Kyle is a good agent. Second time I called was a little rough, but Kyle was gone for the day.read more

I went to Valparaiso First Insurance because they represented Erie Insurance, which got amazing…read moreratings nationwide. A couple months later, there was a minor tornado, and a tree fell on my house. I phoned Valparaiso, but my agent was working out of the office. The person who answered the phone insured me that if I did even file a claim, it could have a bad mark on my otherwise perfect insurance rating, and could possible cause my rates to change. She was very nice. I never did get a return call from the person representing me at the office. (There was a tornado, and I was told they were swamped with calls, which made my agent working from home seem a little curious . . . ) I called Erie. They said the appraiser Erie sent me to said he could come out in two weeks and that I should make sure the (very damaged) roof was covered, or it could cost me more, and that I should make calls and try and find someone who would help me, although considering the number of claims people were making, it would be very hard to book someone. In other words, ERIE INSURANCE and VALPARAISO FIRST INSURANCE were both WORTHLESS when I needed them most. I wrote to Erie, and the president's office sent me a single space note explaining the many reasons I was wrong. My neighbors, who had another major insurance company, were helped within four days. My brothers and amazing friends came out the next weekend. We moved the tree from my roof, I hired a friend (professional roofer) to repair the damage, and DROPPED VALPARAISO FIRST INSURANCE AND ERIE INSURANCE ASAP. People who have had good luck with either of them, I am happy for you. I wish I could say they didn't screw me over in a horrible time I needed them desperately. Personally? I would avoid both of these if at all possible.

Todd's agency is the best and they have the most knowledgeable staff I've ever dealt with handling…read moremy insurance! Would definitely recommend!

The Todd Laczynski agency is best agency I have her ever been insured with. When i call with any…read morechanges I need to make or questions I have it is taken care of the same day. The staff is courteous, helpful, knowledgeable and always happy to help with my insurance needs. Todd Laczynski is a great agent/person he is always willing to go the extra mile for his clients.

I'm giving Sam Allie 5 STARS for saving us $560/yr on our car and home insurance. I've been a…read morediehard client of another company for over 15 years but Sam assured me he could help me save money and he made good on his promise. He even drove out to meet me and the switch was so easy! Give Sam a call if you want to save money on your car and home insurance, too.

Great agent. Right from the community. He and his team are very knowledgeable. I highly recommend…read morethem.

PSA: DO NOT USE STATE FARM and/or ROB RUDAKAS Agency 835…read moreLincolnway, Valparaiso IN 46383 For the last 15 years I have been charged car insurance premiums for my deceased father-in-law whom WE never added to our cars EVER. He never lived with us, moved to AZ 16 years ago and has been deceased for 11 years (AND the State Farm computer system showed he was DECEASED but kept charging me anyway)! This all started for me at the end of July when I just happened to look at the pages they send quarterly to tell you about your policies and on the back of the third page I noticed my deceased father-in-law listed as a driver! I went into the agency whom we have been with for over 20 years to find out what was going on. She showed me the screen that even showed they knew he was deceased. I had them remove him and asked how long I had been paying for him. She did not know. Tried to blame it on new computer software. Passed the issue off to a corporate person for a "Deep dive." After 2 1/2 months of no resolution and now she was not returning my calls I made an appointment with the local owner Rob Rudakas. First appointment he was not there another computer error. When we finally sat down with him he stated things like this have been going on with State Farm customers and it has been a problem. Well everyone should know this! He then stated they closed that inquiry and had credited me a couple hundred dollars. They didn't note a thing on my bill and didn't tell me it was closed. I was pissed. The owner then opened another inquiry now 3 months in. I received 2 checks in the mail that only equaled about $1200 and I was told by my agent they could only go back 6 years. Well by my calculations 6 years of back pay was about $3600 so they still owed me $2400 for those 6 years. My agent at this point sent me an email I would have to open another inquiry for the remaining 9 years. Seems he was done trying to fix the problem State Farm caused. I opened my 3rd inquiry and mentioned I did not receive the correct amount back for the 6 years they already looked into. They would check on both. 2 days later a call from them that they owe us nothing else and can only go back the 6 years. I was told it was our fault for not removing him during renewals. First of all we didn't add him, didn't know he was on our policies and our renewal is automatic. I hadn't personally seen my agent in at least 15 years. If it was our fault they would never have given us any money back. I asked why would they not give the money back for the 11 years he was dead and they knew he was dead and again it was our fault for not removing a man we didn't know was on our policies. DO NOT USE STATE FARM OR ROB RUDAKAS. I have cancelled my policies and changed my life insurance to another agent so Rob never gets another dime from me. I urge anyone with this agent to do the same and check your policies often since they can add dead people without your knowledge. Please keep reposting.

One of the best in the business. Service rates and everything between. You can't ask for more this…read moreplace you're family not just a number

I've been a customer since 2000/01. South Shore Insurance has never let me down. From a hail…read morestorm ridden hail damaged home to auto/home/life insurance, South Shore has tended to my requests and questions each and every time. And one of the best parts, Christine and crew are certified to handle insurance in Illinois from Indiana. I started with South Shore when I lived in Indiana and kept them when I moved back to Illinois. Very happy with the service. Thank You!!!

This was a fantastic insurance agency. I am new to Indiana and needed to insure my car. I wasn't…read moreuse to Indiana laws or anything related to it, yet they made everything so easy to understand and was able to answer any questions I had. They found me an extremely low rate. Couldn't be any happier. Will be going back for my other insurance needs.

I received my home and auto policy and noticed it was with some outfit from Lafayette. It is still…read moresafeco but not with Anderson. I went to the Valparaiso office to pay my premium for the year only to find out that they did not accept payments there so I had to mail it which was no big deal. What happened to Anderson?? I have been a customer for over 40 years and have never put in a claim. If they were getting out of the insurance business, it seems that they could have at least let me know. A thank you note would have been nice since I probably helped them become millionaires. Thanks for taking advantage of me for years. Ken Larsen

From the owner: Anderson Insurance provides Insurance services in the NW Indiana area. As an independent agent,…read moreAnderson Insurance has the freedom to place your insurance with the insurance company that is the best all-around fit for you. We also have the ability to choose from a vast number of insurance companies. From underwriting to claims, you can depend upon our friendly staff to be there when you need us. We are located in Valparaiso, Indiana and service clients throughout Lake, Porter and La Porte Counties.