Great variety of items. Everyone very friendly. Good prices, there is a lot of competition in the…read morearea.

Great store with a good staff. Located right on Main St in…read morefront of Legends Field. Huge collection of everything baseball. Gifts or collectibles for all ages. Prices are comparable to all the other souvenir shops on the strip, but this one has a really good selection, especially signed memorabilia and jerseys. Some collectibles are very different too ( "one off" stuff) As for the pricing on collectibles, you need to know your pricing\ value here just like you would anywhere else. But loads of affordable gifts too.

Wonderful service, fantastic products. My favorite is the goat milk soap, unscented. Great for…read morethe skin. Very reasonable prices. Will continue to shop there.

I had heard rumors that a more famous brand in town uses this company to produce some of their…read moregoods, so I thought I'd check it out. This beautiful little shop is located in the back of a building. I loved the layout - very shabby chic with lots of different products artfully displayed. It's so easy to spend time here going around and sniffing all the different soap combinations! Goat's milk soap is a bit more creamy than other kinds of soap, and I was told that the scent lasts longer as well. While I didn't purchase anything this time, I'd be happy to return again.

Just so happen to stumble upon this store and thank goodness I did.. my son souvenir that he wanted…read morefrom Cooperstown was a necklace.. as walking into the store you are greeted with a wholesome smile by some very kind people.. as I was looking at the necklaces I really couldn't decide on which one to get my son.. I wanted something to represent him coming for a baseball tournament but I also wanted something he could wear all the time and not be girly.. the lady helped me decide which ones were more purchased by woman and which was mostly picked by the players.. She also help me make my decision by giving me a visual by putting what u wanted together to see how it looked.. she wasn't rushing me or anything and due to her kind help I ended up getting a necklace I believe my son will love.

Quaint little shop on the Main Street of Cooperstown. Lots of knick knacks and souvenirs you could…read morepurchase. This store is also attached to a Christmas store next door that sells some Christmas decor. Went in about 30 minutes before closing time to browse and gentleman that was working was very nice. He made tons of conversation with us and told us a lot of history from the town. He was very knowledgeable and pleasant. Husband ending up buying a Tshirt. Prices were decent. Nice little shop.

Fairly priced shop with lots of memorabilia and cards sorted by player name. Had a lot of vintage…read morecards and even a few junk wax boxes as well. Actually bought more cards from the gentleman who had a table set up right outside. Worth sorting through the cards to find deals.

BLUF: This store has my lifelong baseball memorabilia business!…read more I am a US Marine stationed in Okinawa, Japan for three years. I recently was home on emergency leave. One day on my way to the hospital, I decided to try to clear my head and do some searching for an anniversary gift for my wife. She absolutely loves Jorge Posada. I looked at a couple of stores, but didn't find anything worth while. Then I walked into Paterno Brothers Sports. I looked on their one wall and I couldn't believe what I saw. They had a certified authentic, autographed baseball by Jorge Posada. So, I asked them to see it. I then asked if they had anything else autographed by him. They said yes. So, I was shown an autographed book. It was Jorge's autobiography. At first, when he said he had a book, I thought it was the one that he and his wife had written about their child with cranio. I only say that because I told the gentlemen my son's story of cranio, and how Jorge's and Mrs. Posada's book helped my wife with so much during that time. Not looking for a discount, the gentlemen then said he would give me a discount and to tell my wife that he hopes she has a great anniversary year. I was taken aback by his generosity. But it doesn't end there. When we went up to the counter, he asked where my wife and I live. I told him that I am stationed in Okinawa. He thanked me for my service (I still don't know how to properly respond to that except to thank a person back). He told me how to ring out on his IPad teller and said he would be right back. Now, at this point, I was only purchasing the autographed baseball. After I signed and was done emailing myself a receipt, he then presented me the autographed book with another thank you for my service. My jaw dropped! I couldn't believe the amount of generosity that this man had. It will forever stick with me. I even almost left my credit card. I want to thank the Paterno Brothers for making my stressful trip into one that I will remember for the rest of my life. Your generosity means so much that I can't thank you enough! Thank you and I will make sure that I return to your store for the rest of my life.

Placed a large order for candles only to have the seller cancel the order days later saying they…read moredidn't carry that fragrance anymore. A few weeks later, I was shopping for the same candle and almost repurchased from this same site because their website still lists them as available. Luckily, I caught it just before submitting my payment again. You'd think they would update their website after the first mishap.

Great store, variety of household items. And owner gives great classes! Great store to visit.read more

It's a consigners dream. The best attribute of Cornucopia is that as a consigner they accept most…read moreanything. I'm so used to Silks and Treasures long list of items and brands they don't consign as they only have so much room because everyone consigns there that they want only things that can bring a larger sale which makes sense but so many gently used or barely worn items I couldn't bring went to Cornucopia and always sells. I've gained some nice returns at Silks but more than trippled that at Cornucopia in half the time. My consignment experience with Shakedown Street was awful. I never saw even one item I consigned on the floor and things like brand new bags and shoes which would have sold in a couple days, a week at most at Silks and Treasures were never bought at Shakedown. I consigned hundreds of dollars worth of clothing, bags and shoes and got one payout for 12 bucks and another for 22 bucks. That's it. Pretty sure they made a killing selling my stuff online, at least that's what I heard. Cornucopia actually let's you have your items back too if they don't sell which is the major draw for consigning there. And the store looks nice for the most part. My only complaint is the new clothes they have are too expensive so naturally people buy the used stuff. I've bought many nice dresses and jeans there this past year and they don't take out anything so I find myself looking for tank tops by pushing past the turtleneck sweaters but it's worth it. No fuss no worries no list to remember and I either pick up my cash or pick up my stuff if it ends up not selling so I never loose or feel cheated.

I used to stop in here once in a while to see what they had. Every time I went there, I was always…read morea mess. Boxes of items never unpacked, and the 2 girls that work there just sit behind the counter on their phones. In the back room, there are clothes on the floor, and it is just an unorganized clutter mess. The clothing and shoes are in terrible shape and outdated and they smell. I will not go back, it is pretty gross.

I have almost as much fun shopping in this store as I do walking through the Hall of Fame. I…read moreremember going here as an 8 year old and wanting everything in the store. Now I'm 31 and I want two of everything. Sure, they have all the stuff you'd expect to find in a Cooperstown gift shop: name/number t-shirts for current stars and Hall of Famers; New Era hats for all 30 teams, as well as vintage teams like the St. Louis Browns and Colts 45s; bumper stickers for the Yankees, Mets and Red Sox. But what makes this place special is the vintage souvenirs and fan gear. Remember puffy stickers? Remember 4-inch buttons with players' pictures on them? Remember batting helmet sundae and cereal bowls? Remember painter-style hats with MLB team logos? Remember ceramic bobbleheads? They're all here. And they're authentic. They don't sell replicas or reproductions of kitschy 70s and 80s fan collectibles. They sell originals, the same ones I was browsing over in 1989. One case contains mid-80s stickers for several MLB teams with a sign that says, "Ask about your favorite team!" I didn't see the Yankees, so I asked. "We've been sold out of them since the early 90s," replied the shopkeeper. "Once these are gone, they're gone forever. They don't make them anymore." In a strange way, I was more excited to hear that. Despite this, prices are fair and don't seem too far off from what they were in the 1980s. After you're done in the Hall, come here for a very different trip down memory lane. Even if you don't buy anything (doubtful) you'll leave with a smile on your face.

Visited in November. Super friendly staff. They were extremely helpful and recommended tons of…read moreplaces nearby to visit. I bought adorable Cooperstown trucker hats for my young nephews and they wear them all the time!

Incredible place to stop by! The owner is so kind and spoke about being a retired teacher. He loves…read moreselling antiques and vintage goods. He gifted me a beautiful lovely little teddy bear. The gentlemen are super kind. We loved the various decor for in and outdoor settings. The prices are great and he gives out masks during COVID-19. Absolute lovely place, affordable prices and great customer service! Despite everything - it's so great to be able to interact with human beings again! Great place to also purchase local maple syrup and vegetables too!

Joe, the owner is friendly, helpful and quite knowledgeable. The store is full of just about…read moreeverything you can imagine. A wonderful walk through time gone by.