HUGE portions of delicious ice cream the staff was friendly. Busy busy busy but we didn't have to wait too long. Sat outside and enjoyed our cones. Couldn't below the low prices 3 cones and a milkshake for $17 read more

Eder's Ice Cream - Enjoy tea berry and melt away icecream cone. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montoursville, Pennsylvania

I stopped for some ice cream and I tell you what, I suggest you order a kids size because a small is 2 big scoops. I got chocolate peanut butter and melt away they both were very yummy. The staff was busy waiting on customers seemed very friendly and efficient on waiting in the customers ! Establishment was very clean read more

The ice cream is so good. Nice variety of flavors too. The staff are friendly and helpful. The only down sides are small and chaotic parking lot and the line often is very long and you have to wait outside in the sun. read more

Eder's Ice Cream - Outside - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montoursville, Pennsylvania

The ice Cream is great. The service is great. The prices are really cheap.

One of the top three places I have ever gotten ice cream from. The ice cream is incredible. The old fashioned chocolate was probably the best chocolate ice cream I've ever had. Also,the portions are crazy. A small is more than most places medium. We will definitely come back again. The only warning is the cookie dough is intense. There is equal parts cookie to ice cream. We stopped by for a quick snack before dinner and ended up not needing dinner. read more

Eder's Ice Cream in PA is an absolute gem! The ice cream is delicious and the portions are huge, especially considering the prices. You may have to wait a little while in line, but it's well worth it once you get your order. The staff is always friendly and welcoming, and the whole place has a cozy, old rustic charm that makes the experience even better. There's plenty of parking, and even the other customers you meet there seem friendly, which adds to the community feel. If you're looking for great ice cream and a nostalgic atmosphere, stop by Eders. We happened to come here during the Little League World Series and everyone recommended it. We were not disappointed and I wished we had listened to everyones comments about the sizes. The three of us could have shared one. read more

Great ice cream with enormous serving sizes and awesome prices. A small building with a line usually out the door, but it's well worth the short wait. This will be a must stop every time we're in Williamsport for the World Series. read more

For GREAT Creamery ice cream check out Waltz Creamery in Salladasburg or Main St Creamery in Wellsboro. Used to love Eder's. 100 yrs of success, now in 2023 enter the 4th and lazy generation Tye Sheets who took it over and is destroying his familys legacy. For one thing the icecream is no longer mixed. Tye says it's always been like this!? So order Cookie Dough and one guy gets 2 scoops of only vanilla ice cream and maybe the 3rd person gets the chunk of cookie dough? No Tye, it wasn't always like this. We've been going there for literally 20+ yrs. It only stopped getting mixed after this new owner took over. Mr.Sheets just got lazy with the family recipe and is going to run this long standing business into the ground. What really prompted this review though is how Mr.Sheets responded to my original comment on their FB page. I simply mentioed the ice cream not being mixed with some pictures and got a very simple "it's always been that way."...and then blocked me from the page! Not that my comment was at All personal or negative but as a business owner you better get thicker skin than that, and you need to be open to constructive criticism. On that note Mr. SHEETS, if it's worked for 100 years, leave it alone!!! WALTZ CREAMERY in Salladasburg and MAIN ST. CREAMERY in Wellsboro have a much wider and unique variety of flavors...and the owners are always open to constructive criticism. They won't ignore you and then block you like this creamery owner. read more

Eder's Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montoursville, Pennsylvania

See all

Love the ice cream and affordable prices at Eder's, a community staple! I grew up going to Eder's for ice cream and always stop back when I'm in town. Portions are huge for the price. Service is good with limited seating inside and some outdoor benches. Jiffeo, a combination of cookies and cream and peanut butter ice cream, is my flavor or choice! Always recommend over any chain. read more

Eder's Ice Cream - Jiffeo ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montoursville, Pennsylvania

Delicious ice-cream, good service. We have to drive further but it's well worthwhile. Would recommend it to all who live within driving distance. read more

The coffee ice cream was top tier, serving size was over the top, and the service was pleasant. Definitely will be making an effort to stop by if I come through the area again read more

Eder's Ice Cream - a man holding a cone of ice cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montoursville, Pennsylvania

A Lycoming county must! Great ice cream at a great price. This is local food at its finest.

We stopped for a little after-dinner treat before heading back to the cabin for the night. It's the fall, not the summer, but Eder's ice cream was so delicious it's no wonder they're open year round. Their portions are enormous! I got a small but maybe should have opted for the "baby" size! Aside from eating too much, I highly recommend! Friendly young staff. Plus they had great flavor options, including a new one for me: teaberry! read more

Wonderful homemade ice cream, great service and a quite a value. This is a throwback to childhood days.

Good service and delicious, creamy ice cream. We ordered vanilla, butter almond, caramel, and Oreo flavors. All were great. Three happy campers here. read more

So many delicious flavors! :D! The portions are very generous, and the prices are extremely reasonable. :]! $2.50 for a "small" that's actually ginormous. You can get it in a cup or a cone. I had the peach and the cookie dough (weird combination, I know, but satisfied two cravings in one!), and my friend got the oreo. It was glorious! Definitely stop by here and give it a try if you get the chance! :] read more

Eder's Ice Cream - 2 ginormous scoops for $2.50! :] - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montoursville, Pennsylvania

See all

It's a gem with some amazing ice cream. Not that I can't eat a large there, but the baby size is the appropriate size that is basically equivalent to a medium most places. Knock yourself out. Also, cash only with no atm read more

It's our number one choice for ice cream! They're a one of a kind ice cream shop. Highly recommend Eder's!

This was just amazing. It's in the middle of nowhere but the ice-cream is to die for... the coconut was amazing had it in a milkshake and the fruity coconut (pineapple cherries and chunks of coconut) Made the trip all worth while read more

The ice cream is amazing the service is also amazing the people there are so nice to you and get your order right

Some of the best ice cream I've ever had. The chocolate peanutbutter is my favorite go-to. Due to COVID concerns, the paying at one window and picking your oder up at the other window on the other side of the building is a bit of a pain; hopefully that will end soon. But it's worth the effort to enjoy this delicious frozen dessert! read more

Excellent ice cream, and a small is enough for two! Homemade banana ice cream is a favorite in my family, and Eder's is the closest match we've found. Choose any flavor, honestly, you won't be disappointed. read more

The ice cream is so good! The inside of the creamery is rustic-charming, with antique tools and matchbooks lining the walls. Wooden floor and counter. Homemade ice cream in traditional and also special flavors. Prices are so reasonable even without the authentic experience. Don't miss this beloved snack spot on the Loyalsock Creek read more

This place is the best. Having grown up with it, there's a certain amount of nostalgia with this place, but I really do think their ice cream is the best in the area. Definitely nothing fancy about the location and the inside hasn't changed much in the years and years I've been going here, but who cares as long as the ice cream is as good as it is. They have tons of options as far as flavors and they are frequently trying out and adding new things. My favorites are the light chocolate and the Jiffe-O (peanut butter ice cream with Oreos). The prices are extremely low and the amount of ice cream you get is... a lot. I usually just get the "Baby" which is one (very large) scoop. Again, this place is the best. read more

Eder's Ice Cream - a variety of ice creams - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montoursville, Pennsylvania

Huge portions cheap cheap prices . I personally only like a few flavors at the place. It's also a very cool place regarding the fact that local high school kids get jobs in the facility. It teaches them work ethics and I've never had a problem with going here . However in the summer it gets extremely busy and there is a wait time for service. This is to be expected when it's August but I should mention it. Some people have no patience. read more

Amazing Ice cream, great prices, and large portions! My family lives roughly 4 hours from here and passes through about two times per year on our way to camp and its a tradition to stop every time! I always go for the cookie dough or the jiffy-o (peanut butter mixed into cookies and cream). You won't be disappointed by anything you get here. read more

Eder's Ice Cream - Jiffy-O - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montoursville, Pennsylvania

See all

Darn good ice cream and great service. Very nice staff considering we got there 10 minutes before close. Awesome selection. read more

One of the things I miss most about Williamsport is definitely Eder's ice cream! My favorite is the dark chocolate. This place is very simple. They sell their own homemade hard ice cream, milkshakes, and basic sundaes. You can get it in a cup or a cake cone, or in tubs to take home. There's a small selection of pretzels/chips, and that's it. No sprinkles, no soft serve, no dip top; they don't even have sodas, though they will give you a cup of tap water. The place is staffed by disinterested teens. That being said it's my favorite ice cream ever with a lovely location, so what else do you really need for that perfect summer ice cream experience? If you're in the area you must try it, even though it's a bit out of the way! read more

Only reason they don't get 5 stars is once in a while they miss flavor consistency. Other than that great ice cream & milk shakes. Great prices and massive portions. Unless you plan to have ice-cream for dinner get the baby size, the large is massive. We visit friends in the area every month and make it a point to stop in. If you're in the neighborhood are just feel like a drive it's worth it. read more

Great homemade ice cream for cheap yet they give you massive servings. I have been going there for 15 years and I have never seen anyone order a large because it is two meals worth of icecream in the baby size. read more

This place is a MUST visit for us every time we visit the area. Fresh and unique flavors coupled with huge portions makes an ice cream lover like me happy as can be. Get the kids size?! Heck no!! I love the quantity and quality that we get every time we go there. Today I was amazed by the dark chocolate and almond joy. Yum. Of course I will be back. Too bad I live so far away from this special place. read more

We love Eder's Ice Cream!! Best ice cream around and it is made on location. They are a little short on parking, but it is worth the trouble. Stop by and I promise the ice cream will not disappoint! read more

Eder's Ice Cream - Store front - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Montoursville, Pennsylvania

See all

Went there last night. Service: Since it was our first time there, the guy scooping our orders was very helpful at explaining what was in all of the Eder's-only flavors. He was very patient and helpful and we did not feel rushed despite the line behind us. He also let us choose what order the flavors were put onto the cone, which was nice (see note about the Dark Chocolate flavor) Flavors: GIven that they have two-dozen or so flavors on a given night, I was surprised to find out how many had peanut butter or peanuts in them. I'm not a huge peanuts/peanut butter in my ice cream fan, but I know some folks are ::wink:: nuts about that sort of thing. We each got 'smalls' (2 GIANT scoops for $2.50) and between us tried four flavors - Dark Chocolate - melted the quickest, but actually had flakes of real chocolate blended through it, this was our joint favorite flavor of the ones we ordered. Since it melts faster than most, put it on the top of your cone or bowl. Cinnamon Crunch - good, but more subtle and so got lost when paired with the chocolate. Still a nice flavor. Would get again. Mint Whoopie Pie - this was described to me as mint ice cream with peppermint patties in it. I've had whoopie pies before and so knew that a whoopie pie was more cake like. The mint base was good, but the whoopie pie pieces (which were cake-y, not peppermint patty) were dry and not too chocolate-y tasting. I'd try something else next time. Cherry garden - Marashino, pineapple, coconut. Tasty, but somehow not over the top amazing. I will keep trying other flavors (or just order the dark chocolate and call it good enough) Other comments: 1. Someone else said, get the 'Baby' size unless you want to have ice cream for dinner. This is pretty much true. When we come back next we'd consider just getting a pint or half gallon to go (so we can enjoy it in whatever serving size we'd like). 2. Since the ice cream can be so hard, the plastic spoons you get have a rough time sometimes getting into the ice cream. 3. Our neighbor told us about the place because he provides raspberries to Eder's when they make their red raspberry flavor. Points to Eder's for sourcing locally! read more

I have been going to Eder's for 10 years, and my Dad for over 20 years and we are both extremely satisfied everytime we go. The people are so friendly, nice, and helpful. The ice cream is to die for, with tons of amazing flavors. And it always has me coming back for more! read more

Although we are flatlanders, whenever we're in the area, we always stop into Eder's. The ice cream is delicious no matter what flavor you get, and the portion sizes are incredible for such a low price. The staff is friendly and helpful. It is such a pleasure to go to an ice cream parlor that's so unique and homey. Love you Eder's! read more

Great ice cream! Love it when they do specials. They're birthday cake ice cream I only saw them make once. Was the best!!

Cheap price, huge potion, some good test ice cream. Good stop for summer time especially at night.

I've been going here several times a summer for as long as I can remember every year with my grandparents. Nostalgia may be a driving factor in how I see it, but the service has always been phenomenal and the ice cream has always been fantastic. All of this for prices that beat any competitors by a mile. The atmosphere has a wonderful rustic charm with a genuine small town feel to it. I highly recommend Eders to anyone in the area who wants a fantastic desert experience!!! read more

Service is horrible! There are chunks of ice in the ice cream. I would never give this ice cream to my child who could choke on a piece of ice read more

A friend that lives in Williamsport took about 10 of us here when we were there for the Little League World Series. We all loved it! It's the best ice cream we've ever had! Not to mention the huge scoops for the cheap price. Plus customer service was great! read more