Create a Cake

4.2 (5 reviews)

Bakeries

Add Review

Call

Directions

Create a Cake Photos

Create a Cake - a chicago bears birthday cake - Bakeries Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

Create a Cake - a pink cake with white icing and pink roses - Bakeries Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

Create a Cake - a bowling ball and a bowling pin - Bakeries Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

Create a Cake - Gingerbread Class - Bakeries Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Create a Cake

Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.

Start your review...

Browse more easily on the app

Michelle E.

7 years ago

Never disapointed!!! Moist delicious cakes made just the way I want them. Icing is fabulous... so good!!! Ultra talented decorators... who would have thought you could find a world class bakery in Kokomo? You can at Create-A-Cake Bakery!!! read more

Create a Cake - a snowman wearing a blue hat - Bakeries Near Me - Kokomo, Indiana

See all

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Julie M.

7 years ago

I've been getting my cakes here for years because they are the best in town! I don't care what she's using to make that icing cause it's outta this world deliciousness! I've never ever had a problem with any cake, cookie, cream horn etc I've ever gotten from here! The icing has always been thick and my cakes have always been moist and delicious! If this is cake made from a box then hats off to the baker because my cakes have never been even close to the yumminess experienced from this shop! I'm not a friend of the owner and I don't know the owners but I do know I love their cakes and I will continue to get all my cakes from this shop! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

C T.

7 years ago

I begged my dad to get a cake for me from Create a Cake. I did not want a "grocery store" birthday cake. I love homemade cakes! My dad asked the lady who took his order if the cakes are homemade (meaning: mixing flour, sugar, butter, etc.) and he was told "Yes." I wanted a chocolate cake with chocolate icing. He said the lady told him I could only have white frosting. Wha?? I was excited, regardless. A real cake! But...I and everyone at my party noticed the cake frosting tasted weird. In addition, the frosting was so thin, I was impressed it was possible to put so little on the cake! The cake was moist and tasted ok, as good as any boxed mix; it just did not taste like scratch/homemade cakes. I did like the average flowers and edge frosting work. At least those areas had thicker icing...but that icing taste?? I was so upset. And...the mystery was on! We all started asking questions. My brother even looked inside their dumpster (what he found, confirmed by a knowledgeable person...coming up). I talked to people-in-the-know about why the white only icing? Weird tasting icing? No homemade tasting cake as told? First, we found out they use cake mix! ALWAYS! Regular box cake mix that we all can buy at Walmart! As for that weird frosting? Their recipe for the frosting is simple, having 2 ingredients: white shortening and confectioners sugar. GROSS. No butter, no vanilla flavoring, nothing else. This recipe is simply colored for any decorations ordered. My sleuthing also gave me my answer as to why the white instead of chocolate frosting was supposedly the only flavor the place wants us to order. The frosting is 90% of the time white because of the recipe they use. (Again, shortening & confectioners sugar, yum.) If a customer insists on chocolate or another flavor of frosting? Or the owner is friends with/likes a customer? Someone from Create must leave the bakery to go purchase a plastic tub of the pre-made frosting. The cake flavor pushed onto customers is never chocolate, strawberry...and more. The place buys yellow and white cake mixes from stores, the same mixes and stores we all use. Why is a head scratcher. White and yellow flavors make mixing those boxes of cake mix in large quantities easier. If any customer orders a cake flavor other than yellow or white? And the place decides to accommodate? Someone from the store has to run out to a grocery store and buy that flavor of cake mix to be cooked for that customer. Also, a special bowl with beaters must be prepared for these other flavors. (Just a guess here...laziness?) Hey, why not just bring Create a box of cake mix, cooking oil, and a couple of eggs? Definitely remember to bring the plastic tub of frosting to frost the cake as well or you will get it frosted/decorated with sugared oil. All that is left is to just pay Create to cook and decorate your cake for you. I believe this would cut down the price quite a bit. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Pam R.

7 years ago

I absolutely love their cakes. The staff is very friendly and helpful. You can't go wrong here. I would chose them over any place in Kokomo. Thank you Create a Cake for many years of awesome cakes and cupcakes! read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

Monica B.

7 years ago

Just ordered a turtle cake and a strawberry cake with almond joy cupcakes and everything was amazing and the custom artwork was just what I wanted. There custom icing are delicious. read more

Helpful 0

Thanks 0

Love this 0

Oh no 0

More info about Create a Cake

2032 S Elizabeth St
Kokomo, IN 46902
Directions
(765) 452-2253
Call Now

Hours

What time does Create a Cake open?

What time does Create a Cake close?

Outdoor Amenities

Does Create a Cake have parking?

Yes, Create a Cake has parking options.

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

People searched for Bakeries 191 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

Verify this business

Explore benefits

Dan's Variety Bakery

Best donuts in town. We always get them there. We've tried other places in town, but they are not…read moreas good.

Need donuts at 1am?! This is your place. Believe it or not...there will probably be a line!…read more I was traveling for work and asked where I could find the best donuts in the morning. They said you had to crosstown, but Dan's was the place to go. I got there at 4:30 in the morning and believe it or not there were four construction workers ahead of me in line. Sidenote: Things that I have learned in life: if you go past a diner or a restaurant, and it is filled with police cars or construction vehicles. it's a winner. ALWAYS! I got two dozen mixed donuts and took it to a safety meeting. Everyone inhaled the donuts and they were excited I had chosen the best local donuts. They were light in texture and great flavor.

Photos

Apple fritters (after we already ate 3)

See all

Indulgence

I tried calling multiple times to place an order for a cake that I needed, and no one ever…read moreanswered. When I went in person, they weren't open on time and informed me that I should've placed an order before to get my cake at the desired date. But they never pick up their phone I tried to order weeks ahead.

I tried some of the cupcakes at Indugence as they were AMAZING! The cupcakes were soft & moist with…read moregreat favor. The frosting was the perfect combination of butter & sugar, not too sweet! Will definitely visit whenever I'm in Kokomo!

Photos

Cupcakes ordered for a baby shower!

Take a peek at this beauty!

See all

Perfectly Pink Wedding Cake

Miller's Variety

4.8

(6 reviews)

7.8 mi

The deli has a fantastic selection of meats and cheeses. Some are hard to find these days. My go to…read morefor real ham salad and Lebanon bologna amongst many other items. Big variety of locally produced goods. Lots of good things to offer and they're super friendly. Definitely worth the trip!

I love this little store great bakery goods,sandwiches, Amish food easy to get to get there early…read moreor bakery goods are gone.

Photos

This is the owner's information. It's now named Plevna Country Market.

They're baking fresh goods six days per week.

See all

J Edwards Fine Chocolate

The service was excellent and the understanding of importance to buy a blueberry cake yes, lol a…read moreblueberry cake for our daughter 42 birthday it was delicious n moist. Price was good thank you to everyone who made her say very special bakery has tons of amazing chocolates creative cupcakes gifts so much more!

I went out of my way to go to this chocolate shop after getting a box of their assorted chocolates…read morewith flowers my husband got me. They were SO good, I had to take a trip to their store to see what else they had. Did not disappoint! Will be going back!

Photos

Exterior

See all

Took this to bring gone to my family

Lucky Lemon Bakery

4.5

(11 reviews)

2.0 mi

I had the dill pickle soup which was absolutely delicious! It was so good that my omni daughter…read moretried mine, and made me go back and get her some! I also got a couple chocolate chip cookies which were delicious too! I grew up in Kokomo and moved to Ohio 17 years ago. I started transitioning to being a vegan last year, and never imagined having an all vegan restaurant in Kokomo when I came back to visit! This is amazing!

As a vegan moving to a small town I thought my only option for take out would be Chipotle…read more Thankfully I found Heather on a vegan app and have been following her from her Farmer's Market Days to her new brick and mortar. First off her customer service is excellent. It always feels like I'm having a quick chat with a friend when I stop, by which sometimes is multiple times a week. There are weekly specials along with the core menu and different baked goods always offered as well. Everything on the menu is vegan and she has gluten free options as well. It's hard to pick a favorite item off the menu. I love that I get to support a women owned local business. I suggest everyone stop by and try even if you aren't vegan.

Photos

Breakfast smoothie bowl

Dill pickle soup

See all

Chocolate chip cookie

Etta's Gooey Goodies

4.0

(3 reviews)

7.7 mi

The brownies are the best!!! I've had Etta's Gooey Goodies a second time when they've been at…read moreFriends of Fred Food Truck events, specifically at Riley Hospital. This time I got a classic brownie and the extra gooey brownie and that was so moist, gooey and chocolately goodness! The classic brownie is exactly THE brownie! The brownie portion is absolutely perfect size and they will ask if you prefer a middle or corner piece! The brownies are pricey but again, they are pretty thick and large portioned - and worth it!!!

Had the taco burrito and it tastes delicious but the ice cream is to-die-for!!!…read more Ice cream: peanut butter cookie dough and raspberry something

Photos

See all

Pucket's Pies

2.5

(2 reviews)

2.5 mi

Drove all the way from Lafayette to find it closed because these jokers don't know how to update…read morehours online. Not worth it. Probably missed nothing.

I love this place and the people who run it. Great prices, and excellent pies. It doesn't look like…read moremuch from the outside, but definitely worth a visit.

Blondie's Cookies

3.0

(4 reviews)

0.8 mi

Best cookies in the entire world. There's something about their chocolate chip cookie cake slices…read morethat are absolutely divine. I wish they had a location where I live!

Are used to go to this place as a child I believe they went on shark tank and somebody bought them…read moreout I went there a couple months ago and spent $50 on chocolate chip cookies that were frozen several weeks when I took them home to eat them they crumbled from being too dry and brittle I'm very disappointed in them not making them fresh

Meijer

Love this store. They have taught me as a dasher how to find the product. Example being B1-45. They…read moreare always helpful and go above and beyond what I thought they would. And Nick in the department that picks orders is always smiling and very helpful.

We shop here every week and really like this store. However, when is Meijer going to update this…read morestore? It is definitely outdated compared to the surrounding area stores. I know that money isn't the issue as they are building a second Meijer in Lafayette... I give it only 3 stars because of how dated and dingy it is.

Photos

See all

Cone Palace

Cone Palace is crazy busy at lunch time. I popped in for a soft serve cone after seeing great…read morereviews on Yelp. Cone Palace is a local family-run business that been serving Kokomo since 1966. The drive-thru line of cars wrapped around the building, so I decided to go inside. The parking lot was almost full. The prices are incredibly reasonable with tenderloins 2/$8. The burgers look popular. I was excited to see a coffee flavored soft serve called Cappuccino. My medium size serving was huge in an old school cone for only $2.59. The ice cream was creamy and good. The cone itself was remarkably fresh. The service was friendly and quick. The staff was busy. The dining room is clean and modern. Most people grab and go. Cone Palace is a fun little local place and worth an ice cream stop.

cheesy burgers good ice cream food 9/10. lady's so so nice 10/10 go achanna. idk ambiance.read more

Photos

Medium soft serve

See all

Sunshine

Culver's

I'm always happy when it is Walleye season at Culver's. For a few short weeks (maybe 6 weeks) in…read moreFebruary and early March Culver's has their famous walleye on the menu. I heard that today was the first day of walleye so I made a plan to visit a Culver's location for dinner. I happened to be traveling past Kokomo for work so this was a convenient stop. I ordered my walleye sandwich and a couple of sides on the app for curdside pickup. My order was ready on time and a friendly employee brought it out as soon as I checked "l'm Here" on the app. My food was excellent. Walleye is my favorite fish snd Culver's has the best, although for a limited time each year.

The Culver's in Kokomo, IN is a very reliable and welcoming restaurant. The restaurant is normally…read moreclean and relaxed. The service is great and quick. The food is superb. Especially the onion rings and cheese curds. The sourdough melt is my go to burger and it simply can't be beat. The frozen custard is also excellent. I have visited Culver's locations all over the Country and they are outstanding, but Kokomo, IN actually exceeds their usual standards.

Photos

See all

7 Brew Coffee

4.0

(12 reviews)

1.0 mi

Bussin drink! Try strawberry banana smoothie! The lady's are the sweetest! Looks all fine Ambiance.read more

I had went to try this place out since I have never been here before. It was a drive up which was…read morereally convenient. The person taking the order was very friendly and explained everything. The prices were very reasonable. When I got my drink I didn't care for it too much. It had too much of a coffee taste instead of being able to taste the Carmel. The drive thru was well lit and I could read the menu. The area were the workers were working looked clean.

Photos

See all

Black Wax Cafe

4.1

(15 reviews)

2.4 mi

Black Wax Cafe in Kokomo, IN was so cool! It's a record store & coffee shop in one, with endless…read moreoptions of music and drinks ~ obsessed with this place! The Koko-Kong, dark chocolate, banana iced latte WITH BANANA COLD FOAM? One of the best iced lattes I've ever had. Definitely a fun spot in Kokomo, IN you should check out if in the area.

This is a really cute cafe and vinyl shop! It's quite…read morespacious and has a large selection of both new and used vinyls to peruse. The range of different genres was incredible, and even included some comedy records which I didn't even know existed until yesterday. They also have a smaller selection of CDs and cassette tapes. While searching, you can sip on a beverage. Not pictured but I had a hot bullseye chai with oat milk. It was pretty good and not overly sweet. I would definitely recommend this place to someone looking for a fun, cool spot to pass some time in.

Photos

The Blizzard Of Ozz Peppermint Frappe is back!

The Butter Beer Magical Frappe!

See all

Christmas is here early! Try the new Chocolate Tree Cake Frappe today!

Kokomochi

5.0

(5 reviews)

0.1 mi

Stopped in on our way through town, great food and service. Hidden gem! We had the shrimp fried…read morerice and the American Dream roll.

We had the Kokomochi roll which was a unique and original roll that was spicy and delicious!…read moreThe American Dream roll was even more delicious and beautiful looking. The waitress was very polite, quick, and attentive. She definitely knew hospitality and how to be an excellent waitress. The ambiance is simple, much like a diner. I will come again!

Photos

Chicken Hibachi Dinner

See all

Steak Hibachi Dinner

Fusion Bowl

4.1

(7 reviews)

3.0 mi

Tried over the weekend for a late lunch…read more I don't expect great sushi in Kokomo, there were a couple thing here that stood out as surprisingly good, others that were just off. The decor of the restaurant is that of an old English/Irish pub, including a bar in the center. They have enough seating for 20-30 people, but their business is set for everyone to take the food togo. They hand you a paper menu, and tell you to use a kiosk, but then if you want to pay cash, you have to deal with the person behind the bar. I ordered the Sushi appetizer and a bowl. The appetizer was a fair value, but they don't have sushi ginger, instead they had ginger strips, bright red, that they had diced - I had the same ginger in the bowl, but they left that in strips. All of the food was delivered to my table on a tray, using to go containers that you find in the grocery stores - including a plastic fork and soy sauce packets. Was the meal fairly priced - yes Did this place feel welcoming - no I would not go planning to eat in the restaurant - but if I wanted takeout while in the area, maybe? I guess they are shooting for the takeout lunch crowd at the hospital/hospital support offices I have gotten to the point I don't trust yelp, too many compensated reviews, too many fake reviews, but all they care about is quantity of reviews - how sad

This place is our date night go-to! Great, hot, fresh food served in Togo containers! The service…read moreis always good. Sushi is always a hit. The general tso is our favorite from here. The dumplings and the sauce are great. Definitely a hidden gem!

Photos

See all

Create a Cake - bakeries - Updated July 2026

People who viewed Create a Cake also viewed

J Edwards Fine Chocolate

39 reviews

$$$

Indulgence

10 reviews

Moore's Pie Shop

22 reviews

Dreams To Reality

7 reviews

Kokomo Frozen Custard

9 reviews

Jack's Donuts of Kokomo

19 reviews

Kelly's Ice Cream

11 reviews

Jack's Donuts & Pizza King

3 reviews

Bolins Donut Shop

10 reviews

Ashley's Ice Cream

10 reviews

Create a Cake

Create a Cake Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Create a Cake

More info about Create a Cake

Outdoor Amenities

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

Dan's Variety Bakery

Indulgence

Miller's Variety

J Edwards Fine Chocolate

Lucky Lemon Bakery

Etta's Gooey Goodies

Pucket's Pies

Blondie's Cookies

Meijer

Cone Palace

Culver's

7 Brew Coffee

Black Wax Cafe

Kokomochi

Fusion Bowl

Create a Cake - bakeries - Updated July 2026

Best of Kokomo

People found Create a Cake by searching for…

Trending Searches in Kokomo, IN

Browse Articles

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Related Searches in Kokomo, IN

People who viewed Create a Cake also viewed

Create a Cake

Create a Cake Photos

You might also consider

Recommended Reviews - Create a Cake

More info about Create a Cake

Outdoor Amenities

You might also consider

Verify this business for free

More businesses like Create a Cake

Dan's Variety Bakery

Indulgence

Miller's Variety

J Edwards Fine Chocolate

Lucky Lemon Bakery

Etta's Gooey Goodies

Pucket's Pies

Blondie's Cookies

Meijer

Trending businesses in Create a Cake's area

Cone Palace

Culver's

7 Brew Coffee

Black Wax Cafe

Kokomochi

Fusion Bowl

Create a Cake - bakeries - Updated July 2026

Best of Kokomo

People found Create a Cake by searching for…

Trending Searches in Kokomo, IN

Browse Articles

Browse Nearby

Browse Brands

Related Searches in Kokomo, IN

People who viewed Create a Cake also viewed