They are going by Jacob's Pizza now.... They've taken away the restrooms for the customers and they've made a small room where they make the dough fresh daily. So the dough is different from before and it tastes very good. I got a small pepperoni pizza and garlic bread. They still have dine-in but only for about four people. read more

Angilo's Pizza - Full order of garlic bread. - Pizza Near Me - Milford, Ohio

See all

The medium veggie pizza was perfect! We also tried the meatball hoagie and onion rings which were delicious. We'll definitely be back.

This is not an Angilo's franchise and should not be listed as one. The sauce is not good and the crust changed as well. Hoagie rolls were way overcooked you could drive a nail with them. Just not for me. I miss the old angilo's. read more

Terrible service and food. Bring back the old pizza place. Never coming here again. Place looked run down and nobody was available take my order since I got ignored the whole time. Owners are terrible. read more

Just tried the former Angilos Pizza. Now Jacob's Pizza. This was very good! Toppings were top notch! Will be eating there again soon!

Would rate zero stars if possible. This place has terrible customer service and is a badly run business. I ordered wings by calling the store. The online price showed $8.50 and was not told on the phone of my order total. I get to the store and hand the younger lady my credit card and she swipes it saying your total is $12. Me: I ordered wings and it should be $8.50. That's not what the price says online and that's unacceptable. Her: We've changed our prices and haven't updated the online prices. Me: That's false advertising and you should honor the online price until it's fixed. Then an older gentleman(using the term loosely) says how they give more chicken than any other restaurant around and that the price of chicken has gone up and they are losing money selling the wings for $12. Again, I state that doesn't change the fact that the price should be what was advertised and that I wasn't going to pay close to 50% more than the advertised price. Sidenote: If you are losing money selling a product as a business, why are you selling it? I was told that all the Angilo's share the same menu online. I didn't think this was true and checked when I got home. I attached a screenshot of the menu and you can clearly see the address/phone number for this store on this menu and no other stores. Each store has its own menu online like I thought. I put an arrow showing the online price ad $12. I politely asked for the owner's contact information and was told they couldn't give it out. I then asked the young lady(found out was supposedly the manager) for my money back. The older man asked what I said and I repeated myself. He looked at the young lady, said give him his money back, snatched the wings off the counter and stormed to the back of the store muttering something I couldn't make out, nor did I care to. Needless to say, this will be the last time I ever order from this place. I have ordered on a monthly or better basis for years, but this is completely unacceptable. I'd rather spend my money with a business who puts their customers first. I'd love to be able to allow the owner to know how their business is being ran. Hopefully they see this and make changes so others don't have to have a bad experience. read more

Angilo's Pizza - Prices aren't correct online. Don't be tricked! Charged me $12 for wings! - Pizza Near Me - Milford, Ohio

Stopped in and asked a customer how the food was, he said it was great. Had a cheese pizza and really delicious. The Philly cheesesteak was also quite tasty. The staff were very friendly and helpful. Would definitely go back and def recommend. read more

Great pizza and swift delivery. Close to our house. Kudos to the little guys up against the giants like LaRosas, Marcos, Pizza Hut, Jets and others. Good pizza and friendly employees. We have never "eaten in" if that is even a thing with them, but the exterior of their shop is clean and well kept. Try them! read more

Literally the worst pizza I have ever had. There was only like 1 maybe 2 pieces of pepperoni on each slice of pizza which leads me to believe this is why they cover all toppings with cheese- so you don't realize how bad you were cheated lol Won't ever order again which is sad because I would rather patronize a small business instead of a chain but Donatos it is next time ‍ read more

This location continues to skimp and disappoint me on pizzas and quality. Ordered 2 large cheese pizzas and paid 3.00 to make sure extra cheese and basically kids ate doe and sauce Just horrible. Called and got credit but will never order from this location again read more

called in for delivery and the man on the phone was so friendly! His attitude was as if he loved helping me! Food was excellent and hot when it arrived by the equally friendly driver. read more

Ordered a 5 topping pizza and was so unimpressed with quality that I will not ever order again. When I walked in I noticed that they use pre-packaged pizza crust that they pull out of a bag and it absolutely tastes like crap. Next they had two kids maybe 16 making pizzas that they really didn't know what they were doing. I've never ordered a pizza from an actual pizza joint that didn't make their own dough . Do yourself a favor and order from somewhere else. read more

I got a 9'' pizza with four toppings. The price was reasonable, but I didn't really enjoy the pizza. The toppings and cheese were good, but I wasn't a fan of the bread or the sauce. The bread was spongy, and the sauce was too sweet and inconsistently distributed. There was barely any sauce in the middle of the pizza and too much near the edges. I'd come back to try the hoagies. Update (4/20/17): I tried the philly cheesesteak--not good. The onions and peppers were undercooked, and the meat was dry and flavorless. read more

Angilo's Pizza - 9 inch pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Milford, Ohio

See all

Will never order from Angilo's again. We used to be frequent customers until our large pizza and steak hoagie was not cooked all the way. We had waited 30 minutes so we were hungry, popped the food in the oven and ate. We called them and told them how their pizza was under cooked and they went full defensive mode. They asked if we could have a driver come pick up the pizza and told us they cook all of the pizza dough every morning (not exaggerating). We were not wanting any free food but maybe just a acknowledgement and apology. read more

Angilo's Pizza - Not even cooked hardly - Pizza Near Me - Milford, Ohio

pizza taste like lunchables pizza literally exactly lived by here for long time waiting to try it and wanted to like it but will not be going back lunchables pizza taste test it owners, switch something up I wanted new york pizza, I wanted italian pizza I wanted goodness and this was a young childs to go build your own "lunchable" pizza read more

Never disappointed. They sure don't skimp on toppings. I keep meaning to try other items but I just can't get past the pizza !

I had Angilos for the first time and i will never ever go back worst food ever! My order was 21 dollars which I do not think is a good price for what I received. The wings had a horrible flavor and almost no sauce they were cold when i got them. There was sauce all over the outside of my box though. The fried pickles were cold and entirely to salty they are my favorite appetizer so that being said they were the worst. The cheese fries were burnt looking and had to much cheese on them. Never going back I tried them for the first time ive heard they are not doing great business now i can guess why read more

Great selection on the menu, we had the spaghetti and meat sauce, and the steak hoagie with pizza sauce and cheese. Everything was prepared perfectly with a generous amount of their famous sauce. We will be back to try the other menu items as we are Angilo's fans now. Kim and I are realtors and and we had a client buy a home with the criterion that it must be with-in three miles of an Angilo's Pizza, now we know why! read more

Very clean, super friendly, the sauce is the same as when I was a kid, everything was fresh they care about the customers. This has to be the last Angilo's that is the same as the old days. All of the other Angilo's I've been to have been dirty and the food not so good. This one gets an A+ and I will definitely be back! read more

Wonderful food! Had an Angilo's Special pizza, wings and hoagie. All tasted great. Highly recommend!

I've eaten Angilo's my entire life. First in Springdale and now in Milford. It was here before all the chains. Always been great. Always distinctly different. Nothing fancy. Great sauce. read more

Just received our order from angilos. Have been a customer for years and have always loved the food. This was undoubtably the worst experience ever. Usually order from Milford, but My daughter accidentally ordered from Goshen tonight. Took an hour and 10 minutes to get here. Food was cold. When my daughter ordered she asked the difference between large and small hoagies. The answer given was just a smaller version. Reality is it is half a sandwich! When I called to question my bill as compared to website was told that isn't their website. They don't know who put that up???? Really? Manager reviewed charges with me when I discovered I paid 6.00 for delivery of 3.1 miles!!!! This is ridiculous. I will never order from this location again. Beware.... don't use the website and be sure to ask about delivery charge. Too many pizza places around the area to have to hassle with all this. read more

I ordered a steak hoagie with pizza sauce I received a steak hoagie with mushroom sauce call them if I wanted to bring it back they would fix it, no attempt to deliver since we picked it up and the agreed that they gave me the wrong one. Also we ordered fried mushroom and received only 6 mushroom for 2.99 what a ripoff... think twice before ordering and check your order... the owner name is Randy.. read more

Angilo's pizza is a very good alternative to the regional/national chains on the area. They have a wide variaty of items including fried chicken! Their pizza crust is a bit flowery for my taste however it has a good flavor. I would have to say the best thing about this restaurant is that they use gas ovens. When the power goes out they keep on cooking. They were the last restaurant in the area that I know of that was open after Ike hit. A- overall had to take a star for the crust. read more

Side menu is great. Good onion rings, mozzarella sticks, etc. I like their pizza, but it can't compare to real pizza. The 131 Angilo's has always offered consistent take out when I've gone. read more

Tried it for the first time because I had a gift certificate. I had a large pizza and was not impressed. The sauce was good but that was about it. I have had better frozen pizza. The crust is not fresh and very "bread" like. It tastes like it came out of the freezer. I'm pretty sure that is isn't hand tossed. The cheese is not quality mozzarella. The mushrooms are canned and the sausage was hard to detect. There are many better choices for pizza in the Milford area. Mios, Padrinos, Larosas, Donatos, The Works, and even Dominos are far superior pizza. read more