Absolutely scrumptious and HUGE cookies! Take their advice and warm... make sure you have vanilla in ce cream on hand! read more

Fat and Weird Cookie - Desserts Near Me - Panama City, Florida

Don't let the location deter you, these are extremely tasty cookies. The store front is located in the warehouse that I assume they package and maybe even make the cookies. These are fat and they're weird! A lot of them are stuffed and some are not. My favorite was a circus animal one that was stuffed with icing. YUM! I gave it 4 stars because I thought the prices were a bit much and the edible cookie dough wasn't good. Just not the same. read more

See all

When this company first launched, their cookies were absolutely incredible--hands down the BEST I'd ever tasted. I meant it when I said 10,000/10! Unfortunately, they're just not the same anymore. After a couple of years, we decided to order again, and the difference was heartbreaking--especially for the price ($80!). The cookies were smaller, had a grainy texture, and were overly sweet without any real depth of flavor. My husband and I were beyond disappointed. I wish I had checked recent Reddit reviews before ordering again--lesson learned. read more

Some of THE most amazing cookies I have ever had the pleasure of trying. Some were a little too sweet for my tastes. A friend of mine ordered a sampler box and I was beyond happy with it. My daughter and I shared each cookie because eating a whole one was too much, lol. read more

Just got mine shipped today all the way to San Diego can say these are the best cookies I ever had totally worth it if you never had em yet read more

Fat and Weird Cookie - Desserts Near Me - Panama City, Florida

This is our first trip to Fat & Weird, but it won't be our last. We selected all stuffed cookies (see pics for which ones). They also have flatties, edible cookie dough, and ice cream. You can also make your own cookie, and they'll bake it on the spot. Takes about 8 minutes. Fantastic service. June was very patient as she explained how everything worked as many new customers came in. Again, we will definitely be back! read more

See all

A few of the cookies that they make, I like a lot but only when I was able to pick them up from the store. They aren't as fresh when they're shipped. Big Sexy and Lettie Doughkee were my favorites The storefront is always emmaculate The staff is friendly but it always smells like gas in there. read more

We didn't have any issues finding the store, as previous reviews stated. The sign is very clear from the main road. Cookies were very fun, definitely a sweet treat, but hit the spot and excited to share with the family. The atmosphere in the store could use a bit of work, perhaps some soft music playing in the background? The employee that helped us was sweet but very shy and there was a lot of silence that took away from the whole experience. read more

Fat and Weird Cookie - Desserts Near Me - Panama City, Florida

See all

We already knew the cookies were phenomenal, so choosing them as our wedding dessert was a no-brainer. Not only did we have the best dessert at our wedding, but the customer service was exceptional. Christian Parks assisted us throughout the entire process, from our initial inquiry to our order, and even helped us make a quick pivot when we encountered a small snag. We truly appreciate the quality, ease, and immense care taken with our order for our special day. Thank you! 10/10 will be ordering many more times in the future. I cannot stress this enough: these cookies are AMAZING. They were the star of the show, and we are still hearing about how much our guests enjoyed them. read more

Fat and Weird Cookie - Photo by Sweet Marie Photography - Desserts Near Me - Panama City, Florida

See all

My son has not yet recieved the cookies I ordered, but I just couldn't wait to review. The service I recieved prior to my order and then after my order was exceptional! I had a few questions about delievery times due to my sons schedule, which were answered promptly. Then, I erroneously omitted my sons apartment number from the order. I was panicked. Within a short time frame, my frantic email was answered. The problem was resolved quickly and efficiently. Highly recommend and I am certain the cookies will be as equally fabulous!!!! - read more

These cookies are so good. Got them for my birthday and ate all of these shown in one weekend. Great for gift giving. read more

Fat and Weird Cookie - a dog sniffing a box of treats - Desserts Near Me - Panama City, Florida

I had high hopes for these cookies and they are fine. I found the stuffed ones to have very little filling in the cookie. They do taste good but they don't look like the pictures I've seen at all. read more

Fat and Weird Cookie - Just to show that the filling isn't much! - Desserts Near Me - Panama City, Florida

Underwhelming gross, highly processed cookies. Just look at all the garbage ingredients. I'd eat PDX cookies over this garbage any day.

Must Visit while in Panama City! They have lots of flavors with some changing every week. You can get filled ones called fatties or just regular - flatties. Delicious!! read more

See all

The storefront is very hidden. There's no sign but it's in a big white building. They have a variety of cookies available to buy in store- they are made fresh and you can ask them to warm it up. We got the party animal- which was an almond sugar cookie with vanilla frosting and animal cracker on top. We also got the imposter- which was chocolate chip with coconut. The cookies were really good! Super thick cookie. It has the consistency similar to cookie dough. Very moist inside. The imposter has a lot of chocolate chips in it which makes it super gooey especially when warmed up. You can also order these cookies online. The only complaint I have is that it's a small cookie for the price - $5 per cookie is a bit steep read more

See all

Amazingly delicious cookies! The fix reminds me of mom's carmel bars back in Minnesota. read more

Fat and Weird Cookie - Desserts Near Me - Panama City, Florida

Stopped into store front to try the desserts. We got a mix of flat cookies and the larger ones. They were all good. A little pricey for cookies. I have had better cookies but overall these were ok. read more

Fat and Weird Cookie - Cookies - Desserts Near Me - Panama City, Florida

Definitely build your own cooked cookie. It's like a warm stuffed cookie right out of the oven. And if you're not local, take some megas home for later. They are so large and delicious, I got them home, cut them in 1/4 and frozen them so I can have some portion control with eating them! Lol read more

See all

Amazing cookies! Went twice on our vacation to PCB!!! Next level good!! Will be ordering online when we get back home. read more

Fat and Weird Cookie - Desserts Near Me - Panama City, Florida

I ordered these cookies 3 times. And I have to say I'm never ordering again. They put WEIRD in the name probably because of the ingredients. These taste like they're full of chemicals. And they are. They use soooooo much food coloring it's almost all you taste. I don't bite into these and taste butter and sugar and flour. I taste chemicals. Aftertaste is horrible. I have 3 more sitting in my fridge ( at $6 + dollars a cookie plus shipping) and I can't even bring myself to eating the rest. Just horrible. So very disappointed. And Yelp seems like the only place you can leave a review on. Thanks guys. I'm done with this place. Not even gonna follow them anymore. read more

The cookies are amazing!! We will definitely be back to eat some more of the stuffed cookies!! read more

Fat and Weird Cookie - This was a great place!! We will definitely be back. The stuffed cookies were amazing!!! - Desserts Near Me - Panama City, Florida

Would leave 0 stars if I could! Customer service is Terrible! Communication is non existent with this company don't waste your time! The "cookies" taste of nothing but dyes and chemicals not what a cookie should taste like! read more

It's all in the name, these cookies are seriously fat and theyre stuffed with some weird combinations, but they're absolutely delicious. Massive cookies that keep a perfect soft and chewy texture with anything flavor you can think of. My absolute favorite was certainly weird, the margarita cookie, which I thought was a risky flavor but they definitely nailed it. All of their flavors were delicious and worth a try read more

See all

The s'mores cookie is amazing ! cute inside and very clean. I will come again when I'm in town !

This place is awesome. Delicious and even gives a free cookie for this review, so you know it's gotta be good...

Ridiculously tasty & the staff was super nice as well. We were road tripping and drove out of our way to try Fat & Weird Cookie in person. So glad we did. Pitchin Tents was read more

Fat and Weird Cookie - Desserts Near Me - Panama City, Florida

I actually spit out my bite it was so bad. I ordered three different cookies and none were actually good. I don't understand how this is a business. read more

Super yummy cookie combinations... order a premade combo or build it yourself...Then being offered to warm and add ice cream? YES, PLEASE!! This is a MIST stop for those with a sweet tooth! Service is always on point and friendly! read more

The best cookies in Bay County! The staff is friendly and courteous. It is an adventure for kids to be able to create their own cookies and watch them being made. read more

I have ordered online and now visited the shop in person! Cookies taste just as amazing online as they do in person! If you cut it open and don't eat the whole thing it doesn't dry out. You can eat on them for a few days. It is a little confusing when you pull in the parking lot trying to figure out where to enter. It's the far end of the building. Everyone was very friendly and helpful! I will continue to support this business. I haven't had a flavor I didn't like yet! read more

Fat and Weird Cookie - The pudge - Desserts Near Me - Panama City, Florida

Let me start by saying I loved these cookies but haven't ordered in a while. I did a HUGE order for me and my daughter and was sorely disappointed. 1 they were completely melted. I live in Texas and it's HOT, however Fat an weird being based in Florida you'd think they'd have a better system during summer for shipping, especially knowing it takes days to get to people and not everyone is home 24/7. 2. We ate one that was still somewhat whole ( not mush) and it was absolutely disgusting. I don't know what they've done but the cookies are awful now. Unfortunately we won't be indulging in these again. P.S. if you look for a way to contact them, there isn't one. That's not good business. read more

Great cookies! Good service! I loved the create your own cookie, I love all the varieties of things to choose from!

Cookies are absolutely epic but their customer service is lacking. They do not respond to emails and there is no way to get in touch with someone over the phone. I placed my second cookie order with them Sunday night. It says it take 2 business days. It is now Thursday and I haven't heard anything and I cannot get a hold of anyone. read more

Y'all need better workers. I had never been here before but I saw it on TikTok and on social media so when we took a beach vacay to PCB I had to stop by. Place was empty. Not inviting at all. Clearly I didn't know what to order or what was the best but the lady just stared at me not saying anything. Didn't greet us or anything. Didn't ask what we wanted. I had to force her to talk to me. This place was so hyped up and so disappointing. read more

If you want to pay for overpriced cookies that have no flavor, look no further. These cookies were very dry and unfortunately not tasty. Store was also very had to find. read more

Such an awesome place! The cookies are legit and the service is absolutely awesome. You can order and pick up from the bakery or have the cookies shipped. They have a lot of options. Highly recommend. read more

Fat and Weird Cookie - 5 cookies - made to order Spatula Koozie - Desserts Near Me - Panama City, Florida

See all

The best cookie I have ever had ! Great service, friendly counter staff. Will definitely be back.

The Yabba Cereal Cookie I had was nasty. It had chewy bits in it, like dry oats or something. I e-mailed customer service and they couldn't care to respond. read more

Cookie were incredible! Love the idea of the store front! The Service was top notch and everyone was so nice and helpful! I will be coming back! read more

Cool idea. Can get stuffed or flat cookies, also can make your own. Raw or baked. Only downside was few batter options were gone and some toppings not available. Otherwise it'd be a 5 star. read more

Fat and Weird Cookie - Cookies, cookie cakes, stuffed cookies, flat cookies, make your own - Desserts Near Me - Panama City, Florida

See all