Sport for haggling, but ultimately a means to an end rather than a destination for shopping…read more I'm not sure they are even around anymore since they always look closed and their phone number has been disconnected for weeks.

Do Not Go to this place! Guy randomly refuses business if he doesn't like you. I made a previous…read moreoffer and since a deal was never made apparently i can't enter the store anymore. It might be other reasons too but i cant assume his intentions. Place is dirty and the owner is really bad for our community. *** please do not waste time here ***

I love this place! It has EVERYTHING needed for us old school gamers of the 1980s, 90s, 2000s and…read moreBEYOND! This location is especially great! Jay is the man! Very kind, cordial and helpful. THANK YOU, VGTP!

My review is for the Bayshore location…read more So much potential, but horrible customer service. No one greets you or ask if you have any questions. Walked around the store for 10 minutes. Passed two employees on the phone. I am an avid collector and will spend my money where i am not welcomed. Sad, opportunity missed

Not the friendliest atmosphere or the cleanest. It's the…read moremedia equivalent of a thrift store. You might find something neat here or there but for those wondering why they are called Mr. Cheapo, it's likely because of the experience selling items to the store. Not pleasant, they will lowball you to less than 10% of the value of your item, hem and haw about how they won't be able to sell it for much, then list it for way way way more than they told you they would. I come here if I'm bored and need to kill some time but it's never a fun experience really.

I've come to this store for years and it's hard to give it an honest review. But to the people who…read morewant to sell their things like CDs, DVDs, VHS and laserdisc/ players, it's definitely not here. They'll try to lowball you instead of giving you a fare offer, they do it all the time. Also the guy with glasses in the counter was given my buddy a hard time when he was trying to negotiate his DVDs. Like not giving him a better offer or other options. The guy who works there probably had a bad day, but I don't think anybody would want to put up with his attitude. Also If you're looking for a specific title. They may or may not have it, so you're better off finding it somewhere else. *In conclusion. It's fairly good. I think for most people who want to find physical media, discover and stay away from the internet for a bit. Above average, it's not a bad store

Sometimes I really don't wanna review the places that I want to keep secret to myself! About once a…read moremonth I visit retro games to see if they have any new stock on DVDs, blue rays, VHS. They have a really good selection. I have found some amazing movies from nostalgia and I don't even have a VHS or a Blu-ray player and I will buy the movie anyway! Because I have a collection addiction. they often have a decent crowd looking for video games. they also have some toys like Barbies and I think I saw my little ponies as well. They are located on the upper floor of what I believe is the Tri-County mall? Which is a nostalgic site to see all on its own so dedicate some time if you want to trip down memory lane.

The people who work here are unprofessional. Their system for pricing/negotiating feels sketchy, I…read moreleft feeling like I had gotten ripped off. There are so many better and cleaner gaming stores nearby, I have no reason to ever go back.

My guy and I go to Kill Screen Games at least once a week. The folks that run the place are…read moreknowledgeable and always helpful!! Love having a neighborhood game store we can rely on!

Sold some childhood Pokémon games to this store and they gave me good prices and didn't waste my…read moretime. It was after I had driven to about 5 other shops that wasted my time. This was the first shop I've sold any of my Pokémon games to. I recommend them. Costumer service was great too.

Friendly and nerdy staff - what you would expect. But the selection was a bit overpriced. They…read morepriced games that were heavily damaged the same as games that weren't damaged at all. I think if you're willing to wait for shipping, just buy your retro games on ebay.

Love coming here. Employees are always great, friendly and there to help. Get a lot of my Pokemon…read morecards here. Great selection of stuff to check out.

Awesome comics. Great weeklies. Amazing exclusives; the best in the business! They goto every…read morecomic con. Some nice older books and cool Funko Pops! And the owner Steve is awesome. Thanks my LCBS!

Love this store the people are very friendly and extremely helpful they always have the most resent…read morecomics and old ones also. The store is stocked with pops and toys and things that you can't find in other places. What I love the most is you can look at there stuff and they don't tell you not to touch anything. If they don't have what you looking for they will order it for you and tell you the truth if they can get it or not, they will also tell let you know it may take some time for it to come in and once they get it they let you know I'm on there comic list for the new comics that come out every week so I know I'm going to get my comics I'm happy to support this small business and I recommend it to everyone that's looking for old games and new pops and comics

Really nice people, solid selection and they'll usually work with you a bit on trade ins or prices…read moreof items. Too bad this mall is being re developed eventually, hopefully vgtp stays. The levittown one is also great

Alex is a wonderful guy and it's my first time in New York and he gave me the most warm welcome and…read moreshowed me around and had a wonderful chat definitely check this place out!!!

i brought in a few cards with my son from hidden fates(2021) told me the stuff he had was worth 5…read morebucks checked when i went home all of the stuff i gave him was worth $1000 fuck whoever did that to me bc my kid fell for it and i don't do pokemon it was only until my brother in law told me that they were more that he gave us fuck the person in the red shirt with reddish blond hair and beard who "helped" us at 6:21 on Tuesday April 7 2026 fuck u but although the last time i came there there was a different guy who was very kind and helpful that actually told Us real pokemon card facts that could help us

I brought my cards to the shop and spent nearly an hour having them evaluated, only to be offered…read morean extremely low amount. I understand that shops need to make money and cover their overhead, but the offer wasn't even close to reasonable. I sent the same cards to an online buylist service, where they scanned and evaluated them through their system and came back with an offer five times higher than what the shop quoted. At that point the difference stops being about business margins and simply bordering on robbery.

If you're into books, video games, Manga, StarWars, anything like this or more than this is the…read moreplace for you to browse, buy and sell. I brought in two ds 3D games to sell and within minutes I received about half price the lower rate listed on ebay. This was fine by me because I didn't want the hassle of selling online myself. I bought 2 games that I was looking for. I brought my game with me and I tested them before I bought them. They have a 12 day return policy.

I'm only really here for the movie collections (bring back physical media!) so I can't really…read morecomment on the manga, book, or music selections although it seems those sections are just as popular. They do buy items but I myself haven't sold anything to them. They have a generous two week policy to check the discs to make sure they work. I go between here and the city location often to see what's in stock. The employees are kind, welcoming, and knowledgable. I've often called to ask about stock questions and they're always quick to help. I do occasionally check the children's section because my dream is to have the old Sweet Valley books of my youth, but the YA section is I'd say from 2010 on. There's a large lot with plenty of parking.