Bills Bake Shoppe is owned by Bill Cast. He has been baking since he was 8 years old in his…read morefather's bakery, he is now in his 70's. If you want Authentic Italian Pastries look no further. Come to Mahoningtown... It's worth the trip! Tell Bill Kenny sent you.

This is where we stop every time we drive in from Pittsburgh to visit old friends. I have long gone…read morerelatives from this area and grew up in New Castle. You won't find many bakeries left like this. I've never had anything bad from here!!! We're on way next week! love talking to whomever is working. Great service!

Cookies and Candies by Christy is a small local business that creates and sells homemade desserts…read moreand some sides. I have purchased from this businesses numerous times. Please note that I have ordered this food only through the Market Wagon website. Here are my reviews for the foods that I have bought: Lady lock cookies - 5 stars - These cookies had a flaky and moist outer shell and were filled with a wonderfully sweet cream. My husband loves lady lock cookies, and these cookies met his high expectations. Cookie sampler - 5 stars - The sampler contained cookies such as buckeyes, snickerdoodles, a seven-layer bar, and peanut-butter blossoms. One cookie was minty and was just OK. Strawberry pretzel pie - 4 stars - This pie had pretzels on the bottom and then strawberries, a jello-like substance, and whipped cream on top. The pie had a unique and sweet taste. S'mores - 5 stars - These s'mores were not typical s'mores. The marshmallow and graham crackers were on the inside, and the chocolate was on the outside rather than the inside. These s'mores were a tasty treat. Chocolate-dipped stroopwafels - 5 stars - These stroopwafels had a caramel filling and were covered in milk chocolate. I have eaten authentic stroopwafels in the Netherlands, and these ones tasted just as great. Chocolate-covered bacon - 4 stars - This combination of flavors was OK. The milk chocolate did not make the bacon soggy. Pasta salad - 4 stars - The ingredients of noodles, vegetables, and pepperoni were very fresh. Sfogliatelle - 4 stars - This sfogliatelle tasted sweet and had some citrus peel inside. The dough was NOT flaky as it was supposed to be. Snickerdoodle cookies - 5 stars - These snickerdoodles tasted exactly how they were supposed to taste, and they are one of my favorite types of cookies. Banana bread - 5 stars - This banana bread was moist and flavorful. Pecan tassies - 5 stars - I have eaten this dessert only once in my life, so it was new to me. The cookies were very fresh, and I liked the sweet sugar and pecans. Pineapple upside down cake - 4.5 stars - This pineapple upside down cake was moist and had a subtle flavor of pineapple. Chocolate-covered Oreos - 5 stars - These Oreo cookies were covered in milk chocolate and tasted very good. Carrot cake roll - 5 stars - This carrot cake was moist, and my husband enjoyed the icing. Cheesecake cup cookies - 4 stars - My husband liked these mini cheesecakes. Chocolate-covered strawberries - 5 stars - I have ordered these strawberries multiple times. These strawberries are always a large size, are covered in delicious milk chocolate, and are not soggy. Banana pudding dessert - 4.5 stars - This pie contained Nilla wafers, vanilla pudding, some slices of banana, and icing. It tasted very sweet. The Nilla wafers were no longer crispy. Zucchini bread - 5 stars - This zucchini bread had a moist center and a crispy crust, and I liked the flavor.

I placed an order of several hundred dollars for fresh cookies and 3 days past the agreed upon…read moredelivery date I received moldy cookies. Christy has since stopped responding to all correspondence and despite agreeing to refund my money she has not done so. It's been 10 days since I requested the refund and she will not respond to me. USPS has confirmed she did not pay for guaranteed delivery therefore they are not liable for the late delivery. I would not recommend wasting your money here. Really disappointed as these were for my wedding.

Always our go to spot for donuts. We have enjoyed them…read moresince we were little kids. Our favorite is the Maple cream filled. But honestly, they are all delicious!!

Delicious, they are the only to eat in New Castle. The glazed twists bring me back to the 1970sread more

This bakery has been out of business for over 30 years. When it was in business they had the best…read morebread and baked goods in town. My mother would always travel from Wampum to New Castle to get my birthday cakes from them. I miss the this place.