I forget where I first heard about this place (probably TikTok), but thankfully I had it bookmarked. It was about 15 minutes off the highway on our trip back from New Orleans to Texas on a Friday, and hubby rarely lets me down when I propose a foodie detour -- so he was game! Thank goodness I didn't read the reviews too closely beforehand because apparently they can sell out early. We rolled in around 11:30 am, and while there was a short line, it moved quickly -- and they still had EVERY flavor available. Score! We opted for a box of four ($3.50 for a standard flavor, $3.75 for a seasonal one) -- honestly, way cheaper (and better) than that sad Crumbl franchise. We went with the s'mores (the gal in front of us said she came in just for that one), a mint Oreo, a butter cookie, and a chocolate one with cheesecake inside. It's now one day later, and there's only one left -- that's how good they are! The texture is that perfect slightly under-baked middle, which, in my humble opinion, is the superior way to bake a cookie. Of the three I've tried so far, the mint Oreo has been my favorite -- rich, chewy, and perfectly balanced between chocolate and mint. The s'mores was also fantastic -- melty and gooey in all the right ways. On to the owner's story -- which is seriously inspiring. Caroline started baking cookies at 21 during Covid, selling them to friends and family. She quickly realized she had a business on her hands. With the help of her dad -- who's also a business owner -- she launched this company, and now she's absolutely killing it with three Louisiana locations, a growing team of employees, and a reputation for selling out almost daily. What she's built takes guts, and it's clear she's not just surviving -- she's thriving. But what I love most is that she didn't settle for a boring, cookie-cutter (pun intended) storefront. Nope -- the place is FUN. The doors and walls are painted with playful cookie designs, and the vibe is super inviting. You can tell Caroline put real thought into making the space feel special. Even the merch is next level -- embroidered sweatshirts that are super high quality. Yeah, they're $50, but honestly, they feel like the kind of sweatshirt you'd live in all winter. I came this close to buying one for MY sister Caroline -- but alas, budget constraints got the best of me (for now). And the marketing? Genius. She's got that cool, low-key social media strategy that makes you feel like you stumbled upon a secret -- even though the line out the door proves otherwise. It's not just the cookies that make you want to keep coming back -- it's the whole experience. Caroline's story, her energy, the atmosphere -- it all makes you want to root for her and support the business. I'm already thinking about my next road trip just to swing by again (and maybe justify that sweatshirt purchase). read more

See all

I definitely understand the hype of these cookies! I went on a Saturday morning at noon (they opened at 11), and I was one of the last ones to get one of everything that day. Such an adorable store filled with delicious cookies. I got a box full of various flavors of cookies. From peanut butter and chocolate to animal cracker to red velvet, there was a flavor for everyone. The cookies are a decent size, not as big as Crumbl but bigger than a regular cookie, and most are stuffed with something. I found the cookies to be moist and full of flavor. I really liked on the box it tells you how to store them if you don't eat all of them right away. For a full box of cookies, 6 of them, it was $22.. each cookie being $3.50. The staff was so amazing and patient with everyone. I was so glad I was able to come and experience this amazing cookie spot! read more

Caroline’s Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Lafayette, Louisiana

See all

Caroline's cookies is always a hit! The specialty flavors each week are so fun and amazing! 10/10 recommend!! read more

See all

Caroline's Cookies is one of the newest dessert joints in Lafayette and has had a huge social medial following, especially at their start up, now it's mostly word of mouth about these two hour wait, six cookie limit, sellout after an hour of opening places. Sounds like a major headache and some bs for some cookies, right?!? RIGHT. Well, lucky for me and you, my stubborn ass (because, lines? Waits? No guarantees? No thank you!) did finally have a dear friend stand in line one morning recently for us to try one (ok six) of these babies. And I get it you guys. I freaking GET IT. Tip-put these in the microwave for a few seconds. Oh lord, are they are decadent! The ones we tried (see photos) were all good... but the Peppermint Hot Cocoa y'all...goodness. Chocolate, marshmallow and a hint of peppermint. They taste like Christmas love. Freaking Christmas love, ok? Absolutely delicious, absolutely worth every single minute in line. Believe the hype about these cookies and do not hesitate to go to Caroline's!! read more

See all

These cookies are thick and gooey (and delicious). I enjoyed trying some of the June flavors, but I think my favorite is still Circus (not pictured but available year round!!). The store branding is adorable. There's always a wrap around line but service is efficient and runs smoothly. Very impressed by this business run almost exclusively by young women. Will definitely be going back. read more

Caroline’s Cookies - Brownie sandwich - Bakeries Near Me - Lafayette, Louisiana

See all

Literally just the best cookies you've ever had! And just the sweetest workers!!!! Love Caroline cookies so much!! read more

Caroline’s Cookies - COOKIES - Bakeries Near Me - Lafayette, Louisiana

Caroline's Cookies are the BEST! I've tried other "cookie" shops and there's a reason that Caroline's sells out almost every day! They're great! I love that customers can get punches on a card for free cookies and after the 3rd card they get a dozen free plus the ability to bring a favorite flavor back on the menu for a day. So many flavors, such a hard decision! (Thankfully, there are little to no wait times in Lafayette any more. But they still sell out.) read more

Caroline’s Cookies - Waffle with butter and syrup , surprisingly good! - Bakeries Near Me - Lafayette, Louisiana

We are from Texas and had heard great things about these cookies. We happened to get there early and decided to wait for opening and I'm so glad we did because a line started forming before opening. It moved so quickly because they have a very structured system in place for getting people in and out! Now the cookies - phenomenal. Way better than any Crumbl or modern cookie shop. They're not overly sweet, thick, the perfect texture, and full of flavor. Can't wait to be back! read more

Caroline’s Cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Lafayette, Louisiana

See all

I can cry just thinking about not having these for another year. The Christmas tree was absolutely spectacular. The topping was so good, fluffy, and sweet. These cookies are really sweet, which is kinda nice because you can just eat half a cookie at a time. They offer delivery, which is amazing. They arrived perfectly in a box and came within the time slot specified. read more

Caroline’s Cookies - Hot Cocoa, Christmas Tree, Stuffed Chocolate Chip, Eggnog and Peppermint Bark - Bakeries Near Me - Lafayette, Louisiana

My granddaughter really wanted these cookies so we decided to leave the house early from New Orleans to Baton Rouge to buy some cookies. We arrived there a little after 12 and waited over 20 min to get waited on, when we did they were all out of 5 different cookies. We did not know that until we got there and they advertise that they updated their website every 5 minutes so we keep on checking every 10 min kind of like a game and they kept on posting that they had all flavors. I have no respect for a company that states one thing and doesn't deliver. As far as the taste goes and as a baker myself they all tasted the same except for different add ins like chocolates chips or M&Ms or sprinkles. read more

Ok, since my last review I've visited Caroline's again and she's started doing this time slot thing which really helps with lines! This was actually executed quite well and it was cool to just wait, grab a card, and return during our assigned time! I liked that she tried to help battle the crazy line situation and this really made our experience quite quick! My only gripe is that she did run out of cookies we wanted to try which was a bummer. So this kinda turns into waiting in line for the soonest time a lot, rather than now waiting in line to get cookies first. It's definitely a much better system than before though. I also still don't love all the flavors. Some of these just feel like overload and I wish she'd take a more creative approach with seasonal flavors. I came during the Halloween specials and recently for the December ones, and I've gotta say, Circus cookie still wins every single time. She had a cinnamon roll one during October which was really simple but great! None of the December flavors felt standout. The hot cocoa was really just sugar overload (reminded me of the worms in dirt one, which also felt like too much). But she's doing great at improving and I'm excited for her to grow. Also, as you can see in my pics below her Halloween decor was ADORABLE. read more

See all

Now I don't even know how to feel about Crumbl anymore. I fought tooth and nail to find their booth at Festival Internationale to no avail so I decided to go to the brick and mortar yesterday for cookies. As soon as I opened the door, a pleasant odor of fresh baked cookies engulfed my nasal cavities. I promptly waited in line while filling out my order. I was surprised with how quickly the line moved and I am very impressed with their system. I ordered 8 different cookies. The pricing was not half bad considering the size of cookies. The cookies are mounds of pure deliciousness. When you bite into them you get every morsel of cakey gooey ness. I really enjoy soft cookies and these didn't disappoint. My favorite so far is Nutella stuffed. Please go here for friendly service!!!! read more

my favorite place in the whole world ! I mean you know you're doing it right when your COOKIE SHOP closes 3 days of the week/weekend !! I love all of the cookies. The original chocolate chip w/ salt is actually my favorite. Thank you Caroline for putting your hard work into this place ! read more

Everything is amazing!!! Not a negative thing can be said about this place!! Love every single flavor of cookie that is made here!! Staff is always friendly and welcoming read more

Make sure you wake up at 7 am and get you a time slot! Great cookies. They are large and tasty. My family and I enjoy grabbing the monthly specials. Awesome cookies. read more

Caroline’s Cookies - Different cookies - Bakeries Near Me - Lafayette, Louisiana

This spot is a must visit while in Lafayette! Some of the best and most unique cookies I've ever encountered. The cookies themselves were so delicious with each one having its own speciality taste and look. My personal favorite was the Oreo swirl with cream cheese icing that was out of this world! The inside was super cute with a little spot to take pictures. The only downside is that the place is so popular that you have to reserve a time slot to go a pick up cookies and later on in the day they allow walk-ins. Which I understand but at the same time it kinda doesn't make you want to wait for some cookies. Even though they are worth the wait! Totally recommend! read more

See all

Was extremely disappointed in this cookie shop. Ordered 4 chocolate chip cookies bc they were sold out of all the other flavors. When opened the box the cookies looked as though they were raw. When we tried the cookies they had no flavor and tasted like raw flour, were not sweet, and seemed as though they didn't use vanilla or sugar in the batter. read more

Caroline has really made something special with her cookies here! I never had her cookies when she was selling at the farmer's market, but it's so incredible to see how quickly her business has grown. Her cookies are delicious! My favorite are the Christmas tree cookie and customers choice, but one thing I love is that they are always getting creative and trying new flavors because it makes it very fun. The cookies are fairly priced for how big they are, too, I think. I brought some when we were visiting family in Lake Charles over the holidays, and they were crazy about them too. read more

It could've been due to the holiday rush, but our Mother's Day cookie cake was borderline inedible. The dough was clearly undercooked, and you could tell with color and confirm with the taste. The icing was so off-putting since it was tasteless. I took one bite as we put it our for serving and I immediately had to take it off the counter in fear of other people eating it. I've had good experiences with them in the past so I hope it was just a rush/timing issue. If it wasn't, the cookie cakes are not good at all. read more

I tried going inside to get some cookies a while back and was told they were out of cookies. Figured I would give them another chance today about 1:45 in the afternoon on a Tuesday as I was passing by and the door was locked, apparently they are closed. No closed sign, no hours of operation posted anywhere. Who does business like this LOL? Seems like it is more of a hobby than a business. Show some respect to your potential customers and treat it like a business. read more

Without a doubt, my favorite place to order cookies in Louisiana. Whenever I'm in town, I try to sneak a spot in the virtual queue and pick up a half dozen to bring back to the family in NOLA. No matter what the seasonal/weekly flavor, you won't be disappointed! read more

A very good cookie spot in laffy. I'll say you do need a reservation and the spots go fast. Lol have to find a spot online. But the cookies are spot on. They have a different flavor each month so be sure to check it out read more

I love supporting local businesses and caroline is so young which makes me love the cookies even more. But the cookies are actually amazing they are unlike anything I've ever tried. I mean really if people are waiting in line for hours at a time over a cookie they haveee to be good And they 100% are!! read more

See all

Everything is amazing!!! Not a negative thing can be said about this place!! Love every single flavor of cookie that is made here!! Staff is always friendly and helpful!!! read more

Cookies were amazing and the service was very helpful, friends and efficient. Will definitely be back again!

Hear they have great cookies! Problem is they are always closed and I never get to try them. Why can't they just open everyday like other small businesses around town :( read more

Caroline's Cookies is better than any dessert you could find. Her cookies are the perfect way to end (or start) the day!! Baked and sweetened to perfection Shes nothing but hard working and passionate about her business. A must for anyone and everyone!! read more

If you want the worlds best cookies look no further. Caroline is the hardest working 19 year old and business owner I know. She puts her heart and soul into getting as many people as possible cookies, and works to perfect them each time she bakes. The waiting in line is definitely worth it. Don't let anybody else tell you otherwise. Buy Caroline's Cookies, you won't regret it. read more

These are the best cookies I have personally ever had. The cookies are very unique and are very flavorful! I understand other customers frustration with the line but I believe the wait is worth it for true sweet lovers. Can't wait to have a Caroline's cookies on every corner. read more

Caroline's Cookies is quite honestly the BEST cookies around. I've never been a huge cookie fanatic, but after trying Caroline's Cookies I've never craved anything more than I do these cookies! Not only are these cookies the best you'll ever try, but the customer service is amazing! Caroline and her employees do everything they can to keep their customers happy and I just know they exhaust all of their ideas on just how to do that, even when the line wraps around the building! Not only does the line wrapped around the building every day open, show how good these cookies are, but the fact that a lot of the customers in the line are returning customers coming back to wait in that same line they waited in the first time they visited and buy these cookies again and again!! Caroline's Cookies, y'all are killing it and as a 19 year old, self-employed woman, Caroline, you should be proud of yourself because everyone else is amazed by you! read more