Everything is fresh every day. I've been coming here for many years and I've never been disappointed. This is one of those old-school bakeries that I hope never leaves this earth. They do things the way it used to be done back in the day. Cookie trays and pastries, always stocked and presented with precision and attention to detail. The staff will always make eye contact and greet you as you enter and are happy to assist. They have a few tables and chairs set up for people to pop in for a few minutes and enjoy their feel for Italy. They offer a self-serve coffee station set up, but if you really want next level, order yourself a latte. read more

See all

I usually like the treats from this bakery, and I recently went to get a celebratory fruit tart for me and my family but the ones I received had fruit that were fried up and on the verge of rotting! read more

Dolci Momenti Bakery & Cafe - Rotten fruit on tart - Bakeries Near Me - Holbrook, New York

Shout out to the girl that helped me, who was so patient, and kept giving me cookies to keep Bruce occupied while ordering dessert to bring to my brother in laws for a barbecue at his house. My mom gave me the tip that after 3pm the donuts here are buy one, get one free. Definitely worth it because they are pretty darn tasty. There weren't many left because it was toward the end of the day, but they had the staples like a Boston crème and a crueler and a regular frosted which is what I had. The fam seemed to enjoy them as well. In all seriousness, this place has been here for a while, and there is a reason why they have stood through the test of time. Definitely a good place to stop if you need a sweet treat that's not far from the expressway. read more

Really awesome desert spot! Went in for the first time and grabbed some rainbow cookies and a cannoli. The cannoli was fresh and crsip, very good. Great experience. Already planning to go back in the future. read more

Hidden gem !! Who knew you could find the BEST Rainbow cookies on the planet in a tiny bakery in a strip mall in the heart of Holbrook!?

My go-to bakery for cakes! I tend to get things last minute so I get whatever they have on display and they're still very good. It's a cute little bakery, but you can still sit and enjoy a treat! Customer service is great and they're open later than most bakeries. read more

See all

Our hometown bakery! We love to bring bakery goods from Dolci Momenti to any holiday party. There are rarely any leftovers (aside from crumbs), and the pastries are delicious! I've also purchased cakes, pies and horseshoe rolls. Everything is exceptionally good. read more

Stopped in to get a Rainbow Cake for Thanksgiving. was told to come back later today as the baker said they should have them. I asked if I could order and pay in full and pick up after work . Told we can't do that we have no place to hold it for you. I couldn't believe it. This was seriously bad customer service. I went and got it at another bakery. read more

Over the last decade my family has ordered dozens of cakes for various types of occasions, never a deviation from the exact type of cake we order besides the writing on top. Our most recent order was for my brother's birthday. He didn't care what we ate for dinner, he didn't have a preference whether we went out or ordered in. My Brother's only request was the cake from Dolci Momenti. Sticking with tradition, the exact same order was placed. As expected with our lovely President and his Build Back Better plan, the cake was smaller than usual and the prices continue to rise. This isn't the end of the world, we've blindly supported DM over the years despite multiple mishaps because they were usually met with at least an apology if not a fair accommodation. Dinner is wrapped up, cake is served, the first slice is handed to the Birthday Boy and it's the wrong cake inside. Not only is the order wrong but of course it's something he doesn't eat. This may not be the end of the world but it was his only request and it should be a simple one to fulfill seeing as that's why you go to a professional bakery. We call DM and the employee's response is "oh, the owner isn't here." We ask for a call back. "No, you have to call back when they're here." No thanks, we had a good run. Next cake we're headed to Gargiulo's or Alpine. When you leave your business in the hands of teenagers I guess this is what we should expect. Thanks for the lack of any type of customer service, I'd almost rather someone tell me oh well deal with it vs blatantly ignoring the issue. Very disappointing as everyone always preaches brand loyalty, how about customer loyalty? Have a good one. read more

Fantastic pastries. Very fresh with good flavor. All the usuals plus some fine tuning. For example the lobster tails came in custard or whipped cream. They had a raspberry cheese bear claw type dessert. Everything we got was a 10! Can't wait to go back. read more

Friends and neighbors, Dolci Momenti hands down, has the best bakery donuts ever made! The Boston cream donuts are to die for! The jelly donuts are the best! Every donut is delicious! Always a smiling face when you enter. Friendly people and the bakery is always spotless. Warm and cozy inside! Do yourself a huge favor and check out their cakes and desserts. You will be so happy you did! read more

Picked up 4 pastries yesterday and 3 of those 4 pastries were so old and so dry that we had to throw them out in the garbage-( Holbrook location) I had the same problem a few years ago and they wouldn't let me exchange them for something fresh & edible! read more

Serive was great big selection Rainbow cookies were delicious Pignoli cookies and eclairs were great too read more

Dolci Momenti Bakery & Cafe - Bakeries Near Me - Holbrook, New York

Authentic Italian bakery with a great selection. We were visiting from out of state and this was a welcome find.

Usually a very good bakery , but today I bought a small marble cheesecake for $25 and it was not fresh . Tasted stale and not very creamy . Very disappointed. We wound up throwing the cake away . read more

Went there several months ago, asked for linzer tarts. Have purchased cookies and cakes from them before. The cake tart was stale. Called and stopped back, person at counter asked for a receipt, I had a box with several pasties. Was told they were fresh - they were not. With out receipt, nothing they could/would do. Bad answer. I haven't been back since. Alpine, many others around. read more

Great cakes, pies, rolls, pastries, and cookies! Dolci Momenti is an awesome bakery!

DONUTS! o.k. to be honest, everything is good here, but I love the donuts... if you remember donuts when donuts were REAL and not mass produced junkfood, you will want these donuts. My favorite? The Boston cream donut. Like the donuts from swanky bakeries where you take a bite and the cream is in every bite. The cheesecake is heaven. I could go on, but you get the idea. Go early for donuts. Otherwise, you won't get any read more

Their cappuccino and espresso are great . Staff is very nice and welcoming. Place looks clean and desserts look tasty. I usually buy my family get togethers desserts from this place. read more

There was a group of about ten older men holding court today. Noisy and very opinionated. I have seen similar arrangements at Dunkin Donuts. Not good for business. read more

ordered an expensive cake (vanilla) ... received a chocolate cake. called to let them know, no response. this is how they roll if you read other reviews. they lost a loyal customer. had to pay for an incorrect item that the guest of honor wouldn't even eat. read more

Yesterday we celebrated my son's first birthday and had the BEST cake ever! Everyone was impressed by how stunning the cake was! It was also delicious!!! Thank you thank you thank you!!!! read more

Dolci Momenti Bakery & Cafe - a birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Holbrook, New York

See all

Absolutely fabulous bakery. Friendly helpful counter ladies. The pastries make your tastebuds dance. I don't go as often as I would like, because, well, you know..... I'll never find my dream guy with a 500lb butt & wine barrel belly passed out with powdered sugar around my mouth because THIS place would make you do that! It's that good. I went in for a Napoleon but came out with that and a Rainbow cookie Cupcake thingy filled with a strawberry cream topped off with chocolate ganache. Heaven in the round! read more

See all

First time trying this bakery , and it's everything you can ask for !! They have a large selection of pastries and really good ice coffee ! It was a hard decision to make due to all the delicious pastries they had , but I went with a chocolate dipped jelly cookie and an ice coffee , both were so fresh and delicious ! The young girl who served me was very nice and I felt bad I couldn't leave her a tip on the credit card slip . However , this bakery is amazing and they have coffee flavored ice cubes that do not water down your coffee like regular ice cubes do ! Such a smart idea . Will be returning , hope you still have ice coffee in the colder seasons ;) ! read more

Dolci Momenti Bakery & Cafe - Bakeries Near Me - Holbrook, New York

Smells so wonderful coming in. Bought a box of cookies and the girl behind the counter was so sweet, I mentioned that I didn't remember the names of some cookies since I moved from NY 28 years ago and where I lived didn't have local bakery's (Chesapeake, Va and now Bradenton, FL) only supermarket bakery's. She was so kind when I just pointed and the number I wanted. She mention that they may open a bakery in Tampa or Bradenton. Please put me on the email list when they do move here. So fresh and delicious!!! read more

Maybe it was just not a good time to go to a bakery (Sunday early afternoon), but everything we ordered was bad. The Rum Baba was dry (how can something rum soaked be dry), the sfogliatelle stuffed with cannoli cream was DRY (cannoli cream dry means it's old), the savoiardi cookies were very stale and had been refrigerated and were guess what, DRY!! The mini Napoleons were, one guess!! I've heard such good reviews about this bakery but either we are spoiled ( from Brooklyn) , was just a bad day (Sunday?) or this place is just lousy. The only reason I gave it 2 stars were because the young lady that helped us was very pleasant. read more

My favorite bakery in holbrook/holtsville area. They always have a great selection, I'm always impressed when they have pastries stuffed with cannoli cream! Yum carrot cake so moist and rich, delicious cream cheese frosting. Their lace cookies with jelly between them are amazing! Super fresh, I have never been disappointed... only when they put it on the scale and figure price lol. read more

This is the best bakery I've ever stepped foot into. They have the best.............everything!! Seriously! Jelly donuts, tiramisu, rainbow cookies, black and white cookies, turnovers and their breads and croissants are to die for! No other bakery compares! The worst part is picking what to buy lol read more

The pasty, cakes, pies, cookies , breads and everything else in this bakery are always fresh , rich, decedent , and flat out amazing.. I have had at least five specialty Birthday Cales makes for my son and we have been delighted with every one . Thank you for being such a wonderful place to go for all my Holidays and also having great hours for when I just want to come in for desert . 10 stars read more

Yummy had a 7 layer cake and some pastries for a party. Every thing was delicious as good as little Italy. Try it you won't be disappointed.

best rainbow cookies around. moist and fresh good amount of jelly in between each layer, the chocolate on the top and bottom is the perfect amount. ratios are perfect. i love rainbow cookies and tried a lot of rainbow cookies from different places this one takes the cake. i will be back. i would post a picture but i ate them before i could remember to make this review lol. thank you :) read more

Nice and quiet place. Friendly staff, ready to help. The pastries are delicious. You cannot leave without first having a cappuccino and a cookie. mangiamo! read more

Just simply "Awesome"! Great prices Everything thing they make is amazing You won't be disappointed read more

So tasty and comforting. a throwback to how bakeries once were. Everything is fresh and newly baked. They keep quality high so don't mind paying a little more for the better products. read more

Had to be one of the best strawberry short cakes I have ever had. The girls that worked there were super friendly and very helpful. I will be a long time customer. read more

Best bakery on Long Island! Been going there for the last 20 years - for any occasion or holiday,or just to satisfy your sweet tooth!

I went to this bakery in order to get a birthday cake for one of my coworkers. When you walk in, there's a wide selection of breads,cakes, and pies. I asked the person behind the counter to explain what was in each one of the cakes. Some of them are obvious (like the carrot cake) others not so much. I ended up with the cake with the cannoli filling. How can you go wrong with cannoli filling? She wrote happy birthday on the top of the cake and I was on my way. The cake was good. I think could've been a little more airy, but good. A solid choice in the area. A+ for service, and a B+/A- for the product. read more

Great local bakery. I have never bought something from here that didn't exceed my expectations. Friendly staff, honest pricing, great selection. There is really no more you could want than what Dolci Momenti has to offer! read more

Polite service. Great raspberry cookies and the strawberry cheesecake was very tasty. Nice location in a strip mall with a few tables to sit at and enjoy a nice cup of coffee. Best bakery that I've found in the area so far. read more

We received donuts from this bakery as a gift at the office that I work at. They were the most delicious donuts I have ever eaten in my life! The entire staff was ooohhhing and awing over these donuts. I live in Commack. I'll be stopping in soon. This bakery is worth the drive. The donuts are worth the calories! read more