One of the very first places my daughter asks to go every time we get to Prescott. We love that you…read morecan just order pizza by the slice, they heat it up fresh right then, and we can take it over to the lawn in front of the old courthouse for the sweetest little picnic. It's become one of those simple traditions we always look forward to. They have such a great variety too, so everyone can find something they love, which makes it even better when visiting with family or friends.

OMG Loved It! Tasty pizza with amazing service!…read moreIf you go, ask for Robb! Coolest server ever! Love this place!! Gluten free pizza actually tastes like pizza!

My wife and I were very impressed with our visit to Limoncello…read more Our server Haley was the best, she knew the menu well and pointed us in the right direction for our order. The two drinks we got were very tasty (Limoncello Lemon drop & The Hugo). Being a Saturday night, it was understandably busy, but the wait staff was incredibly patient and helpful despite the circumstances. Also, all our food still came out very fast (granted, we didn't get pizza). The ambiance is awesome, with a pizza oven shaped and styled like a lemon!

Disappointed with our visit.... -Porcini mushroom / Sausage…read morepizza was ok. Crust, dough good but I really didn't like how the mushrooms were cut into slimy cubes. I expected larger actual mushroom looking pieces. Sausage was good but I couldn't get past the mushroom. $21.95 -Spinach salad (spinaci limone half) felt like a rip off. It was a small 1/2 plate of spinach with a few pecans and raisins. See picture..$7.99 -Amalfe drink was good $11.00 - Service at the bar was good. - There is also a credit card fee. Too many other good restaurants, Italian as well, in Prescott to go to. We won't be back....sorry we love family run businesses too.

In my ongoing quest to find the best pizza in Prescott, I recently ordered an XL pepperoni and…read moresausage from Two Mamas'. The sauce was flavorful, cheese was generous but not overdone, and the toppings were tasty and plentiful. The crust was nice, although I wish it were just a bit more firm. But I would definitely go back. The overall pie was comparable to Granite Mountain Pizza Company, if you like their pizzas.

Service was friendly. We picked up a pizza to go because they close for business 30 min before…read morethey officially close. The pizza is OK. Not great. When they made the sauce oregano was evidently on sale. It is clearly the only dominant flavor in their sauce. Cook temp is also way too low. The crust doesn't crisp like a pizza should. I didn't check out the oven but i bet it doesn't include a fired tile platform. No char on the bottom of the crust at all. Its not somewhere i would return to by choice, and certainly not a destination but its edible.

Always prompt and fast service Great selection of food and…read morebeverages Large beer selection on Tap

I wish I could leave a review, but I never got to try your food. You see, I ordered food through…read moreDoorDash, but the food never arrived. The Dasher, Joshua, delivered to the wrong address. I texted him, and he texted back apologizing, admitting he delivered to the wrong address. He said he would contact DoorDash and tell them to credit the account. I followed up with a call to DoorDash customer support. I explained the situation but was having difficulty understanding the representative due to her accent. I asked to speak with a manager. She put me on hold saying SHE would explain to the manager what happened. The manager came on the line for a brief moment, saying she was declining our refund, didn't care we never got the food, and said her decision was final. I would suggest your establishment stop using DoorDash as they do not reflect well on your establishment and don't care about your customers.

We had business in town and wanted to grab a bite to eat... but avoiding the fast food,…read morevending-machine garbage. There was a parking spot immediately 8n front of The Grumpy Sicilian so I thought "Why not?" Good choice. None of us wanted a big meal so we risked getting just a slice -- which was delicious! I feared that it might be dried out, but judging from the traffic, the pizza was freshly baked and the town foot traffic made short work of the pie. In other words, it was freshly baked and disappeared fast. Excellent pizza, too. Good vibes, cool place, excellent food... and I like that they kept a parking spot open for our arrival!

I've been on the hunt for good chicken parm, did not find it here. So far the best parm I've got…read morewas at Rosa's, the parm here is like 3/5 very mediocre. Tried the parm with fries and was unpleasantly surprised to get mouthfuls of dry, flavorless starch from the thick cut soggy fries. There's a reason they use thin cut for stuff like carne asada fries and marinara does not go well with french fries in my opinion. So why the 5 stars? The grumpy slice is some of the best pizza I've ever had. I thought it looked questionable that they seemed to just reheat pizza that was sitting on the display counter, but the taste and texture were perfection. And only $5 for a slice. Only place you'll get cheaper pizza is at a gas station.

Yummy!!!! It had been awhile since we had been here. We…read moredidn't realize they close at 7:00 pm so we just slid in right before. The girls working were friendly. The place was clean and picked up. We need to get back when we have more time so we can try a few more items.

We had our order delivered. We ordered the jalapeño cheese…read morebread but received plain garlic bread. The garlic bread is thin and does not have much flavor. They also do not include a dipping sauce. We also ordered a meat lover pizza. They are generous with the toppings but the crust is flavorless and tough. The same can be said about our build your own pizza. I also did not receive the family size greek salad that we ordered. Over all the experience was very disappointing.

We had dinner tonight at Papa's Italian Restaurant, and if you've never been, it's a place you…read moreabsolutely must try in Prescott. If you've dined here before, you already know exactly what I'm talking about. We ordered the Spicy Sausage & Broccolini Ravioli and the Meat Ravioli, and both dishes were outstanding. Every bite was flavorful and perfectly prepared. The service was exceptional, and the warm, inviting atmosphere makes you feel as though you're dining in Italy. Thank you to everyone at Papa's for continuing to make dining out such a special experience. We'll definitely be back!

So while I understand this establishment is owned by human beings who likely care I will just say…read morethis, if you own an Italian restaurant, my advice would be for you to go to Italy, or in the U.S. to New York City, Chicago and other places where there large swaths of Italian culture and the Italian food is galaxies more authentic and much better. Experience it. Learn from what you experience and take that back to Prescott. In sum, the food (while Italian style) was not at all representative of authentic Italian culture. The warmth of being in an Italian home like many establishments throughout Italy and the U.S. was not present. And the food! The sauce was amateurish at best - composed of huge chunks of canned stewed tomatoes than actual sauce. The chicken (in my Chicken Parmesan) was intensely dry and rubbery which tells me that the breasts we're made and then frozen. The pasta was regular cheap grocery store pasta. The salad - "Italian" dressing - tasted it came from a commercial brand. Lastly the service, was ok at best. No one offered or was even around to give us fresh grated Parmesan cheese or fresh cracked pepper in our salad. The bread served on the table was good and our Aperol Spritz was excellent. Overall, I suppose we should have expected this... ethnic food in a small town is far more "miss" than it is "hit" but I did appreciate how warm and inviting the atmosphere is. Sorry... I just want people who come from out Of town who have traveled and experienced many beautiful versions of of the Real Thing... this is not that.

Best pizza I have had in the area yet The service staff…read morecouldn't be nicer. Great New York ambiance with the hip vibe!

I liked the food here but I had an issue with their soups. I ordered a cup of soup and my BF…read moreordered their bowl of soup. We got basically the same amount of soup. The soup that was served in the bowl could have been poured in my cup and would have been the same portion. When you serve soup in a large bowl then you should really try to fill it at least past the halfway point. So I feel we overpaid for the bowl. Other than that....we liked the rest of the food. Again with the bowl situation...they served the spaghetti in the same bowl but the portion size was chintzy. What's the point of using that big bowl then ? The pizza was good and the staff was friendly