Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Casey's

    2.0 (1 review)
    Open 3:00 am - 10:00 pm

    Casey's Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Casey's

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration
    Photo of Jake W.
    0
    30
    10

    6 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Casey's

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Pizza 1,879 times last month within 15 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Moscato's Pizza & Italian Bakery

    Moscato's Pizza & Italian Bakery

    3.6
    (44 reviews)
    1.7 mi
    $

    We love the pizza at Moscato's and usually order once a month at least. They really pile on the…read morecheese! Great pizza!!! Nice staff :)

    First, in this economy, you want the places you spend your hard earned money at to AT LEAST get the…read moreorder correct. Besides several missing items and errors, the quality of the food was poor at best. The pasta was severely under salted, which is pasta 101.....SALT THE WATER. The garlic bread was dry and extremely bland. It tasted like four day old bread that was about to mold with just enough butter to give it color, but not much in the way of flavor. Their sauce tasted severely over-cooked. The meatballs were.....well....wimpy in flavor and texture. The chicken parmesan was rather small in size, but they give you a ton of pasta on the side to compensate, I guess, and (again) needed seasoning. I suppose I had to give them a small bump for their pasta portion size (the cheapest thing an Italian restaurant can provide, really). I will add that they were apologetic when we returned to get the items they forgot, but it's not much comfort when all the food is cold by the time you get back with the missing stuff. It tends to kill the appetite. The desserts are okay, for the most part, if you don't require super sweet stuff. Overall, it was extremely disappointing and not worth the $120 to feed four adults. And, in our smaller town with slim pickings for restaurants, we can easily (and sadly) cross this one off our list of places we will order from again.

    Photos
    Moscato's Pizza & Italian Bakery
    Moscato's Pizza & Italian Bakery
    Moscato's Pizza & Italian Bakery

    See all

    Sam's Pizza

    Sam's Pizza

    4.1
    (20 reviews)
    1.3 mi

    Finally had an opportunity to try Sams pizza. What a great place and the owner/workers were so…read morefriendly. We ordered a medium sausage pizza and 2 cans of pop. It was absolutely delicious. We thought the pizza had the perfect amount of cheese, sauce and sausage. Yes, like others have stated, the sauce is a bit sweeter than most, but it was not overly sweet. We really enjoyed it cold the next day which is a plus. We will be telling our friends and going back there soon.

    I feel badly giving this place a bad review because so many people rave about it (what are they…read morethinking?) but the stars are strictly for the great service. Lady on phone was super nice as was the delivery guy. The pie was piping hot when it arrived. I've never experienced that before, ever! Now the pizza itself. The crust was fine but there was way too much cheese. I know some people like that but to me it's just gross. The sauce is mediocre at best. Thin, watery, tasteless and too salty...also sort of sweet? Not zesty at all which I think is vital. The absolute worst part was the veg on top (see photo). The green peppers were pre-cooked, I think? They weren't fresh. They were sort of soft, pale and slimy/watery. Bleck. They also use those cooked mushrooms out of the can. Eww. I think the onions also may have been pre-boiled or something? Idk! It was the strangest pizza I've ever had. If you're putting that crap on pizza, I'm sorry but you don't know how to make a good pie. I'm pretty sure the Italians don't do their pizza this way, and people are saying the owner is a first generation Italian. Sorry, but this place is a definite no for me!

    Photos
    2025 Menu (cash only)
    2025 Menu (cash only)
    Burnt pizza crust from Sam's

    See all

    Burnt pizza crust from Sam's
    Little Caesars Pizza

    Little Caesars Pizza

    1.4
    (36 reviews)
    0.6 mi
    $

    This location in general has not given us any particular issues! Our pizza was hot and ready…read more HOWEVER, I'm not sure if it is just this location (as we do not have another that closer to us) or if all LC's have changed their dough. The texture is like a sponge and very difficult to chew. We are SO sad!!!! It was our favorite quick and cheap pizza. But the new dough that they've been using, just is NOT the best. Bring the old recipe backkk!!

    Place my order at 7:19 went down there to see if I can get my pizza out of the portal. . So the…read morepizza that I sit there and stared at for over 15 minutes sitting on top of a box on their counter a young man that looked like he just came in off the street with no gloves on hands in his pockets cut my pizza up. And said here you go imagine how cold that pizza was and how upset they were when I asked them to remake it they wanted to argue with me people that left to drive through had to come inside they wanted to just sit there and talk then supposedly after they put my pizza in the oven the young man left and now the young lady left and neither one of them look like they're dressed to even work in there be one of the last times I go here I can't even trust my food now. In the photo was in the oven for one minute??? So now I'm waiting for a fresh one. Would you trust to eat it. Manager needs to check the cameras. Were these 2 people wearing street clothes no gloves. Hands in pockets fronts and backs???? One female staff was professional.

    Photos
    Little Caesars Pizza
    Unevenly cut pizza
    Unevenly cut pizza
    Crazy bread not cut and shoved into bag

    See all

    Crazy bread not cut and shoved into bag

    Casey's - pizza - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...