Let me start by saying, I am not usually a cake person. I've had professional bakery cakes, homemade, ice cream, grocery store bought, you name it...but this was my first experience with a Smith Island cake. I got the basic cake with chocolate frosting for my son's first birthday. Everyone at the party raved over it. Usually leftover birthday cake sits in the fridge a few days then gets tossed...but I had a piece after the party...a piece the next day. I am down to my last 2 slices and already planning the next occasion I need a cake for! I can't wait to try some of the other flavors, they sound amazing. The prices are reasonable and the service was excellent. I called in my order during the week and quickly and easily picked up on Saturday morning. They even offered to write a message on the cake, which was more than I expected! I will be getting all my cakes here from now on! read more

Classic Cakes - The most amazing cake ever! - Bakeries Near Me - Salisbury, Maryland

Fantastic Smith Island cake. Very moist and beautiful frosting. I really liked that they have some cakes on display that you can get by the slice. We got the Oreos and cream and the banana, both amazing. I also thought it was a good deal for $3 a slice. Very friendly place as well and you can see the people make the cakes behind the counter. No place to really sit, but that didn't matter to us. Will be back again! read more

Classic Cakes - Bakeries Near Me - Salisbury, Maryland

See all

The cakes are delicious, and have come in very handy when we've had unexpected company. They are well worth the price you pay! On two occasions, I have seen the younger owner become very short tempered with customers - hence, the loss of a star. She could have been having a bad day, but there's no reason to take it out on customers. The older owner is very nice though. read more

I have ordered many cakes from Classic Cakes and they are always very good quality. The staff has always been happy to answer any questions that I have. I enjoy walking in and seeing everyone working hard to produce a great product. Very reasonably priced as well. read more

Wanted a cake for daughters bday, was told the pastry chef was on vacation and would call me back within a few days. No call. After 2 additional trips to the store, they kept telling me id get a call from him to discuss our cakes. After another few days i just ordered my cake from CakeArt. Til this day (about 2 weeks later) i still have not recieved a call from anyone at ClassicCakes. CakeArt told me the pasrty chef had quit from classic thats why i was given the run around. Horrible service. read more

I ordered a German Chocolate Cake to be FedExed to a 90 year old birthday girl. There were no pecans in the frosting and the coconut was cooked into the icing so it wasn't fluffy. This isn't the way a German Chocolate Cake is supposed to be cooked. See this recipe: http://www.browneyedbaker.com/german-chocolate-cake-recipe/ What a drag to disappoint a 90 year old birthday girl! The cake and shipping was $69. I called them and she said they never put pecans and explained the cooking process of the coconut. I love their cakes, but don't really know if I'll order from them again or go somewhere else. read more

we have been ordering cakes from here for years. however this year we realized the cake was 3 days old when we picked it up. I wonder how many times we ordered cakes days in advance only to be given something that has sat on the shelf for days. read more

I chose Classic Cakes to do my wedding cake because they have great smith Island cakes. Worst mistake ever! Ten minutes before the reception was about to start we didnt have a cake; So I had to call them to remind them that they need to deliver the cake. When the cake was delivered the decoration was pathetic, frozen in the center, and the cake was the wrong flavor. To make the situation worst. I was also disatisfied with thier attempt to right the situation. It took two weeks to get in contact of the owner to finally get a solution, and the end result was a gift certificate to the store. Classic Cakes have a lack of professionalism, and concern for thier customers. read more

using candle wax mixed with chocolate to make peanut butter eggs shiny isn't okay that is not edible...

Wow, I like the regular chocolate Smith Island cake, but the banana was amazing! Wish I had bought a slice of the coconut too... and maybe the cookies and cream and red velvet and .... read more

First,when it comes to there chocolate smith island cake,i will say it is good.however their service as completely turned me off. i will not be returning to this place again.keep in mind i am a repeat customer but I went there about 30 min before closing and i was told they could not slice a new cake for me because it was close to closing time.This is one of two instances at this place,and i will not be returning.its too bad and i will take my money somewhere else. read more