I don't know how a legit Napoletan pizza place found home on the Isla but I'm just a happy…read morebeneficiary of it. Andrea, an instructor at our dive shop, is Italian, and he said this place is amazing - what better recommendation does one need? We landed on jackpot the first time we came here: the Siciliana is one of the two best pizzas I've had outside Napoli. If you like olives and don't mind anchovies, or are scared of the anchovies but have never tried it, get this with an egg in the middle (ask them not to cook it all the way through). It's briny and salty and heavenly in olive oil. Add some crushed red pepper, and voila - belleza in your mouth. Ask for the balsamic vinegar to mix with oil and dip the crust. Ugh. Yum. The staff here is also super sweet. They saw us three nights in a row but they were just as nice the first night. I wasn't a fan of the seafood pizza (frutti di mare), and the carbonara was ok - the carbonara comes with whipped egg, so ask them not to do that and to put it in the middle instead, again, not cooked all the way through.

This place was actually recommended by a burger bar. The kid pointed us to this restaurant as the…read morebest pizza in town. Definitely it is the best pizza. Everything is fresh and the attention is amazing "Ricardo" great guy.

Very good pizza. Sonny (originally from Canada) has been living here for a few years. Sonny's pizza…read moreis some of the best pizza I've had anywhere, much less on Isla Mujeres. Delicious. If I remember correctly, they are "cash only." I think you can pay in USD if you want/need to. Parking in the immediate area is limited. The new Presidential (Mayor) building is literally around the corner so the curbs in the immediate area are now all painted red (no parking zones). There was a full row of small vehicles and golf carts parked in a red-zone when we were there. None were towed or got tickets but they had been newly painted in the past 48 hours (April '26). I would suggest finding "yellow" parking in the immediate surrounding area and walk to Sonny's. There is also a Sonny's "south" located at The Joint close to Punta Sur. However, they only have a limited menu of about 6 pizzas. We prefer the original located downtown. Bottom line - Delicious pizza . Worth the visit. Parking is limited. Bon appétit, y'all.

Sonny's pizza is amazing. We stop by for his wonderfully seasoned margarita cheese pizza and…read moreSangria every time we are on Ilsa. Food and service is consistently good over all these years.

The lasagna is the best we've ever had... but the seafood linguini is life changing…read more Most folks don't think of eating Italian food while in Isla, but you MUST enjoy a meal at Mamma Rosa's. Authentic. Delicious. Great service. Good wine list. And air condition!!! DELICIOSO!!

Who knew I'd come to a little Mexican Island for the most exquisite Italian food. All the pastas…read moreare homemade and it shows. We started out with their meatballs (cut with a fork tender) and mussels (delish). Their Cesar salad was equally amazing and could be shared with 3 people. I had the lobster fettuccine Alfredo, so so good! My husband had the seafood pasta that came out foil wrapped and steaming. Seafood was tender full of flavor. Their ragu meat sauce tortellini was homemade and the sauce was heavenly! Even the pepperoni pizza had great crust and sauce flavor. Size was big! We sat outside on the cobblestone street where they come by and play music, such an amazing experience. Service is friendly! Oh and our wine and cosmopolitan perfect! This is a must stop in Isla Mujeres

Amazing food and service... Really cool ambiance. We tried this place from recommendation from 2…read moreother people, glad we tried it and looking forward to coming back for dinner before we go.

My family loves this place! Whenever we visit Isla Mujeres, we always enjoy having dinner here. The…read morewaitstaff was welcoming and very accommodating for my needs as a plant-based diner. They were attentive to our needs and checked on us regularly. The outdoor seating was lovely with the street performers and string lights. Inside was just as pretty with sky lighting and a fountain. My husband ordered rigatoni, my kids had their pizza and I enjoyed a vegano (vegan) specially requested pizza made without oil. It was delicious and fresh! I highly recommend you give this place a try if you happen to be visiting Isla Mujeres.

I dined here on Valentines day last month with my granddaughter and her partner. It was packed but…read morewe managed to get a table right away. The hostess was nice and got us in the door. She was walking us a little towards the back, but since it was my first time to Isla, I wanted to people-watch, so I asked about a table up front. As soon as we headed over, I saw why she passed it - it was right next to the saxophone player! Thank goodness his volume level was perfect! Just loud enough to be heard over the crowds walking down the 'lane' out front and the restaurant diners' chatting. But not so loud that we 3 couldn't chat. We loved it! Now these two can EAT - and love to try everything on the menu, whereas I tend to eat smaller portions. I ordered the shrimp tacos and they were fantastic - huge pieces of shrimp, so good! The lobster mac n cheese is so good, I would have loved to bring a big container of it home with me! The restaurant is very busy but very clean and tables are well organized for maneuvering a quick trip to the restroom before leaving. Our server, Maylen was attentive and pleasant. The bar area, facing the street, looked like a lot of fun, I'll have to try it next time!

There was a saxophone player while I was there. I tried the chicken tacos. They were good. There…read morewas a table with a birthday there and the staff brought a dessert with a sparkler on it. And the saxophone player walked up to them played for them. That looked pretty nice. We sat next to the bar and there were some obnoxious gringos at the bar while we were there... which is common on the north side of the island.

READ BEFORE YOU GO! As far as Isla pizza goes, Mike's is very good. But, they recently moved. So…read moreif you are looking for it at their old address (Av. Perimetral Ote. S/N 77400), you won't find it. I know where to go but, unfortunately, I can't tell you the new address. It's at the corner of Calle Paseo de las Aves and Calle Macabi. What I will do is screenshot the location while standing in front of it and maybe that will help you find it. They do deliver if you don't want to pick it up. TWO PRO TIPS: First, They only take cash and second, like many places on Isla, they will screw you if you are paying with American dollars. They will take it but their 'conversion rate' is high. Do yourself a favor and pay with Pesos. Now, as far as the pizza, like I said, its pretty good. It's a long way from the best I've ever had but it is one of the better pizzas on Isla. I don't think you'l be disappointed if you order it. Bottom line - Good pizza. Pay with Pesos if you can to save money. The address listed as of 4/1/25 (Av. Perimetral Ote. S/N 77400) is NOT correct. I hope this helps. Bon appétit, y'all.

Keep in mind this was the day after Tropical Storm Helene hit the area…read more We ordered, for delivery, the Mike's Famous Stuffed Pizza and cannoli. They didn't have the cannoli but what would you expect after a storm? I also asked if they could deliver ice, as we really don't want to head. Our guy delivered, on time, with ice! The pizza was warm and delicious and the ice was...well...still ice! He earned a big tip. I highly recommend!

We stopped for lunch because we heard they had really good pizza. It wasn't busy and around lunch…read moretime when we came. We were seated quickly and put in an order right away. It was a very chill, fast casual kind of spot, perfect for the day we were having. My friends were not disappointed with the pizza and garlic knots. The portions were huge and looked absolutely amazing. I had chips and guac and shrimp ceviche. Both were big portions, tasty and fresh. Service was good and if you are in the area stop by for some food.

Excellent NY style pizza...hand-tossed!! Had the Italian Sausage and it was excellent! Highly…read morerecommend going if you're on the island! Service was wonderful as well. Would definitely return!

The beautiful upstairs patio decor immediately caught my eye. Peppers was the first restaurant my…read morehusband and I tried and it did not disappoint. We both had the half order of cheese bread, which was fried to perfection. I ordered the Popeye pasta dish and my husband ordered a chicken pesto pizza. Both were delicious but the Popeye pastes dish took the gold. ALSO Passion Fruit Tea is so good and the staff was excellent! I highly recommend.

The good: friendly service reasonable prices for Calle hidalgo, good ambiance, generous pizza size…read more The bad: pizza sauce is made with tomato paste. unlike real Italian pizza and on the contrary to their claim, pizza dough is pre-made, don't let the hand roller in the pizza boot trick you. And it tastes like it too. We will pass this place and continue our search for a good pizza

Mixed review for Angelo's - we visited on night one and had a phenomenal experience. 6 people and…read morewe ordered so much food - every single item was out of this world. My favorite was the lobster - and whatever sour cream/cheese/butter they serve with the baked potato was the stuff loaded potato dreams are made of. Second trip - prices seemed to have doubled and I'm not sure how our bill was so high. Lobster cost 3x as much as the previous visit 48 hours before, and while I understand market prices, that seemed a bit extreme. Also had trouble with our bill after it posted - the restaurant added an additional tip despite us tipping very well in pesos. Overall - great food, but pay attention to your bill.

We gave this place a chance and enjoyed it a great deal. Try the pizza & pasta!…read more We absolutely loved the fresh hand made pepperoni pizza, top 3 pizza I've had in my life. I wasnt sure about the shrimp Alfredo but this too was fabulous. My friend also tried to bolognese and it did not disappoint!

Really awesome decor in this place! One of the best I've seen so far!…read more Sadly, no one else was at the restaurant besides our small group of 4. What a shame! This food is so good! Oysters to start with the Mediterranean salad. Very good base to get started! I had the jumbo shrimp wrapped with bacon and Gouda! The dipping sauce they made for it was fantastic! My friends had the octopus and the catch of the day-----soooo tasty and cooked perfectly! Would love to see this place popping on a weekend night. It's a shame that no one else was eating there. Russell was our server and he did a great job accommodating our group!

So good went there twice. The arranchera was very good with white rice and mushrooms. Definitely…read morerecommend. Kinda expensive but good is very good solid 4 star. If meal didn't cost $100 US I would give it 5 stars.