Hard to believe its been 7 years since my last review and think its time for another one…read more The place closed up for about a year and then reopened with different management and staff crew. They are still in the stage of refreshing some of the interior but what's improved is the cookery of the food. On this visit it was their typical Tuesday Tractor night and was good to catch up on some ole friends. I ordered a typical dish which was their hamburger steak and side of mashed potatoes and side salad. I was surprised and impressed on how well the hamburger steak covered in their brown gravy sauteed onions and their mashed potatoes where especially tasty. That alone made the trip and food worth the visit. I look forward to seeing how their improved dishes is reflected with the other menu items.

Eric Miller is truly an excellent chef. Waverly Steak House is truly a Goldmine when it comes to…read moreamazing culinary this side of South Dakota. Chef Miller will not disappoint! The lamp chislic was prepared medium rare and was truly moist and flavorful. The New England clam chowder was probably the best I've had and has compared to the more traditional clam chowder of New England! Jumbo shrimp dinner was simply amazing and worked so well with the squash. Peach cobbler was one of the best I've had and finished off nicely as a desert.

Delicious Delicious Delicious! Our steak was flavored spot on and cooked to perfection. Mashed…read morepotatoes were excellent (the best I ever ate). Staff is very friendly. For sure we will be back again and again!

This place is amazing! They have it fit for hunters to come and relax with deer, bison, mountain…read morelions and others on the wall. They have a great selection of whiskey including some harder to find stuff like Blantons and higher Crown Royals. The salad bar is one of those great salad bars in roadside steakhouses. The potato salad was great. If I was hungrier I would have gone for the Oreo fluff and a couple other things. I ordered the NY strip steak and fries. The steak was delicious and the fries were good, as well. The bartender and I talked about the area and discussed the bad weather they've been having lately and I asked about Castlewood. One of those great Midwest places!

not good food, out of everything. Would never be back. Had a steak, not good. No salad, no burger,…read moreeverything was bland on what I did get.

Food is delicious, but be ready for unpredictable waits. We sat around 6:30, ordered by 6:45,…read moreanother table came in and ordered. They got their food and were done with it before our food came out at 7:40. Very frustrating, especially for someone that is diabetic and has to wait that long for food to be brought out.

The walleye fingers are our favorite thing to get with the eggrolls from the appetizer. There were…read morevery good compared to our entrées. I ordered a salad the shrimp that came out with. It was jumbo size and they gave quite a bit. My husband ordered the hamburger and it was average just very greasy. The service was quick!

Sat at the bar- no bartender or service for 15 min. Asked a…read moreserver if the bar was open- then someone came. Poured me a beer that had no head (that means flat). I said the beer doesn't look good- before I could order a different one- she disgustedly poured it out and tapped another flat beer... I said- the beer is probably old or not charged anymore- she dumped it out and went back to the same tap even more disgusted. She was having a bad day- I was ready to order a large steak dinner with salad and app.... I made the decision to leave. The restaurant is huge- and it was 20% full. That should have been my first clue. Just showed up to a place with lots of locals. Service is friendly and the beer is fresh. Don't go to Mavericks.....It looks good online- menu looks great- place is clean- but the service is not very inviting.

We had an excellent experience here from start to finish. The food was outstanding -- perfectly…read morecooked, juicy steaks with great portions, creamy garlic mashed potatoes, and bread with butter that honestly beat Texas Roadhouse (and that's saying something). The Smokey Old Fashioned was the perfect finishing touch and one of the best I've had. What really made the night special was getting to meet the owner, who was incredibly kind and welcoming. You can tell they genuinely care about the food and the people who walk through the door. Great food, great drinks, and even better hospitality -- we'll definitely be back.

Needed a South Dakota steak dinner before crossing over to MN. Delicious chislek for appetizer and…read moregreat steaks! Staff was very friendly and cute ambience.

A great spot to get a steak dinner near Pickerel Lake in South Dakota! We typically go to The Lodge…read more(same owner) and decided to venture up to Hilltop for our date night this visit. My husband and I sat at the bar and had gin & tonics, a delicious 10oz sirloin steak, potato, and salad bar! We left full and happy and even had leftover steak to make a yummy salad for lunch. We recommend if you're in the area and in need of a comfort meal.

Arrived with a starving group of four. Ordered drinks and the appetizer of pub chips. They came out…read morehot and so delicious. We all were in heaven. I ordered the flatiron steak with hash browns and a side salad. The salad had perfectly fresh greens with large slices of cucumber and a couple cherry tomatoes. Couldn't have asked for anything better except maybe a couple croutons. The steak had a bourbon glaze, was cooked to a perfect medium and ever so tender. I had to share a bite with everyone because it was that amazing. The rest of the group was just as happy with their food. Chislic with steak fries, Tuscan pasta with chicken and BOMB burger. Everyone raved. If you are within 30 miles of Castlewood, EAT HERE. You will not be disappointed.

It's nice to know that there's a decent restaurant in a small town called Castlewood. The place is…read morenice and clean. The food is delicious. We came here for the Walleye and it did not disappoint. The jumbo shrimp tasted fresh though a little bland in flavor. The service took a while though. We sat for a good 15 mins before our server took our order, though the place wasn't packed. So good food, slow service.

Food and service great! Would recommend. Great option close…read moreto Watertown. Steak cooked to expectations and salad bar yummy.

The steak was tasteless and the service was even worse. Yeah...it's gonna be a while before we try…read morethis place again.

A regular stop during our trips in SD. Cheap beer and whiskey, pool, darts, shuffleboard, and…read morefriendly service. A great place to kill a few hours (or a whole day.)