Love it open early on a Saturday pick up a couple of bottles of wine before the exciting party today. Brand new store huge store. I'm sorry huge store tremendous great amount of selections plenty of stock and the owner is always behind the counter on a hand to help you at all times. he also has four reserved parking spaces so you know you can get a spot close and carry out your case of wine. read more

Brewster Wine & Liquor - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Brewster, New York

Been going here for years and best thing was moving to larger space New space is open and clean and is exactly what this business needed. Will always be a patron. They are Always helpful suggestions they make are spot on. read more

What a great place! The selection and prices are great and the owner, Greg, is very knowledgeable. I highly recommend this place, you won't regret it! read more

Show value, create an experience and always strive to exceed customers expectations. That's exactly what John from Brewster Wine & Liquor did! So I've been hunting around for a specific amaro that me and my family used to have in Italy. I have not been able to find it here for years. Ever since I moved up to NY I figured one day I'd be able to find it here since a lot more things get imported. I recently found out the whole state of CT doesn't carry it either. My nice friends at Caraluzzi's Wine & Spirit in Danbury, CT suggested I try my local stores in Brewster. He said they could order the product and get it to any store in Brewster. I had no idea this was even possible! I started calling up all the local wine & spirit stores until I landed with this gem. Initially, all the other ones I called just kind of brushed me off. I figured this place would do the same thing. John told me he would take my number and check on the product and call me back. Not only did he get a hold of me, he found the amaro! Went out of his way to call his provider and tracked me down leaving me voicemails and all. We placed the order, picked it up and he said that of I ever needed anything else to let him know. I told him how appreciative I was of their customer service and for going out of his way to order my one bottle. He said: "it's what we do". Seriously, Brewster Wine & Liquor you outdid yourself! It's true, there are many other places to shop at and perhaps with more varieties and better prices but this place deserves a 5 star review for their customer service, going above and beyond and for their loyalty. Keeping your word is truly much more valuable than anything else! read more

Brewster Wine & Liquor - a man shopping in a store - Beer, Wine & Spirits Near Me - Brewster, New York

See all

This shop has an amazing selection for its size, good pricing, and always a friendly smile from Greg behind the counter. This is the kind of local business we should all support. read more

This business is very well organized. They are always friendly, and answers any questions you may have!

Best spirit store in the area. Very friendly and informative. Always willing to answer question and offer choices. Well stocked and tons of variety. Jason read more

I asked the price of a bottle of liquor and I went to buy the next day and he tells me $15 dollars more than the price he gave me the day before. read more

Bought one bottle of wine too many. Decided to bring it back for a return. Mind you this is a sealed unopened bottle of course and I have the receipt. Guy says they don't take returns because it's against the law. Really? Where? http://blog.timesunion.com/tablehopping/22378/no-law-prohibiting-return-of-unopened-booze/ Guy says "It's because it might be tampered with". Really guy?? It's sealed and even corked! How and why would someone tamper with that! Then he says maybe he'll do an exchange if I want something else.....huh? I thought you just said it's illegal to take it back? Listen it's real easy. Be honest. Try it. People are not stupid. Have I returned alcoholic beverages before at other places? Yes. Apparently other places are breaking the law? Or at the very least maybe they care about customer service over money. Yes we all know there are liquor laws and basically consumers are not allowed to "sell" liquor, or even back to a seller, I get it. But I wasn't selling it. It was already sold to me by YOU and I had a receipt for it. That makes it perfectly fine to take back. And yes, I would have actually bought something else had you not been so shady. I usually buy those $100+ bottles of high end scotch. But it's my fault for trying a new place to buy and I was not on my usual route. I should have drove a bit more and stuck with my usual store. There's more than enough other liquor stores out there everyone. Skip this one. read more

Store owner def knows knows his stock and every time I go in there tries to help with any questions and pick out the perfect wine for any occasion. I've found lots of wines in different price points depending on what I'm looking for read more

Any store that sells liqueur is a liqueur store. What makes this place special are the people who work there. Always willing to go that extra mile. A grade "A" establishment. read more

The owner Greg knows his stuff from wine to bourbon and is more than fair in his assessments of everything that he carries. You give Greg a price point and he will give you good value for your dollar. Very knowledgeable about his products and will match those products with the customer's needs. He's straight forward and honest which is a relief in today's retail environment. My favorite wine store. read more

I've bought several hundreds of dollars worth of bourbon here, but the guy who runs the shop is a little too slick for his own good. No matter how many times I go in, he gives me the same introductory spiel about how he gets all the hard-to-get stuff, but "whether he puts it out on the shelves is another thing". On one occasion, I inquired about a bottle that was in a glass display case (with no price on it) - he laughed and explained that he usually sells bottles like that only to his preferred customers, to which I said, "If you don't want to sell it, why put it on display?" Eventually, he did sell it to me, but not before putting me through the wringer. Another time, we had another of our "first-time meetings" and he asked me what I was looking for, and explained that what was on the shelves wasn't everything he has. I told him what I was looking for, asked him if he had it, and he replied "Maybe. How much you looking to spend on that?" (It was a $40 bottle, at most). I politely explained that I probably know a lot more about bourbon than he does, know how much things are supposed to cost, and will not get taken advantage of. You might find some nice bottles here, but you might also have to jump through hoops to get them. Don't let yourself be taken advantage of, and don't be afraid to walk out the door. There are a lot of liquor stores in this area, and with a little effort, you'll find what you want. read more