Satisfying sandwiches! Don't know how they make it, but every time it's perfect. Never had a bad order. Pizza is good but sandwiches are better read more

Pizzas are very good. Always great quality. Friendly staff. The Resturant is clean and cozy

This is a hometown favorite in the Connersville market. From the moment I walked in the phones were ringing off the hook for lunch time orders. The girls behind the counter were working their butts off! I really felt welcomed and loved the atmosphere of the dining room. I would've stayed in the dining room to eat had I not had to carry out to go elsewhere. Their menu has pizza, sandwiches, and salads. I ordered the 8' veggie pizza. It was packed with olives, onions, green peppers and mushrooms. I prefer my pizza thin crust and this was not thin but not pan pizza either. This is the ONLY reason I'm removing a star. To me, this pizza had a homemade taste (which I loved) and reminded me of the times I would make pizza with my mom in our kitchen. My tummy just can't handle thicker pizzas now. Any who...the salads are large and a great bang for your buck. The Cobb and Chef Salads are the most popular. I also heard the breadsticks being amazing too. Another friend of mine had the 8' barbecue chicken pizza. They really loved it. read more

See all

What a delightful surprise and change of pace for us always going to pizza king. We got breadsticks, baked spaghetti and a few pizzas for our large party. Restaurant is pretty dark inside but otherwise great. Outdoor seating when weather permits! Employees are great and doing their best to hustle from table to table. read more

Food was good, especially the breadsticks. Was a lot more expensive than I remember but I have not eaten there in years.

Connersville store has really upped their game since the last time i have gotten pizza from them. Pizza was cooked perfectly, on time and very good. I did extra cheese on mine this time and if you like cheesy pizza - I'd recommend you do too. read more

The Big Hog. Really good pizza. The sweet tea here is worth the stop as well. The handmade breadsticks are some of the best in town. Don't forget the cheese cup. read more

Big Boy's Pizzeria - The Big Hog. - Pizza Near Me - Connersville, Indiana

waited 15 minutes for waitrwas tonight . never ack that we were there . went eslewhere to eat 1/31/2025

Good pizza,sandwiches pasta and brownies for desertBaked SpaghettiBarbecue Chicken PizzaChef Salads

As this pizza place is highly rated, I wanted to try it. I've had pizza practically coast-to-coast and I'm always eager to find a new, great place. This one was downtown near the post office. To me, there is nothing better than a good deluxe/supreme/special/whatever you want to call it. I want the vegetables, as well as the meat, so pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, onions, and green peppers are essential. Some places leave off the green peppers because they're expensive. Big Boy's Pizzeria makes the 8 inch The Big Boy at a really impressive, low price. With a medium drink, it was about $1.50 cheaper than any other place in Indiana or Ohio. It didn't take long for the pizza to be finished, even though they seemed busy with all the carry out business. When she brought it to me, it wasn't cut well, but it was hot as...a coal furnace? :-D I took time for it to cool, so I wouldn't be trying to scrape pizza away from the cardboard or the roof of my mouth. After a couple of minutes, I started tearing the pieces away from each other, and it was really thick. The cardboard beneath it was really soaked with grease from the meat and/or oil from the cheese. Since it's so thick, I wonder if they bake it in a pan lined with oil. We did that at Cassano's with our deep dish skillet pizza. It was better than good, but not quite great. The grease really put me off, and it wasn't good for the stomach either but not enough to stop me from returning. Considering that Mancino's wasn't very good, and Pizza Hut is never really good, but somewhat more reliable, and your other choice is Pizza King, I see Big Boy's as the only place to get good pizza in Connersville. read more

See all

Really good food haven't had many opportunities to try alot of their menu items but from what I have had really liked it..haven't been inside the restaurant I had food delivered, it was really easy to order what I wanted and the one who took my order was extremely nice read more

Lies about to employees about pay raises! Was told I would make 8.50 at the new restaurant in Cambridge city and never did!

We took the grandkids on the Polar Express train 3 blocks away and my daughter and I were looking for a good pizza place in town for afterwards. I didn't have high expectations for a small town like this, but this pizza was so incredibly good. I couldn't stop eating it. Outstanding and you will not be disappointed. read more

Love their pizza! They have a delicious cauliflower crust pizza too. I also like their location. It gives my poor neighborhood a pizzeria they can walk to. read more

Great pizza! One of, if not, the best pizzerias in Connersville. I would have gave a 5-star but they lose a star for doing what all the pizza joints try to do now They charge a delivery fee while not giving that fee to the driver while expecting us to tip the delivery driver at the same time That is the business slipping their hands in to the pocket of the delivery drivers tips and nothing more and I will not pay for this game. Your driver is the one who will suffer for this practice cause any restaurant that charges a delivery fee ensures the driver does not get a tip from me read more

Randomly found this place when driving out towards Brookville and we were very impressed. Excellent pizza and breadsticks and a friendly staff. read more

Big Boys is my favorite pizza joint in Connersville. It's clean, the delivery is relatively quick (especially compared to Pizza King) and the prices aren't exorbitant. The "Big Boy" itself is my favorite pizza they serve (it's kind of their version of a Supreme)... it's loaded with toppings and has just the right amount of grease. I can't make myself get too excited about the Chicken Ranch pizza, but that's just my personal preference over actual quality. And Joshua's right... the breadsticks are great. As far as I'm concerned, the taste and service blow Pizza King out of the water. Eat here, not there. read more

Ordered a Big Boy Pizza on 07/21/2018 for the price of 21.46,,Was not worth it,,,Tasted like a Cheese pizza,,,Your online picture of this pizza was made to look good,,Should never have walked out the door with it.. read more

Great pizza by far the best around. Drive 15 minutes away just to get one. You'll definitely get what you pay for here! In a good way I mean. Awesome service for a small town business that should open one in my town! read more

This is some the best pizza around that I have tried annd for a great price. All of it is homemade. If your in town visiting or passing through and cant make dinner this is a definately a must have. read more

alright I know, I know Connersville probably has the most pizza places per capita then anywhere. But, Big Boy's is the best in my opinion and i've tried them all. I think last time I counted there were 8 pizza places in our small town, and now I think a new one has opened up where the old Big Boy's was originally located. anyways back to the review, I love Big Boys for a couple of reasons. 1. Chicken Ranch Pizza- I'd never had anything other then the usual toppings being pickier in my younger years. But, the first time I had this masterpiece I was addicted. The ranch they use for the sauce is absolutely perfect and you can tell they make it themselves. 2. Service- I've never gone here and they didn't have enough workers available which meant I get my order taken quick and within 10min (sometimes less) I've got my food piping hot in front of me. also the prices here are extremely reasonable. oh! and the bread sticks are too legit to quit. I rarely get delivery we usually just go in and eat, so I can't tell you how that is, but I'm sure it's just as good! read more

Big Boy's Pizzeria - menu - Pizza Near Me - Connersville, Indiana

See all

Their pepperoni pizza is excellent. It's diced pepperoni, not circles, but it has lots of flavor. Circular pizza cut into squares (crust is very good too). read more

Big Boy's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Connersville, Indiana

See all

The BEST pizza and breadsticks in Connersville! And fairly priced! You definitely get your money's worth!

Had the chicken fruit plate. Loved the chicken salad. It is a drier chicken salad, not soupy or heavy with mayo. The fruit needs improvement in regard to quantity and what is actually put on the plate. The only fruit on the plate was a small, salad dressing cup with canned pineapple tidbits. I was expecting mixed fruit, eg: possibly strawberries/bananas/blueberries/melon/grapes. The place is very clean and service was great. read more

Came to Connersville, IN for Polar Express. Picked Big Boy's off Yelp. Awesome place to eat pizza. Garlic bread, bread sticks and pizza were all great. If you come here, please eat there. Server was wonderful too. read more

Best Pizza In town! This place knows how to make pizza. The crust is perfect, tons of toppings, Tastes like deep dish. the cheese is wonderful. I have had the other menu items and they are killer. Some one would have to be crazy not to like this pizzeria in my opinion. Keep doing what you are doing and dont change a thing! read more