Greg came recommended to me for my first tattoo from a friend. After I called I was in his shop within two days for a consult. Went through everything paid my deposit and I had my tattoo done two days ago by Greg. The detail, the shading, and the jokes throughout we're all amazing! I have friends that have seen my tattoo and have told me also how impressed they are with all the detail and what great quality it is. I highly recommend! read more

Won a gift certificate at a silent raffle, took some time to call for an appointment. I now have a awesome arm tat and I recommend Custom Tattoo to anyone wanting their first or next ink done. read more

Great job with both me and my son! He was super easy to work with and the place was VERY clean! Will be back for more! My new go-to!! Prices were what I would expect! read more

Everything was going great, came in for the consultation for a custom half sleeve. Paid $40 for the sketch, got a rough sketch three weeks later and then nothing. I reached out multiple times over two months and Greg never got back. Sweet business model of taking our money for sketches and then ghosting customers. If Greg didn't want the work he should have told me upfront. read more

I picked Custom Tattoo for my first tattoo, and I'm so glad I did. When I came in for my consultation and knew exactly what I wanted, Greg said we could do it right away. He made me feel so comfortable from the moment I walked in and throughout the whole process. The shop is spotlessly clean and they obviously take sanitation seriously. The work was quick and affordable, and my tattoos healed beautifully. I really can't say enough good things about the experience. I will 1000% return if and when I want another tattoo. read more

I'm so happy I ended up here to get my celtic shamrock. I was shopping around for a place and many places had long waiting lists. Greg answered the phone and got me an appointment in a week. I sent what I wanted, and we discussed size and placement, and he got the template ready. The shop is clean and professional and very calming. I was nervous when I got there, but once I was in that chair, Greg chatted and told the most amazing stories. I could just listen to him all day. His knowledge of the industry and years of experience is evident, and I couldn't be happier with the way the piece turned out. I highly recommend him if you want the best quality work done for a reasonable price. read more

Greg was amazing. It was my daughter's first tattoo and she was very nervous and he made her feel at ease. The tattoo turned out beautiful! He's very professional and also at a great price! read more

First of all, I called and literally was in the chair within the next 30 minutes which was awesome. It was my first tattoo (6/14/18) so I was really nervous and indecisive and Greg was SO nice and incredibly patient. The whole process took like 30 minutes and he redid my stencil for me and was extremely patient and understanding while I almost fainted. The tattoo itself didn't really hurt and turned out absolutely perfect. I'll update once it heals and everything but honestly, it was an amazing experience for my first time! (Besides almost fainting lol) Thank you Greg! My boyfriend will be coming to you once he decides on his tattoo Update, had to get a touch up about a month afterwards and they did it free of charge and now it's just as I pictured it read more

I had the best experience with Greg this weekend. Being that it was a lettering tattoo, he was attentive to the detail and the spacing of the letters which I really appreciated. I felt very comfortable at his shop. I'm sure I'll be back for more in the future. Thanks Greg!! read more

Greg = one of the owners of Custom Tattoo = super nice guy who wants you to feel good about your tattoo and will talk through/work with you to make sure it's just perfect. I got my mom a gift certificate to Custom Tattoo for her 50th birthday a few years back; she'd always wanted a tattoo but had been hesitant with the follow-through her whole life. Claims of "I'm going to get a huge badass snake tattoo running down my entire arm!" were obviously bogus, although she sure liked to talk big... Enter myself and my brother throwing down to get said birthday gift certificate. Now you have no excuse not to get that biker snake arm badassery, mom! Of course she opted for a slightly-smaller than hand-sized tattoo of an Iris, her favorite flower. (I told you... all talk on that snake business. Pfft.) After some help easing her into the process itself - she was so *so* nervous - Greg worked with my mom to make her feel comfortable with sizing, placement, and the artwork itself. She ended up loving the Iris tattoo she had done by Greg on her shoulder blade; and while it turns out she's not great with the buzzing/needle/actuality of the tattooing process, she rocks tanks in the summer like no one's business to show that thing off. Lisa's right; the environment is extremely clean and simple/minimal in décor/setup. Obviously different artists boast different styles when it comes to their work, and Greg's no exception. That said, mom loves her tattoo and I'm just about positive she secretly wants another one. Maybe for her 60th... read more

I recently got my third tattoo, and my first at Custom. Everything about the shop, its owner and their work was top-notch. My artist was Greg, also the owner, who made me feel comfortable throughout the whole process. I came in with the basic design, and he made the modifications I asked for and created a picture of what I wanted. When it came down to the actual work, he was really friendly, relaxed and helpful in answering the care questions I had. The shop is immaculate and bright, and they usually have tunes going. I got tattooed to some Beck and Tom Waits which helped me relax during the 2 hours I was in the chair. My tattoo is nothing short of spectacular. I know that with one touch-up appointment, my Custom tattoo will most certainly be my favorite. I'll upload a photo for the site when it heals, but you have to trust me, this is a great shop. Best tattooing experience I've had, and I can't tell you how proud I am that it happened in MKE. read more

I don't normally do yelp reviews but Greg is such a talented artist and great human being that I feel he should be recognized for the great work he does. I am forever grateful for my tattoo and I can't praise his work enough read more

I have a few tattoos, and have never really stuck to a specific shop...until now. Greg is a very talented artist, and also a really nice guy, who will make you feel right at home in the chair. I was in for two sessions, and couldn't be happier. I booked in advance both times, but never had to wait longer than I wanted for an appointment. 10/10, would recommend! I will definitely be back. There is a slight upcharge if you're paying with plastic- I recommend having cash. read more

Greg Foster is my favorite tattoo artist! I cannot recommend him enough. He's done a few of my tattoos in the past and I'll continue to go to him in the future. I love traditional style tattoos, and Greg really excels at it. Thick, solid lines. Bold colors that haven't showed signs of fading. I've come in with an idea of what I want to get done, and he draws it up super quickly and it looks EXACTLY how I want it. Prices are competitive, and honestly inexpensive for the quality. They don't do any Friday the 13th specials, but I come here on Friday the 13th anyway because I'd rather spend more money and get something that takes more than five minutes in a packed room full of people who want to spend $20 on sub-par work. Street parking can be a doozy. I recommend scheduling an appointment. read more

I had my half sleeve done here by Troy last fall. He was super professional and very friendly! Most importantly I love my tattoo! :D

My wife and I take frequent trips to MKE from Chicago and I was looking to get a ring finger tattoo to celebrate our marriage. I haven't gotten any tattoos in about ten years and the experience here at Custom Tattoo was so warm and welcoming. The owner of the shop, Greg, was so cool and easy to talk to. He really made me fee comfortable and the experience as a whole was so awesome. He did a phenomenal job on my tattoo and I couldn't recommend this shop any more. read more

I have to give one star because that's as low as I can go way over paid for a chewed up not what I asked for tattoo. Very disappointed.

My son introduced me to Greg and Custom Tattoo when he was getting most of his body done. I have since had Greg do 7 tattoo's and I am so grateful he is still active because I wouldn't go anywhere else. Greg's skill level is off the charts. He has over 21 years experience and it shows in his work. I have never experienced any infection of any kind. The shop is clean, professional and in a safe location. Trust is essential when you're getting inked and you can truly trust Greg and his performance. read more

Loved the experience here. I went and I got a tattoo for the first time in August and Greg was very kind and explained in great detail the must-dos for before, during, and after the process. 6 months later the tattoo still looks great and I couldn't be happier. read more

Got my first tattoo done here and Greg was gentle and really helped me relax. The place is clean and the staff is incredibly professional...highly recommended! read more

Nice place. Nice people. I was nervous to get my tattoo and Greg helped me to relax, he's got some pretty awesome jokes to tell..... Even though my tattoo was a small job, he treated me with respect, overall great service. Definitely would go back for more. read more

Custom Tattoo is where I have gotten three of my tattoos done. The simple and clean environment is certainly a contributing factor as to why I chose to come here so many times. Greg Foster did a great job with my tattoos and is by far one of the best people to have ever inked my skin. I don't cry and I am not a squirmer, but his words of encouragement and care for my well-being were comforting as I was being tatted. I'd like to compliment him specifically on the great job that was done with shading! read more

Thank goodness for this shop. I was starting to think I was going to have to go all the way back to CA to get a clean shop with nice artists that don't try to make you feel like poo. This shop is clean, and both Greg and Troy did great work. The best tattoo experience both my husband and I have had, and we've had a lot of them. We will be back. read more

Everyone at Custom Tattoo was very friendly and helpful, and even though I was only getting my lip pierced, I didn't feel like the process was being rushed or taken less seriously than if i was getting something more complicated. The shop is clean and bright, and in no way scuzzy, and noone had that pissy attitude you kind of expect to encounter in a tattoo shop. Really nice people! I haven't had any abnormal problems with my piercing (it's been 3 days since I got it), and I had a good experience overall, but to be honest, I don't think I would get a tattoo here. I was maybe a little spoiled, because I got my first 3 tattoos done at Insight Studios (in Chicago, check them out!) and couldn't be happier with them, so I do have really high expectations of tattoo artists as a result. The tattoo work at Custom, at least based on what I saw in the artists' portfolios, is a little inconsistent. Some of the work is truly beautiful and really well done, but enough of the other stuff has amateur problems, like shaky and heavy-handed linework, that would make me too nervous to go here for any inkwork. That might just mean that the portfolios are in need of an update, with some newer and better (and cleaner) stuff; I'm just going off of what I saw on their site and what was in the photoalbum next to the counter. I definitely wouldn't write these guys off completely, and their pricing is really fair ($25 for piercings, including the jewelry). Just be careful, because you do tend to get what you pay for! read more

Just got my first tattoo done over the weekend along with my wife, father and brother. Troy did the tattoos for all of us and it went great. I couldn't be happier with the way it turned out. We had an idea of what we wanted but not the complete picture and we left it up to Troy to draw out the details and it came out awesome. read more

Troy is the absolute best! He was so patient and completely supportive of my vision. He made me feel so comfortable and he did a great job with my tattoo, it was a simple one but he still spent time making sure it was exactly what I wanted, I would definitely recommend this place! read more

Greg Foster is fantastic and really listens to what you want. Typically you should schedule an appointment but this past Saturday some friends and I were lucky enough to walk in and he fit us in. The shop is clean and Greg has a really good way of putting you at easy while he's doing your tattoo. I will definitely return to him in the future and recommend him to anyone wanting a tattoo. A++ read more

Amazing experience ! I worked with Troy on a tattoo I have wanted for over 3 years and could never find the right artist to do the work. I love tattoos but have always hated the experience. When I shopped around a lot of artist were rude or tried to pressure me to get the tattoo they wanted to make . This was completely different. Troy treated me with respect and really took the time to create what I wanted. He took the ideas I gave him and improved the design. The tattoo was pretty big and his wonderful personality made the experience of having it done meaningful. He was funny and let me take breaks when I needed it. He was kind and that made me feel at ease. The tattoo turned out perfect! He took the time to explain aftercare and for a large tattoo it healed in record time. I can not say enough good things about this shop. I will be back. Thank you for a great experience! read more

Today I just got my first ink at Custom Tattoo. Mike was the artist I worked with there and he did a great job taking my ideas and the multiple images I emailed him and integrating them into a fantastic design. He worked fast and his shading suggestions were great and really added to the design. I might have given 5 stars, but since this was my first tattoo I don't really have anything to which I can compare. His price seemed very reasonable. He quoted me a price that was higher because we weren't sure if we would use other color or the complexity of the design, but he came in under the quote which was a great surprise! read more

The experience is worth the trip to Milwaukee. I had a design concept that I shared with artist/owner Greg--we worked together to refine the idea--and in the end the collaboration was a success. Greg took the idea presented, balanced the graphic, and sized it to my proportions. The end result was a perfect rendition of what I had envisioned. The shop is pristine, well lit, and the peeps leave their attitude [if they even have one] at the door. Great experience. read more

Greg is fantastic! Would recommend this place to anyone that's looking for someone that loves their work, and cares about doing a great job!

At 51 years old I had my first tattoo today by Troy. Wonderful! I love it! I am so happy! Really painless. Great job Troy and thank you.

I came here for a cover up tattoo, and was told I'd need to cover it with three large flowers (it's a pretty small tattoo, and he was suggesting a half sleeve to cover it). Couldn't make an appointment for another month and a half. Didn't receive any sketches like I had asked, and once I finally saw them, only two flowers were done and the wording was completely wrong. Plus, I had already made a non-refundable deposit. I decided to go back to my original tattoo artist back home and he covered it with one small flower the same day. read more

After much hemming and hawing, I decided to get re-pierced while in the Milwaukee area. I had gotten a piercing at Gothic Body in the past, which was a so-so experience. I remembered seeing Custom Tattoo appear on the east side a year or two ago and checked out their website. I was pleased by it's sleek design and the fact that piercings are only 25$ including jewelry! The studio is extremely clean and well designed/decorated. The piercer was incredibly kind, informative and confident (precisely the traits you like to see in the person who is about to punch a hole in your face. ) The whole experience was fast, wonderful and an incredible bargain to boot. If only I needed another piercing... read more

Terrible customer service and sub-par artistry! Me and my friends will not be going there again. While my tattoo turned out nice, it was simple and took little effort. My boyfriend on the other hand got "With great power comes great responsibility" done on his forearm by a guy named Cole last year. The end result is anything but professional. The lettering is uneven, not sharp, and there are various places where he did not fill in ink on his arm. We came in with the font printed out for him so there is no excuse for the lettering being off. I recently left Custom tattoos a message about our experience and asked about getting it fixed but have not heard a response; no "we're sorry", no nothing. This business clearly doesn't care about keeping customers or acknowledging their mistakes. We'll be finding a parlor that doesn't just want our money next time. read more

If you are in Milwaukee and want a tattoo, go to Custom Tattoo! The shop is clean, beautifully decorated with vintage photos and the owner Greg, and the other artists are friendly, professional, and know what they are doing. I got my first tattoo there 3 days ago and could not be happier. I had an idea in my head, brought the photos to Greg and he created a beautiful tattoo. Since this was my first tattoo he made me feel relaxed and really took the time to explain everything and create the exact design that I wanted. I am so happy how it turned out. I cannot recommend this place enough! read more

I've been to two other tattoo shops for previous tattoos and was very pleased with my experience at Custom. Greg did an amazing job adding on to my lotus. He quoted me $100 for my addition, but after two hours in the chair he simply wished me a merry Christmas and came in under what he quoted me! Too awesome of him. I will definitely be back and will absolutely be recommending him to my friends! read more

I have gotten eight tattoos by Greg Foster at Custom Tattoo, and I will definitely not go anywhere else to get future tattoos! The shop is very clean, simple, and not at all intimidating. Greg is everything you could ask for in a tattoo artist; he's extremely talented, welcoming, and has some great jokes to help you get through your tattoo. I would highly recommend this shop! read more

My sister and I both had a phenomenal experience with Custom Tattoo! Upon entering the shop I immediately noticed how clean and neat everything was. It is clear that they really take pride in their business. We were both nervous to get our first tattoo, but Greg made us feel comfortable and at ease! He made sure that we were handing the pain ok and even told lots of jokes to distract us. It really felt like we were all just hanging out and made the pain of the tattoo seem a lot less intense. The artwork that Greg designed for our sister tattoos was exactly what we had asked for and we couldn't be happier with the end result! His attention to detail in line work and shading really makes my tattoo pop off of my skin. I got it just two days ago, so it is still quite fresh, and I already get tons of compliments on how intricate and beautiful it is. I absolutely LOVE it! I will certainly be returning to Custom Tattoo in the future! These guys are passionate about their work and it shows in their amazing tattoos! read more