I've realized I'm not a fan of crepe cakes yet I still think this business is The packaging alone is the most perfect flex I've ever seen. The little cake single serve boxes, the ube cheesecake dome, the milk tea cut and lid.... All friggen next level and very appreciated. I'm definitely ordering my customized milk tea again... maybe I'll see about another desert too. I hope they do well because while I'm not a baker or into half these desserts, I can tell they are passionate about this project. read more

See all

Delicious personal-sized cake at a reasonable price, kind staff, adorable store, and clearly marked items with nuts, which is very important for someone like me with an allergy! I love that the store has crane games and declarations, making a cute ambiance. read more

Cake Fairyland - Strawberry cake roll - Custom Cakes Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

Words cannot describe how much I love this adorable place. I've tried their boba, it's great. Ive tried several of their pastries, all delicious. ( the egg tart is unmatched please try it) Here's what really set this place apart. After trying them a few times and having consistent quality & seeing what amazing/ unique creations they have, I asked if they would be able to do a custom cake. I showed them a picture of what I wanted & that I needed it kinda short notice. Price wise was very fair. They absolutely nailed it. read more

Cake Fairyland - Custom cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

I called and went to this place and there's was a sign for rent. So disappointed this placed looks like it closed down

The cakes are all really pretty but slices are pretty small, eh for their price. Packaging is pretty cute. They have pineapple crepe cakes in the fridge to hide the smell which I would say is pretty considerate. The place is very clean and usually not busy. read more

See all

Expensive, kinda dark and meh inside. Not as much cake variety as I thought and the fudge caje was dry and underwhelming. Cheesecakes look decent but otherwise could be better. read more

My girl is so happy for her snoopy cake. 10/10. I only had time to order a day in advance and they pulled it off. 1000% recommend. 11/10 as she says. read more

Cake Fairyland - Custom Cakes Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

Got the matcha cream puff... only to be unpleasantly surprised with a mouth full of MOLD. It felt as if it took the breath out of my lungs..

There are a variety of cute pastries and cakes of many different flavors which I was impressed by. I got this chocolate mousse bear for my dad's birthday as a cute treat - while it was cute, unfortunately, the taste did live up to expectation. The texture was way too gelatinous - I would've expected an airy, creamy texture for chocolate mousse. The chocolate flavor was also not very strong. The cakes and pastries were also very overpriced in my opinion. It was ~$48 for an 6 inch cake and ~$10 for this small mousse bear. You can get a much larger cake for the same price at other bakeries in NYC. Overall, the shop is cute and I would like to try their other pastries, but their prices are not very budget friendly and flavor was disappointing. read more

Cake Fairyland - chocolate mousse bear - Custom Cakes Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

If you are looking for a custom cake that looks amazing and tastes delicious THIS IS THE PLACE! I was a little nervous at first as I had never bought from this bakery before but it had some good reviews and really wanted to surprise family for a birthday party. The baker replied so quickly and really helped me bring the cake I envisioned to life. Not only did they do an amazing job with the design, but the cake was soft and the icing was full of flavor!! I am so grateful, 100% give them a try!! read more

Cake Fairyland - Custom Cakes Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

Hello boba tea and assorted desserts! I am just browsing my way around Stony Brooke and was happy with my purchase (about 10 minutes before closing time actually, the servers were so kind!) It's beautifully decorated and I loved the generally very open design/decor. I haven't tried cakes here, but it's definitely on the To-Do list. Ordered: Grapefruit Green Tea 50% Sugar (You can only do 50% or 100%) Brown Sugar Bubble Milk Tea Machine shook teas so no need to go crazy with the straw. And they come in such cute bottles makes you wanna INSTA CHEERRSS~ read more

See all

Yet another wonderful addition to the diversifying scene on Long Island. Inside you won't find rainbow cookies or biscotti, but rather cream puffs, egg tarts, crepe cakes and more! I ended up ordering a simple taro bubble tea with a matcha cream puff. Service was relatively quick and helpful. The bubble tea came in a cute container with plastic ears on top and whether it was purposeful or not, it also came with a purple straw to match the taro's hue. The taro milk tea was excellent. Not powdery, plenty of earthy taro flavor. The boba itself, nice and chewy. The cream puff, had plenty of cream in the middle, with a tender crust surrounding it. My only gripe is that there was a dusting of matcha on top that was a bit too much. Gave the puff an unpleasant bitterness. But, is that one factoid going to stop me from coming back to try all of their offerings? Not at all. Give it a try! read more

Cake Fairyland - Custom Cakes Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

My kids are giving this review because they love anything unique and different when it comes to food. They love their crepe cakes and enjoyed filming the chocolate mouse dog being eaten although they thought the taste was MEH. Overall, they enjoy the crepe cakes especially the rainbow one. read more

See all

This is my second year ordering a birthday cake from here, and once again it was perfect. I only showed them a photo and they brought it to life beautifully. The cake looked stunning, tasted fresh, and the ingredients were clearly top quality. I wouldn't go anywhere else for cakes. read more

My annual visit to LI isn't complete without a visit to Cakefairyland. Loved the coconut coffee latte and the strawberry crepe cake. Hubby got the mango milk shake and really enjoyed it. The taste of the drinks and cake were on-point! The kids had the rainbow cake and cheesecake and loved it. Thank you for such yummy desserts cakefairyland! Can't wait to return next time, wish there's one closer to home. read more

See all

Cute place. The desserts are eye candy; you will be tempted to try everything. We ordered the brown sugar boba tea, sugar cane fruit tea, and crepe cake. The wait was quite long, and the prices were pricey. Unfortunately, everything tasted like water. I don't know if it was a bad day for them, but it was not worth the trip there. read more

See all

I really hate to leave bad reviews, especially when it's something I was so excited to try. I loved that there's another Asian bakery option on town that is cute but I was honestly so disappointed. The slush drinks were ok but everything comes from a powder (but I guess that's normal). The iced coffee did not have milk/creamer so we asked for creamer. The girl had to smell the carton of half and half to see if it was fresh...? This is very weird to do in front of the customer. The sesame crepe cake was very dry and bland. I was not able to finish it. The chocolate pup was cute but it tasted like watered down mousse, it was not good but my kids liked it, probably because it was adorable. I'm glad we only ordered two pastry items, it was pricey but I did not mind since it was eastern Long Island, however, I can tell the pastries were not fresh, they might want to limit their selections and focus on freshness instead. read more

See all

For the Suffolk county bakery scene this is a great new addition, adding a good flavor representation for black sesame, egg, and taro desserts. I really enjoyed the crepe cake which had a lovely black sesame layer coating the top of the cake and a good ratio of crepe to topping. Also, it was not too sweet something that is a huge plus in my opinion. Other desserts while good flavor wise were a bit off in texture. The taro pastry and the egg tart were a little dry. The bakery staff was very friendly and placed all desserts in cute boxes that could be nicely presented for sharing with family. In total I would probably say this location is a solid 3.5 stars. However, there are limited options in Suffolk county and the flavors still represent the desserts well so I bumped them a bit since 3 stars would be unfair. I will definitely return for another crepe cake as it's on par with other versions of the crepe cake I've had. read more

WOW. WOW. WOW. Just found this adorable and mindblowingly delicious place tonight. What a delight! Cannot wait to visit again and try more of these wonderful treats. The service was awesome too. read more

Cake Fairyland - Peach Lychee tea and Oreo Crepe cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

Cute dessert place. A bit pricy but a good variety of treats. They have a selection of asian baked goods and cookies. A huge selection on cakes. The mango pudding is good. Not overly sweet. We had tried the taro cream puff and it was delicious. Tons of cream with a good taro flavor. The drinks are okay. Ive definitely have had better. read more

See all

I have been so curious about this place since I saw the sign go up ages ago. I have to say, it well exceeded my expectations. The store itself is so cute, and it has entrances on both sides of the building which is fantastic for parking. The interior is so cute! Love the marble tables and the chairs, looks like a great place to study. Everything is clearly labeled and the staff were so knowledgeable and attentive. They have bubble tea with the cutest cat-earred covers. I got the Peach Rose at half sweet and it was pretty tasty. But the sweets are the the star. I got the Rose Mille Crepe cake and it was so light and floral that I was in love at first bite. I also got shortbread cookies that were so tasty and buttery! Will need to go back to try the puffs and egg tarts! So glad this place finally opened. read more

See all

Very delicious birthday cake! Perfect for party. Friendly derive with great communication!

Came here again visiting family, had their new summer favorite drink Blueberry Yogurt bubble tea! It is so refreshing and yummy! Ordered a strawberry mousse cake for a birthday and it did not disappoint! Keep up the good work! read more

See all

Food: pretty good! The highlight was the taro puff. The puff was delicious and the texture was perfect, a little crunchy at the top thanks to the caramelized sugar, the rest of pastry was nice and soft. The cream filling was really tasty too. I also got a pork floss pastry that was actually really good! I wasn't sure what to expect. It had a nice balance between sweet and salty (it was mostly savory with a hint of sweet, I recommend it). I was a bit disappointed with the rainbow crepe cake, it lacked the flavor I was looking for. Kind of bland. I'd want to see what their other flavors taste like. Atmosphere: clean, but not trendy or anything like that. I think I saw maybe 2 tables with 2 chairs each. We ate outside on the picnic tables. Price: a bit on the pricey side, but it wasn't too bad. read more

See all

Very cute and nice pastry/bubble tea place. They have many desert options and all the cakes are delicious. read more

Cake Fairyland - Custom Cakes Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

See all

Have already been here a few times already, and love it every time. The food & drinks are so good, and the atmosphere is adorable (they even have claw machines), as well as the different pastries. The staff is so sweet, considerate & attentive, and will ask any questions you have. Service is very quick as well, you can be in and out in a few minutes. Planning on getting a birthday cake from here, the example cakes look so pretty, and I'm sure they are delicious. Highly recommend stopping by for a quick sweet treat. read more

See all

This was my first visit here and I wasn't disappointed! I got the brown sugar milk tea boba and it was delicious. Not too sweet and the boba were the perfect texture. I also bought the rainbow crepe cake and Castellan cake. Both were fresh and delicious. I never had either before and I would absolutely get them again. The Castellan cake was so soft, it melted in my mouth. I bought a taro cream puff and regular cream puff as well but we haven't tried those yet. I'm sure they will also be delicious! read more

Cake Fairyland - Rainbow crepe - Custom Cakes Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

See all

Such an adorable place with great pastries and bubble tea! Since discovering, my husband and I have been back many times to try all the different goodies they have to offer. Staff is always very friendly and we love the atmosphere there. read more

Cake Fairyland - Oreo crepe Triple chocolate mousse - Custom Cakes Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

See all

Beautiful desert, coffee and tea shop We had a strawberry crepe cake that was delicious and light as air. The Japanese cheesecake was beautiful and tasty. Not as sweet as what we were used to but very good The drinks come in the most adorable animal cups We had the strawberry fruit tea w/boba it was great and my decaf latte was delicious. We will definitely be back read more

Wow... I am surprised to find this pastry shop all the way out east on Suffolk County. This place is delicious. I bought numerous crepes cake to try out. YOU MUST try out the Boba Milk Puff. It is very good and you won't find these type of cakes unless you go back to Queens. They also have tasty Boba milk tea and other drinks. I didnt take photos but i took some videos on my YouTube channel. So heavenly, even my cat wants to eat more! https://youtu.be/ZkkjRMbTX8I https://youtu.be/Df4fwStZ-qo read more

Decent desserts and very clean! Would go here again! The egg tarts are my fav in Suffolk!

I love the boba and baked goods here! So delicious and the service is always friendly and quick! They have tables if you want to eat there also, it's very nice inside! Highly recommend! read more

Absolutely adorable Been looking for a traditional Asian bakery on Long Island for years! My new go to spot! Crepe cakes are amazing read more

Got to try a bunch of different flavored crepe cake slices from this place that friend brought to a gathering. They were light and just the right amount of sweetness. All the flavors we tried were tasty so I can't wait to go back to try more things! read more

Unbelievable cake! I want to go there everyday. Such pretty decorations and fluffy golden cake. The ppl are super friendly too. read more

The mango green tea and peach lychee fruit tea was good. Blueberry cheesecake crust was very hard to cut through. The tiramisu was light and had good coffee flavor. read more

Thanks cake Fairyland, I ordered two cakes for my daughter 's birthday, everyone loved her cute bunny cake.We likethe sponge cake base, and whipping cream frosting. It's light and not overly sweet. This birthday cake made my daughter so happy. read more

Cake Fairyland - Custom Cakes Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

See all

After reading all these great reviews we were excited to try It. Girl behind counter was non responsive to any questions Specialty seems to be the crepe cakes . It was not crepe layers at all. It was an edible paper with a tasteless unsweet cream between the layers. The other hazenut pie had no flavor ever. Bill came yo $17.01 for two small pieces. Gave her a $20 . Even with a comment asking to let it slide we received $2.99 back .seriously???? We expressed our disappointment when leaving and didnt even receive response just a blank stare. read more

Came in the day before a birthday party to order a special cake and they were so helpful and worked in a timely manner! Such a beautiful shop and smells delicious. Their boba is amazing, recommending the yogurt flavor! read more

Cake Fairyland - Strawberry box cake - Custom Cakes Near Me - Stony Brook, New York

See all

I love all the attention to detail though the boba tea has a weird after taste but it's still so adorable inside and out I would for sure go again read more