We just recently switched to Carlisle Vision Care, and we couldn't be happier. I was amazed by the…read moretechnology they use, being able to get a retina scan instead of having drops in my eyes. They found a small tear to my retina, which I wouldn't of known about otherwise. Dr.Graden was so nice and friendly. I didn't feel rushed. The staff is awesome too. I am so, so happy with this practice.

I have been wearing glasses for nearly 70 years and this is the only practice I have ever trusted…read moremy ocular health to. Obviously, the staff is completely different than when I started as a three year old, but today the doctors are great, young but well trained and truly caring of your vision. I have been treating for glaucoma for over 10 years and feel confident that there treatment program is spot on. You're not a just a number here. I recommend them unconditionally!

I have visited here annually for about 5 years as it is conveniently located in Gettysburg, not…read more2.5 miles from my home. It is not on a main drag, so no stress trying to get in or out in heavy traffic, andvthe parking lot in the back has ample space. The staff all seem the same over the years ive been going which is a good thing as staff retention says a lot about an organization. I have always seen the same optometrist until my last visit. He was new to me, but was fine. The front staff is always attentive, courteous, and helpful, particularly Katie, and the office manager is swell, but I cant recall her name. I have always felt as though id received a thorough exam upon leaving which is important as I value my vision immensely and want to preserve it as long as possible. Hopefully my eyes last longer than I do! I've gotten new eyeglasses there thrice over the years and have been happy with them. They have a fine selection, and the staff are patient and helpful. Prices are not cheap, however quality eye care is crucial to me as alluded to above, therefore I fell asleep though I have received a "product " of value. In summary, a fine place for eye care where I will continue to visit indefinitely!

This office is extremely outdated and not patient-friendly. I had an overdue balance and attempted…read moreto resolve it by sending my information through the mail. I was never told that payments could not be processed that way. I only learned this after calling the office myself. When I then tried to pay over the phone, I was told they needed to contact the eye doctor, who apparently handles billing. In 2026, a medical office that cannot clearly communicate payment methods or process a simple payment efficiently is unacceptable. I take full responsibility for paying late, but once I made the effort to take care of the balance, the office made it unnecessarily difficult. Poor communication, outdated systems, and no consideration for patient convenience. I will not be returning.

Annie is back! It was great seeing Annie back - she made finding you glasses so easy - she knows…read moreframes and what you need for a painless experienc. Thank you Annie.

Dr. Nardis and the staff at Gettysburg American Eyewear are excellent at what they do. I do not…read morenow nor have I ever worked here, but I am an American Board of Opticians certified optician, so I know what to look for in an optometrist and optical technicians. I read through other reviews posted here, and they seem fake to me (look at where some of them are posted from!). Bottom line: I wouldn't go anywhere else for my vision/contact lens exam or to get my glasses made, adjusted, etc. Several of my family members also come here, so it's not just me who is very happy with Gettysburg American Eyewear.

Eye problem? -- No problem!!…read more REVIEW DESCRIPTION I recently had something in my eye which caused continuous irritation and discomfort. I was able to get in first thing in the morning and had my problem diagnosed within minutes. The staff was very professional and handled my insurance with no issues. I was impressed by the office and the concern the doctor and staff afforded me. Will definitely come back.

The people are great here. They do like to insist on the retinal scan which is an extra $45 or say…read morethey need to dilate your eyes. And the prices are quite a bit more than the last place I went to. $100 at a previous eye doctor is $200 here.

From making at appointment to picking up my new pair of glasses, I have been nothing but satisfied…read morewith the service I received. The exam itself was very thorough (most intensive I have ever received.) Dr. Nelson was very pleasant, and I didn't feel rushed when seeing him. The staff there was also very friendly. When it came time to choose a pair of glasses, the staff was helpful, but not pushy. I didn't feel like I was being 'talked into' anything. I was told the glasses may take 10 to 15 business days to receive, but to my surprise, I received a phone call 5 days later, saying they were ready! When I picked them up, they were just perfect! They even took the time to make sure they 'felt good' on my face, and adjusted them accordingly. I have been to several different optometrist's offices over the years, and this was by far my best experience! I'm glad I found them, and look forward to working with them in the future!

I've been visiting this location and their Westminster location for 15+ years now. Well today at…read moremy appointment, they decided to add another fee to their long list of fees, and in this case claimed my insurance doesn't cover a $75 contact lens fitting fee. I wore my glasses like I was told to, but without my lenses, they're gonna hit me with another fee. My last visit. It's all about the money, not the patient.

Dr Rennie is the Best! So thorough and caring!. The quality of care received is second to none!read more

Outstanding staff, not limited to Robin at reception, Parker who does initial exams and Carey…read morefinishing up after the appointment. Dr. Rennie makes her patients feel comfortable, addresses concerns, however trivial and provides knowledgeable service a patient can trust. With the Mt. Airy Eye Care team, I feel confident in my eye care.

Just went here for eye exam. Website said they take United Healthcare. Scheduled 3 weeks in…read moreadvance. Called ahead to set up appt and left message on answering machine with plan # and insurance info day before. I take off work & get there and they say they do not take insurance from United Healthcare. I am told they haven't in 5 YEARS. I pull out phone & show them where my plan is listed on website and am told that they called to change that (not sure if the website company she was referring to?) and that hasn't been changed. 5 YEARS and that is not fixed? She says she will talk to the office manager to have it fixed. Too bad for me and missing work I suppose. The woman was nice enough and I don't blame her but this is ridiculous. Hate posting negative reviews for anything let alone a local business - sorry guys, unacceptable

I have been searching and searching for help with my vision (astigmatism) and getting glasses that…read moregive me back my 20/20 vision. I have ended my search. Dr McGahan has gone above and beyond trying to discover and understand my vision issues! I have never encountered a doctor who is that dedicated, that knowledgeable and that willing to spend the extra time needed to figure out my vision difficulties. I am so very thankful for Dr McGahan

Friendly, helpful staff. Dr. McGahen is very thorough. He detected issues with my vision that…read moreprior Optometrists failed to discover. I would highly recommend Dr. McGahen's office to anyone who is searching for the best care for all your vision service needs.