Staff is SUPER friendly, they were great! The starter wasn't great, the cheese tortellini was over fried so there was no cheese left, just a crisp pasta husk. The sauces weren't my favorite either... Italian salad dressing, chunky red sauce, and the cream base of Alfredo sauce (not good - basically just plain cold cream). The white chicken Parmesan entree was very good though, well worth the trip! read more

Preteroti's Spaghetti House - Sophia's Melody - Italian Near Me - Findlay, Ohio

See all

This seemed super average and a questionable stop after seeing only one server and some mid appetizers- UNTIL we got our meals. Out of the park on all four dinners. The server amazingly kept up with all and it was well worth it! I will return on my next pass thru. read more

I travel, I eat at lots of places, spaghetti is hard to properly prepare and meatballs are almost impossible. Pretreotis Spaghetti House hit the ball out of the park!! A true traditional homestyle spaghetti and incredible sauce perfectly seasoned and consistent blend of herbs making this sauce the talk of the meal. Meatballs, wow ! They are huge and again perfect to taste, the seasoned taste will wake your taste bud's simply because you have never had the true Italian meatballs. The mall is offered with a slice of buttered garlic bread that says hi I'm straight from the bakers oven and melted in your mouth. A side salad is wonderful with this meal and if you like Italian make sure and have the house Italian dressing it absolutely will not disappoint you. I will always return when in or close to Findlay, OH. Special thanks to momma, Micah your amazing!!! read more

Just...WOW!!! We started with calamari and split the lasagna main course. We each had a side salad and EVERYTHING was SPOT ON! The bread was particularly noteworthy. From being greeted to seated and served in a very prompt manner....it was a cordial, convenient and completely satisfying experience! Having grown up in Findlay, the last time I was in the building it was a pharmacy. Wonderful ambiance and relaxing dining experience! I would include pictures of our meal, but trust me when I say, "Go with the calamari appetizer and lasagna main!" You can split it and you'll still be full! read more

Preteroti's Spaghetti House - Front entry side of the dining room. - Italian Near Me - Findlay, Ohio

This little restaurant is so adorable. Much bigger on the inside than I had imagined. The lighting is very nice with large windows. We were treated promptly upon arrival and received very fast and friendly service. Everything was very quick to come out. Appetizer was AMAZING! Salad was nice and fresh, and our main course. To die for! Possibly the best Italian dishes I've ever had. Dessert was also rich and delicious. read more

See all

Loved this cute little spaghetti house! Service was great, quick and attentive. The food was yummy with lots of pasta but a very small piece of meat. I had the lasagna which i found great albiet a little sweet. We also got the chicken parm which was a great choice in terms of flavor but i wish the chicken was just a little bit more. read more

Enjoyed our dinner here this past weekend. Chicken parm was cooked perfectly. All of the food we had was yummy. Service was extremely friendly and attentive. Relaxing atmosphere to have dinner. read more

Called in an order for take out. Food was hot when I arrived at my location around 14min from restaurant. Food was delicious and filling! read more

Great Food, great service, just all around amazing can't wait to go back. I had the Parmesan sub and it was the best sub I have ever had.

Both dine in and to-go are great! Food is top tier and always great quality! Definitely my go to for Italian cuisine!

Great service, great food. Was busy when we walked in. Had our food very quickly. Fresh, homemade and you can't go wrong with that! read more

Preteroti's Spaghetti House - Chicken Parm - Italian Near Me - Findlay, Ohio

See all

First of all, this is a very cool looking building. Simple but crisp. Everything was very clean. Our service was outstanding. There were only 2 working the front of house, but we didn't want for anything. They were helpful with suggestions and prompt with orders and refills despite being busy. The mozzarella sticks were perfect. Please note we were impatient and ate a couple before I snapped the picture - you get more than what is shown here. The sauce is tangy and full of flavor. We had the lasagna and spaghetti. Both absolutely outstanding flavor. The quality of all 3 dishes is top notch. Our bill for 2 drinks, an appetizer, and 2 large main courses was just under $45 - extremely fair for the amount and quality of food and service we received. We highly recommend Preteroti's. We'll be back, without a doubt! read more

See all

The food is unreal!!! very clean and nice environment. Service was amazing as well. We will be back

Seated right away. Service was very good. Waitress gave us time to decide. It was a simple salad, which was fine. Entrées were fantastic! Restaurant was charming and simply decorated, but very clean. Will definitely be back. read more

Preteroti's Spaghetti House - Ravioli. The basalmic was different, but was a very nice addition! - Italian Near Me - Findlay, Ohio

See all

Service and ambience wasn't terrible. But it's very bland for being $54 for two people. I have no idea what the 95 year old recipe is but it seems I could get the same meal in a frozen box at Walmart for $5. Do not recommend unless you have money to throw away. read more

The food was delicious! They had a full house so we had to wait a bit for our meal, but never lacked for anything. My son had the spaghetti and he said the meatballs were the best he's ever had. My husband had lasagna and loved it! read more

The food here is amazing! The price is great for how much you get! The service is amazing as well, very quick to your needs and helpful! Always love coming here to grab a quick good italian meal! :) read more

Preteroti's Spaghetti House - 3 cheese tortillini - Italian Near Me - Findlay, Ohio

We stopped while traveling in the area. Findlay was very busy throughout the town, but we were looking for something off the beaten path. Preteroti's was an excellent choice! The restaurant was small, but very clean. The service was very good and the food fabulous. We ordered the Chicken Parm and Spinach Ravioli. Both were very flavorful. The portions were generous and included salad and bread. The price was less than the chain restaurants. Altogether a it is worth another trip in a couple of weeks. read more

I had the lasagna and meatballs appetizer. Both were very delicious but the meatballs were my favorite! The service was great and the restaurant clean. read more

This is my second time here and I must say I am just as impressed as the first time. The food here is phenomenal, I can't stress that enough. The service is amazing as well! read more

Had meatball sub. Looked good till I tasted it. They use GFS meatballs. Dry no seasoning nasty. read more

Preteroti's Spaghetti House - You can see how dry out the meat balls. Didn't eat it just packed it up and paid bill. Let my dog eat it. - Italian Near Me - Findlay, Ohio

I am not one to leave a review whether it's good or bad, but this little restaurant was just so good. Great scratch kitchen food. The atmosphere was great, the music was great! Micah was our server and she was great! I loved everything about it. Definitely will be back!! read more

Adorable little Italian restaurant with delicious food that was served quickly. Prices were reasonable. Our waitress was very friendly and took great care of us. Only complaint is the woman who seated us was a bit rude and basically ignored us. read more

This place is a small little restaurant that you wouldn't expect to have such good food! My husband had the chicken Milano and I had the lasagna. Both were so good and their garlic bread was good too! If I could put in recommendations for the restaurant, here would be my 2 cents. The chicken Milano was great but it could have used a bit more mushroom and sun dried tomato, there was only 1 or 2 in the dish. The lasagna was perfect. The salad you get with the dinner is basically just lettuce. I did see a few pieces of shredded cheese but that was it. I would recommend adding a few cherry tomatoes and some croutons maybe a bit of onion or go with a Caesar salad. But hey, what do I know. I will definitely be eating here again in the future! The portions are huge! read more

I really wanted to like this place. I just can't. I heard good things, and I want to support small businesses. On the plus side, it's a very friendly place (That's what earned the star) on the other hand, the food is over priced and served lukewarm. Don't bother with the $9.00 pizza bites as it's really nothing more than a Stouffer's French bread pizza served with a side of cold marinara. I wish I could say it got better but for us on our visit, it didn't get better. read more

Went on the recommendation from a friend. Small, cute restaurant, I liked that the decor wasn't overdone. Waitress was fairly new, but efficient. Food was good, came out piping hot and pasta was cooked perfectly. My only criticism, our table was a little sticky. I saw the bus boy cleaning other tables, maybe just the cleaner. Otherwise, great! read more

Delicious affordable Italian cuisine, excellent service and very positive experience! We will definitely be back!

Incredible food! Love the small town, classic Italian vibes. Great customer service. Chicken milano is awesome... my wife is OBSESSED. Garlic bread is dope as well read more

Great, friendly service and the food is so good. I suggest the lasagna and my wife loves the ravioli. Prices are good and the food is very good. Blows Olive Garden out of the water. read more

Cute little Italian place. Really is a gem. Service is friendly and the food was good. The garlic bread is A M A Z I N G! Highly recommend, authentic Italian food. read more

This place is great! We had the chicken parmesan, fried ravioli, meatballs, and chicken alfredo. The food was wonderful, and you can definitely tell that it is all made from scratch. Even though the menu is not extensive, everything on it is done to its highest potential. A lot more filling than expected! Definitely some of the best Italian I've had in quite a while, go check it out! The pictures don't do it justice! read more

Preteroti's Spaghetti House - Chicken Alfredo - Italian Near Me - Findlay, Ohio

See all

Got takeout for the family and will definitely be back! Had the fettuccini, chicken fettuccini, lasagna, chicken milano, mozzarella sticks, calamari, limoncello, and tiramisu. Everything was good. The lasagna, limoncello, and bread were awesome!!! Super friendly service. I feel like the lady who took my order and I are new best friends! read more

We were sat almost immediately. The atmosphere was super comforting and cozy and the staff were very friendly throughout the night. I ordered the ravioli and my husband got the lasagna. I hardly ever finish my meals when I go out to eat but I cleaned my plate and then ordered cheesecake for dessert. The food was delicious and this is definitely a spot we will be frequenting! read more

Our waitress was very nice, but sadly didn't catch her name. The food was no so great. Our appetizers (calamari and fried ravioli) was barely warm and didn't taste the best either. Our meals were hot (fettuccini Alfredo with chicken and spaghetti and meatballs), but sadly they weren't very good. The spaghetti sauce was very very sweet and the fettuccine alfredo tasted mostly like garlic. We didn't particularly like the garlic bread, it was very soggy and tasted sugary. Don't forget your parka! The place was freezing. read more

Yes I ordered food there I've had it before it wasn't bad they did mess up a few times but this time it was absolutely terrible I called my food in the girl can't hear me on the phone I had to pretty much yell at her for her to hear me That's okay that's understandable then she tells me 30 minutes for my food I get there 10-15 minutes later 30 minutes go by still don't have my food 45 minutes go by still don't have my food I finally after an hour got it and I asked for a refund the man said he could do but I couldn't have my food I might go okay that's fine I understand that so can I pay half of it and still get my feelings compensated something no I can't do that but you can make me wait an hour and I wasn't the only person there was another people that was actually in there that was waiting an hour and then I was walking out the man sees me when I'm walking I had the phone up to me ear My hand when like this up it just my fingers did he would open up the window said did you just let me off no I didn't then he closed the window do not go to this place they are so rude and they don't know what the heck they're doing save your money go somewhere else read more

We stopped in for something new. We were greeted & sat quickly. Our service was great. Summer took very good care of us. The limited menu (for me) was actually kinda nice. No wasting time looking for a needle in a haystack. Has a diner feel. On to the food, not bad. We have a pretty bland palette but still the food wasn't bad. Couple plates of Alfredo & couple chicken parm's. Sauces were watery/thin consistency. Plate looked good (sorry no pic's). Chicken Parmesan was good but I like thicker sauce. I still cleaned my plate, so I can't complain too much. We'll go back/take out again. Hope this helps. read more

The service was horrible. Waited over an hour for our food. Waitress never came to back to table other than to bring the food and then the check. The food was gross. It was very chewy and cold when got to table. Saw many people get to go boxes once food finally arrived to table. Such a small place yet spacing wasn't even considered with covid going on. No one had on mask on properly. Definitely will not be returning here again. Just plain gross!! read more