Private parking lot...check! Seating...check! Pleasant staff...check! This location sits back off a busy street, it is set up like all, wuth the drive through or walk up order option. The area was clean, outside of a customer leaving there trash on a table. They do allow you to sample before you make your choice, always very helpful. I went with Egg Nog and White Turtle, my son went with Strawberry Cheesecake and they both where yummy! The staff was really sweet. read more

See all

Bruster's has always been a family favorite. Since my mom and nieces are in town, I decided to take them. Upon pulling up, we were the only customers, so we decided to walk up to the window and order. The young lady taking the order was super nice and patient, as we had 4 different ice cream orders. I ordered a chocolate kids cup with gummy worms, a cup of 3 scoops of Cotton Candy, a cup of 3 scoops of pistachio, and then a cup of 3 scoops of orange sherbet. My nieces loved their chocolate and cotton candy ice creams, however my mom stated her pistachio ice cream tasted like mint ice cream and the pistachio nuts in it were extremely chewy, almost unrecognizable aside from the color. My orange sherbet tasted like orange ice. The sherbet wasn't creamy at alllll. Kroger's generic brand of orange sherbet knocks this right out the box. I threw it out the window on the way home. It was extremely disappointing to have this experience when Bruster's has always been our family favorite. read more

Too expensive, too soft, not flavorful. Sorry. I used to love Brusters when I lived in Snellville years ago.

I am an ice cream connoisseur. I would eat it every day if it didn't have so many calories and causes weight gain. On more than one occasion I've tried different flavors of Bruster's ice cream. Sadly, none of them have much flavor. I really tried to like them because it's more naturally made. A big PLUS as I only consume for more homemade type ice creams. Somethings to keep in mind if you decide to try it. read more

Customer service was really good! The woman working was very patient and helpful overall and the ice cream was great! read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Cookies & Cream Regular Cone - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

I ordered a birthday cake for my Mother in laws birthday. I ordered online in the area where they ask what you want written on the cake I put "Happy Birthday" when I got the cake it terrible writing was " happ B-Day" no I did not mistype they literally forgot the "Y" in happy .I ordered blue berry muffin/strudel? flavored ice cream layer with yellow cake and a caramel middle layer they completely forgot to put the caramel on instead they smeared the top with what I assume is blueberry compote the icing decorations were not even they were all different shapes and sizes make the cake look terrible. When I called the store to ask for a refund they told me no that that is just how the person writes and everyone writes differently. I called corporate customer service several times and for an entire month I got no reply. Finally a guy called me two days ago and said he will see about getting me my money back but he isn't sure because it has been over a month..... (WTH how is that my fault I have been calling) I told him if he wants to keep me as a customer not only do I want a refund I want some kind of compensation for them ruining my mother in laws birthday and making me wait a month to get my money back and he said he doesn't think he will be able to do that..... If you are going in for an ice cream maybe you will be fine but do not order a cake from this store if anything goes wrong ( which it probably will) you won't be getting your money back. read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Bad writing and messy design - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

See all

Customer service is poor: they lie and treat their customers like trash. I will never return to spend my money here ever again. Plenty of places to get ice cream. read more

Everything needs to improve at this location was visiting, and my daughter told me multiple times how nasty the workers are! They need to hire young workers that care about their job and have adult supervision. They are rude and unmotivated people that work there. It's disappointing that you try to get an ice cream and have to adore the abuse and filth of the outdoor area. There's ants all over the trash cans and ice cream ridden areas of the benches. The manager or owner needs to be aware of how awful this is run. read more

Was in drive thru for over 30 minutes and they still messed up my order. Really bad customer service and they don't seem to care at all. Maybe hire people who actually care and can work read more

If I could give a 0 it'd be a 0 extremely rude staff! Will never support this business again! Hope everyone who witnessed their actions tonight stops supporting them as well! Waited in line outside for over 40 minutes with my kids - only to make it to the to the window for them to tell me they're closed and refused to serve me.. There were several families behind me as well who they turned away who also waited a very long time. Beyond unacceptable. This is the 2nd time this has happened to me at this location. Never again! read more

This was almost $8 will never go here again. Highly disappointed. Quality has definitely gone downhill with new owners. Cheapskates at least give me a whole waffle bowl read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Small Waffle Bowl - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

See all

The girls at the counter claimed they were only "taking cash" so suspicious of what was going on my girlfriend sat and watched them take care of several customers cash only. I guess the cash register wasn't working either because the orders were not even rang up. Really guys where is the service read more

Went for a blast at 8:30 pm with their closing time being 10 pm. We were told that they've shut their machine down to clean it. Not the way business should be run. You can clean after you've served your last customer. read more

Great ice cream. I always order online for pickup. Order has always been ready when I arrive

Well, my overall experience was a good one from start to finish. Yes there was a long line in the drive thru but it moved and I was able to order, pay and leave within 10-12 minutes I'd say. There was a small crowd of people ordering at the window but no issues going on there or so it seemed. This was all on a Friday night two hours before closing. My hot fudge brownie sundae was pretty tasty. My hot fudge was even hot, I'm not sure why this location scores so low. Even the employees working were professional and did a overall great job with their customer service I'd say. Give them a try don't go off the ratings, it'll be worth it I promise! I'LL BE BACK! :) read more

Just terrible. The service was horrible and the product has really gone down hill. The ice cream used to be so good!

Greatest Ice Cream Place they took my order fast through the drive through love this place will be back !

My times here have been great! The ice cream was great..the service was great. Environment was clean...no trash outside and the grounds are just generally kept nice. Looking at some of the recent reviews...yikes!! I've never experienced these issues..thank goodness!! My favorites are the Banana Split and Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough. When I'm on this side of town and craving the sweets, this is my first choice~ read more

Bruster's Real Ice Cream - Cookie Dough/waffle cone, (melting) Brownie Fudge Sundae, Banana Split and Peach/cake cone..eat it fast!! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Fayetteville, Georgia

I love this place. I always get coffee/chocolate chip. It never disappoints and is worth the price! read more

Yes the management must have changed! I have to pay for a lid for my ice cream cup...for real! The customer service is different and I don't know I if I'll be back. The lady just seemed not nice and rude, the people there were always young people and they were very courteous. I don't like the change! I'll go and buy banana pudding ice cream from Kroger's and call it a day! read more

Love the ice cream here. The staff is super nice now that the rude ones are gone. They really try to get your order as fast as possible but they get really busy. And I have been behind a couple of families that get big orders! I really don't mind since the butter pecan is my weakness. read more

Took our order then left us sitting at the window for almost 15 minutes. No one came to the window to acknowledge us or anything. Just pulled off. Never going back. read more

Very rude. Yells at customers. Language barrier is the problem, but screams at customers when we can't understand. Disappointed.

I order a birthday cake for my granddaughter the owner took my order himself he said I could pick up the cake after 3:00 he wrote down what I wanted I ask him do I need to pay you know he said it don't matter l went to pick up my cake after running other errands for my baby party at 5:00 already running behind people At my house when I get there no cake he said he call because he didn't know what to put on it he called once at 4:30 after 3:00 the only thing he could say we are not going to sell the cake well you think it was not ready but this is not the worst he did this to me before but I was still trying to give them another chance because my grandchildren love this ice cream no more will find a new location they don't trust black people I guest or they just don't care no cake for my babies party read more

The new management sucks. They are dead slow without customers and they still rush you while taking your order. Whipped cream and a cherry is extra on a sundae?? Since when?? Okay welp that's fine we won't be back being as I would have paid for the extra toppings but you don't want to listen to my complete order. read more

Rude af ! We asked the lady at the drive thru for napkins and as she handed it to us she said " okay go". Never going back . Ice cream was average read more

Wow this place is so great. I live the Sea Salted Caramel and White Turtle Milk shakes.

2 stars because service could be better. Owner is rude. Cakes are lopsided. But the ice cream is consistent with other locations.

There must of been a change in ownership, scoop size is a fraction of what they were. It has become way to expensive for what you get. If your craving Bruster's the Peachtree City location was still good at last visit. read more

We sat in the window for 10 min while the ignored us and took other customers that arrived after us at the other window. No acknowledgement. No apology. Just a sad way to end a pretty summer day read more

We got to the drive-thru at 9:35pm and waited 25 mins to finally get to the order kiosk. It was one minute after 10pm when they close and they refused to take our order. Only two people were working and it was a complete waste. They took so long to do anything and it prevented us from ordering, even with a fairly short line. Do not try to go here even an hour before closing. And to the management - maybe try not having two teenagers close that take ten minutes to do one order and make excuses to refuse service to customers that got in line well before closing. read more

I'll give this location a 1star because I have to. The owner was very rude this evening as I was trying to get a better understanding of the menu. Unfortunately, I was not being accommodated as I asked for toppings on a waffle cone. I was told "it's going to fall off" referring to my request of Carmel drizzle. Shortly after the owner asked do I want it or not and didn't give me any additional options! I literally left with no ice cream nor did I feel like a valued customer. Will not be returning to this location. Unacceptable customer service read more

I asked for a New York cheese cake and got a vanilla ice cream. No they did not mess up but it came with no crust which is the reason why I order it. When I spoke to the lady about it she got rude and looked at me like I was the crazy one vs just fixing the problem. And no I didn't eat half of the ice cream and then complain I actually had all of it in there. Well won't be coming back to this location I'll head to PTC. Customer service is important maybe they should focus on that. read more

I ask for a thick chocolate shake and it was totally opposite. It was good, but nowhere close to being thick! It was like drinking chocolate milk. I won't be back! read more

This is by far the best ice cream ever. The staff is always friendly, I always get the waffle cone and they are always warm. DELICIOUS!!!

I LOVE these guys! When I forgot to order my sister's birthday cake ahead of time, they totally pulled me out of a jam. A day before a national holiday, they managed to cook up a chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream cake with purple, white and blue frosting! (Yes, I know how ridiculous that sounds but the baby sister wants what she wants...) They did not charge me a fee for it being a last-minute/rush request AND they came in early so I could surprise my sister in the afternoon (instead of having to pick it up in the late evening). So, um...can we agree that they're awesome? be/c they totally are! read more

The ice cream was really good but i think it was a bit too much of ice cream and since it was hot outside it would drip and i wish they had something other than napkins to not make it drip but other than that it was great read more

My family and I have been customers here for many years but a new staff started a few months ago and they have an extreme customer service problem. They don't value their customers, provide extremely portions. They refuse to give you the order as you request it, not sure if it's language or cultural barrier or just plain stubbornness, I definitely will not be taking my business there again. read more

I loved this place before it was purchased by a new owner. I live right down the street so we would walk there at least 2x week in the summer. I use the cards to get the punches since I purchase so much. when I forget my card I just ask for another card and get it punched. I never had an issue giving them more than one card as long as I had 9 punches on the cards in total. But when the new owner took over he stated he was not the owner and he was the manager. He was very rude and condescending. he told me he was not going to take several cards, very argumentative. Then threw the cards at me and told me to leave and take the ice cream. He was speaking to a woman in another language talking about me in some way. I contacted corporate to make a complaint and found out that he was actually the owner and not the manager. He called me and was still very rude on the phone and I couldn't get a word in edgewise. I will never go to this one again. I will travel to Peachtree City. read more

The service is as great as the ice cream. The biggest pecans I've ever gotten in butter pecan. By the way, the price is on target also. Recommend to all. read more