In my ongoing quest to find the best pizza in Prescott, I recently ordered an XL pepperoni and sausage from Two Mamas'. The sauce was flavorful, cheese was generous but not overdone, and the toppings were tasty and plentiful. The crust was nice, although I wish it were just a bit more firm. But I would definitely go back. The overall pie was comparable to Granite Mountain Pizza Company, if you like their pizzas. read more

Two Mamas' Gourmet Pizzeria - Extra large hand tossed pepperoni and italian sausage pizza - Pizza Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

Service was friendly. We picked up a pizza to go because they close for business 30 min before they officially close. The pizza is OK. Not great. When they made the sauce oregano was evidently on sale. It is clearly the only dominant flavor in their sauce. Cook temp is also way too low. The crust doesn't crisp like a pizza should. I didn't check out the oven but i bet it doesn't include a fired tile platform. No char on the bottom of the crust at all. Its not somewhere i would return to by choice, and certainly not a destination but its edible. read more

We got a build your own pizza to go this evening. Thin crust medium was plenty for two people with a few slices left over for lunch. We ordered by phone and the pizza was ready for pick up when we arrived. We decided to pick the pizza up early and reheat later (avoiding the evening rush). We have eaten here several times in the past, always a great place and one we always recommend to people visiting Prescott. Nice small town atmosphere in the restaurant. read more

Two Mamas' Gourmet Pizzeria - Medium thin crust pizza - Pizza Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

Excellent authentic Italian food. Great staff. We had the lasagna and baked ziti , highly recommend

Nice people, average pizza. Too little sauce, too much oregano. It's fine. Greek salad was good, but it was iceberg instead of romaine.

We love their pizza, they make it how you want it. The staff is always personable and will remember you. Their menu includes salads, lasagna, calzones which are really good. We have tried other places for pizza but Two Mamas is the BEST!! read more

Lousy pizza! Send your pizza maker to CULINARY SCHOOL! Sauce was lousy, crust is screaming for help, service is clueless. read more

We had some of their pizza delivered and loved it so Ed went in to restaurant for first time and ordered lasagne and an anti pasta salad. We split them between us and loved all of it. And to top it off the server was great. Far above usual, even ones co spidered good, servers you get. I must highly recommend Two Mommas! read more

I stopped by on a Friday early evening. The clean and spacious dining area was comfortable and Frank Sinatra was singing on the speakers. The server was friendly and helpful. I ordered a slice of hand tossed and a medium thin crust. They have a big menu, including sandwiches, pasta, and calzones. The hand tossed crust was delicious and toppings were tasty too. The thin crust was crispy and also delicious. I'm going to have to come back to try more menu selections! read more

Two Mamas' Gourmet Pizzeria - Thin crust, pepperoni, mushroom, onion - Pizza Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

See all

Yummy pizza delivered mostly warm. But the flavor made up for the temperature. Definitely a better experience dine-in for that reason. Bummer their POS system hasn't been upgraded in the years I've been ordering from and going here. If it doesn't crash with my order, it will with someone else's. Bummer for the employees. read more

Was pleasantly surprised on how good the pizza is, Prescott is definitely lucky to have such an establishment!!

Two Mamas was the first pizza joint we ordered takeout from when visiting Prescott for the first time in 2020. They're our go-to now that we live here, anytime friends/family come visit. Amazing quality to their crust and ingredients -we appreciate the two mamas! read more

I've been looking for a good chicken parma and this was not quite it. The food is mediocre and over priced. Not bad, but not good enough to justify the prices read more

My favorite Friday night pizza spot! If you crave a pan style pizza two mamas is the best...the margarita style is delicious & we love getting the hand tossed meats too! read more

We ordered online for pick up. The ordering was easy. The order was ready right on time. Nice variety of choices. Pizza and boneless wings were great. read more

Every time I come here, the pizza is perfect. The balance of flavors is just right, and the toppings are always fresh. It is my favorite place to grab a good slice. read more

Two Mamas' Gourmet Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

Although I haven't had the pleasure of eating there in a few years my go to was the Gumba pizza. I'm 63 and have never had a tastier pizza than that and I've had my fair share of pizzas throughout the years. read more

Adorable little Italian restaurant just a small walk from the Courthouse and Whiskey Row, with friendly staff and delicious food. I had the deep dish pizza...so yummy!! read more

Two Mamas' Gourmet Pizzeria - Deep dish pizza - Pizza Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

I haven't been here in years so decided to visit since staying nearby at the Springhill Suites. My friend and I had our fur babies with us so decided to get takeout. She got the Italian beef and I ordered the chicken parmigiana with spaghetti. It came with 4 small breadsticks. Both were good. Breadsticks were bit burnt but edible. My meal was little bit more cheesy than I'd like and wish it came with two chicken parmigiana patties for the price. ($22). Overall great service and would recommend. read more

Two Mamas' Gourmet Pizzeria - Chicken parmigiana - Pizza Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

very average pizza and ... really $23 for a small pizza, don't waste your money. Ok, so Dominos is two doors down and less than half the price. read more

My Chicago buddy's keep telling me to try this place so I am. The staff is courteous and nice. The ambiance is good plenty of room. Wine selection is limited so for me a 6/10. They do have tap beer and cocktails as well. I tried their house Chianti and it was a bit musty and lacked flavor no problem though she didn't charge. The Cabernet Sauvignon was great for a house wine. I ordered a large 16" Chicago combo with black olives! Gotta have the olives. The crust style is the hand tossed and was very light and crusty. Ok I didn't order the deep dish more Chicago style. The Italian beef and sausage was great. The roasted peppers made it. For a finale I had a Moscow mule and it was great. I like it. Is it Prescott's best pizza? It's good. Ok that Moscow mule was sooooo great I ordered another one. So bottom line I love park place plaza pizzas they are as good as I've had in Italy. Two mamas well there's is a close second but but there is hard alcohol here. Wine is no contest but but but. This Moscow mule is great. read more

See all

Very overpriced for what you get. The food was OK and the service was OK. I had a gift card from this business. Otherwise I would never have gone there. I don't think I'll return due to the high prices for the mediocre food. read more

Excellent food. I wish the calzone back home was as good as it was at Mama's. Thin, chewy crust with good flavor. If I were a local, I'd make it a regular stop. The seating area is not huge but accommodated my family of 6. Has only one server, and she works her tail off. Thanks for a very nice lunch! read more

My Wife and I decided to stop for lunch after a Tuesday bike ride. We chose Two Mamas based on reviews and menu. We really liked the way they cut the pizza into small slices, crust was good and overall not bad. Both my wife and I came to the same conclusion which is there was no WOW factor being this is a "gourmet" Pizzeria. The sauce, crust, toppings were just very plain. (I hate to say it) No better then a godfathers or chain pizza. The pizza was certainly not bad, just not very memorable where "you have to come back". I guess we live in a time of $50 dollar lunches where I expect much better. read more

They have wonderful pizza! I really like their crust and love, love, love the Caprese! Their service is spot on!

Pan pizza is the best I have ever eaten with the perfect crunch! Pastas are underrated and the cheese bread is a perfect side. Consistently delicious! read more

We love coming to Two Mamas every time we visit my dad out here in Prescott, but missed it last time we were out so we finally got to come back. We ordered Italian wings, Italian Buffalo wings, hand-tossed pepperoni pizza, and a deep dish pepperoni pizza. The pizza has always been delicious, but unfortunately this time I'm not sure if the order was taken incorrectly or not, but we had ordered a hand-tossed pizza and received thin crust which ends up being a little over cooked. Still good, but I'm not a huge fan of thin crust so that was a huge let down. The wings are delicious as always and their Buffalo Italian wings are the best. Perfect combination of flavor, juiciness, and a little wet spice from the Buffalo. We always get the same girl whenever we go and she is very friendly and attentive. The inside hasn't changed much since last year, still feels like a basic pizza joint, and there were hardly anyone there right at dinner rush so that was nice. read more

Two Mamas' Gourmet Pizzeria - Italian Buffalo Wings - Pizza Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

Good quality food ingredients, preparation, and flavor were 5 stars. Hand tossed pizza crust was delicious. Pasta with red sauce and buffalo mozzarella, excellent!! read more

I ordered chicken wings. I got burnt chicken wings. I guess I should've stuck with pizza. I didn't think you could screw up chicken wings, and I had a side of potatoes that weren't bad. read more

We eat here every time we visit Prescott. Food was fantastic, as always. If you live in Prescott or plan on visiting and want good Italian food, I highly recommend Two Mamas. read more

Gave them a 3rd chance.. As a local in Prescott, I am trying to support a local business but COME ON!!!! Spent $100 on 2 pizzas and Mozzarella sticks... Got the order completely wrong!!!! WTF?? Are you trying to fail?? Listen to your customers!! read more

Food was great. Service was a little slow. Waitress was working alone and there was enough business that she needed help. She did an outstanding job, just needed help! Nothing fancy here, a nice place to grab lunch. I would surely go back. read more

Seriously? $23 for a 9 inch pizza? My fault for not looking at the size I was ordering but this is ridiculous. The pizza barely had cheese on it. So disappointing. read more

Two Mamas' Gourmet Pizzeria - Not enough pizza for three people. - Pizza Near Me - Prescott, Arizona

This place has 3 different kind of gluten free pizza crust, including three sizes of one kind. I've never had so many choices before! The menu itself is extensive. Tons of specialty pizza options. We got the BBQ chicken and vegetarian on the regular gluten free crust and they were both delicious. read more

Love their cheese steaks and Pizza Pricey and Takes a minute but yummy Enjoy while in Prescott AZ read more

They have great salads so that's why we're giving a 4 star vs 3. This time we got the Greek salad. Their food is good and large portions. Chicken parm was good. We added meatballs but they were a little bland. read more

Really excellent pizza! The sauce had a good zip to it and the toppings on the Goomba were generous. My only complaint was they were a little too crispy for my taste. We also ordered cheese sticks and while they weren't anything special, they were well cooked and the sauce added a good flavor. We ordered online and went to pick up the food. The place is a comfortable and cozy little place downtown. It wasn't a huge crowd when we went but the business was steady. The staff was friendly. The prices are a little above average for pizza but I found it worthwhile. They have a good menu of appetizers, salads, sandwiches and pasta, so I'll definitely be back to try other items. read more

Pizza is pretty good normally, but never use the online app to order. It's completely unreliable. Go in or call in the order. The app is worthless. read more

Once again, everything was great, the food and service. If you have not tried it, PLEASE go there you will not be disappointed! Douglas

Five star pizza delicious fresh great ingredients. One of my favorites is Philly cheese specialty pizza must try it second best is the barbecue chicken specialty pizza. This pizza is so good that it only gets better after you reheat it the next day. Thank you, Two Mamas for your awesome pizza. read more