Sweet little shop with lots of treats! Lol. Lots of old childhood favorites & new delightful chocolates & fudge that melted in your mouth. Bright & fun place with lots of giant stuffed toys! The lady behind the counter cooperated in our walk down memory lane to entertain the kids however the kids weren't having it...too exicted for the candies! read more

Quaint little candy shop! No frills - but I mean that in the absolute best way possible! It has all the nostalgic candy you'd hope for, with some new stuff too. All very candies - which is nice! They have candles, chocolates - all the sweet stuff! Highly recommend if sweets are your thing! read more

We stopped in as we wanted something sweet and been this location before. The old man behind counter was just nasty. I ordered many pieces of fudge and he said make-up your mind, to that I said I was buying every piece he cut. Why bite at customers that are buying. 6 pieces of fudge and 2 bear paws at a cost of over $45, wow. We did not know they had other locations, as much friendly counter in Sister Bay location. I guess I would say if you are having a bad day DO NOT TAKE IT OUT ON OTHERS. Next time other people can take our money. read more

Well, while they have a good variety they are quite expensive. However, after shopping there for so long, and coming to fall fest my entire life, they have fully disappointed us this year. This year they entered ping pong balls and the prize was a 1$ off something in their store. What a solid disappointment for children, they are outrageously priced so maybe they should've just done a small goody bag or one free piece of chocolate or anything... you all really need to get it together read more

Good selection of candy for kids and adults. The old man was gracious and kind. I was able to make change for him as he needed singles. Our selection was tasty and delicious. read more

Looking at the reviews of the other DC locations, I'm not quite sure why Sister Bay's warrants a lower review. This is our second visit to this location and during Columbus Day weekend they were generous with setting out samples. Good fudge samples at the register, large chocolate malt balls towards the back. I know I should spend more time looking at the handmade chocolates up front in the case, but I enjoy picking candy from the large backroom whether at $7.98/lb from one wall or priced by the piece elsewhere in the room. Location is great in Sister Bay - easy and perfectly timed detour as we were waiting for a table at Al Johnson's. Staff have been nice enough on both visits even as we made our purchases of penny candy. read more

Cute little 'old fashioned' candy shop located on the main drag in Sister Bay. They have candy that I haven't seen in ages. There is pre-bagged candy, and a section with bins that you can fill your own bag and pay per pound/ounce. There are also many other goodies such as fudge and giant peanut butter cups! read more

Ordered chocolate in Bear claws with cashews directly as labeled in the case we went for dinner we opened them up and we were given something different I brought them directly back to the store show the same person that sold them to me he gave me cashew clusters which is not what we ordered and he said there's no return on candies and he said if you want those you're gonna have to pay for them. I said you did not give me what I ordered though so now I have candy I don't want the one I want said you should do something he just looked at me like oh well they were very rude I've never had the service in this store before. I will try to visit one of the other ones because they must've had someone else take over because this gentleman was not very nice there's usually very nice ladies in there and I've never been taking care of at any store here in Door County I had my receipt I everything in my order had caramel in it he clearly gave me the wrong thing and he knew it and was not willing to even charge me half so please make sure if going here you get what you ordered before you walk out of the store. read more

This candy shop is so cute.I bought some candies and a toy as gifts for my cousin.So I don't know what it tastes.I hope it's better than look. read more

See all

Don't expect to find homemade candy as these stores would lead you to believe. A lot of their candy comes from Schaumburg, IL. Plus, very few things are safe for those with allergies. The staff told me that anything with chocolate could basically have nuts or wheat in it, do don't eat it if you are allergic. Either the staff is too lazy to know what is in their products, the company is too lazy to provide their staff with training on what is in their products or their manufacturing plant is too lazy to clean equipment and segregate items in a clean and allergen conscious way. It's door county and I cannot even get a chocolate covered cherry because it might have wheat in it! Seriously?! read more

The Door County Confectionery is about as close to the old-time general store candy shop as you can get now days. It is chuck full of different candies of all types including many from many years ago. read more