Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Bake Me a Cake by Angela

    4.0 (1 review)

    Bake Me a Cake by Angela Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Bake Me a Cake by Angela

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Bake Me a Cake by Angela

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Custom Cakes 899 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Lavender Cupcakery & Dessert Shoppe

    Lavender Cupcakery & Dessert Shoppe

    4.8
    (40 reviews)
    11.3 km

    I ordered a personalized cake for my birthday. There is a two week custom order time frame!…read more I sent her my ideas for what i wanted, shape, size, and everything. She asked clarifying questions to ensure my cake was how I wanted it to be! I ordered a heart shaped funfetti cake with cannoli filling. It was DELICIOUS!! Super moist cake (unlike the dry ones from the generic supermarket) and it was sooo beautiful. I've always wanted a cake like this for my birthday and what better way to get what you want than ordering it yourself! This is your sign to stop waiting for someone else to surprise you and JUST DO IT! Also got some small cute cupcakes. Will come back here for more!

    It's unfortunate that the communication has been so poor and unfriendly. The experience felt very…read moreunprofessional, which is disappointing. While her cakes are absolutely delicious, the ordering process is unnecessarily difficult. Customers are not allowed to discuss orders in person or over the phone, which ultimately led to a mistake with my cake design. I genuinely wanted to give her business another chance because the cakes are excellent, but the way emails are handled and responded to has made that difficult. Customer service is a big part of the overall experience, and unfortunately, the communication alone makes me hesitant to spend my money there again. A more accessible and customer-friendly process would go a long way in preventing misunderstandings and improving the overall experience.

    Photos
    Cake pops for favors. I added the tags.
    Cake pops for favors. I added the tags.
    Strawberry cheesecake cups
    Strawberry cheesecake cups
    Macarons

    See all

    Macarons
    Alpine Pastry Shoppe

    Alpine Pastry Shoppe

    4.1
    (491 reviews)
    6.7 km
    $$
    Family-owned & operated
    42 years in business

    We've been to Alpine Pastry Shop several times over the years, and it has never disappointed…read more The bakery is located in a large shopping center with a huge parking lot, but finding a spot close to the store can still be challenging during busy times. The prices are definitely on the higher side, but the quality has always justified the cost in our experience. One thing that stands out is how helpful the staff is. They're always willing to answer questions and help you choose something based on your preferences, which is especially helpful given the large selection. On this visit, we tried four Rainbow Cookie Donuts and four Cannoli Rainbow Cookie Donuts. While both were delicious, the clear favorite among our group was the Cannoli Rainbow Cookie Donut. The regular Rainbow Cookie Donuts were very tasty but extremely sweet, while the cannoli version had a better balance of flavors and was more enjoyable overall. Whether we're picking up pastries for a special occasion or just stopping in for a treat, Alpine consistently delivers fresh, high-quality desserts. It's become one of our go-to bakeries on Long Island, and we look forward to coming back.

    Had to try the Rainbow Cookie Donut ! The anticipation was killing me. It is a bit pricey at $9.50…read morefor its size but it was absolutely delightful . The inside Rainbow cookie is moist and dense. The chocolate outside was one of the best chocolate hardened glaze I have had in quite some time. **This is a weekend item** The inside is full of temptation. I also grabbed Easter bread and a Crumb Cherry Pie. You can order ahead of time and slip past the line to pick up inside on the right side.

    Photos
    Alpine Pastry Shoppe
    Alpine Pastry Shoppe
    Alpine Pastry Shoppe

    See all

    Panepinto Bakery

    Panepinto Bakery

    3.0
    (20 reviews)
    5.4 km

    I'm not one to write bad reviews but this place is definitely off my list. Local to home I figured…read moreI'd try it out since Alpine had a line out the door on Saturday afternoon before Father's Day. Initially we had ordered two rolls and was told no we ordered three so we shrugged it off. I'd also like to note we were paying with a debit card and it's slightly cheapest with cash. The black and white cookie looked delicious so I opted to get one of those. When being rung up we had sticker shock. $9.31 for 1 large black and white cookie. When I said something about it the girl said she'd put it back but we felt bad so we said "no that's okay." because we both felt awkward and it must be pretty special. The apple turnover was $5.20 and lacking apples. We actually threw it in the garbage after 2 bites. All in all the items were not good and not very fresh tasting in our opinion but to each is their own. I honestly with all due respect feel some places are really price gouging since the pandemic. I get that people lost businesses and all but this place is less than a year old and the prices were not justified and not worth it might I add. I wish them all the luck in the world but don't have high expectations for this place. Sorry.

    Nice new bakery in Smithtown just south of 25 on Terry Rd…read more Lots of easy parking, plenty of room in this nice new store. Super easy to get on and out of here. Very pleasant helpful people - greet as assist as soon as you walk Tried bread, rolls, a almond croissant. They had nice cookies, cakes and gelato. in.

    Photos
    Panepinto Bakery
    Panepinto Bakery
    Panepinto Bakery

    See all

    Bake Me a Cake by Angela - customcakes - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...