Stopped in while staying nearby. Not sure how former reviewers found it a great place to get…read moregroceries. I found it fine for a sandwich, chips and a few soda/energy drink choices. Maybe also some emergency medicine, souvenirs and a few pantry items. Truthfully felt a little uncomfortable bought a sandwich and left.

Used to be a great place to stop for subs, sandwiches, drinks, etc. on our way up to go hunting and…read morefushing. They recently raised prices that blew our minds. Nine dollars for half a sub. No more. The young lady who bought the store a year or so ago can cop a real attitude.

It's Average for an ice cream shop. If your around town then yes stop in and have some. But I…read morewouldn't drive out of my way.

I will start by saying MOST ice cream places my girlfriend and I go to are unable to keep up with…read moredecent cross contamination policies (specifically for peanuts and tree nut allergies). It makes us limited to vanilla or chocolate soft serve which I am not knocking but there is only so much you can do with that. It immediately drops their value down to me no matter how good the ice cream might be. That is NOT the case with Fritz. In fact, it is quite the opposite. They handled themselves very well and my girlfriend was able to have her favorite, Cookies and Creme hard scooped ice cream. It was very rich and tasty! My tea berry was great as it always is and my dad's peach yogurt was also worth the stop. The service was quick and their commitment to making sure everyone can safely eat at their establishment meant a lot to us! No dessert treat is worth dying over.

Homemade ice cream that was delicious...what else do you really need? My almost 5 year old ordered…read morethe cookie monster ice cream and they even added candy cookie monster eyes to it! The service was fine ... the girls working the counter were all friendly. The ambiance is your typical ice cream shop. If you're in the area and looking for ice cream, look no further!

What a terrific homemade ice cream shop! On a cold day of the Charles Dickens weekend in downtown…read moreWellsboro, my sister and I ate ice cream. Sister Goldilocks ate a single dip of banana chip ice cream in a bowl. Being an overachiever, I pigged out on a dip of banana chip and a dip of coconut chip in a waffle cone. We enjoyed the homey decor of this establishment and friendly employees. There is an ice cream flavor for anyone who enjoys the fresh frozen treat!

Okay, so it's a long story on how I found myself seeking out Pecora's Creamery, which is a tiny…read morestore at the end of Pecora Road across from the old dairy. Inside is clean and quaint, with tasty breads, meats and cheeses from local farms. And while those are darn good- let's talk about the ice cream. This is the creamiest, most flavorful ice cream I have ever had in my life. No like seriously. This ice cream is small batch and it's AMAZING. I had the chocolate peanut butter egg (their Easter flavor), my husband had coffee, and my son had chocolate. Each was phenomenal in its own way. I don't know when I will be back in this area of Pennsylvania but if I'm anywhere remotely near, I will drive out of my way to have some more. Seriously folks, this ice cream is special.

The smoothest ice cream in a bucolic setting. The staff is friendly and the refrigerator cases are…read morefilled with a variety of products

Friendly and fun. Great service and great selection. Local owner…read more There is a large parking spot and outside tables to sit and eat. People also gathered around some of the cars and on the sidewalk in front of the restaurant. Flavor choices was vast - maybe 50 - with other options like frozen yogurt and ices and Milkshakes. They also serve hot dogs. It's well lit and easy to get to from Waverly, sayre, or Athens.

I ordered a large and a medium and they both came out the same size.... Why pay $5.00 when you can…read morepay $4.50 for the same thing...

Tutrone's Ice Cream is a great place for your sweet tooth! Their homemade ice creams were smooth…read moreand creamy with a variety of unique flavors like Almond Joy and Boneyard Gravy (vanilla ice cream with fudge/peanut butter swirls with chocolate covered pretzels)! They are very generous with their scoops so that was a great surprise! Service was great and the place had a lot of seatings surrounding it. There's even a family friendly area where they had two life sized Connect 4 games for kids to play with. The area was kept clean and the vibe is very family friendly. Would definitely return here the next time we're in the Poconos!

Really good customer service by a group of young individuals working fairly hard to the many people…read morethat fled to the Poconos in the summer. They did have one or two sugar-free ice cream options. Many flavors of Italian ice. They do the hard chocolate exterior dipped cones. Two options for soft ice cream. You can get a sundae with a wide variety of toppings. I lost count after 25lol. Me and my family come to this place at least once or twice a summer and we are never disappointed. I do believe they are open seasonally. Outdoor fire pits for you to sit at while you eat your ice cream, so, even if it's a little cold or feeling like fall weather, you could be warm and eat cold ice cream at the same time and be completely happy. Highly recommend you stop here on your way home or on your way in!

Me and Wife stopped by on the way home…read more Were in the mood for ice cream. She had a soft serve Chocolate cone and me a Hershey's Cookies & Cream. The Ice Cream was delicious. Ice Cream is tricky, especially The Hershey's Cookies & Cream, since it has to be stored at the right temperature. If too cold ice crystals will develop and make it more icy rather than creamy. Too warm and well you know lol. The Cookies & Cream was Amazing quality :) Both hers and mine (3 scoops) was about 6-7 bucks. GREAT PRICE. Since in NYC something like that would cost 12-14 bucks. A definite must visit.

Stopped in on Saturday night of Memorial Day weekend while in town visiting my parents. We were…read moredriving by and the kids (teenagers) wanted ice cream. Sign said open, lights were on and other customers were in their cars. It was 6:50pm. Kids went up to order and the man and woman working seemed very annoyed to have customers. My daughter came back to the car and told me the man said the "F word" as he came in to help with the ice cream. My son came back to the car and reported the same thing. Watching from the car, the couple seemed to also be having words with each other. My 74 year old father came back to the car and also said they were rude and seemed as though they didn't want any business. They flicked off their lights as soon as we stepped away from the window despite another customer approaching. This was about 7:04pm. I'm not sure why they have chosen such a joyful business if they don't have any joy to spread. I'm not happy that we spent our money there.

Soft serve ice cream very friendly family owned business. Recommend the vanilla orange sherbet…read moreswirl!

Yelp wouldn't let me check in here since it was reported as closed. We were just there this weekend…read moreand I can assure you it is very much OPEN. The owner was there and told us he took over the business in January and that he is working on fixing things up. This was our first time here and it certainly won't be our last. The mini golf course is so much fun and it's cheap! As of June 2024 it's $6 a person and it's one of those older courses with something at every hole instead of just green. We went a Saturday morning it was threatening to rain so we had the whole place to ourselves. After golf we had to try the ice cream everyone has mentioned in their reviews. The cheesecake soft serve is probably the best I've had. Hubby got some donuts and said they were pretty good too. There is a shop too but it looks like they were selling down on stock to change how that's set up. Interested to see what they do with all the space.

Business sold. Was great in its day! The bakers were amazing and the ice cream was always a hit.read more