I bought a $2100 a year insurance policy on a 10 unit rental property in Loveland…read more I wanted sewer back up coverage so Christina added it to the comprehensive and liability policies I bought. So I decided to sit down and read that portion of the policy. Turns out the policy specifically EXCLUDES sewer back ups. Christina told me then that the company does not even offer sewer back up coverage in the State of Colorado. Seems to me she should have known that before she sold it to us and took a check in full for it. I had to Cancel this policy after 2 months and get Farmers insurance out of Greeley to get this property insured correctly. Then the kick in the gut comes,Christina and American Family kept a $196 cancellation fee for cancelling a policy that was not written correctly through no fault of my own. Christina just told me to contact American Family,even though she admitted she made an error. What a complete waste of time, now I have to wait for an American Family investigator to see if I am entitled to my own hard earned money. They say they are commercial property specialists, don't believe it. Hours of my time wasted on showing them the property, filling out paperwork, giving supporting documents, filing a complaint and I am still not done. I live in Berthoud and I wanted to do business locally. I will update this posting once I hear from the American Family investigator. I am not holding my breath for my $196. Update: I got another check for $3. Had to call the supervisor,Maureen, of the investigator,Sheri White, because she was not following up in the time frame she promised to,I was promised I would have an answer tomorrow the 26th of september. It has been a month since I had to cancel this policy because I was sold sewer back up coverage that does not exist in the State of Colorado by this underwriter. I am still owed $193. Will update accordingly. Update: I threatened Maureen with a complaint with the State for insurance Fraud against the Berthoud office because they sold me a coverage that did not exist. 5 days later,I was contacted by someone in their legal department saying that a check for $193 was on its way,I have received my check. But it took complaints to 2 Berthoud office people, their regional supervisor, the Supervisors supervisor, and a member of their legal department and over 5 weeks with a threat of a Fraud complaint to the State to get my money. Buy Insurance anywhere else.

While Heidi was unable to help with me was my insurance needs I found her to be personable and…read moreknowledgeable about the insurance industry. She was extremely generous with her time and helped me to understand the components of insurance I needed in my particular situation. I would definitely recommend her for your insurance needs.

Heidi helped me set up a policy for my new small business and I can't believe how easy it was! She…read morewas quick to find the best option for my specific needs and made sure I fully understood all of the coverages. On top of that she is a wonderful person. Highly recommend!

I love Rachelle! I have not used a local agent for years. I now remember why having a local agent…read moreyou can trust is so important. We have many vehicles being driven by teenagers, motorcycle for my husband and now we bought a house. Rachelle has been able to get all of our insurance needs met and at a lower rate than ANY WHERE else. I would not have been able to get everything we needed for our family with out her by our side walking us through every step. She truly cares about her clients and will go above and beyond to get the job done!! Thank you Rachelle for helping our family!!!

From the owner: Whether you're looking for homeowners insurance, auto insurance, renters insurance, or another…read morekind, I'm here to help you understand the insurance coverage you may want. Serving the Berthoud, CO area since 2002, I can help you understand your coverage options so you can protect what matters most to you. Stop by in person, reach out online or call to get a free quote today.

Very poor service, I'm wondering if they're even in business any longer since I've been calling…read moredaily for almost 3 weeks and they have yet to return a call so I can talk to a living person. Their website says they're open and so does their phone message but no one answers or calls back. My only other option is to call State Farm's home office. I DO NOT recommend Mike Bagley's State Farm Insurance office in Berthoud!

After 13 years with this agent, changed our business to another agent. Office never returned call…read morewhen we left a message we wanted to increase coverage, meaning we were trying to give them a higher premium. Office staff unapologetic for not returning call, though acknowledged receipt. Staff member completely unqualified to handle business. Sent email directly to agent to explain why we were moving our business. Thought he would want to know. Obviously he didn't mind, as not even a follow-up email in response. Extremely poor service.