There will never be a better pizza. Period! The only pizza we will eat. Straightforward service w a smile. read more

went to Dicarlo's in wintersville last week , 1st time in years. Nothing like it used to be. very disappointed.

not sure who is making the pizzas this evening but you can tell it was sitting out and they reheated it. beyond thin, dry and tough. tossing it out. read more

My favorite place to get pizza! Great and fast service, cheap, and great pizza! Definitely recommend.

called ahead for order, when I got there, they have no clue of my order, after 25 minutes . I left

I would highly recommend the buffalo chicken sandwich it is so good I get one weekly pretty much especially when I worked over that way, and they have great pizza it reminds me of when I was a kid and got Wellsburg all the time they are very close first for me now with Wellsburg Amazing Pizza got to stop every time you're near! read more

Always the best - Live in Texas . When I come home always have to make my stop there & even take back pizza. Funny is when go through security. Never fails that the TSA make a comment about me being DiCarlo's Pizza back . Very well know at Pittsburgh international!!! read more

Great down-home pizza. Plenty of sauce with a tasty cheese blend. You only get two pepperoni per slice so I may get extra on my next order. Good pizza that I enjoy whenever I come in town. read more

I love the pizza especially when it's crispy, can't give a full 5 stars because it's different every time.. but we'll worth it.

Best pizza ever! I live in Georgia; when we come up north we make it a point to stop in there a few times and even take some home (frozen) to eat later! read more

It's DiCarlos's. What else can you say. A Steubenville tradition for decades. Excellent crust, cheesy cheese, tart and tangy sauce. Sittin' on the bench absorbing the smells, reading week old newspapers, watching the old TV while your order bakes, are all part of the experience that non locals just can't wrap their heads around. Poking holes in the lid to sneak a piece of pepperoni on the way home while dad drove are lifetime memories. Pepperoni only upon request on Fridays back in the day. I recently ordered a clothing item on line for my brother in law for Christmas and the ordering and delivery process including delivery update emails were very welcoming. read more

Service is horrible. Lady ahead of me had waited 30min without anyone letting her know her pizza was ready. We waited almost 10 min before our order was taken. This place is locally loved. It's probably the best pizza around that area. But for someone from out of town this pizza just doesn't amount to anything. Crust is the best part. Sauce has no flavor.. basic spaghetti sauce. Cheese is flavorless. It's cold toppings which I really like for a Chang up. But being from Pittsburgh there are a lot better places in Pittsburgh that do this style. Was in the area and tried it out. If you grew up on this pizza I get why you love and defend it. But from an outside point of view it's just not that good. read more

Dicarlo’s Original Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Steubenville, Ohio

Best. Pizza. Ever. I'm from the area & grew up on this pizza so it's amazing to me from that standpoint alone. The crust is like something from a dream that you never want to wake up from; it's truly out of this world. Everyone has their own exceedingly personal & specific ways they prefer to enjoy their 'za so to argue about which one is better is kinda silly. You like what you like, I like what I like - fuhgettaboutit! I recently made a trip back home & after so many hours on the road the first place we went was this specific location to get the world's greatest pizza. It was hot as balls, the place has no ac, but I would seriously kick 4 toddlers in the face to get another tray of pepperoni & extra cheese right now. I would kick 40 toddlers in the face for a location in Minnesota. 400. 4000. read more

The service, food and time it took to get our food was just minutes. The price was excellent!

Di Carlo's is a former pizza titan that defined the style that made the Steubenville pizza brand what it is today. However, just like the titans of history, their popularity is better left as a memory. There is nothing generous about the portions of ingredients that you'll find on their pizza. In comparison to their competition, the price point is high and the quality is low. Fast, friendly, or convenient service could almost mask the over-all quality of their product, unfortunately, they fall short there as well. read more

good pizza, better ingredients, that's the dicarlos way. -Your Friendly Neighbor Spider-man read more

Every time I come to Steubenville I must have the Original DiCarlos Pizza still the same after 50+ years of providing great square cut pan pizza. Salute from Sacramento, CA. read more

Love it! Crispy crust, best sauce, no need for extra cheese cause they are generous! Traditional cheese and pepperoni 16 slice square tray for under 16 dollars. read more

Because this one is near, we tried several times with the same result. The staff at this location is unpleasant, they act like they are doing you a favor and even got an eye roll when I asked for the cheese to be melted. I hear the ones on Adams or in Weirton are fine so I won't go back here for more waiting and eye rolls. read more

The crust is great handmade crust. It doesn't come the same way every time like a big chain pizza place. The sauce is chunky and tomatoey, which put me off at first but it really grows on you. I like the by-the-slice price method. Sometimes the staff is not a ray of sunshine though. read more

I stopped in this past Tuesday. The pizza was excellent. Dough was fresh, thin, and crispy and cheese was excellent. My only compliant was the time i spent waiting and they gave me the wrong toppings on my pizza. read more

Sure I am biased by a family history of eating here, but I love the pizza and really haven't been disappointed.

I have been going here since Peppy owned/ran the place. Great pizza then as well as now.

Not so good anymore! There was a time when you'd wait 25 mins and be happy with a few nice squares, not anymore. I was highly disappointed the with the taste and small squares I found in my box. Definitely behind Rays, Brunos, & Giannamores. Drive two more mins please! read more

Okay, this place has now become the best pizza in the area!! When I come to town, I always stop by and pick some up for the family! Crunchy crust and very tasty! The place is very clean! I heard there were new owners so I thought I would try it out again, now I'm addicted!! Great job!! Very impressed! read more

I stopped for a couple of slices, what a mistake! This was by far the worst pizza I have had recently. I love DiCarlos in Weirton but this one you couldn't tell it was DiCarlos. Frozen pizza tasted better. Never again will I waste my time stopping here. This is a disgrace to the DiCarlos name. read more

I grew up on this pizza like most people around here. The pizza has sure gone way down hill. I don't know what happen but I don't even bother anymore. Plus they when you walk in the ask what you want and then they walk away and not even listen so unless you want pep only you will have to tell them again when they decide to make you pay. read more

Worst pizza ever...I like the DiCarlo's on 3 springs dr in Weirton better. l will never eat pizza from here again!

This square sliced pizza is nothing like I have ever experienced. Pizza crust and sauce are baked removed from oven and then the toppings are sprinkled on top and not returned for further baking. It was so weird. I know the locals love this square pizza stuff but if you are not local beware. read more