The food options are pretty limited in Kenton, but this pizza place is pretty solid. We come here…read morewhen we're in town visiting my grandma. This time my husband and I got: - Chicken Ranchero Pizza (14" with Traditional Hand-Tossed Crust) - Italian American Pizza (12" with NY Style Crust) - Cheesy Breadstix The Chicken Ranchero was my preference between the two. I didn't pay close enough attention when ordering and didn't realize the Italian American didn't have sauce. It was good, but I think it would have been a lot better with a tomato sauce. The Cheesy Breadstix were cheesy as advertised and delicious. This continues to be my go to spot in Kenton.

Ask your server what the real prices are before you order. All the prices in the menu are wrong. I…read morediscovered this when I got my bill and saw I was charged more for all the calzones that we ordered than the price in the menu. When I brought this to their attention they acknowledged prices had changed but the menus aren't updated. When I pointed out the price in the menu is the advertised price the owner (through the waitress because he wouldn't face his customers directly) pointed to a statement on the front stating the prices may be different. This is false advertising. The food is really good and the waitress was awesome and she ultimately adjusted the bill (I hope she doesn't get in trouble for doing the right thing). We will not be returning because we don't support shady unethical and illegal practices that this establishment is engaging in.

Aggressively average. Just leaving a review to combat the unwarranted enthusiasm of others. To be…read morefair: I did not eat the pizza, so maybe that's the attraction. I had a sub. My wife had a fold over. You could do better at home or an upscale cafeteria. My Italian sub was served with mayo on the side and topped with some kind of store bought salad mix. The people are very kind.

THE SAUCE IS AMAZING!! This is one of my favorite pizza places. It's carry out only, so don't plan…read moreto sit down. We have tried most of the specialty pizzas and all have been good. Our favorite is a veggie junior jumbo with extra sauce and stuffed crust. A great value and really good pizza. The crust is more of a doughy style.

Great food and drinks outside patio is huge, Asher special is amazing pound of chunks and two…read moreorders of fries, ranch and your choice of sauce all in one pile

We ostes a retirement party in their back room! We served pizza and chicken chunks. The room was…read moreclean and well appointed with a private serving area, bar and lots of comfortable seating. Included were round tables which I particularly like for events. The food was excellent. The chicken chunks were all chucken, served with a variety of sauces and delicious! Pizza was great and kept warm in some nice warming tables. The server/bartender was attentive and did a nice job serving us all. Flexible with cash and credit card options. We were there in January but the outdoor venue looked very nice and I look forward to heading there this summer!

Susie's pizza is my favorite pizza! Whenever I come to visit family (I live in NC now but grew up…read morearound Upper)I order their pepperoni and green olives- their crust is light and crispy. I literally order when I am 30 minutes away as a I drive from Columbus airport. They only take cash!

Yes the service good and restaurant was all amazing I really love the pizza there and the prices…read moreare great

Good pizza and the waitress/owner could not have been nicer. Probably good takeout, but not much…read moreof a dine in place.

Absolutely delicious! Solid 8/10. Sauce was yummy and…read moreseemed to be an average amount to me. The garlic bread was very garlicky which I liked! Will be back in the summer.

You're minus one star because we drove 30 minutes just for tickets. The buffet is over until…read moreoctober but we all thought you opened at 12:00 just for tickets on Monday. The salad bar was the best.

Everything the pizza and subs and the service and how it arrives at your house still hotread more

The pizza was perfect. Crust was light and crispy, right amount of cheese and sauce. Dory our…read morewaitress was warm.and welcoming. Very enjoyable experience

Simply great! More later if I get a chance. Classic small town atmosphere. Ezzo was delicious. Dori…read morewas a wonderful host

Friendly service. Taylor helped us get our order in quick so we could make it to our movie. We had…read morea medium Taco Supreme it was amazing. Would get again!

We ordered a pizza to take home because we had our dog with us. It only took about 20 minutes to…read morereceive our order. We got a pepperoni and sausage medium pizza. It was really good! There was plenty of cheese, almost to the edge. If we are traveling through Milan again, I would definitely eat at Jim's Pizza Box.

Food here is amazing!!!!!!!! Small little mom and pop shop, but the pizza is out of this world!…read moreSauce is tasty, crust is crisp, toppings out to the edges. Prices are great too. I would recommend this pizza place to anyone looking for a tasty meal.

A little pricey for pizza but great taste and awesome service. The subs are delicious and a very…read moregenerous amount of ingredients.

Very well run operation! Great pizza and great wings. The "fold over" is a must try. Beer and wine…read moreonly. One of the cleanest food service operations I have ever been in.

Great small town pizza place!! Food is great as is the service. There is a small area to eat but we…read morealways grab it to go and enjoy at our camper.