The place has a cool decor on the inside of the bar and had good music. It was a little annoying that the outside was not open and it was very crowded inside. Also the cash only option is rough when nobody carries cash anymore. There is an ATM available for cash withdrawals though. read more

This place was a colorful sanctuary for any member of the rainbow brigade. We stopped by for Monday Happy Hour and we were not disappointed. Deb, the bartender, was amazing and she made everyone feel welcome. We had some green tea shots for Miley Cyrus Mondays, had a slice of delicious free pizza, and finished off the Blue Moon draft beer (sorry, Deb). We will absolutely be back. Everyone should stop by and visit Deb. read more

Cubbyhole - Monday Happy Hour at Cubbyhole! - Gay Bars Near Me - New York, New York

Small. Cash only in 2022. Just ok drinks. Patrons are decent. Ive been to cubby a handful of times and each time my experience has gone from cool to so so to just not great. My biggest issue is the bartenders and it looks like im not alone bc this seems to span back nearly a decade. The bartenders here are not friendly and are borderline rude and standoffish. As a lesbian bar, call it what u will, i don't understand serving and paying more attention to any men that may walk in but my past two visits it seems like unless your a man or white the bartenders arent really interested in serving you. I dont want to call racism, though yes I got that vibe, nothing blatant happened to me personally for me to fly that flag. But the undertones were there for sure and i would just about believe any claims of it. I dont need to go to cubby, its just an ok bar imo and its lack of diversity are personal turn offs, but if i went once a year only that would be enough. read more

Any night at Cubby is honestly better than going anywhere else but make sure you go on Mondays because Marissa is quite possibly one of the best bartenders EVER!!! Friendly, fast, & always keeps the vibes just right no matter how crazy it gets. Always a great time with them. read more

I went for the first time today with a friend and was waiting about 15 minutes for the bartender girl to acknowledge us and serve us but she apparently served other people before us so we left to another bar up the block. I didn't like her vibe and won't go back. read more

Can always count on a good time to be had here. The staff and bartenders really look out for you and make sure that it's an inclusive, safe and welcoming space for everyone. At any night of the week you can expect a diverse crowd with regulars and first-timers and all those in between making it a friendly and fun vibe. Whether it's a bday celebration, happy hour special deal, a theme night or friend group meet-up - the staff here really goes the extra mile. What a special place! read more

Cubbyhole is a fantastic bar. It is a home to the lesbian / queer community, along with being super cute and fun. The staff are so kind, welcoming, and are genuinely dedicated to providing a safe and positive experience for everyone who steps inside. I can't recommend Cubbyhole enough. read more

Me and my cousin visiting from Italy had such a great time . Such a safe space for lgbtqia. Great music and atmosphere . Deb the bartender was amazing and you can tell Deb really loves her job and made the experience even better ! Come check them out . read more

Our visit to cubbyhole was wholeheartedly satisfying- while I can echo some of the criticisms other folks have had of the place (overcrowded on the weekend and why are there dudes working the bar?) I can't remember the last time I was somewhere with such great feminine energy. Also, the space is fantastic- the decor is a lot of fun and the non-stop slumber party jams were right up my alley. If I ever return to NYC I'd aim for their happy hour as opposed to the packed evening vibe. Considering that the well drinks we scored for $7 at peak hour were freaking strong, I'd venture to say the 1/2 half happy hour is truly worth the visit. read more

Cubbyhole - Look at that happy hour deal! - Gay Bars Near Me - New York, New York

$28 for 2 drinks. Gave bartender $50. No change! No thanks!!!!!!! Music was lame and so was the atmosphere. Do yourself a favor and go anywhere else! Lots of awesome places to grab a drink and this isn't one of them! read more

What a welcoming home! Happened to come here on a night when they gave free shots and pizza but besides that just a delightful friendly vibe. read more

This was my first time at the bar and I want to stay pretty positive for the most part. The atmosphere was very welcoming. Everyone pretty much stays to themselves and you'll get the occasional flirty women here and there. When my partner and I arrived it was fairy empty, around 10ish the crowd started to pick up and it became standing room only. The music is controlled by the guest which is a unique feature of the bar. It's always changing and surprisingly there was a good mixture of genres playing. The drinks were a little disappointing. They were a little light on the liquor but I guess that's bar tactic-makes you keep coming back. All in all I had no complaints, crowd was low-key, music is upbeat and it's a chill place. The non judgemental feels of the place would keep me coming back, I enjoyed my partner being there with me and the look of happiness on everyone's face. read more

Cubbyhole - Gay Bars Near Me - New York, New York

I really wanted to leave you a good review Cubby, but your bartender was beyond rude to patrons that did not deserve it. The overall place has a nice vibe and the drinks are fine, but after overhearing an older female bartender (ironically wears a "Good Girls Are Boring" t-shirt) be so nasty to the customer to both the left and right of us immediately killed our vibe. We witnessed her berate a customer for trying to order a drink, then rudely demanded another customer to leave more tip money. My gosh. I didn't know people still actually treated others like this, especially in a community that is supposed to encourage a safe space in general. We weren't directly affected, but witnessing these two interactions made us feel so unwelcome here that my group immediately left. read more

I've come to Cubby a few times in the past and most recently stood out as a stellar experience thanks to the bartender, Deb. It was the Monday after Pride, which happened to be my birthday, and my girlfriend and I popped in for a drink or two. Deb was the only one behind the bar, thanked us all for being there, and announced she was ordering us all pizza on the house! Free shots were then passed around to those who wanted one and the atmosphere was really kickin'. When my girlfriend had gone up to get our second round she mentioned to Deb that it was my birthday, unbeknownst to me, and before we dug in to the pies Deb got the entire bar to sing me happy birthday. It was such a wonderful way to spend the afternoon and I sincerely appreciated the welcoming and positive energy from Deb. read more

Ignore the bad reviews. This is a genuinely drive place. The women who run it are incredible and they're so real and down to earth. You can tell it's a "community" when you're there. You go alone and you'll make friends. I can't wait to be back! read more

I am between 3 and four stars. I have been here 3 times since New years and it would be way more if it weren't for external reasons.. I like it here. PROS:The environment is chill. I can't help but to look around amongst the crowd and of course at the ceiling. The first night I came in guess who I saw.. Big Boo from Orange is the New Black! I love that she was hanging around in this bar and though people noticed her, no one was crazy trying to get her attention because she was with a friend. Another time I was here, a beautiful possibly drag (to each his own!) woman came in and read my fortune. It was pretty entertaining. Oh and on Tuesdays come for their specials! CONS: So small and the crowd is usually in groups that seem clingy read more

Cubbyhole - When running into a red bombshell that read palms! - Gay Bars Near Me - New York, New York

Classic lesbian bar with a good happy hour. It gets insanely packed here so if you're not comfortable having someone unavoidably rubbing against you every five seconds this is not the place for you. read more

We were visiting from Long Beach, CA and had a great time meeting locals in this fun, easy environment! I highly recommend stoping by this friendly neighborhood bar full of character and l once CoVid restrictions are lifted of course! read more

Cubbyhole - Gay Bars Near Me - New York, New York

We thought this was a lesbian bar or at least a queer bar, but unfortunately it seems to have divulged into just another dive bar full of straight cis males taking up space they don't need or deserve. There really is no atmosphere to speak of at Cubbyhole since music is picked using one of those jukebox app thingys and bartenders appear dissociative and uninterested. My girlfriend and I suffered through one well drink while the guy next to us loudly flirted with any straight passing woman within 10 feet of him and dominated the jukebox with what he perceived to be "cultured, underground tunes." FYI everyone knows who Chet Faker is, you're not special or cool, dude. Anyway, the bartender also seemed to have a disagreement with a queer black woman over some previous happenings there and refused to listen to her concerns while becoming defensive and childish. Not the way you should act in your place of business, especially toward the community your workplace is supposedly serving. We left for Henrietta Hudson after reading Christina C.'s review and though it was very low key, the vibe was much better with room to dance, a pool table, and best of all, it was ACTUALLY queer. read more

No, whhhhhyyyyyy. My girlfriend and I were so looking forward to checking out this alleged lesbian bar - one of the last in the country of its kind, sadly - and at 8:30PM on a Saturday it was already so packed we could barely move. Worse, much worse, almost everyone in there was male. IT'S A LESBIAN BAR. LEAVE IT TO THE LESBIANS. We didn't stay and instead went to Henrietta Hudson - much better and soooo gay (lesbian). Calmer, quieter, more spacious. Fantastic. Bartender was great. Plenty of attractive ladies and a pool table. Go there instead. read more

A really cool lesbian bar! The only thing it is a very small space so we had to wait for an hour to get inside. They have lots of cool things hanging from the walls which makes for a fun atmosphere. It's cash only. A nice spot to start the night. read more

Cubbyhole - a group of people sitting at a bar - Gay Bars Near Me - New York, New York

I was outside waiting to get in with my roommates, both women. The bouncer out front told me and a girl from a different group that we couldn't get in because we didn't get in a single file line when he asked us to. It was the most shameful power trip I have ever witnessed in my life. I'm sad to see that an establishment this well-known would employ a bouncer dripping with that much toxic masculinity. Would have loved to come in and experience the service, but we just didn't get the chance to ‍ read more

Cubbyhole - Gay Bars Near Me - New York, New York

See all

This place is extremely cozy and welcoming. The bartender on Friday nights is extremely friendly and is always super friendly. It's pretty much all gay people. Weekends the dance floor gets too crowded so you can't really dance if that's what your looking for It's more of a sit down talk loud sing type of bar where you can socialize. read more

Too many men. Thought this was a safe space for lesbians/queer women/femme folks - we don't have many. Lots of specifically gay bars in the city - please leave this one for us read more

looked great inside and looked busy, however we asked the bouncer how the crowd was inside and he was not friendly. tried to make light conversations through basic questions and we interacted for about 3 minutes. while short, he gave an unwelcoming vibe that caused my friends and I to end up leaving the "line" he made us start, we left the line to try another bar and he made an odd comment about us not waiting. seems like a great bar however I don't think we would try again based off the first impression. read more

The Cubby's been my favorite bar for as long as I can remember. I used to go a lot more, but I moved out of the neighborhood and got older so drinking isn't as big a deal for me now. Still, going back, always feels like coming home. It's a super friendly bar. You can rock out the Juke box, and drink for cheap. Saturday and Sunday afternoons are filled with super hot guys. All really friendly and not too cliquey. Like you can actually talk to them and not feel judged. Was there last Monday for Happy Hour. The new guy is great, he made us great cocktails on request and impressed me and my friends when we started talking about Rome and Cicero! Some bad reviews here about bouncers and what not. Most of them look like things the bar doesn't have a lot of control over. Bouncers can be unpredictable, but if you go into a space and are respectful and keep an ID on you and don't throw a hissy fit if you do get ID'd, I don't really see how you can have a bad time. The place is rinky-dinky tiny. So, it gets super crowded, super fast. I usually only stay for a few drinks because of this. Also, there can be long lines to get in, because it is so small. so be prepared to wait. read more

Had a blast there! Tiny place and it was packed so full of life and love , but it was perfect place for our crazy group.

Cubbyhole is a place where everyone can feel at home. I've always had an amazing time. The staff is amazing, especially Brit. So friendly and so personable! Give her a raise! The drinks are great! Queer women are the back bone of society. read more

One of the best classic bars in New York hands down! I mean like in all New York not just Manhattan!!

I go here to pick up girls. My boyfriend likes the drink specials. #thenewnormal But seriously. It's a total lesbian bar. Lesbian couples, groups of lesbians, single lesbians. There's also a bunch of random straight couples, gay guys, etc. It's a fun place to meet girls - if you're into girls. There's girls here looking for anything from a casual hook up to a relationship. As I'm already in a relationship (with a dude), I'm really only looking for the casual... which has worked out in my favor ;-) There's also great drink specials - especially Monday, Wednesday, Thursday until 1am. They make a drink called the Dirty Shirley (cherry vodka, sprite, & grenadine) that's absolutely delicious and only $4. Everyone loves dirty shirleys. Even straight boys. read more

Since moving down the street (and for many months before), a good friend of mine (who is not a lesbian) has basically moved into the Cubby Hole. It's not really an exaggeration to say that pretty much any night of the week you can find him here, and thus over last year or so, I too have ended up here many a night to bask in the glow of the Cubby Hole's favorite gay boy and his posse of lesbians. But now I can understand why he feels so at home here. The crowd is friendly, the music is what you make of it (literally, it's a jukebox), and the drinks are cheap. I've gotten to know the staff and many of the regulars, and I've met some fantastic people. So Cubby gets a bump to 5 stars merely for never being anything more or less than you want it to be. And if you see my friend Andrew, tell him I'm on my way. read more

Unfortunately I don't think I can go here anymore, in spite of its many charms and in spite of it being one of the only queer bars for women in NYC. As others have mentioned in previous reviews, there is a massive a-hole of a bartender who *called me the c-word* when I simply asked for something I had left behind the bar earlier and was worried might have gotten stolen. It was absolutely ridiculous, and unwarranted, and frankly disgusting for a supposedly women and queer women-friendly establishment. I was visibly angry, but the other bartenders tried to diffuse the situation and tell me he was "a good guy" and "didn't mean it" and blah blah blah. I rarely ever leave a negative Yelp review, and I'm usually willing to shrug off bartenders who are stressed or disillusioned or snappy, but that was just out of line. I will say that the bouncer was friendly and the other bartender was a complete doll. But no, avoid this place unless you like misogynistic bartenders who are consistently given a pass on bad behavior. read more

Awesome place! Great bartenders and the bouncer is a big Teddy bear, but have an ID. He wont let you in without it.

The best. The staff is so friendly and is so kind and respectful. It was my first time at this cornerstone of the LGBTQ+ community. I can't wait til the pandemic is over and I can experience the inside. read more

Crazy, tiny, packed bar that's nonetheless a lot of kitschy, cheap fun. There's pretty much only beer on the menu, but bartenders are chill and friendly. The night I came, it was predominantly gay/lesbian and my boyfriend and I both had an interesting time rebuffing advances. I don't know why some reviews are calling this a dance bar because there is absolutely NO space for dancing, even if it weren't the weekend and super crowded. It's already a tiny place! Where are you showing off your moves, that 2 sq. ft dark corner in the very back? All in all, a fun pit stop to grab a beer before dinner at one of the many restaurants nearby. read more

Cubbyhole has been our happy place for years now. We come here not only for the atmosphere but also the staff that works there. We love our Geeta and Zack. They always make everyone feel welcome. It's the place you want to come and relax and have a friendly conversation. We love this place so much, that we've had friends get married here and of course all our birthday celebrations. Wish every place had a Geeta and Zack! read more

The best bar literally ever! Omar is the most welcoming and kind bartender - because of him I consistently back

This place is a gem! I was visiting my friends, while out from CA. I really enjoyed the reasonable priced cocktails because Happy Hour in LA is $9 draft beer night. After reading other reviews I am trying to understand why people are trying to make a point of saying it's a Lesbian bar?! If a "straight" bar were to make a point of saying "this is a straight bar" the media would be parked outside and lawsuits filed. Everyone's money is just as green. Its 2019 people live and let live. Why can't we all be inclusive? The decor here is super fun it's like a unicorn decorated. I recommend trying it out for yourself. read more

Went here on a Monday. Visiting from Boston. It started out as a good night but the bartender told us there was no dancing in there. I thought that was ridiculous. He had asked one of his friends to Share that with us. He also got upset because my friend was only ordering water. I don't think a bartender should be upset for someone trying to be responsible. They rest of our party ordered drinks. read more

This place is so tiny hence the name 'cubbyhole'. I have no problem going on a day where I know it won't be packed but if you go on a Tuesday (2$ margaritas) or anytime on the weekend you go in and it's like you're suffocating. Or at least that's how I feel. There's a jukebox that plays anything you want which is pretty cool. But other than that just looks like a unicorn threw up ornaments and lights and rainbows everywhere. read more

Cubbyhole - Gay Bars Near Me - New York, New York