Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Advantage Insurance

    3.7 (3 reviews)
    Closed 8:30 am - 7:00 pm
    Updated 2 months ago

    Get a quote

    You can now request a quote from this business directly from Yelp

    Services - Advantage Insurance

    Advantage Insurance Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Advantage Insurance

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    6 hours ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Tim R.
    1
    63
    34

    11 months ago

    Outstanding customer service. The reps are all amazing. I've been working with them for about 2 years and I haven't had any issues.

    Business owner information

    Photo of Jessica P.

    Jessica P.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Advantage Insurance

    Allstate Insurance: Steve Ward

    Allstate Insurance: Steve Ward

    (3 reviews)

    I must say I was very discouraged, fearful, and overwhelmed with my homeowner's policy and the…read moregiant price increase they had bestowed upon me until I talked with James Pugh, my hero. Wow, I can't say enough about James. Not only did James change my homeowner's, which saved me a great deal of money, but he also helped me save a ton on my car insurance which was an extra added bonus for me. I cannot begin to tell you how much this helped me. When I say James Pugh is my hero, I kid you not. I had no idea what to do next, how to do it, or how to even understand it unil"Jim Dandy" came to my rescue. Knowing that I had no understanding of electronically sending documents, James helped me with everything. He has great patience, gives instruction with such finesse,and just makes the complicated seem so juvenile. Oh, and his personality, well that was just God given!!!!! ALLSTATE, you can never go wrong with agents such as James Pugh representing you, he truly is a great asset to your Allstate family. I wish to thank James for going above and beyond, you have truly made my life a little easier. Thank you.....

    I wouldn't recommend Allstate because of this agency! I was a transfer costumer but charged as a…read morenew client. I had no tickets perfect credit score and was still over charged! I never met anyone I talked to on the phone. When I was going to sign my insurance paperwork the guy didn't even have a pen at his desk .... call yourself professional? I had to call my last agent because this Allstate agent threatened to take my money for next 6 months ( my policy went up for no reason other than I am paying for the sun! Per the agency secretary!) I could go on & on . When you have to reach out to your last Allstate agency to get out from this office it's really sad! This man really makes Allstate name representation really bad even my last agent was upset this was done to me. Would Not Recommend this Office !

    Allstate Insurance Agent: Joanne Fisher

    Allstate Insurance Agent: Joanne Fisher

    (2 reviews)

    HORRIBLE, stay away! Seems to always be looking to get you on a higher premium. 23-24 policy,…read more'after paying', my policy inferred I may need to pay up to 45% more premium if there's a catastrophy. Also, already included policy for following year 2025 which was double, before policy for 2024 even started. Final straw, requires inspection again, knowing my wiring was already code and passed previously, and again passed yesterday with flying colors, but her employee Kim Lashley now contacts us to say they may not insure, again looking to upsell us! She knew what we had, made us pay for an inspection that passed, and now wants to point us to another policy!!!!

    This insurance company sent me an unsolicited home ins…read morequote. I asked them if they good do better. No! The home insurance company is not important. It's the Fisher Financial services I'm reviewing. These people were quoting in their name. Kind of a rude agent when I asked if they could do better. So I turned them down because they were too high. I turned others down. I have no problem getting quality homeowners ins. anywhere. Then I get a letter giving me an ins score. Not bad but never have I received anything like this . I am going to complain to the place they used! I turned them down. They act like they turned me down.!! This is a rather immature reaction. I have a problem with companies like this I would consider using another financial services company because of these practices!

    Allstate Insurance: Carolyn Hersh

    Allstate Insurance: Carolyn Hersh

    (1 review)

    This agency will outright lie to you. They will tell you repeatedly, in writing and by phone that…read morethey will or have taken action on your behalf when they haven't! I received a letter from the insurance carrier that proof of installation of a new roof had been completed, or my insurance would be cancelled. I supplied the proof within two days of receipt of the cancellation notice. I was told by the Allstate agent by email that the information had been forwarded to the insurance carrier and that they were waiting for a response from the carrier. A month and a half later I received a second notice of cancellation of my home insurance by the carrier. When I contacted Allstate again wanting to know why my home insurance was going to be canceled, I was advised that the carrier had the information and that it could take weeks or months to get a response from the carrier. I told Allstate that I would be calling the carrier to find out what other information was required or what did I need to do before my insurance would be canceled. When I contacted the carrier the next day, I was informed that they received the documentation the day before and would have it processed within three to five days. Thanks for lying to me about the issue being with the carrier. The issue was clearly the fault of inept, lying Allstate agent. There's more...I contacted Allstate corporate to have my agent changed to an honest, trustworthy agent. I was advised that I could not change my agent because the agency had been purchased by a new person and that I could not change agents for one year from the date of purchase. So the only way to change agents was to cancel my policy with them. When I contacted the agency to request cancellation, I had to speak with the same agent that had lied to me repeatedly. I requested my policy to be canceled effective immediately. This agent did not cancel my policy and continued to bill me for the policy that I had canceled. Now I am stuck in a legal dispute because the agency turned me over to collections for a policy that I canceled. If you like being lied to...If you like being held responsible for a cancelled policy, then this is the agency for you.

    From the owner: Contact my Agency to get a Quick,Personalized Insurance Quote Today! A great rate is just a call…read moreor click away. I have lived in the Tampa Bay area for 40+ years. My passion is raising Guide Dogs for Southeastern Guide Dogs, located in Palmetto, FL .

    Advantage Insurance - homeinsurance - Updated June 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...