The walnut Kolache is just like my grandmother used to make many years ago, only she didn't use as many nuts. This is the fourth time I have ordered, and I have to say, I do not share with anyone. I savor every loaf not caring about the calories. I am very glad I found this company and I will continue to order to treat myself. read more

At the risk of getting an even bigger belly than I already have, I'd eat their chocolate walnut kolachi every day! The perfect blend of buttery pastry, chocolate, and crunch! read more

The Kolachi cookies are buttery and sweet always great The rum balls were very moist and tasty I am never disappointed in anything they create read more

Your Kolachi Rolls taste just like the ones my grandmother made! Absolutely delicious! As you can see, I keep them in the freezer. They seem to stay fresh forever... When company drops by I pull one out and leave it on the counter. In an hour it's ready to serve. It also makes a great hostess gift when visiting friends. I bring one for their freezer, and I bring one to eat while we're there! We have tried every flavor so far... anxiously awaiting your specialty flavors when the holidays roll back around! read more

Butter Maid Bakery - There is always room for more Kolachi rolls!! - Bakeries Near Me - Boardman, Ohio

My order has never arrived! I expected to receive the order over a week ago. Since this is a food item which is perishable, I would expect it to be delivered much sooner. read more

So delicious and moist, I d give more stars if I could. A little pricey but worth every penny. And by the way,,,they ship freaky fast!

These folks produce AUTHENTIC Slovak confections. I've ordered poppy seed roll elsewhere, but no other place compares to this one. Almost indistinguishable from the delights my grandma used to make. read more

Tha nut kolachi cookies are the best. Bought 3 boxes and my out-of-town company thoroughly enjoyed them. Have bought from Butter Maid many times..never disappointed. read more

If you love Kolachi...this is your place. I've tried several different varieties now, and each one is outstanding. I especially like the flavors you don't see everyday...pumpkin, chocolate walnut, and apple cinnamon. All the Kolachi has been moist as can be. And they don't skimp on the filling! I've always received fast friendly service here, and I recommend this place highly for Kolachi, delicious cookies (esp salted caramel), and wedding cookies! read more

See all

Butter Maid Kolachi are the real deal. Just like mom and grandma used to make, maybe even better (more varieties). The cookies and service are also fantastic. read more

Best Kolachi around. I buy from this shop on a regular basis & then I freeze my extra rolls. The filling is liberal & the dough stays fluffy for a long time. Super fast shipping too. Sign up for specials & get the deals when they come out. It's a large variety, so expend & buy a bunch of yummies. Their cookies are great too. Thank you! read more

Look no further for the most delicious mouth watering Honey Nut Kolachi. Its filled with the most amazing nut filling so smooth and filled with flavor. This Kolachi brought back wonderful memories of my Moms baking and transported me back with every bite. Order more than one as I didn't want to share, but I did. It will leave you wanting more.. read more

I have ordered from them many times. I grew up in Ohio with Hungarian and Polish grandmothers and great-grandmothers, so I know good stuff and this is good stuff! I got the nut roll, apricot kolache, and clothespin cookies. All were fresh and securely wrapped and delicious. Also sent the same order to an 83 year old friend living in Colorado, but raised by Slovenian family in western Pennsylvania and she said they tasted as good her grandmothers. read more

I stumbled upon an ad for Butter Maid Bakery's walnut kolachi rolls - and I've been buying in multiples ever since. Memories: my mom, sister and niece made nut rolls every Christmas, and my sister tediously made lady locks (what Butter Maid calls "clothespins") - and these are just like homemade with REAL BUTTER, California walnuts, and honey if you choose honey walnut kolaches as I do. Ships fast from Ohio to TX! We enjoy a slice or 2 for dessert, sharing with friends, as a handy gift from the freezer in a pinch. I'm very picky and highly recommend this bakery. read more

Five stars for their honey walnut kolachi. It's like my Mom used to make.... moist and lots of filling. I've also ordered some of their other flavors and cookies, but my favorites are the honey walnut kolachi and butterball walnut cookies. read more

When I heard there was a place that made kolache (fruit or nut rolls) near my aunt's, I made plans to stop in. My grandmother, and mom, made kolache, and I've made it several times. It is a lot of work (worth it, but still a big process.) It's not something I see in stores in Columbus, though it makes sense that it is more available in Youngstown and Cleveland. It's a nice little bakery, with cookies and donuts on display, plus a whole cooler with kolache (and more in the back.) Quite a few different flavors; I stuck with traditional ones like apricot and plum, plus a chocolate walnut. They were all good. Not quite homemade, but eggy dough, full of layers of filling. Service was great, selection was great. Only thing keeping them from 5 stars is the price: $15/roll. Ouch. But, they are big rolls, and if it's only something you get for a special occasion, it's worth it. read more

See all

Butter Maid Bakery mailed me a 20%-off coupon in the mail, and I used it to order ~16 apricot kolachi cookies for $20, 8 peanut butter buckeyes for $16, and 2 dozen lady lock cookies for $20. I live only one hour away from this bakery, but I wanted to ensure that my order was delivered quickly, so I skipped the free delivery and paid an extra $11 for UPS Ground. Delivery occurred two days after I placed my order. All of the food was packaged neatly in a box, and none was vacuum-sealed. I liked the taste of all of the food. The quality of the food was similar to what I have purchased from other good businesses. I deducted one star because the shipping could have been slightly faster, and the prices are more expensive than at some other local stores. read more

I keep ordering the original nut roll. Arrives quickly and is double boxed with pastry vacuum sealed. Freezes well. Not too sweet and pastry does not fall apart. read more

Excellent Kolachi! This bakery was fantastic to work with when my cookies came broken in the box. They immediately sent me two new ones to make up for the containers that were broken. I haven't eaten anything from this bakery that I didn't like. Everything is great! I order at the holidays and their order and delivery process is very easy and quick! read more

gee what no ten stars, because that's what I would give these delicious, we call them cold dough cookies, or kolache. Yes my mom, aunts, mother in law, all used this very same recipe.......or at least they certainly taste like that, honest. I would say baba's tasted the same, but both my grandma's passed before I was born. We are Slovak on both sides and only made the apricot, and the ground walnut kolache. I have been buying my cookies from Butter Maid for years. Living in Texas I do have to watch the time of year, so I buy dozens in the Fall like now. Freeze them, except for the broken ones, those are for me, haha!!....and I freeze to use for holidays and special occasions. Thank you for being the best, and using my mom's recipe...haha! Blessings, read more

They do more mail order versus walk-in. Good selection of cookies, lady fingers and giant buckeyes. Nut rolls (Kolachi) unfortunately only came in the vacuum packs like the ones you order online. Good but was hoping for a fresh one not vacuum packed. No seating just an order counter. Will stick to mail ordering, but I was in town. read more

Doesn't taste as good as it used to. I can tell the ingredients are different. Been ordering for a long time. I don't think tge quality is the same. Disappointed. read more

Buttermaid Bakery is the best in Youngstown! Always flavorful & the softest cookies ever! I have them delivered to me in Florida.Let's face it. Baked goods this awesome do not exist in Florida.Nobody comes close.Plus everything is consistently good. read more

Absolutely incredible just like Mom used to make ! I am in NC and was so impressed at the fast processing of my order and shipping took no time to get to me and the quality was just outstanding. Will definitely be a long time customer. read more

Butter Maid Bakery - a box of doughnuts - Bakeries Near Me - Boardman, Ohio

The staff was polite, and the food is always delicious!!! They have a good selection and a variety to choose from. read more

We absolutely love Butter Maid Bakery! They are our go to for nut rolls, clothespin cookies and more. Product are always fresh and arrive on time. The nut rolls remind us of our grandmothers - perfection! Clothespin cookies- light delicacies. Try eating just one. Excellent customer service. read more

My family love their nut rolls and they arrive carefully packaged. I highly recommend this company.

The absolute best kolaches in the Country! Great service, fast delivery. A Star Quality Bakery. Give them a try, you will become a regular.

If you want quality products that are just like mom/grandma use to make, look no further. The Kolachi rolls are our favorites. We order at least twice a year and are never disappointed. read more

I had been a long time customer and had recommended their products to 11 others that have become customers. I no longer will purchase anything from Buttermaid Bakery. The last order I received from them prior to Christmas contained a moldy product, even though it was supposed to be vacumn packed. I was unable to notify them the day of the delivery since later that day I suffered a medical emergency. Upon returning home and getting back to normal on December 16, I notified Buttermaid of the moldy product I received. I received a reply on December 19 stating they were working on it and would get back to me. I hadn't heard anything so on December 27 I again asked about a refund. I received an email latter that day saying they were on vacation until January 9 and would respond then. On Janyary 10, I sent another request. I received an email stating I would hear back as quickly as possible. On January 11 I received an email from Butter Maid stating they would not issue a refund for the moldy product even though I offered to send date and time stamped pictures because the timeframe was too long between receiving the product and reporting the issue. If you buy from this company, make sure you document and report any issue with your delivery as soon as your order is received. Another friend of mine also will not buy from them anymore since Butter Maid's carrier (FedEx) delivered the products he ordered were damaged so badly he could not give them as Christmas presents to people as planned. Butter Maid told him to seek restitution from FedEx. He;s still fighting with them and this January 14. read more

I purchased the reduced sugar walnut kolachi. The problem is their service. I received the packaged and it's so dirty and damaged. I emailed the Butter made bakery regarding how I received the package delivered by FedEx. I took pictures of the damaged package including the damaged content and I emailed it to Butter made bakery. They sent me a return label thru email. I took the damaged package to FedEx and I asked for receipt. I emailed also the photo of the receipt to Butter made and I said to replace the kolachi or refund to me my money. I was told thru email that they will refund my money as soon as they receive the damaged package. I said, I already sent to you all the evidence that it was damaged. Actually, I need to be compensated for this. I reported them to my credit card company and credit card helped me to get my money. Butter maid bakery, no reputation, no courtesy. read more

Received my order, and once again, it was amazing! Just like Grandma used to make! It takes me to Grandma's kitchen in Cleveland, Ohio. I was never able to find anyone who baked the way she did, and then I found you. Thank you so much!! read more

Excellent nut bread. Sent to everyone for Christmas. Butter Maid had great customer service, and shipping on time

Butter Maid Bakery is my family's 100% recommend. We enjoyed their poppyseed roll, nut roll and kolachi cookies as part of our holiday tradition--and now we will be ordering them all year long. Our grandmothers to the current young cousins have baked these items for fifty years--All that practice and we simply can't make them as well. We have sent these beautiful, fresh baked goods as gifts to delighted recipients. Butter Maid Bakery is a treasure we are so happy to have found. We are already anticipating our next order. read more

I have ordered nut rolls and apricot rolls for my sister in Myrtle Beach for years....this is the first year she did not receive them? something about no apartment number...?? I don't know if they were returned to your bakery or what? Order number 800410...tracking number 9405511206217509661619....sooo disappointing!...Carol drueckhammer cbfruth@yahoo.com read more

First Time order and I will have to say that my family was very happy with the quality of the Poppy seed and Walnut rolls that we ordered for delivery last week. They are filled with filling and are as close to what I make. I will be ordering these again because it takes a lot less to order than it does to make and the quality is Fantastic. read more

Very good bakery! Just like my mom & grandma used to make. Nut roll, poppy seed & apricot are my favorite.

we have been ordering from Butter Maid for many years. Their 'nut roll' is exactly what my aunts in Western Pennsylvania would make for every holiday. Delivery is always quick. read more

Kolachi is my favorite dessert, and you can get the best at Butter Maid! They often have mail order specials, and have special flavors throughout the year. read more

If you are wanting the taste of delicious homemade nut rolls without all the sugar, I highly recommend Butter Maid Bakery's Reduced Sugar Walnut Kolachi Roll. They have a lot of other rolls and cookies made with sugar, as well. The online order process is simple. They offer coupons often and free shipping when three items or more are ordered. read more