The Short Version:
Chain restaurant serving North-Americanized Italian food for the masses. If you set your expectations accordingly, it's A-OK for what it is.
The Long Version:
Anyone who knows me knows I always prefer small independent businesses than big chains, so chains are rarely ever my first choice for places to eat, but I usually don't make a fuss if I'm part of a group and others want to go.
Anyway, East Side Mario's is a Canadian chain that started out in London Ontario back in the 1980s. Since then it's grown to over 60 locations across Canada, with the bulk of them in Ontario. I would describe it as serving North-Americanized Italian food that would satisfy a large group including those who aren't too adventurous. Their claim to fame is their unlimited garlic loaves, soup and salad.
I have been to many East Side Mario's over the years, always as part of a group. However, I only recently visited this particular location for the first time. I would say it's pretty much the same as any of the other locations I've been to. Service was friendly, decor I imagine is dictated by corporate because they all have the same look and feel, and food was fine for what it is.
I was there for lunch and had the Pizza from the lunch menu. It was $14.99 for a personal-sized pizza with 2 toppings and my choice of soup, salad or fries. I chose the garden salad with the dressing on the side. For my toppings I chose grilled chicken and mixed peppers. The lunch specials do not come with unlimited garlic loaves, soup and salad. You can add it on for an extra $5.99, but I did not do that.
My pizza was all right. The crust was thin and it wasn't overly saucy, which I appreciated. It tasted similar to Domino's pizza in my opinion. I liked that the mixed peppers were green and red bell peppers. Makes it look prettier with more colours. The chicken was a decent amount and tasted similar to the ready-to-eat grilled chicken pieces sold in the deli section at grocery stores.
The garden salad was iceberg lettuce (not my favourite type of lettuce), red onions, tomatoes, black olives, croutons and a pepperoncini pepper. The dressing was their house Italian dressing. I liked that it wasn't too oily. It came on the side, as requested. Ingredients were fresh.
Oh one thing I enjoy is that they offer freshly grated Parmesan cheese on everything you order. So I did have a light sprinkling on both my salad and on my pizza.
My friends both had the salmon and shrimp spaghetti ($26.49) from their special "Garlic Fest" menu which is for a limited time only. Their meals came with unlimited garlic loaves, soup and salad. They both got Ceasar salads and only ate one portion each. They didn't have any soup. They seemed to enjoy their meals though.
Although I didn't get any dessert, I saw they had mini desserts for $2.99, which is great for a small sweet ending to your meal without overindulging. I think more places should offer mini desserts.
I also didn't have any cocktails but noticed they were very reasonably priced at around $7 each.
This location is in a plaza. Lots of free parking in the plaza parking lot.
Review #112 (2026) read more