We always enjoy our time at "The Stag", including its more formal, supper club style, including…read moresigning in upon arrival, the lack of reservations, time at the bar before dinner, dark, dimly lit ambiance and interesting pictures on the wall. However, as with the most interesting places to eat, there is a certain way things are done here. First, you do not have many choices, and it's better that way. They know what they do well and they stick to it. First, you will have bread service and salad. The salad will be served as a quarter iceberg head, which you will cut up and apply three available dressings. The dressings can be applied individually, but are meant to be mixed. If done appropriately, you will have a soup of dressing after finishing your salad. I have never experienced a salad service like this anywhere else, and it is really fun to watch the uninitiated experience it for the first time. Second, you will get one of few protein options: beef filet, porterhouse, ribeye, or a few other, non-beef options, like swordfish, haddock, and chicken. Most people probably get the steak, and of any restaurant I have been to, this is one that you will get the exact doneness level you specify. Do not undercut your doneness to anticipate an overcooked steak - if you order medium rare, that is what you will get. The steak is delicious and is served from the open charcoal grill to your table via a charcoal heated platter, complete with a ladle of flavorful au jus. You can even watch the grill master prepare your steak; it is a unique and fun experience unlike any other restaurant I have been to. Third, you will receive a baked potato with sour cream and chives. Options aside from this are grilled onions and mushrooms. Fourth, you can get an ice cream drink for dessert, and that is about it. Very simple, very well done. It is refreshing to know a place that so understands their strong suits that they do not offer options they cannot deliver on. There are not many things left up to chance here. You will get the salad, you will get the potato, and you will get the steak or protein you ordered in the level of doneness you specify. And I am sure you will really enjoy the whole process.

If you're local, you know how amazing this place is, and if you're a visitor let me explain to you…read more This place is one of the best restaurants you can dine at. The food is immaculate, service is top notch and the price is more than fair considering the quality! My wife and I had the ribeye "Dave's way." This will be one of the best steaks you never knew you had to try The flavors are bold, and the steak just melts in your mouth. Everything starts with a head of lettuce and 4 salad dressings, french, clear, russian cream and caesar garlic. Dinner rolls are also included. We also ordered mushrooms and onions to go with the steak, both grilled to perfection. Lastly, you get a russet potato loaded with butter, I recommend also getting the cheese and chive topping in lue of sour cream. While the food is fantastic, our server was the star of the show! Cyndy gave us 10 star service! It's no surprise considering she has been serving her for 37 years wow! So attentive, very nice with a bright smile and clearly knows everything about this place! Last thing I will note is that I ordered "The Robin." An old fashioned with maple syrup, very tasty. As this was my birthday dinner we received a blackberry sundae This supper club has been around since the mid 1956 and clearly has a vibe that fits that era. The inside charcoal grill is clearly what separates this place from almost anything else you will find.

Place is great. Alway treated us right. This place always had a really good food atmosphere…read moreeveryone treated us good and I was never upset to spend my hard earned money here

This place is awesome !! Great food , seafood , steaks…read more Ricona the owner is super friendly and cares about the food she serves Suzie her mom may be there too and is very nice , family owned over 40 years They have a great variety on the menu, and all food is hand done Can not recommend enough!!

We have gone to Ed's in October the most. He has for a few weeks German dishes that are all…read moreunbelievable! The duck is my favorite. I also tried the Venal Schnitzel. Either one you can't go wrong with. It is well worth the drive. The menu covers everything you could possibly think of. Steaks,fish,chicken and sandwiches. The service was also great. Our waitress had quite a sense of humor which added to our great time there. Along with friendly bartenders and a cozy back room to eat in, you will not be disappointed. Tom S.

We have been patrons at Ed's every Friday all summer, but no longer. Prior to being seated tonight…read morewe were asked if we were "the couple that always orders appetizers". We aren't, but thought it odd we were asked that. Then we were seated in the dining area, but sat there for 20 minutes and no one took our order, or even said a word to us. During this 20 minutes, I watched two kitchen staff try to stomp something, then stop when they saw me looking at them through the window. The blond waitress with a pony tail then looked at the bottom of the baking rack within the dining area, which prompted me to do the same. I saw what looked like a mouse, right next to a table of dining patrons. As I continued to wait for 20 minutes for our food order to be taken (never happened)I watched the mouse move around and eventually disappear, I can only assume right back into the kitchen. Neeless to say we left the premises and will not be back EVER. Do better Ed's Main Street, and call an exterminator while you are at it.

This place is an absolute must-have in Eagle River! For our family night out we all decided this…read morewas our unanimous option! The Cheese Curds were absolutely fantastic, we killed 3 plates with no issue (there were 9 of us). Most people got the pan fried Walleye, i would say it's a specialty of the restaurant and NOONE WAS DISAPPOINTED!!! Our waitress forgot to bring out our salads but there was so much food no one even cared! Each dish came out perfectly hot and delicious. When you're in the North Woods you absolute have to stop here! They've got a great ambiance and the food was fantastic, stop in and enjoy the best meal you'll have all week!!

This is a perfect little up north spot. The wait for a table was about 30 min. The service was ok-…read morethe waitress seemed to get flustered and confused when we asked for separate checks (but ended up doing it anyway)- she just kept repeating there's an atm. The food was pretty solid. My only complaint/concern was one of my daughter's chicken strips were not cooked- thankfully I was cutting them when I found out. Everything else seemed to be normal be type food.

Wow!! What an awesome find thanks to the Supper Club coupon book! We drove 90 minutes each way to…read moreexperience this awesome restaurant! Service was great and the food was amazing! We had the goat cheese balls as an appetizer...wow!! It was awesome! My tenderloin was very tasty and the mashed potatoes and broccolini was very good! Then, dessert!! OMG - the BEST turtle cheese cake I have ever had! I highly recommend this restaurant!! Enjoy!

Visited with a group of 10. They were very accommodating and friendly. Drinks at the bar were well…read moremade. Menu is modern American. Everything was delicious. They were able to accommodate dietary restrictions (gluten). Atmosphere was casual however still a good special dinner location. Highly recommended.

Everything was great! Atmosphere, service, pre-dinner drinks, the old fashions were excellent. We…read moredid get there right at opening and the parking lot was full ( always a good sign), our wait was only about 15/20 minutes. However when we left it was about a 2 hour wait, so just be prepared to wait as there are no reservations taken. Worth the wait, 2 full bars to help pass the time.

Best steak dinner in town. Insanely good service, great drinks, zero complaints. Very reasonably…read morepriced. Maddie the bartender was also great while we waited to be seated.

Nice downtown restaurant, friendly service and fair prices. We decided to go there after viewing…read moretheir website which featured German food. Once there we were told that the website is owned by someone else and the new owners couldn't make changes and no German food. Not sure if these new owners are very experienced in food service. Little things like the awkward way they served the food and drinks (hand over the top of the glass) seemed to suggest they're new at this Nonetheless, the food was excellent! Great selection of dishes and tap beer. I'd say give them some time to get things figured out and it'll be a great 5 star restaurant!

We came here around 5:15 pm on a Sunday. We were seated immediately, there were only 2 other…read moretables. We ordered cheese curds which I felt were good but extremely greasy. My salmon was okay, I didn't like the garlic sauce on it. My entree came with a salad or for $1 more a soup. My husband's Mac and chicken was amazing. I should have ordered that. We ordered cheesecake for dessert. It was pretty good, but not worth the $10 price tag. I usually pay $7-$8 for a cheesecake of that size. Large selection of wine and beer.

mashed potatoes were like soup and I doubt they were real potatoes…read more I ordered a boneless ribeye, the entire circumference was gristle which tells me that was not a ribeye. The other three in my party were also dissatisfied with their meals. We also wanted a side of onion rings and they didn't have onion rings that night which is interesting ?

Good food. Not cheap. They have a horrible policy of advertising a special, but running out. And…read morewhen they do, they don't even try to make the customers happy with some other substitute.

We consistently have great service and food here. Tonight we had the prime rib and shrimp scampi…read more We also tried the escargot for the first time here, and it was fantastic! The prime rib was perfectly seasoned and melted in your mouth. The shrimp scampi sauce was super flavorful with excellent jumbo shrimp. The restaurant is really cute inside with a nice bar and a big deck with outside seating overlooking Half Moon Lake. We also love their Friday night fish fry, the old fashioneds, and ice cream drinks. As another reviewer mentioned, literally the only thing that would make this place better would be larger water glasses

After living in Minnesota years ago we have not been in a Wisconsin Supper Club for a very long…read moretime. Traveling from Minneapolis through Wisconsin on our way home to Ohio we found ourselves in Tomahawk, WI. Using YELP to find the best restaurants in the area we decided to try the Birch Supper Club which was ranked as the # 1 restaurant in the area. The Silver Birch Supper Club was more than what we hoped to find. The food was spectacular and the employees were so kind and helpful (my wife has some serious health problems). Our server, Oriana, was extremely kind and understanding. Being in Wisconsin I felt obligated to order a Brandy Old Fashioned, and it was one of the best drinks I have ever had! Hats off to you ma'am. We live in Cincinnati, but we are already encouraging our daughters to bring their families to the Tomahawk area and to go to the Silver Birch Supper Club on vacation. If I could give this restaurant 6 stars, I would.

Brats were outstanding as usual, but the service this visit is the reason for my review. We watched…read morethe young man (Jorden)behind the counter juggle 3 customers at once. The patience he showed with the woman placing an order in front of us almost made us cheer when she finally left with her steaks. His smile showed us it wasn't his first rodeo. I think I can speak for most part time residents: if your employees enjoy their job- it makes the customer want to come back! See you next summer!

Owners/Butchers are very knowledgeable and helpful. Excellent selection and variety of meats as…read morewell as many speciality products. You can have virtually any steak , chop cut to your liking.