us, this one is quite the jaunt. The primary focus is beer & there's a nice variety of…read moreoptions to fit everyone, they even offer a creative seltzer selection (made with syrups on site) and having n/a options are a great alternative. Food consists of pre-made pizza from Jamestown, ND (Johnny b) and is cooked on site for $15 each or $20 on Thursdays with 2 pints included. It's a small place with big flavors, located across from veterans park. I suggest grabbing a spot at the bar and chatting it up with the owners/brewers. These guys, like the sign says, are awesome! (With a real knack for flavors & brewing)

Was in the area and heard from locals that Pizza Shop was good so family decided to try the large…read moreTaco Deluxe take and bake. The pizza was ok. Came with instructions on how to bake. Didnt come with any sour cream nor olives despite the description. However, it came with tomatos and lettuce. Crust was thin and the cheese was thin. The sauce and cheese fell off easily, adding the melting effect of pizza. Overall, it is ok. Not the worst or greatest pizza I had but good enough to fulfill your pizza craving.

The food was amazing!!! Everything is homemade and home cooked. The chicken is never frozen. The…read morewaitress Marcy has the most friendly attitude. I love the rustic look. The corrugated tin on the ceiling gives a perfect ambiance. The quaint town of Mayville ND has so much history. The place to be for all the local or anyone passing throug!

Good dinner, Good service, good food, clean! Would recommend a visit. Polite servive.read more

For a whopping 19$ The food was absolutely disgusting. The pizza available on the buffet was dismal…read moreand old the food available was either doughy and not cooked enough, overcooked and rock hard or over loaded with toppings.