We came to Zelma's looking for multiple furniture pieces. The selection was amazing and the help…read morewe were given was above and beyond what we hoped for. We found a dining room table, chairs, a sideboard and a table for our entry way. The quality was exceptional, the service and prices were equally as good. Love this place and will be back again and again!

Amazing actual ANTIQUES in this store. No yard sale stuff! You need to furnish or decorate, this is…read morethe place. Beautiful paintings rugs glasswares clocks books .......i got some beautiful Tiffany pieces. Staff fabulous!

Call before going. It's a Friday & hours listed say open 10-9. Nope. They close at 6. Not hard to…read moreupdate hours online!

Nice antique store. Good selection of sterling items, coins, glass, primitives and toys. Limited…read moreselection of furniture. Great staff and good hours. I had one or two nice finds here. Def. check it out when you are in Hanover!

Great food, great service and great atmosphere! The fireplace is very nice and warm. Makes a warm…read morefeeling all around.

This little rustic resale store is really very nice. It' s clean and the people that run are…read morefriendly. Plus their stuff is reasonably priced. If you're that way, it's absolutely worth a stop in. Shirley

I love the variety at this antique mall!! There's something for everyone, and 80% of the dealers…read morehad posted sales. The folks working there were helpful and friendly, and I came home with come great treasures for very reasonable prices. Definitely worth driving off the beaten path vs. visiting the more centrally located shops in Carlisle!!!

This was a pretty cool find while driving down the turnpike. It only took 8 to 10 minutes upon…read moreexiting and paying the toll to make our way to their location, so that's a bonus for those looking for quick stops along the way to a final destination. I think Mall is a bit of a push, but nonetheless, the number of booths and inventory they've fit in both the upstairs and downstairs sections was impressive. There's a lot of glassware and ceramic ware if you compare the overall breakdown of content. There were a couple vendors on site while we shopped who stopped by to say hello while we checked out their booths. Overall a pretty nice atmosphere to take one's time and find some good items. Pricing wise it is all over the place, the higher end (higher quality or rarity) items are priced accordingly. While there is a decent amount of expensive items there is also a good selection of affordable finds. I guess it all depends on the buyer's target items. Will definitely keep it in mind for our next jaunt down the Turnpike!

Always worth a stop. Wander through a large inventory of furniture, folk art, and appropriate…read moreaccessories. Chances of finding a treasure are very good!

This place is so comforting and welcoming! The staff is always super friendly, and the pricing…read morekeeps me coming back weekly. They have a wide variety of clothing and accessories, but I only wish they had more home decor!

Loved this thrift store! There are so much to choose from. We were able to get everything we needed…read morefor skiing. Too bad the place closed down on Jan 11.

The Treasure Trove Toy Store is located in the Shoppes at Newberrytown, a borderline struggling…read moreflea market. Parking is not an issue, just grab a spot. The store is located in the middle building, behind the restaurant. Use the doors on the side of the building for the easiest access. Treasure Trove is huge and spread out, taking up a large portion of the building. Selection includes retro toys of all varieties, both new and loose, and a huge Pop Vinyl selection. Everything is very well-organized including separate rooms for specific items. Pop Vinyl's were well priced and included both common and rare ones. Huge stock of wrestling toys of all varieties, including a lot of older figures. Has a small clearance section with various items including a lot of physical media. One of the things that also stood out was the condition of items, most of the toy boxes were in good condition. Treasure Trove's biggest weakness is it being a little out of the way, and that the Shoppes at Newberrytown is not the most known place in the world. Treasure Trove really is the core of the Shoppes at Newberrytown and absolutely worth a stop.

Next to a dirt track a few hills and turns off of Interstate 83 in Neberrytown, I stumbled upon…read moreTreasure Trove by accident. It takes up most of one of the barracks representing The Shoppes at Newberrytown, a classic dirt mall that is home to a few of our area's best magick brokers and resellers of unusual ancient relics. Surprising, I know. Lady Matilda and I were meeting an antiquities dealer to procure the Emerald of Queen Zinth supposedly the gem that resurrected Lord Ghuul the Ineffable in 1233. The deal fell through because when we exposed the item to a low-level EPK resonator, it did not register the proper psychic frequency. Turns out the gem was just tinted glass from an Art Deco lighting fixture. Anyway, as Lady Matilda and I were figuring out what to do over pancakes at the nearby diner on site, I spotted a massive wall of Funko Pops through the door leading into the next section of the barracks. Pops as far as I could see; pops sufficient to build a small house. I had to investigate. While the major focus of the inventory is on professional wrestling figures and related products, Treasure Trove has a massive collection of loose figures from almost every franchise I could imagine. I was able to fill in the gaps in most of my old collections. I experienced an OCD moment as I had to dig through piles of rare items, discovering something new everywhere I looked. Each loose item was bagged and clearly priced. Boxed and packaged items are in pretty good shape and displayed safely. I didn't see much of the price gouging that is common in most used/collector toy stores. In fact, what I dropped on that first visit was pretty reasonable when I compared it to eBay and similar online resources. If you're looking for spare parts for broken toys, you'll have to dig, but there is a section of the store dedicated to them. The store also has old magazines and some comics, too. Things are organized in a general sense, but there are a lot of displays to investigate. If you go, be prepared to take some time on that first visit. The Funko Pop Wall is, indeed, massive. But the wide selection of products kept me searching the nooks and crannies of the store for an hour - which was only as long as Lady Matilda would allow me before getting ornery about it. She is not a fan of portable toilets, which is all "The Shoppes" seems to offer. Plus, she was fighting the urge to exact revenge on the dealer who had just tried to con us into buying a fake relic. (Be advised, that vendor no longer operates at that location...or in this dimension...any longer.) Since that first visit, I have returned many times, lured by a steady rotation of new items and great sales offers. The owner was also quite friendly and helpful. We chatted briefly as classic pro wrestling matches played on the overhead television.

This place is not that great. I have found that in Carlisle, there are a lot of reasonably priced…read moreCRAZY cool antique places. This is not one of those places... The old guys in there are not very welcoming either. Stick to Serendipity!!

We stopped yesterday and really enjoyed the store. We were specifically looking for stained glass…read moreand landed 2 pieces that worked perfectly that worked for the living room. Both ladies were very helpful.