This was our first time visiting and we were so happy we went to this brewery. My sister was…read moregraduating from Saint Bonaventure University with a Masters. Her honors program came here to celebrate. Everyone was very accommodating and made sure we were taken care of in a very positive and caring manner. I would definitely recommend coming here. There are many choices and everyone is friendly.

I can't say enough positive things about this tour, the amazing staff, the beer, the buildings, or…read morethe food. 100% a must visit place and experience! The building is historical and used to be Olean brewing company prior to prohibition. They redid this place so well while keeping original things. Jarrod, our tour guide, was so knowledgeable and passionate about the brewery, history, science, product, and community involvement. He gave us an amazing tour and offered to take pictures of us in the brewery. The food is unique and delicious. Just like the beer menu the food menu is limited, but extremely high quality. What they do do they do flawlessly. The inside restaurant, beer garden, land scape, and brewery itself were immaculately clean. There is a 2nd floor to rent Everyone was friendly, fast, knowledgeable, and happy to be there. A real all genders, ages, races, incomes... welcome type place.

Stopped in for lunch today and their name is now "The Wing" as the owner retired and a long time…read moreemployee took it over and dropped "Broken". Had their 16" one topping pizza (pepperoni) and the crust is thick and tasty but could have probably been in the oven a bit longer. The sauce could use a bit more flavor however was satisfying. Had 10 of the Buffalo style wings (5 mild and 5 sweet chili) which were fried with a slight crisp, both good. Had a couple of side salads which were very nice, not to much and not to little. Recommend this restaurant!

Every one was so friendly and the cook was pretty cool even asked how it was and how we wanted ifread more

I can't wait to come back home just to eat these Irish wings. They're made out of potato dips. And…read morethe lemon drop martini was perfect

Was only there once, and the waitress was very rude .Spiky blonde hair ask for a shot.She gave me…read morethe wrong one still charged me for it.And then she drank, it will never, ever go back there

UN BE LIEVABLE…read more The food, the service, the value, the staff! Hard to put into words how cool this night was at the bar as a solo dude here in PA on business. They had cheese, chicken and steak options on their quesadillas. I asked if they could do grilled shrimp instead. "YEP" It was the largest, chunkiest, tastiest quesadilla I've ever had! They tossed in sour cream, salsa and pico without batting an eye or adding cost to it. I asked the gal that emerged from the kitchen if she was the chef. She was indeed the saint who made my quesadilla, so I was able to let her know I had just consumed the nectar of the Tex/Mex gods in her offering. The bartender/my server was the nicest, most easy going person ever. He could be selling airplanes for Boeing but somehow he's here doing his craft. I've traveled the US and have gone to literally hundreds of sports bars/restaurants etc. It's hard to describe when you don't encounter a negative person or scene in any conversation or request. If I lived around here I'd sleep in the parking lot so I don't miss a meal or drink oppo. If there were 10 stars I'd give it. I've left some harsh reviews so I don't type the above lightly. To the owners of this patch of golden humanity..... THANK YOU! Why? For finding and hiring great people who care about their work, products and guests. If you're reading this and deciding where to grab a drink or quality food, -----stop here and thank me later.

My husband and I stop here on Wednesdays for our date night. We haven't had a bad meal yet. Love…read morethe specials they offer and the home made desserts are wonderful!!

I tried out The Old Library Restaurant today and I found it really lovely. The building is so…read morelovely and it was fun to experience that old architecture. We were seated promptly and welcomed. They had a specific lunch menu, but also said we could order from the dinner menu as well. I chose to order chicken Marsala. It was served with a creamy risotto and roasted seasonal vegetables. It was a wonderful dish and I really enjoyed it. One of the people I dined with needed some dietary substitutions and the staff was absolutely great about, everything came as ordered. After we were served our meal, we were still given a lot of attention from the staff and they were happy to separate our checks. If you are ever in Olean, NY you should definitely check this place out.

Nick was an awesome waiter. It is a nice place set in an old library like the name says…read more The artichoke dip was very good. The chips were not over salted like some places are. There is a nice cheese and seasoning sprinkled on them. Very tasty. I had the NY Strip Steak. It was cooked to perfection and the potatoes were delicious My wife had the haddock stuffed with crab. She is not a fan of crab but said it tasted good. It was on a layer of rice. Definitely recommend this place for a nice dinne

Great location to sit and unwind or join friends for a lovely selection of craft beers and quality…read morepizza out of the wood-fired oven. A cozy, courteous and popular haunt where I have always had kind and attentive service. Yum.

I can't review the food because we waited 25 minutes to provide our order but no one came to take…read moreit after we waited 10 minutes for a menu. The place is beautifully appointed and the atmosphere was great. We had family in town for the holiday weekend so we were really excited to try out the place. I don't blame the servers. This was definitely a management issue since the place was 1/2 full and there was only one person to take care of the bar and tables. Unfortunately, we left hungry and ended up elsewhere.

We stopped in to check this place out. We don't normally think of breweries as a place to have a…read moremeal or a light snack, but we have begun to realize that these places are more than just a place to drink. This is such a nice business concept, and a clever reuse of a former gift shop enterprise. The food offerings are light fair, Panini's, pretzels, pizzas. We would definitely recommend Beer Justice!

A great stop for a yummy beer! I was finally able to make it to Beer Justice and I would definitely…read morego back! My husband and I wanted to enjoy the summer night, so we took a motorcycle ride down to the brewery on a Thursday night. When we arrived, they immediately scored points for having cool plants, and pretty lights. The ambiance is great. We ordered at the counter and our bartender (I suspect the owner) was friendly and helpful. He even had his pup, Toby, in the bar, which made me so happy (shout out to all the beerboss pups of the world)! The beers were very enjoyable. I will say that they use the terms "a hint of" loosely lol. I really liked the blond stout (which had a strong chocolate cherry flavor) and the cream ale! I tried the peach cream ale, and it was delish, but very peachy :) my husband had a hefe which he said was great but didn't taste very "hefe". For food, they had a small menu, and we ordered the chicken panini (7/10- just needed a little seasoning) and the cheeseburger pizza (11/10-yum). There was a good crowd playing song trivia on Thursday night, so it felt warm and inviting. We talked to a couple on the patio for a bit, but decided to stay inside due to the mosquitoes swarming. Definitely worth a visit!

9/17/2025: Amazing! Updating my review because our last 5 experiences have been great all around!…read moreKitchen consistency is back to amazing again and so are the waitresses. THE BEST steak and prime rib in town without a doubt! Great burgers with a good variety to try! Good garlic butter pasta. The best steamed and buttered broccoli you'll ever have in your life! Nice big portion of spaghetti with meatballs. The meatballs are big and juicy. Good fried pickles. Good beer and drink options. Skilled bartenders. Very very very clean looking behind the bar always. No sticky bar, no dirty cups piled up, no fruit flies, no gummy soda guns, no stale beer smell, no dusty bottles.... very nicely kept. The only disappointment/thing I don't like on the menu is the little frozen premade beer fish fry. They're such a great restaurant, I think they should do their own big hunk of beer battered fish fry dinner instead at least for lent. My 2023 review issues have all been resolved! Yay! I highly recommend them!

Don't let the plain storefront misguided you, there is great pub food and a variety of good drinks…read moreinside! Staff also very nice.

There's a huge selection of imported and domestic wines, liquors and mixers…read more The clerks are knowledgeable and ready to help. Parking can be difficult depending on the time of day, but worth it.

The prices are not too above considering the location. My 2 stars reflect the customer service. The…read moreperson checking us out was beyond impersonal. There was no thank you to the customer ( not just us) but instead a monotone statement of price. A tip to staff...a simple smile ( if even phony) and a THANK YOU would not kill you; for without your customers, you have no business.

Cool atmosphere. Not sure what the bartenders problem was in the back but he was rather rude. Did…read morenot have a great experience because of that.

Fun place. One of my must-visit restaurants while visiting E-Ville…read more Great vibe, came for lunch, it was quiet but once we got seated, it started filling in. Prices are reasonable and the restaurant has a very nice feel to it. Highly recommend.