Stopped here for a breakfast sandwich when working nearby. I was drawn in by the unique and funny business name plus the great reviews and delicious looking food in the pictures. I opted for the bacon, egg, and cheese on their semi-hard roll. It was a delicious and hearty breakfast. The staff were friendly, though the line to order was slow moving. Once I ordered, the sandwich came out wrapped in foil about 8-10 minutes later. They do have a few tables if you want to sit and eat there, but I took my food to go. It is setup to order at the counter then you wait for them to call out your order when it is ready. The pizza operation looked legit and smelled great. They were already firing pies and serving up slices in the morning when I was there. Next time, I definitely want to try the pizza. read more

Two Fat Guys And An Oven - Bakeries Near Me - New Castle, Pennsylvania

Everything I have had from here has been outstanding! Pizza, pepperoni rolls, fresh, baked, bread, and pastries are all of the highest quality! read more

Great service and selection. The pizza and the sweets... can't be beat. This place was such a great find. Would come here every time I stumble through town read more

Best desserts around. Unreal! Best pies, cakes and cookies I've ever tried. Coconut Cream Pie is to die for!

If you're in town check this place out! Fantastic bakery, pizza, among other things. Talked to the folks that worked there and they were great. Great experience and wish we lived closer. read more

We were in the area and decided to find a local bakery and gosh this place did not disappoint! We always get a large variety of items to sample and we're thrilled with the large selection. We ran into a local upon our arrival who made solid recommendations. Our favorite item was the snuggles. It's almost like a puffed pastry dough with cinnamon sugar twisted in. It was flavorful and delicious. Everything we tasted was yummy! The scones are another item that deserves a shout out. We had already eaten pizza, but the pizza they had looked delicious too! read more

See all

Was looking forward to this place because of the catchy name. Very disappointed with the food and atmosphere. The place is very small, tried pizza was only ok. Got some pastries also only ok. Staff was doing their job but not overly friendly. Bread looked good but did not try it. I won't be returning. read more

The taste was excellent. We got their Easter Bread and it was delicious. We had the lemon flavored, it came with icing and sprinkles.

Great food & pastries We had a strudel and it was delicious. We also bought some other pastries to bring home

Love this place! They are friendly, and helpful. The food is good. Love everything I have tried. I went in one day on my way home and just wanted a 2 pieces of pizza for lunch. I stood there waiting for help and this lady came in and came right in front of me and took the rest of the pizza. They felt so bad and made me a pizza. Love the meatball sandwich and their bread. If you're ever in New Castle and see Two Fat Guys and an oven stop in, you won't be sorry. Just heads up there a busy place but well worth it! read more

Wow so flippin good! Everything is freshly made from the pizza dough the sauce, excellent quality. I got the chocolate chip cookies and they are fat thick and moist was just enough crispiness on the outside to give you that texture where it's a little crunchy but soft. I also got the peanut butter cookies with a chocolate drop in the center and it taste like a homemade peanut butter cookie where you can taste real peanut butter, the chocolate drop is an actual delicious tasting piece of chocolate not immitation. 1000 times better than the Amish cookies that we usually buy out at the cheese house or at Apple castle. These cookies are simply better ingredients, fresh and taste better. We are from out of town, but we're going to make this a stopping point every time we're in Newcastle. My only regret is I didn't buy more stuff! read more

Two Fat Guys And An Oven - Bakeries Near Me - New Castle, Pennsylvania

See all

Really great homemade bread and pizza. Breakfast sandwiches are amazing. Recommend to everyone that I know. Staff is always great as well. read more

Everything is always wonderful and fresh. They offer a large variety that makes deciding what to get extremely difficult.

Great food, the place was clean and the employees were nice and understanding. When I get my taxes I will be going there again read more

Two Fat Guys And An Oven - Bakeries Near Me - New Castle, Pennsylvania

If you find yourself in New Castle, be sure to stop by Two Fat Guys and an Oven bakery for some fresh delicious Italian baked goodies. The Cannoli are incredible! They have fresh baked Italian bread, flatbreads, pepperoni rolls, pastries, cookies, rolls and buns. There is also a soup, salad and sandwich menu and a small dining area to enjoy your baked treats with coffee or to have a nice fresh baked lunch. read more

See all

Excellent baked goods. The cinnamon sticks with maple icing are absolutely our favorite.

This has got to be the best bakery around!!! You just can't make up your mind once you enter the building, too many goodies to choose from!! Lots of different kinds of bread daily, (good old homestyle is still my favorite though, perfect). Get there early though! Cinnamon rolls are my favorite, melt in your mouth. Be sure to buy extra, put them in the freezer. Few seconds in the microwave and they are delicious!! Everyone is friendly and the prices are very reasonable. I would highly recommend, every time we're in the area we stop. I can't imagine how anyone could give them a bad rating (as I've seen here from a few). We've been buying from them for years and have NEVER had one thing that wasn't delicious and we've bought for many friends over the years and they are all in agreement. read more

We went to this bakery during our visit to Pennsylvania. They have a wide selection of freshly baked breads,pastries and cookies. They have a few choices for cakes and they make sandwiches,too. Definitely coming back the next time we visit my in laws. read more

What a delightful surprise to find this hidden gem of a bakery. i love the fresh baked bread and there are so many pastries, cookies, bread-bowl soups, and even pizza, plus more to choose from. Worth the trip. 10/10 read more

Be still my heart! What a Sweet place to stop by to fill my sweet tooth! Another Yelper said "if you're ever in New Castle, this is a must stop" they were sooooo right! I would imagine the selection would've been better in a Saturday had we arrived earlier, but we were thrilled with our purchase! Due to COVID we are in the car, although, there are a few table set up if you wanted to eat in.. My hubby got the "The Booky" breakfast sandwich and it was Huge! Definitely enough for two, although he devoured the entire breakfast sub! He says it was the best breakfast sandwich he has ever had! I got a egg, sausage, cheese sandwich and it was very good. I ended up eating it open face to save calories for the sweets we bought. We barely made it out if New Castle before polishing off a Cannoli & Vanilla Shoe Horn. The Cannoli was very tasty and had a hint of orange to it. Now, that Vanilla Shoe Horn....Oh my....It was sweet, Flaky and Delicious!! Soooo good!! They are called "Two Fat Guys" for a reason. Portions are Huge and they spare no calories! Do Not Miss this stop when in New Caatle!!! We will be back next time we're in town. read more

Love this local shop for breakfast sandwiches--remind me of NYC bodegas for a meal on the go. The oatmeal chocolate cookies are a must!

This is the worst bakery I've ever been in and believe me, I'm in a lot. I have one weakness, baked goods. I'm a sucker for baked goods. When we found this place with such a catchy name I pulled in without hesitation. That was a mistake. The space is tiny so there was no space for social distancing. I marshaled on because their goods looked delicious, but alas, looks can be deceiving. How can you make a cream filled doughnut that isn't sweet? And what is that taste that clung to my mouth for over 30 minutes. The same thing goes for the pumpkin cinnamon rolls. Maybe we got the wrong things or maybe they forgot the sugar. I don't know but I won't chance it again. read more

Great variety of fresh bread & cookies available in this small bakery! They serve sandwiches and donuts too. Well organized display cases show items to choose from, and rolls, buns and loaves of bread are on racks become the counter. read more

Two Fat Guys And An Oven - Fresh & yummy! - Bakeries Near Me - New Castle, Pennsylvania

Stopped in at the new place. Love the new space. Had sandwiches which were awesome - Philly Steak & Italian Sub. Tried several pastries & brought some home for later. Good food. Great staff and service. Highly recommend. read more

We got pepperoni cheese bread here and it was a lovely road brunch snack. When we arrived nobody was around then a sudden rush. They had a variety of pull apart breads, excellent looking classic breads for subs or toasting, and some great looking cinnamon buns. We'd return. read more

I love this place! No trip home to New Castle is complete without at least one trip to Two Fat Guys and an Oven. This time I got the salted onion bread and pecan cups and a stromboli. They have quite a few choices of fresh made breads, a few different featured each day. The salted onion rye was a hit! They will slice it for you, but I like to slice it myself.The stromboli was lunch for 2days. Very good with pepperoni, sausage, peppers and sauce. Bread was soft and fresh. The pecan cups were ok. A little dry. They also make sandwiches and a different soup each day. Don't pass this place up! read more

Really wished this place was better but its probably the worst bakery I've been to. For a bakery, the quality of their baked goods is worse than any bakery I've ever had. I thought their name was creative though. Otherwise, I'd look somewhere else. read more

Love this,bakery! The only place I know of where I can get the best peppers and eggs on a fresh roll! Pastries arw freat and dont miss the meatball subs! Great place!!! read more

Cookies and pepperoni rolls are fantastic!! My favorite place to go for baked goods and the staff is wonderful!

I ordered cookies for my son's wedding which was in Evansville, Indiana, I live in Hockessin, Delaware. My friend picked them up in New Castle on her way to the wedding. I cannot tell you enough how delicious and beautiful they were. I was worried at first how they would arrive but Melinda assure me that she would pack them well and she did an amazing job, nothing broken or smashed. My cookie table was hit thanks to 2 Fat Guys and an Oven. Every time I am back in New Castle, I have to visit, their pastries are to die for. So happy to see a small business in New Castle doing well. read more

Let me tell you about this place ... just wonderful food and wonderful owners. Today I stopped with my Mom happens to be her 88th birthday today, anyway my Mom moves very slow and we parked where she could walk up to the door. On the way up the ramp the owner came out and said" I will get you anything you need, do you want me to get it for you?" Oh no we said just takes her time moving, it is my Birthday and I want to set and enjoy my son and daughter's company for lunch. We ordered before the food came to the table, both owner came up to my Mom and wished her Happy Birthday and in a container a cannoli ! That made my Mom's day, she was so happy! Lunch was wonderful the food was so good, every time I go there friendly and just love the food. My Mom said to me "Italian restaurant are the best" and this little place in New Castle PA is the BEST! PS Try the SNUGGLES! YUMMY read more

I made an order for Christmas i had been seeing pictures on FB everything looked delicious..... I picked my order up and bought more when I arrived Well the lady locks were empty pastry as were the pecan tassies hollow ,the nutroll were like bread no filling and cannolis tasted lemony ??? And an item was missing from my order wasn't driving hour to pick back up VERY DISAPPOINTED WONT BE BACK! read more

We happened to be in New Castle and passed this place with the unique name! Stopped in for a baked goody and coffee. Excellent!! Everything was fresh and the giant maple roll had LOTS of maple icing!!! Yumm! All kinds of breads, soups sandwiches, breakfast! What a wonderful find for us today! read more

If you like Italian breads and pastries then this is the bakery your looking for, best you will find anywhere. I love their bread and buns and the selection is unbelievable but get there early because their bread goes fast. Nice friendly service,great owners! read more