This is an awesome game store. The staff is friendly and helpful. They work to make sure everyone…read morehas fun. They run a constant stream of TCG - Trading Card Games and while some of the players play in offical tournaments, you can still have lots of fun and the other players don't mind helping you and answering questions to help improve your game play and deck (but you may have to wait until the game ends!) D&D organized play goes on during the week and some weekends and amazingly is still FREE, even though the store is providing you with the space to play. The only reason I give them 4 stars is because I wish they would have a larger inventory of Role Playing Games (like D&D) but until more people are buying these products I understand that they cannot increase their inventory. Some of the Products sold: 1. D&D, Burning Wheel, Traveller, GammaWorld, Pathfinder, 2. Specialized board games that you cannot find in normal stores 3. TCG, Magic, Yu-Gi-Oh!, EDH/Commander, Pokemon, 4. Miniatures: Warhammer 40K, Star Wars: X-Wing, Infinity, Mars Attacks, Relic Knights, Imperial Assault 5. Comic Books 6. Dice, some miniatures for D&D and RPG's. and much, much more! Best of all, when the original store was going to close and there were no other gaming stores within 20 miles, Bear purchased the store, kept it open and gave us all a place to play for 5 years and running now. That alone causes me to be a loyal NGiT follower! Also, I help run the D&D Encounters and D&D Expeditions games at the store.

Bear, the owner, is a super fun and down-to-earth guy.read more

This is the BEST comic store I have been to ever and the variety from comics to children's books in…read moreincredible and the prices are perfect I was able to get 6 comics for 20-30 bucks. The guy at the front counter is so helpful an his service In helping find something in the store is amazing also when you buy comics from there you can trade them in for different ones which is so nice cause I wanted to read a long series but only had enough for around 4 comics at the time so I bought the three comics and returned them so I could finish the series. Also they have action figures from marvel and I forget maybe DC. Also the quality of the comics are amazing no bends or scratches so overall this is an amazing comic store and I love going 5 stars all around a d I really hope for this business to continue.

I'm updating this as Jay's has really taken their shop to the next level. Improved store branding…read moreand decor. Increased square footage. Expansion of trades, back issue selection including plenty of wall books with keys and CGC. They carry all the associated toys, pops, statues,etc...but for me I'm there for the comics. Jay's easily has the widest selection of back issues (raw and slabbed) within an hour driving distance. Get in your car and check it out.

Good little place. Owner knowledgeable and cool. Good collection of old and new stuff.read more

After two years of coming back in forth to this comic book store, I have had the privilege to see…read morehow Tryke, the manager of Comic Alley, interacts with customers of all ages. Tryke displays the enjoyment of sharing comic knowledge to all his customers and he educates them on the excitement of comic book stories. When you arrive in the lower level of this store, you may notice the number of comics, toys and misc. items crammed across limited floor space but let me tell you, this is what makes it exciting. Your eyes will wander with the possibility of a comic surprise that you discover during your visit . One advice I learned over the years is to always ask Tryke if you have any questions on comics or just looking for that one item you cannot find. You will then understand why this local comic book store and the manager who runs it will always be my stop over when visiting Lake Geneva. Support this local comic store and as you walk down the stairs to the surprise at the bottom, say hello to Tryke, take your time in wandering through the comic abyss that awaits you, and more importantly...enjoy!

I am an old school, comic collector. I love the amount of books this store has…read more Don't get me wrong. It's not the cleanest. They had some water damage to a bunch of his boxes. In order to see them, the owner has to get things out of the way just to make sure boxes don't fall. But I love a shop like this. You have to take time to go through things. But he will have the diamonds sitting in the coal. If you are serious about buying some books he is happy to work with you!! My kind of place!!

This is one funny place. It's filled with tons of old comic boxes and stacks of comics. Very…read moredisorganized and not really able to be dug through. Many of the comics have been water damaged due to a flood. I find it hilarious the guy added 1 penny to the cover price of some back issue I bought that had some mold and water damage, but I felt sorry for this mess of a place So it's a mess though it has a nice owner and he can find some things if you know what you're looking for. It's funny someone describes this person as Gandalf though as that wasn't the case. I think people who have no idea about genres or things really are slow AF and have no idea what's real or fake and everything in between as this place is not the shire of comics. I'm surprised a place like this exists in all honesty.

This store I have to say is my home away from home. After walking in 6 years ago just to look…read morearound I've made friends and have been able to play a lot of really cool games. I stop in every week to pick up my comic books and I'm always greeted with a smile and a hello from the owners. Together they have both created an atmosphere of awesome for anyone who wants to learn a new game, join and ongoing game league or just to buy a few comics. I've never found a better store to get my geek on.

I'm new and an outsider to the world of comics and gaming, but I'd never know it from the way Carla…read moreand Don treated me. My boyfriend has been a regular at the store for years, and I went with him to pick up his pull list this past weekend. There were people chatting at the counter when we came in, so Carla didn't see that I was with anyone when I entered the store. She was sure to ask me if I needed help with anything, which is a first in the slew of comic and game shops I've been to recently. The shop is set up with different rooms devoted to your interest, with comics in one wing and games in another, and more general books and collectibles merchandise in the main room where you enter. If you head to the back, you'll find space for game playing and where Don is organizing his back stock of comics. The shop on the whole is bright and colorful, and I felt totally welcome to browse. Don and Carla had a nice word for everyone who came in the store, and it was pretty clear that they have a small army of loyal customers. The outside of the store isn't much to look at - it's situated in an industrial-looking strip mall - but don't let that deter you from the checking out their cozy shop. Even if you're not a full-on geek, there are still things for you here - several of their games are great for a game night with friends.

They have a good collection of comics and figures. They are organized nicely. The employees are all…read morehelpful. We have gotten some deals there too.

The people who work here are great and super knowledgeable with anything you need. I've had no…read moreproblems getting the books I'm trying to get and my pull list orders are always there with no issues. Staff is super friendly and makes you feel welcome every time you come in. Couldn't recommend this place more!

Great selection of reading material as well as collectibles. Always friendly and helpful folks…read more Always a treat to come in a get new comics.

Awesome comic book shop with great customer service! The amount of selection of new and old comics…read moreare by far superior to any other shop. You feel the warm welcome from the staff and they have great knowledge to share.

TLDR: Wonderful customer service, and more than willing to educate and be patient with young (7…read moreyear old) enthusiasts to the Pokemon card hobby. Our 7 year old son is just nuts for Pokemon, but my wife and I know nothing about the cards or the game. We went in to Top Cut with our son and he had his Pokemon binder with him. One of the employees, Caleb, immediately asked us how he could help. He went through our sons entire collection, pointed out some rare cards, and educated us on some of his cards which were fake (super interesting) and some that were valuable. He was very patient with us, and helped our son pick out a few new cards for his collection. I was blown away with Caleb's knowledge of the cards. Caleb is why we will no longer go to gamestop, but to a local shop that is willing to educate us and provide fantastic customer service. We will be back, and we will also be telling others about the incredible experience.

So this is a little crazy to me, a new set got released for weiss a couple days ago and I was…read morelooking for it and low and behold I see two cases of it sitting in the back and was like YES I can get one booster box of it, I ask and he goes and checks to see if he can grab one. He tells me he couldn't sell me one because "somebody called and said to hold them for him" both cases, 48 booster boxes and all this one guys because he called and said hold them for him vs the person who literally just wants one that's already there? How is that fair to the consumer? How's that good business practice? Just really unfair still dumbfounded

Once again, I've taken the time to be THE FIRST reviewer and put a place on the Yelp map. It takes…read morea lil extra care and unselfishness, and tho my exs thought I was the selfish one, it was all projection by them. I have volunteered more, did more for humanity, and in my work treated people better than they ever did or will and I would've done anything for them but obviously they wouldn't for me. Geek Inc Bartlett has some hidden gems in toys, and they have better prices than the nearby Carol Stream store. In fact, often HALF the cost of the main store in Carol Stream. So check this place out. THere's also alot of comics to dig through if that's your thing. Every Free Comic Book Day I find something like cheap AF Star Trek The Next Generation figures, even tho this year I found the best piece at the Carol Stream store lol, a Cobra vehicle. What a weird area these NW burbs are. There are literally 2 Issa's Venezuelan Restaurants and 2 Geek Inc comic stores in these towns. I want 2 smoked BBQ places next. Then I'll be in heaven.

A few months ago, I found the inside empty, when seeing this listing today, 12/17/24 I called them…read morein hopes they were just re-modeling and now re-opened, but it seems it's not open. I tried the phone # listed and got an automated response says there's a new number, but didn't supply it. It was the closest shop to me and had a great staff and owner. They were always generous with their time and expertise. I will miss them if permanently closed.

Great customer service. Helped us understand requirements and provided resources if needed. Amazing…read moreselection.

Shitty service, they sold me a rifle and a pistol I spent well over 500 dollars and when I have…read moreproblems with the products they tell me there's nothing they can do and it was something I did that caused the issues, now I have a Glock 45 that doesn't hold green gas in the mag and a ar-15 that the hop up doesn't work don't wants your money here only purchase from a place that has a 30 day warranty from the store, very disappointed and really ruined my first experience with airsoft