I've been ordering the Toasted Walnut cookies every year at this time and this year I also ordered the Sugar Butter cookies too and neither one disappoints! I love soft cookies and yours are the best, great packaging and delivery! Merry Christmas to you and your family! Jamee read more

I ordered crème filled cookies and the box had lots of ants in it. been trying to contact and I get no reply. very disappointed

I ordered online cookies, cake, and candy. Everything was excellent. I shared them with my post office post master. He took many of the items home to his wife. He told me a few days later that he and his wife were tickle pink and love them all. Thank Butter Maid you make delicious treats. Plus the shipping presentation was outstanding by Staca. She did a great job. Dicoce did a great job with packaging from an other great purchase. Thank you to ALL. read more

the nut rolls and cookies I ordered were great Everyone enjoyed them.. I did have a problem with 1 of the rolls being missing. I was concerned since they were for Christmas. I called them. they said would send another one. but it probably wouldn't be here until after Christmas. I received it Christmas Eve. I will definitely order from them again. Great service. Martha Rogers read more

My wife grew up in Youngstown and we always loved the pastries and food from the area. Her dad made some of the best food, but after his passing we could not duplicate it. But Butter Maid has. We shop food to family in Florida and bring some back here to Columbus. Easy to order. Arrives on time. Price is reasonable. And most of all it is authentic and tasty. Thanks Butter Maid. read more

Absolutely delicious, as always. It's so fresh, you would think the local bakery up the road baked it this morning!

I am never disappointed in the items I purchase from Butter Maid Bakery ! The Kolachi is just like my mother and grandmother used to make...delicious!!! I purchase the low sugar one and it still tastes wonderful! So happy I found Butter Maid Bakery and was surprised it was from my home town of Boardman!!!! Thanks for making such wonderful treats and memories! Gloria Di Iorio read more

I am a repeat buyer and Loyal Customer trying all the different flavors! I ordered the Cranberry Walnut (again), Lemon Cream, and Cream Cheese Kolachi's Loaf/Bar/Lucious Treat! All 3 were Exquisite!! The Cranberry Walnut is a Great New Flavor, my mom didn't make, Most everyone thinks of Cranberry as a Thanksgiving food, once you've tried this flavor you'll think otherwise, I've bought it twice now, because of the sophisticated subtleness of the flavor, It's like a danish, evenly balanced cookie, and unique confection combined into a Rare delight. With Old World Charm, and European Style. You have to try it to believe how Delicious, Moist, plumped with filling till it's bursting, perfection. It's reminiscent of a Cranberry relish(like my grandma used to make) yet Balanced to perfection! - Made from a Master Baker that could make these Blindfolded. She/He is a Force to be reconned with...the skill level that has Won Many Blue Ribbon Awards, I'm sure! That's the quality we're talking about ... The Lemon Cream is filled to the Brim, tangy and sweet, the perfect combo! 14-18 slices of Heaven! A perfect Spring and Summer Treat to share with the girls during a Mani Pedi party for the arrival of warmer weather! It is Refreshing Delectable way to welcome the Sun and share it with Loved Ones! The Cream Cheese Kolachi is the inhouse favorite, and you'll understand why when on your 1st bite, the luscious cream cheese squeezes out the sides, because there is So Much Filling. Hands down this is 3 times better than a bagel with cream cheese, The dough is the best compliment to the Rich Cream Cheese, it really makes the cream cheese shine, and who doesn't LOVE CREAM CHEESE! It's the only reason why I've eaten a bagel just have to try it to understand, how incredible it is. I am very finicky when it comes to food. I know Quality, Skill, and Mastery, when I See, Taste, and Experience it. The Finer and Authentic items life brings to us are Rare and Elusive on the Internet. This Bakery is the Real Deal, With Love to the Naumoff Family, Yay Youngstown, Yay OH, and Triple Yay to the Naumoff's!!! When this bakery says the items shipped are handled with Care and Love, this is an Understatement...All were packaged gently, thoroughly, and with Love. These folks Really Know what they're doing! The Kolachi Has Plenty of Filling and is the Crowning Star of this Bakery! It is baked to Perfection, just like my mom's with an Unbeatable Crust and filling that has a Balanced sweetness that is delectable! The filling choices are numerous and can satisfy Picky Palate's as well. The packaging is also Top Notch. The loaf is in a Thick/Heavy Weight/Plastic bag, vacuum sealed, then in a box that has the type of Kolachi inside. Well thought out, and keeps it fresh while protecting the Kolachi, during shipping. The Customer Service of the team is quite frankly Outstanding, Stars 6+. They don't pressure you to buy; tracking updates are accurate and at the times you need them. The staff enclose a card that is Hand Signed! These are the kind of things Customer Service Dreams are made of! What a Beautiful touch!! I am promoting your bakery Everywhere I can, so your business Doubles/Triples! That is my Specialized Thank you to you for your Amazing Confections and Home Cooked Quality, Integrity and Values! You should be in the Top 5 Bakeries in the US! read more

My first order, a poppy seed and raisin kolache was almost perfect. I was less pleased with the lemon cream kolache. It was sticky, gooey and the package came damaged. I will order the poppy/raisin again. read more

My husband and I drove up to the main bakery where you can watch them making all their delicious goodies. We were greeted by such a sweet young woman who helped us to get our cookies and Kolachi roll. Everything is delicious and made fresh. I highly recommend visiting the bakery or ordering online. read more

Butter Maid Bakery - Here are the Pumpkin Cream Cheese Kolachi Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Boardman, Ohio

Quick delivery. Very delicious. Never disappointed. Ordered nut roll and poppy seed rolls

This is my 4th time ordering. The whole experience was quick and easy. I ordered thru a Facebook ad.. The packaging was great and all bakery came in perfect condition, no broken or smashed kolacis. The apricot are favorites, with nut filling next. Pricing is a little high but I order three items to get the free shipping. I'll order again. read more

Everything we ordered, Kolach and cookies were delicious!! I bought apricot cookies for my sister, walnut for me, both similar enough to our Mom's to bring a smile and memories. Butter cookies for my husband which he loved. Will order again soon, read more

Once I found this place I always make sure to order a few times a year. It is the best and brings back so many memories. I love the poppy seed roll and the Italian Rainbow cookies. I enjoyed the nut roll and the lady fingers that I tried for the first time were delicious! Highly recommend! read more

The treats from this bakery are nothing short of fabulous! Absolutely love the Kolachis and the clothespin cookies! They make great gifts as well, and Kolachis freeze well so get a few to have on hand when you want a bite of baked love! read more

placed an order to be sent to sister in FL when they confirmed they listed the order was being sent to me. I've wasted 1 hr. trying to get in touch with them to correct THEIR mistake. Can't get any satisfaction - sent 3 messages & called . No human to get in touch with. Very frustrating!! read more

I order for every holiday!!! High quality and delicious!!! My grandparents were from Croatia and served similar foods for the Holidays!!! Keeping the tradition alive!!! read more

Excellent pastry, quick delivery and a wide selection of flavors! I ordered kolachi for friends and family and everyone loved it. Will order again! read more

I have been getting my bakery from Butter Maid for 4 years now, and the quality of their products never varies. Than you so much. You Baked Goods remind me of all the things my Slovak mom used to make for us growing up. read more

just delicious I've never had goodies so good just reminds me of my Mom, communication was excellent and packaging was wonderful

I love their Kolachi/Kiffle Cookies. This is the second time I've ordered from them and I will definitely be ordering again!!

I have ordered from them for years and they are no longer the same. They do not stand behind their products any longer. I placed an order and I live in Florida. It was delivered completely fallen apart, melted and the cream was hot and separated. They stated they do not pack with dry ice and there is nothing they will do about it. $120. wasted! read more

These delightful kolachis are unique! Delicious and definitely the gift I'm not capable of creating for special people I love or want to spoil with treats in my home. read more

Every Christmas I send out some form of food product to relatives all over the USA. I saw an ad this year for Butter Maid Bakery in a local advertising paper and decided to give them a try. Being from Ohio I was glad to find a business in Ohio that I could support and that would mail out their products. I wanted to know what I was sending so I had the same bakery items sent to my house as well. I was very impressed by the packaging as well as the speed of the delivery. I ordered three items- cranberry walnut nut roll, apricot Kolachi cookies, and salted caramel coconut macaroons. All were very very good! I can't emphasize how impressed I am with Butter Maid Bakery and they will be my go-to business for future Christmas gifts as well as when I need to send something special. read more

If you are looking for authentic nut roll this is the place to purchase from. My grandmother used to make homemade poppyseed rolls and nut rolls every year during the holidays. After she passed away, we have had a hard time finding a bakery that makes it just like hers. This bakery has the exact recipe my grandmother used to use. The products are vacuum, sealed when shipped. This was the first time I decided to try their cookies. My 13 year old daughter already ate an entire package of the powdered sugar butterballs! I'll need to order more!!!! Holiday staple at our house! read more

Deliciouhs nut rolls. Kifli. Packaged well for shipping. Deliciouhs nut rolls. Kifli. Packaged well for shipping. read more

Dear Butter Maid Bakery, This was my first experience ordering from your company but I can GUARANTEE you will be hearing from me a lot. I have never received such wonderful unrequested "thank yous" ever. Sister Lynn Marie wrote, " without exaggeration, the raspberry kolacki are ultra-delicious". Thank you for producing a product that now I am eager to send to others. Thank you, Eileen Swan read more

Buttermaid Bakery has the most delicious and authentic pastries. The walnut and poppyseed kolachi are just like those that my Croatian grandmother made. My entire family enjoys receiving them during holidays and other special occasions throughout the year. read more

As close to homemade products as you can get. The quality of ingredients and freshness of products is obvious. Very generously filled, they are delicious. Excellent for serving at home or as gifts. I am a repeat customer.... read more

I ordered four different items a few weeks ago; prompt delivery and all are yummy. Can't say enough good things about Butter Maid Bakery.

Their cookies are delicious and my favorite! I'm their regular customer I love them! The kolachi is my favorite Will be ordering more soon read more

So happy to have found your less sugar option! I have been working hard to bring down my sugar levels and this is an awesome option for a special treat! Thank you! read more

The nut rolls and the cookies are top notch here. This is a great option for holiday treats if you aren't inclined to make them yourself. Make sure to sign up for coupons and buy three items at a time to get free shipping. The shipping is fast. read more

Best kolachi I've ever had. Perfect ratio of filling to dough (10:1 ). Get the honey walnut at your earliest convenience. It's gluttonous, but spread some room temp butter on it. If you don't live around Youngstown, do yourself a favor - go to the website, and have one shipped. The sticker shock is going to make it feel wrong, but trust me, it's right. read more

The walnut Kolache is just like my grandmother used to make many years ago, only she didn't use as many nuts. This is the fourth time I have ordered, and I have to say, I do not share with anyone. I savor every loaf not caring about the calories. I am very glad I found this company and I will continue to order to treat myself. read more

At the risk of getting an even bigger belly than I already have, I'd eat their chocolate walnut kolachi every day! The perfect blend of buttery pastry, chocolate, and crunch! read more

The Kolachi cookies are buttery and sweet always great The rum balls were very moist and tasty I am never disappointed in anything they create read more

Hands down the Best Chocolate Chip Cookies. They have kolachi and many other things to choose from. The m and m cookies also yummy. Everything is Made fresh daily and packaged quickly if your on the go. A must have for a gift or an event or for yourself . They are super friendly and the Desserts are yummy. read more

My order has never arrived! I expected to receive the order over a week ago. Since this is a food item which is perishable, I would expect it to be delivered much sooner. read more

So delicious and moist, I d give more stars if I could. A little pricey but worth every penny. And by the way,,,they ship freaky fast!