One Pie Pizza Co. is one of my top spots for pizza here in Buffalo! I've always wished they'd add two specialty pizzas to their permanent menu: a steak pizza and a stuffed hot pepper pizza. They've dabbled with a stuffed hot pepper pizza back in 2024 as a "Pizza of the Month" and it was excellent! For their November 2025 "Pizza of the Month", they're serving up their take on a steak pizza, FINALLY! Overall, this was a solid first attempt! On a Saturday, around 4:45pm, I placed my order for pickup, albeit it took quite a few attempts to call as their phone line kept returning as "busy". Once I got through though, I was able to place my order and was told it'd be ready in 20 minutes. I arrived about 20 minutes later and had to wait a couple minutes as it needed a couple more minutes to cook - Fine by me! The gentleman on the phone and working the counter was courteous and very friendly, easy-going. As we were chatting, he told me he was the one that came up with the November 2025 "Pizza of the Month", which was awesome - I made sure to tell him I was really happy to see a steak pizza on the menu at One Pie Pizza Co.! The only issue with picking up orders is their parking lot - I wish it were easier to navigate and larger. So for dinner, I ordered the November 2025 "Pizza of the Month" - a QTR (six slice) Steak Hoagie Pizza, which is a garlic butter and ricotta cheese base, topped with shaved ribeye steak, mozzarella cheese, (bell) peppers and onions, then drizzled with a savory hoagie sauce over the whole pizza, and per One Pie Pizza Co. tradition, served with a complimentary cup of homemade blue cheese. This pizza was delicious! The garlic butter and ricotta cheese base were excellent; I loved the balance of flavors and the creaminess of it! It was hard to tell by looking at the pizza but there was plenty of steak on each slice, all of the cheese on top did a nice job covering it up. The peppers and (red) onions tasted fresh and were sliced nicely. The hoagie sauce drizzle on top was a nice touch, but in my opinion, might have been a little too much. There are so many flavors and it comes off a bit "soupy" so, to me, the extra drizzle made it a little messy to handle. If/when I order it again, I'd ask for a lighter amount of the drizzle on top and maybe a minute or two more in the oven. Warning: This is a messy, greasier pizza - You'll want extra napkins and to wash your hands (and face) afterward. As for the price, it aligns with the pizzas under their "Extreme Specialty Pizzas" menu, so it's the priciest, but it's worth the price, in my opinion. One Pie Pizza Co.'s "Pizza of the Month" is always interesting and the November 2025 'Steak Hoagie Pizza' is one of my favorites! It'd be awesome if they add this pizza to their permanent menu, maybe tweak it a little bit to make it less messy. I'm certainly going to do my best to order the 'Steak Hoagie Pizza' before it's rotated off! For 2026, it'd be awesome to see this pizza, as well as their stuffed hot pepper pizza, added to the permanent menu... I'll continue crossing my fingers! haha read more