Best Supreme pizza I've had in decades. Great service from Drake. Large booths, good ambiance, love the wall murals.

Really good. The servers are so nice. Don't worry in West Virginia. It just feels like you're walking in a New York pizza shop with all the paintings on the wall. The mural when you walk in it's so nice. It just has good ambience. The prices are cheap get food. The only baddest thing is that the food is a little too greasy. read more

Perfect! Fast service, exactly what I wanted. Family dinner. Everyone enjoyed their meals! read more

Angelo's  Pizzeria - Personal Pizza Pepperoni, green peppers, onion and jalapeño. - Pizza Near Me - Princeton, West Virginia

So yummy! The pricing is low and you get a lot of food! Will definitely be back for more read more

Angelo's  Pizzeria - Cheese fries and mozz sticks! - Pizza Near Me - Princeton, West Virginia

See all

Cool for a local spot. I got a custom pie and a order of onion rings. It didn't wow me, but pthe pizza was decent. The onion rings, well they put me on a diet. The amount of onion rings were few. If my food would have been delivered I would have thought that it was eaten by the delivery driver it wasn't that many in there. The waitress or the server was pleasant she had a nice way about her. Next time I am in West Virginia, I do plan on eating there again. read more

Food is good prices are reasonable. Have eaten there several times same quality. Adequate parking clean restaurant. Only one bad experience and I tool it as an off day read more

The food is decent but the fact that they add an extra 20% HIDDEN CHARGE ON ONLINE ORDERS when they bill you just is shady. After getting the food, I see that my sweet douby douby bread has normal amounts of icing instead of extra. read more

Angelo's  Pizzeria - Edited some things out for privacy but this is what I see on my Bank - Pizza Near Me - Princeton, West Virginia

See all

Worse 26$ ever spent. Stuffed pizza is one pizza on top of a unsauced cheese pizza? (Poorly cheesed pizza and burnt crust on top pizza) lol shameful. The "Garlic" knots are swimming in butter that doesn't taste like garlic, just butter. Will never go back. Can't even eat the butter knots. Gross. read more

See all

I'll give it two stars because honestly, the food taste really great but the price for 2 10 inch hot ham and cheese and two little brisk ice tea in a can over $30 that's a little ridiculous and I ordered no lettuce or anything but what did the sandwiches have lettuce? They do not listen to instructions for two hot ham and cheese sandwiches and two cheap cans of brisk over $30. It won't happen again. read more

I was told Angelo's pizza was great...it was horrible. I got the barbecue chicken. The stuff pizza is a joke and basically a cheese pizza under your pizza. It's a swampy mess and the deep dish is something you can get from Walmart. Worst deep dish I've seen in yrs. Service was good I will say, but I'll never come back here. I would rather have papa John's and that is saying something. Wings Korean BBQ were great, but over all .....this place isn't very good and is lacking basic pizza etiquette. read more

Had carry out 2 times, one for subs which was good and 1 for pizza that wasn't very good. Will purchase subs someday again but not pizza.

The chicken parmigiana was terrible. It was like a piece of chicken from a store bought chicken sandwich covered in mozzarella cheese. Everything else was covered in red sauce. I know italian has red sauce but there was more red sauce than anything. There was one waitress doing everything and she did an excellent job. Maybe she could teach the cooks how to cook real italian food. read more

Oh my goodness. This place is so awesome! This is the best food I've had in the past year. There's a bit of a wait, but that's because they make their food completely fresh. It's not out of a freezer, completely hand-made, and you can DEFINITELY tell! I got a small cheese calzone, and it was the best thing I've put in my mouth. Crunchy, savory bread, gooey, greasy cheese that will leave you coming back for more. Not to mention the servers, how sweet they are! They are constantly checking up on you, asking how the food is, seeing if you need a refill, and are super patient. I could not suggest an establishment more. The atmosphere felt so comforting and beautiful. There were beautiful, large paintings on the walls that just made the place pop. I am definitely suggesting you come here. I cannot believe the sheer quality of this. I have no complaints. read more

This place has really good Philly sandwiches and eggplant Parmesan. It was also nice they delivered to the country inn hotel. I also liked their apple pizza. Their portions are quite big so you can share with someone too. read more

Angelo's has really come a long way. They're one of my favorite places in Princeton to sit down and have a cheap bite with big tables and a waiter/waitress. The food quality is good and the environment is charming. The price is fair and the parking is easy to get in and out. Full marks from me! read more

My wife and I absolutely love Angelo's pizza. We have been going here for years. We think the food is grate and the service is exactly what we expect. We like the staff and the friendly people that come here. The food is the best Italian food in Mercer county. read more

We used to go here often but the wings have gotten smaller and smaller. Last time they made me sick so I'm done. It's a shame because at one point it was great food for the area. Pizza is decent. But I'd not order chicken there. read more

Everything they have is good. Best subs and home made pizza in the area. The philly chicken is amazing.

We called ahead and arrived a few min after they told us the pizza would be ready. However when I got there it was NOT ready!! There were people eating in the restaurant but I wouldn't say they were busy. They went ahead and charged me for the pizza and told me it would be a few min. It was more like 15 maybe even 20 min before I got my pizza. Grrrr!!! That was not cool. I didn't appreciate that they charged me for the pizza before I got my order. They didn't even compensate me for my time by offering a drink or a discount. They could have thrown some breadsticks in there since I had to wait so long. NOTHING!!!! The people in this town have no idea what real pizza tastes like. This is not real pizza nor is it any good The crust was chewy and tasteless. The toppings where strange and bizarre looking. Be sure to see my pic of this gross pizza. The pizza was not good to eat nor enjoyable. The sauce didn't taste good either. The sausage - ha! It looked more like gyro meat slices, what?!! Which did not taste good. This pizza was very cheaply made and not worth getting especially the long wait to get it made. I would NOT recommend getting the pizza, after our experience I do not plan on coming back either. read more

Angelo's  Pizzeria - A very cheaply made pizza. No good taste, chewy crust, and bland sauce. The Meat lovers pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Princeton, West Virginia

Had pizza delivered to our hotel took about an hour but was delivered hot. Pretty good pie. Tasted better than it looked. Some toppings were under the cheese and some on top so it looked like it was missing a lot but it was all there. The tomatoes were very large grape tomatoes so they kept rolling off the pizza which made it hard to eat. I appreciated that they brought plates and napkins because I forgot to ask. Delivery was about $2 I think. read more

Angelo's  Pizzeria - Sausage, bacon, onion, tomato 16 inch. Tasted good. - Pizza Near Me - Princeton, West Virginia

A good place to it eat and has good delivery, only problem is the someone lied about being bitten by my service dog. He only "nosing" the boy... no blood and yet he went back and told people he was bitten...have only ordered once since. would give a 5 star, but can't, and it will be a long time before we order their good food. read more

Angelo's  Pizzeria - MY GOOD BOY JUSTA, MY SERVICE DOG! NEVER BITTEN ANYONE! - Pizza Near Me - Princeton, West Virginia

Everything that I've ever ordered from this place has been wonderful. I can't say enough about the douby douby bread. I often order it and nothing else. I love to dip them in ranch dressing. read more

This is bullshit, ordered and told it would be 30 minutes and 1 hour and 50 minutes the pizza was crap. Never order from this shithole of a pizza joint!!!! Should have gone for a-1 but not an option. read more

Ordered for delivery 2 hours ago. They charged our card immediately. Even placed a call to inquire about food twice. The first time was told your food should be there any minute. Second call 30 minutes later "let me call the driver". Very poor delivery service. No apologies and still no food. But they got their money. read more

Best Pizza place in Princeton! Never disappointed when we eat here! Great service too! Highly recommended!

Called ahead for takeout, and the pizza wasn't ready for about 10 minutes after the time we were told. And then, it was a strange pizza. I've never had anything like it. We got a meat pizza, and the meats that were on there were unusual. The list was normal but the styles of meat were odd. Here's an example: the pizza had sausage on it, but it looked almost like slices of lamb like you would get on a gyro. I think maybe they slice the sausage like pepperoni instead of using ground sausage like everyone else does. Also the ham was in little chunks rather than slices. I could get over all that, but the crust just didn't do it for me. It was bland and a little chewy. Just not what I'm looking for in a pizza. read more

Ordered pickup, Pizza and Pizza Rolls (kinda like Calzones). Affordable prices (remember, you get what you pay for and you pay for what you get), great pizza, great service (In other words, order and pickup was easy in this crazy Covid-19 world, and phone manners were very nice.) I'm from VA Beach, but when I am back, I'll be eating here! read more

This place is a hidden gem. I ordered a chicken alfredo pizza with bacon to go and it was so delicious. A few days later I dined in for lunch and had the meatball calzone. Was glad I decided to order a small calzone because it was huge! Will definitely be back soon! read more

The food was delicious! Everything was on point. We had two pizzas, a calzone & stuffed shells! read more

See all

Very good lasagna and manicotti! Great value for the price. Staying at a local hotel and decided to do takeout and were very happy we picked Angelo's! read more

Don't bother. Super slow (40 minutes turned into an 1 hour, 45 minutes) -- and no one (owner nor employee) could explain why. Keep in mind I was staying 2.9 miles away. Pizza was soggy and cold when I finally got it. Could've gone to Naples, Italy and back. read more

I like their anti pasta salads, their subs are ok. I'm not real big on their calzone's and pizza. I'd much rather use papa johns, Pizza Hut for a pizza or calzones. They don't use real sausage they use that Italian sausage instead. Same with bacon use Canadian bacon which is ham. But that's just my opinion. The waitresses are Nice! But the cooks they always yelling in different language and that's just rude and unprofessional!!! Again that's my opinion. The bread sticks with cheese however are wonderful read more

Stopped in here because of the Yelp reviews and I have to say, they weren't wrong. For a small town like Princeton, WV, the ambience is exactly what you would expect it to be, kind of a hole-in-the-wall kind of place with a lot of fluorescent lighting. Unless the place is nasty, I don't really care too much about the ambience. The service was good although the server seemed a little bewildered. I ordered the gyros with a side of onion rings and I think my friend ordered like 4 or 5 different things...literally. Once thing that was a little bizarre, was the food didn't come out all at once, it was kind of a staggered arrival, but it did all ultimately make it out. The gyros were good. It was one of those things where I didn't expect to eat all of it because they really do give you a lot of food, but once I started, I couldn't stop. They were really very good. The onion rings were good too, but they were a little too big for me (some may think that's a crazy statement), they were a touch too oily, but they gave you a lot. If I ever find myself in Princeton, WV again, I will definitely seek this place out. read more

The best pizza in Princeton WV, Ahmad and his team served us with great pride. if you going to Florida from Canada or PA you must stop here for lunch or dinner read more

Very good calzone and they had quite an extensive menu. Will be visiting Angelo's again my next time in Princeton.

Great pizza! Traveling cross country, holiday weekend, never know what you're gonna get. This was fantastic

Breadsticks and lasagna were good. Pizza was soggy and toppings had very little flavor. It was just a real disappointment. Paid over $50 for 2 pizzas, order of breadsticks and a small lasagna and we were just really hoping for more. Very soggy pizza with insubstantial crust. Sad to say a $5 hot ready would have been better. read more

After a 45-minute wait to have 2 calzones delivered, we opted to go pick them up. There were two delivery vehicles sitting at the restaurant. Our food was kind of warm. We have decided we will leave delivery to professionals like Domino's. read more

Beyond amazing! Salad was simple, yet very good. We had lasagna, chicken Parmesan with pasta, and spaghetti with meat sauce. The portions were very large, but they are tight with the bread sticks. Definitely would visit again! read more

Angelo's  Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Princeton, West Virginia

Last night we ate here and had not only an amazing time, but the food was incredible. It was even better warmed up and reheated in the oven. I had my love get the gluten free meat lovers pizza for us, since I am Celiac and gluten intolerant, and he loved it! We had the cheesy fries as an appetizer and they were delicious too. Highly recommended Even the décor is lovely...the bathrooms were lovely, and since the love of my life is Italian, he liked it. read more