The best beer and whiskey selection in Wallingford. Owned by the same individual who owns a bunch of bigger stores throughout the state, Ye Old benefits from this ownership as it gets access to the product selection of a store many times its size. Think of Ye Old as a boutique booze shop. Small in size but impressive in selection, especially for whiskey and craft beer. Honestly, Ye Old has one of the better craft beer selections in the state, meticulously curated by the manager Nathan, who's an enormous craft beer fan himself. And the whiskey selection is world class, thanks to the owner being one the best whiskey retailers in the state through his many stores. This is a hidden gem in Wallingford with a loyal following among discerning drinkers in the area. Another term for it is "honey hole." read more

I found out that Ye Old is owned by the same person as a few other well know package stores in the area. I visit the one by my house pretty frequently because it is large and has a huge selection. The problem with the large store is they are well known and sell out of the good stuff quickly. I was passed along the secret of Ye Old in West Haven that they tend to keep items I am looking for in stock. Ye Old does not get the same clientele that I have to compete with at the larger store. I can usually find exactly what I am looking for, and in decent quantity. When I go in, I usually ask for Brandon as well. He is very knowledgeable and tends to have the same taste as myself and can assist me with new and interesting items. Whenever I am in the area I try to stop in, even if I don't need anything, just to stock up on the basics. Don't let the size fool you, this shop is a goldmine for your needs. read more

In West Haven, I think that Ye Old is the best liquor store. I will even drive across town to go there even though there are probably three liquor stores closer to my house. It's a relatively small shop, but looks can be deceiving because their selection is quite good related to their size. They have all the basics and then some. Did you know that they will special order items for you? Obviously speak to someone at the store for specifics, but I have gotten a case of Pipeline Porter from Kona Brewing Company in Hawaii delivered just for me to Ye Old. This is a huge plus for someone like myself who lived out west for some time and learned to appreciate many of the craft micro brews of that region which are usually unavailable in this area. Another plus about Ye Old is the staff. A few of the guys there really know their stuff when it comes to wine, especially the one who usually wears a cap and glasses (sorry, never caught his name or I'd give personal kudos!). They have an unassuming, unpretentious attitude when talking with customers which makes you feel comfortable asking for assistance. Also they don't mind if you take your time browsing and they don't bother you if you don't ask for help which is nice when you just want to grab something quickly. Prices are average to less than average for the same brands at other shops. The parking lot is kind of bad: A high curb and not much room for maneuvering. Someone backed into my car as I was pulling into the lot one time because he had his music blaring and couldn't hear me leaning on my horn. Needless to say, I usually try to remember to approach Ye Old in a flanking manner by driving down Third Ave and parking adjacent to the building in the street, which seems safer. I give Ye Old 4 rather than 5 stars mainly because of the parking situation. Also, no offense and obviously it is kind of a gritty neighborhood package store, but some of the clientele is a bit sketchy or unkempt looking. I only say this with the intention of notifying someone who may not have been there so they know what to expect, not to judge the people who shop there, because obviously I'm one of them and it's in my neighborhood. I'm not even suggesting that anyone should trek from towns away to visit Ye Old. It's not going to blow your mind (unless there's no other place that will order your Deschutes Black Butte Porter from Bend, Oregon and you really need your fix). But for me it's the go to place in West Haven to procure my adult beverages. read more

Great place and nice people. If I ask for an alcohol that I do not see, they will actually order it for me! I love this place! I have also gotten some drink recipes from them and the drinks were amaze-balls!!! read more

Great prices anywhere around! Nice neighborhood staple that has loyal customers all around. Only reason for 4 stars is that the selection isn't as wide spread as it could be and I was expecting more after the expansion. Also the parking lot has a terrible hump that does not fair well for the low rider cars. Aside from that surely a home like environment and one that keeps you coming back. read more

The have everything you will ever need. Good small liquor store decent prices. I tell everyone that's close to me to go check them out.

Stay Away! The parking is tough, Prices are way too high for being in a bad neighborhood. I felt like I was going to get robbed while getting into my car. People hanging out near the door smoking cigarettes. When you walk in don't expect to be impressed. They will order anything you want, but trust me you'll pay the price. Run of the mill Australian chardonnay was $20.00, you'd buy it elswhere for 12.00 Guy who helped me I think was the owner Jerry, real rude, snippy put the bag on top of my purchase, didn't even bag it! High prices, bad parking, rude staff! read more

I love this place easy in and out. They have the best selections of the items you will need. I can go in an be out in no time with all the essentials for a good party and still save money. I drive 15 min to get to it cause they have the best prices and they also have good sales. Keep it up! read more