We were delighted to have breakfast two days in a row here while on our vacation in the Endless mountains of northeastern PA. The food was delicious and the coffee was superb (which totally took me by surprise!) Leanne (sp?) waited on us both days and we really loved her. She gave us a great suggestion as to where to go for our anniversary dinner and remembered our preferences the next day and asked about how the previous day's adventures went. Their breakfast sandwiches were filling and omg the special was a chocolate strawberry stuffed French toast and it was sooo good! We also loved the decor of the place-fun colored chairs and lots of sunlight coming in through the windows without it being too hot. I'd love to go back again! read more

See all

Enjoyed my visit yesterday to the American Sandwich Company. It is a nice friendly family owned place that works very hard to make your visit satisfying! Ordered the Denver Mile High corned beef sandwich. This is the kind of sandwich that will tell you if the shop knows what is doing. 1st. The bread. It was not your typical rye. Which was a disappointment. However the bread it's self tasted very good! 2nd.The corned beef was very very bland. Not sure if it was actually cut in house. 3rd. Normally a good Rubin or corned beef sandwich would come with Sour Kraut. I asked for cole slaw. 4. Cold Slaw was excellent with a nice spicy vinaigrette flavor. It altered the flavor of the sandwich from bland to good. 5. Asked for the cheese to be melted which it was not. But then I had to send the sandwich back because the cold slaw was not on the sandwich. Over all the sandwich was decent and acceptable. My guess that being in the middle of no where in a tiny but pretty town on the scenic US Rt 6, this business just does not serve many Corned beef sandwiches. The shop was clean, plenty of comfortable seating. Street parking was good. Excellent WiFi. Prices are very very good! I will go back and try a burger or another sandwich. Something more in their wheelhouse. I give them credit for trying very hard to give me what I ordered. Interesting thing is this sandwich shop sells a variety of beers and hard seltzers. Along with the usual soft drinks in bottles and with fountain. Have to mention Tanya. She was my server. Tanya worked very hard to get me what I ordered. I appreciate her work ethic. Her tip was above the normal percentage because she tried so hard. Stop by. Have a sandwich with or with out a beer. Enjoy the friendly comfortable atmosphere. For a small business, this family works very hard to stay afloat!!! read more

Awesome corner sandwich shop in Wyalusing. Large open seating area with wraparound windows. Welcoming staff with an open view of the kitchen to see what is cooking. Nice cooler with both water, soda, and beer. Had a great neighborhood feel and got pretty busy on a Saturday afternoon. We got the strawberry salad which was nice and fresh. Also there's chalkboard special which was a Ruben burger. I would definitely come back to try their other Reuben and pastrami sandwiches. read more

American Sandwich - Store front - Sandwiches Near Me - Wyalusing, Pennsylvania

See all

This is exactly what downtown Wyalusing needed! Shout out to the owners. They transformed this establishment into something truly amazing. The interior and exterior are top-notch. Hands down the nicest interior for 20+ miles. They've got a great atmosphere and it's exactly on trend for modern day restaurants. If this was in a major city it would be one of the hottest lunch spots. I applaud them for what they've done with this space. I stopped in and ordered the special, which was a Buffalo Chicken Panini ($7.99), served with a pickle and chips. I had my choice of blue cheese or ranch on the sandwich... obviously went with blue cheese. Also, grabbed a drink from the cooler. The sandwich was delicious! They're definitely using fresh ingredients. After leaving a 15% tip my total order rang up just under $12.00. I have no problem paying that for a good lunch (which is hard to find in this area). My only concern is a lot of people in this area don't care about quality... they just want cheap food. I hope this place can survive the local market and that people appreciate how great this restaurant really is! I plan to do my part in supporting them. See you again SOON! read more

American Sandwich - the inside of a restaurant - Sandwiches Near Me - Wyalusing, Pennsylvania

The food is excellent, the atmosphere is casual & the employees are so friendly! My husband and I had lunch today - he built his own burger and I had my usual 'Oven Roasted Chicken Panini'. The first thing I said to my husband today was how the bread was perfectly toasted and NOT saturated with butter on the outside! My husbands burger was perfectly prepared and super tasty! We finished lunch off with their home made slice of peanut butter pie and it was to die for! My daughter loved looking out their beautiful windows, too! It was a perfect lunch date! read more

American Sandwich - Sandwiches Near Me - Wyalusing, Pennsylvania

Ambiance-good. Service- been waiting nearly an hour for food so far. In the 1-2pm hour. Seen waitress only once thus far. Found out our order was skipped over. Got some fries at 58 minutes, very good. Still waiting for Reubens. At the 1:01 sandwiches delivered. Rueben is atypical yet tasty. No sauerkraut but coleslaw on Rueben. Mine had Pastrami on it not corned beef. Tasty but not what I was looking for. I still give them a A for food and effort. The three ladies that are working are working hard. Do still tip your waitress. read more

Philly cheesesteak and mozzarella sticks were on the money. Really cool sandwich shop highly recommend! read more

American Sandwich - the interior of a restaurant - Sandwiches Near Me - Wyalusing, Pennsylvania

See all

My friend and I stopped to try a sandwich and we wound up spending two hours eating four. The sandwiches are all from different parts of the country in style and flavor. We split and shared them. The craft beer selection was incredible. We had never heard of these beers before but they were delicious. The staff was kind and courteous and quick to desceibe any sandwich or beverage we asked about. This is by far my favorite place for a sandwich and a beer in Bradford county, or the southern tier. It's also kid friendly as I saw the kids menu and families enjoying meals together as fathers relaxed with a brew and a big sandwich. I'll be coming here again and again. read more

See all

New and clean. Cool modern country atmosphere. Service was friendly and helpful. My Goodness chicken salad on a pretzel role was very good. So was the Cole slaw. My wife's veggie panini and Mac and cheese which they only have on Fridays was good too. I'd love to see reusable cutlery or at least individually dispensed compostable read more

My wife and I stopped in here for lunch one day she wanted to try it so we stopped. My wife had a chicken cheesesteak and I had a cheesesteak. Well our portions were small for the high price we payed. The subs were ok but for the price I was expecting better. Will we go back more then likely no. read more

Delicious sandwiches, beautiful decor, friendly staff. We went here twice in our two day stay in Wyalusing. Sunday breakfast was such a treat! read more

In a rush going through Wyalusing Found this Quaint Sandwich shop.. looks like it belongs in a small New England town... Out of this world sandwiches, and Wonderful Chili.. Fair prices.. Friendly Staff and GREAT atmosphere. Be worth your trip here just to eat in this neat little restaurant Enjoy !! read more

Good food, good staff, pricy Sandwiches but worth it! Some of the girls can improve on their manners but other than that, 4 stars.

Awesome place to stop in for a sandwich weather hot or cold sit at the front window and take a trip back in time as you read through the books about old Wyalusing. The Italian balsamic is awesome and the Rachel is up there too will definitely come back here. And it's all at a fair price read more

This restaurant/cafe/cool hangout fits the area perfectly. The food is inventive and delicious. The staff friendly and helpful. The service is quick and the staff always makes sure to check in and see if you are in need of anything. Every detail of the decor is perfect & clean. I bring people that haven't tried the American Sandwich Company & they are always glad I did & say they will return. read more

A new restaurant in the Wyalusing area serving paninis and sandwiches mostly. Great atmosphere, very clean, good simple food.

The atmosphere is perfect for this sleepy little mountain town, but the food was even better. Outstanding sandwiches, and soups. They have a solid collection of beers and sodas and the service was excellent! We highly recommend this sandwich shop! read more