Our first time at Andy's did not disappoint! We enjoyed the ooey gooey butter cake sundae. It was full of flavor and oh, so sweet! Ice cream and custard are two of our favorite desserts, and we've tried them all over! Andy's is now near the top of the list. We went through the drive thru, but you're able to order at the window too, which is adorable! The exterior gives diner vibes, but with custard! read more

Drive aisle confusing. The sign with the menu is way ahead of where you order. Portion size was small. Pricing for it I thought was high. read more

See all

Try the Bordeaux cherry topping on vanilla custard. They have specials seasonally and we are waiting for the pumpkin pie concrete. Please. Pretty please. read more

Anyone who doesn't give this place 5 stars is crazy! I come by here weekly. Sooooo many great flavors on the menu and the seasonals are amazing. Love the Key Lime Pie and the Pumpkin Pie when they are both available. A slice of pie jammed into vanilla custard. Yum! Simply the best option out there. read more

Came here for ice cream and we got a banana split. It was pretty good but when we got it there wasn't much chocolate on it so I asked him to add more. The ice cream was kind of melted by the time we got it. No seating inside just one table outside. Cute place in Sanford. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sanford, Florida

See all

Service was fast. I got the Turtle Banana Split. It had a lot of pecans, which was good. It had three scoops of vanilla ice-cream. The bananas were not too ripe. It had the cherry on top. The Banana Split itself was on the small side. The scoops of ice-cream were small. They needed more fudge and caramel sauce. There was no whip cream. It looks like whip cream is not on the menu. read more

Not gonna lie, this was the best custard I've ever tried. Super thick and it didn't melt quickly either. The ratio of my butterfinger topping was perfect. The place is clean looking on the inside and I like that's its drive-through only. Service was super fast. Good thing I don't live close by or I'd want it all the time. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sanford, Florida

I've been to this place a few times now over the past couple weeks since I found out about it each time I've gotten the banana pudding ice cream. It's delicious. I like that. It has marshmallows in it and cheesecake puts spin on banana pudding that you just absolutely love. The staff is super friendly. Service is always quick. I think the longest I waited was eight minutes. They have a walk up window and a drive-through. They do not have an inside seating area, but they have a few tables outside that can be used. read more

Great spot for crushing the sweet-treat craving. The wife and I stopped in on a Thursday afternoon and decided on the Andy's Turtle Split ($7.59) we also asked the staff member to provide a waffle cone so we could have something crunchy with our dessert. Our order was ready fast and the employee was very friendly. The dessert was delicious and was enough for two. The only issue is that the custard melts fast, by the time we got back to the car it was like eating ice cream soup. Regardless it was very good and hit the spot on a hot summer day. One of the highlights of Andy's is that they have a drive thru so don't even have to get out of the car if you want. Great experience and I would come back. read more

See all

We love having Andy's custard as an after-dinner treat while dining in Sanford. It's so hard to choose between their seasonal flavors and traditional options. That just means you have to keep on coming! The drive through is always busy, but I like to order at the window and eat at the benches. I feel like it's a little dangerous getting to the window and crossing over the drive through lane. If you have small kids, it may be best to hit the drive through and take your treats home so you don't have to worry about them darting into the parking lot. I do wish they had inside seating, but that won't stop me from returning! read more

Hands down my favorite spot to grab a dessert. This place is so good! Everything tastes like it was made to order. The butter pecan milkshake and the brownie sundae are go to options. Both are phenomenal. Order the toasted pecans on anything you get. They are the best pecans I've ever had and really add extra flavor. They have so many options to choose from or create your own concoction. Casual spot to grab something sweet or to meet a friend. Drive thru and walk up window options to order. A few tables outside to enjoy your favorite custard item. Treat yo self! read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Brownie sundae! Amazing - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sanford, Florida

A service is always excellent and the ice cream roasted pecans & whipped cream oh my goodness, a perfect treat!

Love this Andy's. It's a great location, has a dive through and a walk up window. The selection of options is outstanding with so many things to choose from you could go every weekend and not try them all. They serve frozen custard so it's much more rich and creamy than traditional ice cream. The service is usually pretty good and you don't normally have to wait very long unless they are backed up on a weekend. Give it a try! read more

See all

I've been a loyal fan of Andy's for years, so I was thrilled to find a location just a mile from home. Unfortunately, this visit was a major letdown--and easily the worst experience I've ever had at an Andy's. I ordered my usual Boot Daddy and some pup cups through the drive-thru. While the pup cups were fine, my concrete was practically liquid. This wasn't a heat issue--I went straight from the window to home, and the dog treats held their shape just fine. There's no question: this was poor preparation by the staff, not a problem with the machine. I expect better quality from Andy's, especially from a location I was excited to support. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Boot daddy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sanford, Florida

This is one of our all-time favorite custard spots! We come here at least once a month and enjoy all of the flavors Andy's has to offer, and there are so many ways to customize the menu items, which makes it all the more wonderful. Plus they have limited time flavors regularly, so there's always something new and different to try! Also, if you're not much of an eating-custard-on-it's-own kind of person, they have floats as well. They're delightful This restaurant is always packed when we come; there's always at least 5 or 6 cars in the drive through and several people inside. It's a local favorite! I usually get the BootDaddy Concrete or the Ooey Gooey Concrete. Andy's is a bit on the pricey side, but it's well worth! I would recommend signing up for the rewards program so that you can accumulate points and occasionally get some yummy freebies read more

This place is always busy around the evening time which is a good sign of course. Love the seasonal options they offer but my favorite is the jackhammers. Another thing to note is they have outdoor seating however they do not have the ability to accept applepay. read more

See all

I usually LOVE Andy's and their frozen custard never misses, but wow... the manager on shift totally ruined the vibe tonight. Came in craving something sweet, left with dessert and an attitude I didn't order. The staff seemed kind of nervous. It was like I was inconveniencing him by existing. Look, I get it. We all have bad days. But if you're running the place, maybe try not to talk to people like they're gum on your shoe? Especially when folks are literally paying for a treat and a good experience. Custard: delicious. Service: needs a full reboot + a manager who actually likes people. Would I go back? Probably...but only if that manager isn't working. read more

Fast service and delicious! I always get the turtle sundae! Fresh ingredients and friendly faces

This is such an awesome and popular place that I wanted to come here for the first time yesterday. It was a hot day and felt that my family and I could enjoy some fresh ice cream outdoors. Around 6pm, it does get pretty busy so both the drive thru and walk up line had a line. The menu is packed with a variety of items like custards, shakes, malts, etc. I ordered the James brownie jackhammer as well as a build your own concrete. Both were made within a few minutes. I did notice some ants by the window which should be addressed since it is so close to the food service area. Both ice creams were soft and flavorful. I feel that the filling could have been filled up more as well as more brownies should be added. Also they should add some tables next to the benches so people can sit and have a place to put down the ice cream. Overall we enjoyed the ice cream as it felt good on a hot sunny day. read more

See all

I tried the nutty waffle crunch, snowmonster, and a custom concrete with brownies (used the free concrete with 1 topping after your first visit on the app) to get this. The custard itself is very good, and I do want to try the chocolate at some point but I like the vanilla too much. Of the 3, the nutty waffle crunch was my favorite and the texture worked so well together between the fresh waffle chips and nuts. The brownies had a slight chemical aftertaste but besides that liked the others as well. The app was a little confusing to use but the cashier was so helpful and kind. Really great service. It seems that you can't upload a receipt to get credit for points. There was a very short line around 2-3pm on a Wednesday. You can only order at the window or drive thru. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Nutty waffle crunch - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sanford, Florida

This is my second visit to Andy's and I'm not sure why I don't visit more. There is a huge selection of custard to choose from. They don't skimp on the additions, you can taste them in every single bite. The staff is friendly and helpful. You can go through the drive thru or walk up. There are several benches to sit while you wait and to enjoy your custard. Andy's is clean and I'll definitely be back when I want to beat the summer heat. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sanford, Florida

Lots of orders going in and not many coming out. People who ordered after us got their order before the line of people waiting. And the whole time we have 2 pints of custard that are melting. Making ice cream isn't that hard - 20 minutes and when we tried to cancel what they weren't making - it took even longer - seriously? Paid $30 for 2 pints of melted ice cream. And ti make it worse - the pints were purchased as buy one get one free and I was charged for both. Unbelievable. I just discovered this place - never knew it existed. Lived 60 years not knowing about it- I'll be fine not ever returning. read more

Stopped here for a little sweet treat and it did not disappoint. The individual taking our order was super helpful and inviting. They have a walk up window or a drive through to order from for convenience. They have benches available but I didn't see any tables to sit at to enjoy our treats. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Strawberry Malt - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sanford, Florida

See all

My gf and I went to Andy's last night (3-19-25) because I had a craving for a chocolate shake. We got there a bit later than I would've liked to but there were still a bunch of people there. I got my chocolate shake and my gf got her root beer float/shake (can't remember exactly) and it was exactly what I wanted and it hit the spot. They even gave my dog a little pup cup! The staff were very friendly, courteous and polite. My gf and I were sitting on one of the benches just talking and as they were about to close they made sure to ask and check to see if we wanted/needed anything else, even offering my dog another pup cup (to which I politely declined) Based off this single experience alone, I would/will definitely return to Andy's! read more

Really good custard. I was pleasantly surprised with its quality. They definitely don't skimp on the toppings, my concrete was packed with strawberries and chocolate. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Snowmonster Concrete - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sanford, Florida

Solid frozen custard. Some evenings the drive through line gets really long though. Could be quicker to get out and walk up but sometimes it is just busy all around. Wide array of toppings and mix-ins. One thing that you can get here that I haven't seen too anywhere else in the can put a core of something down the middle of the ocean cream. read more

Delicious custard, but be prepared to wait...Andy's is NOT a best kept secret in the Sanford area. My James Brownie Funky Jackhammer, though, was totally worth the wait. I arrived and after one look at the drive-thru line took my chances at the walk-up window. First in line and it was STILL almost a 10 minute wait...on a Friday night. The staff, however, were very polite and no one was rushed or annoyed. This custard is excellent and the peanut butter flavor and hot fudge at the center...just fantastic! I am going to have to avoid coming here because ice cream is my weakness and Andy's is very ADDICTIVE. There's also an app where you can earn points for goodies. Oh boy...my waistline is in serious danger with this place only a short drive away. 10/10 YUMMY! read more

See all

Last night I had the pleasure of having dessert at this establishment. I got one of their concretes called the Boot Daddy and it was delicious. It has vanilla custard with caramel and hot fudge and Oreo cookie pieces. The service was quick and swift. The cashier was very knowledgeable about the menu and sizes of treats. The atmosphere was very old school drive up/dive vibes. There was a drive thru or you could park and walk up and order. Overall, it was a delicious experience and I plan on coming back. That's all. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Boot Daddy - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sanford, Florida

See all

Always fantastic service! The staff is always so polite and provides exceptional service at the window or in the drive thru. Download their app for rewards. Check out their seasonal menu. My favorite is the strawberry shortcake which is seasonal. My usual orders are the snow monster, brownie overload with pecans and the turtle sundae with strawberries. read more

See all

A very convenient drive-thru, especially during the Florida summer heat! Stopped by here after work because my boyfriend and I have been craving something sweet. Of course the ice cream machine was down at McDonalds -- so we needed something close by and drive thru. Found Andy's on Yelp! It was an easy to find location and there were only a couple of cars ahead of us. You order at the window. We ordered two medium vanilla soft serve with brownies. We were not aware that they mix the brownies inside the ice cream which was nice. Our server was very friendly and made our orders quick. The only thing I would complain about is how soft the custard was. I wish it was a little bit frozen because by the time she handed us our custards, it was almost soupy on the top. Maybe it's the Florida heat. We're definitely willing to come back to try their sundaes! read more

I've driven by this place a few times and always loved the old school look. This week I finally stopped and tried it. I wanted to start with something basic so I got a small concrete (basically a blizzard) with Reese's cups and strawberries. It was pretty good. At other soft serve places, like DQ and Twistee treat, this item is approximately $4.00. Here, it was around $7.50. I'm not sure what justifies the 88% price increase. Maybe frozen custard, which this place sells, is 88% more expensive to make than ice cream? If that's the case, it wasn't an 88% improvement in taste so they ought to switch to ice cream. Despite the odd pricing, there was still a nice crowd on hand and many families dropping $50+ on their frozen custard bills. Could possibly be a difference of opinion where some people view frozen custard as a luxury item and I just don't. Oh well, to each their own... read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Concrete with strawberries and Reese's - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sanford, Florida

I inhaled this too fast to snap a photo but trust me, this is your new favorite ice cream spot! It's drive thru or walk up only which works just fine for me. I got the grandma banana pudding jackhammer (meaning they jackhammer a hole in the middle of your cup of custard and fill it with sauce. Mine was marshmallow). It had chunks of cheesecake and bananas and honestly I've thought about it every day since. Hubby got the Rico suave jackhammer and I had a bite towards the end and it was delightful-- lots of bits of roasted pecans The staff we interacted was friendly. The only reason I'm subtracting a star is because their kids menu only offers vanilla (+ a topping). Even if they expanded to the 3 basic flavors it would help parents out in that line. We were able to get our kids a small chocolate but it meant paying above kids menu prices. Either way, we will definitely be back! read more

We went tonight thru the drive thru for ONE bootdaddy concrete mixer and added Reeses peanut butter cups. My daughter had a terrible day and asked for this. We ger halfway down the road and no Reeses. She cried, another disappointment today. Couldn't you get one order right? Like really? No receipt or anything. She said "I'm never going back there again". Your ice cream costs a fortune, at least give what's ordered. I know we were charged extra and then didnt get it. read more

I'm head over heels.... and his name is Andy's. Seriously though, I've never had frozen custard until I moved to this area... but I just can't see myself going back to regular ole ice cream, especially after Andy's. Dare I say... move over Twistee's. You're probably wondering what the difference is between ice cream and frozen custard and to that I say... Google it. Nonetheless, service is quick if you hop out your car and go directly to the window. The drive thru line can get extremely long, but that's because people know the deal. It's open very late so you can grab some custard if you're in the mood for it at 10pm and you'll still see a good amount of people waiting around. Their staff is super friendly, they have a loyalty program & they have a variety of dessert options. Now onto the good stuff... my favorite (hands down) is their concrete. It's just frozen custard mixed with some of your favorite toppings. I love the BootDaddy which has chunks of Oreos, caramel and hot fudge mixed in. It's a great local spot & if you're in the area you should definitely check them out. read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sanford, Florida

Great frozen custard. A medium concrete was more than enough for me. My husband got a small and was happy with his portion size. Service was great and snappy. Love that you can see into the area where they make the custard. I'm fully confident that Andy's is hygienic. An employee was out changing the trash bags and scrubbing down the trash cans. They were cleaning the restrooms while we were there and you could tell they do a good job keeping them clean since they were some of the cleanest restrooms I've seen lately. read more

Been waiting in line for 20 minutes! You have one employee in there. Moving as slow as a turtle! Unbelievable. We love Andy's but pay some employees. read more

My wife's exact words. "I can't tell the difference. But I think I like custard better!" You made us believers! The menu has so many options but we just asked for a recommendation at the window and we got a delicious treat! The Oreo cookies were still hard so you know it was made fresh. read more

This ice cream is amazing. You guys do such a good job at making the ice cream, and the service is impeccable. I got a banana pudding concrete, and it was one of the best things I've ever had. read more

So... I've always been a Dairy Queen fan, probably because of my age and well, I just LOVE ice cream!!! Within the last year my bf and I moved closer to Andy's which I didn't want to give into.... I mean who could convince me that frozen custard is equivalent or better than the real deal!?!? So here I am, a full year later and haven't driven the extra 15 minutes to my favorite DQ in DT Sanford... sigh Now that I just read that out loud it's just plain crazy! Let's revert back to Andy's... I'm home, watching Wednesday on Netflix, while eating my "Bootdaddy Concrete" (subbed out the fudge for strawberries and added waffle cone pieces) in pure frozen custard bliss. I won't fill you in on how often we may partake in a quick trip to Andy's, but if you've been thinking about trying it out... do yourself a favor and make your 1st trip of many because... YOU WILL BE HOOKED! Xo, your DQ girl turned Andy's girl read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - S'mores Concrete & Bootdaddy Concrete (to-go) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sanford, Florida

See all

Amazing custard! I ordered the snow monster and I'm always pleased with how delicious it is. They don't skimp at all on the toppings. The service is very quick and friendly. The building has an old school feel to it which is really cute! There's also plenty of parking, I will say they do get pretty busy in the afternoons which will call for a wait sometimes but it's always worth it! read more

Andy's Frozen Custard - Snow monster - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Sanford, Florida