Best Jamaican food in Rochester, hands down (and this is coming from a guy who has been to all of…read morethem). Relatively new, and I don't think the word is out there about this place, as small restaurants rely mostly on word of mouth. Wow, is this place good.
The breakfast menu (yes, they are open for breakfast!) consists of Jamaican staples: Callaloo, Ackee and Saltfish, Liver and Kidneys, and multiple kinds of porridge (varieties rotate daily). I haven't made it there to sample the breakfast menu yet, so this review reflects my many lunch experiences there.
The menu consists of Ox-Tails, Curry Goat, Pepper Steak, Stewed Chicken, stewed kingfish, steamed fish, and of course Jerk Chicken. All are based on availability, but the fish dishes seem to be the only ones that are sometimes not available, though sometimes he runs out of things later in the evening, which is completely understandable for a small Establishment such as this. That said, he's never been out of anything I have ever ordered. There are also daily specials Cowfoot (Wednesdays), Tripe & Beans (Thursday), Stewed Peas (Friday).
The Ox Tails are ridiculous good. The best I've ever had, bar none. The gravy is delicious and savory, so much so that you just want to lick the container clean when you are done. Nicely spiced, but not overdone. The Ox Tails are so good, he knows what I'm going to order before I even say a word. The Jerk Chicken is amazing here as well. The chicken is tender and smokey, with just the right amount of kick in the jerk sauce. If you want more heat, there are an array of hot sauces (Jamaican and others) to add some spice. Some Scotch Bonnet sauce will cure that need for heat right quick! The Curry Goat is fantastic as well, but you'd better love the curry if you order it! I've also tried the stewed chicken and pepper steak, both were delicious. You really can't go wrong at this place. All meals come with cabbage, a few plantains, and a choice of white rice, yellow rice, or rice & peas.
His rice (choice of is also very consistent and delicious. The rice and peas does not play the filler or side dish role at this joint, it's delicious by itself! I came here for lunch the day after I ate dinner at Black & Blue (not a fan). For about a fifth of the price, we feasted on a ridiculous amount of delicious Jamaican food, and the meal was about 10 times better than Black & Blue. The rice & peas was so Delicious, I declared that if I was given a choice of the meal I had at Black & Blue or just a bowl of the rice & peas, I would take the rice & peas without a second thought.
He also has an array of soups, with a different offering each day, so you have to ask what the soup of the day is. The Red Pea & Cow Foot soup (usually offered on Thursdays) is silly good. Spicy and just perfect, packed with fresh spices (sometimes you find the sprigs and leaves in the broth!). I've also had his Chicken Soup, Chicken Foot Soup, Goat Head Soup (AKA Mannish Chowder), and Red Pea soup. All were good, but nothing beats the Red Pea & Cow Foot!
There is a small parking lot on the Dewey on the south side of the building, the neighborhood is not bad at all for the city. Everything is served in takeout containers, but there are a few tables to sit and eat at if you wish to eat in. The soup is served in Styrofoam drink cups (I've seen it in other small takeout places, which is kind of ingenious. It keeps the soup warm, and also makes it portable. Nice.
A nice note here is that unlike many smaller local places, Better Choice is consistent as hell. He has never had an "off day" that I've experienced. Every time I've gone, I've gotten a great meal at a very reasonable price.