Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Frosted Mermaid

    5.0 (18 reviews)
    Closed 9:00 am - 5:00 pm

    Frosted Mermaid Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Frosted Mermaid

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Lilikoi and buttercream cupcakes.
    Debbie B.

    If you want the most delicious tasting & decadent dessert, I highly suggest you contact the frosted mermaid. On my trip to Maui, I was attending a dinner party with friends and decided cupcakes would be the best option. Out of several bakeries that I contacted, The Frosted Mermaid and Melissa was the only one that went out of her way to make a dozen cupcakes within the same week of my event. So it was a last-minute call, but she still fit me into her schedule. She made her signature Lilikoi and buttercream cupcakes, which were a party hit. All of our local friends were asking where I had gotten the cupcakes because they were so moist & delicious. Melissa contacted me several times to go over the details and even personally met us on the day of her child's birthday to make sure we had our cupcakes in time for our dinner party. If I could give higher than Five-stars I would.

    Cupcakes
    Kevin H.

    Wow! Huge thanks to Melissa for giving us everything we wanted and MORE. The cake was one of the best I've ever had - bottom layer champagne and top lager chocolate chip. Design is exactly what we asked for!!! And all of the extras were delightful. There were mini goat cheese cheesecakes, cupcakes and so much more. If you want exactly what you ask for........and then some, Melissa is your baker!!! (And stayed in budget)

    Jackie N.

    Melissa made our wedding cake last month and it came out so perfect!! We asked for a colorful cake in the shape of a heart and it was so delicious. We also go a variety of cookies and they were a crowd favorite!! Would highly recommend Frosted Mermaid for your special occasion.

    Rebecca M.

    I feel SO grateful to find Frosted Mermaid! We had a destination wedding so trying to find the best flavor combo was hard but with Melissa's help it was SO EASY. She delivered our cake and when we saw it we fell in love. (Then we ate it...) and everything tasted amazing our family was so happy. Even the catering company raved of how beautiful her work was. Want to come back to Maui already to get more Frosted Mermaid cake!

    POG (Passion Orange Guava) cake by Melissa, Frosted Mermaid, Maui

    Melissa's Frosted Mermaid cakes are not only out of this world beautiful, they are as delicious as they look! More creative and much, much more reasonable than others in this artistic custom cake category which I had researched online when we and the family decided we would celebrate my husband's birthday on Maui this past August. I was particular about getting him his favorite rich chocolate cake, and I absolutely did not want tasteless frosting of which many of the beautiful custom cakes we have had at other events are made. Her ingredients were just what I knew I wanted, different than the other custom companies' with whom I spoke about their cake and frosting ingredients. Luckily, I chose the right one, Frosted Mermaid, Melissa's, are far superior in taste than the custom design cakes we have had in the past. I explained to her my husband's life-long love of the ocean involving years of scuba diving, and spear fishing, in Hawaii, and around the world. After seeing her cakes on Frosted Mermaid website, and talking with her by phone, I ended up asking her to use her artistic vision to create a deep sea diver design for his special surprise birthday cake. And, what a hit it was, not only with the family, but all those around us at the restaurant. Love the way she blended the colors to represent a diver's view immersed in his deep ocean wonderland. Melissa aced it! She even added fish, sharks, corals, what appeared to be underwater diver's bubbles rising to the surface, and many more clever sea creatures and plants all around the outside of this beautiful tall cake. Cresting the top of the cake was an edible frothy looking stiff tall ocean wave she made...A TRUE DELICIOUS WORK OF ART. The second cake was a POG cake, a total surprise for us from her for our anniversary. Beautifully elegant, she says it's one of her most popular cakes, and we could certainly see and taste why that is. Both the cake and frosting were bursting with delicious POG flavor (passion orange guava for those of you who haven't grown up in, or raised kids in Hawaii). We've had other fruit juice or fruit puree cakes that can't come close to her magical tropical flavor blend. We all kept coming back for more, it was just as good at breakfast as it was for dessert. What a delightful experience it was working with and meeting this talented lovely young woman. Our whole family enjoyed meeting Melissa and her husband, her delivery helper. Aloha and Mahalo to Melissa for making our birthday/anniversary weekend in Maui much more beautiful and delicious.

    JoAnne E.

    The Frosted Mermaid has done cake and desserts for us this year, first for my daughter's baby shower and then for my wedding. Exquisite to look at. Even more exquisite to eat! The flavors are just so good! Lilikoi & POG blew our minds. Affordable, and totally dependable!

    Elizabeth P.

    Absolutely beautiful birthday cake and also incredibly delicious. The delivery to our condo rental was above and beyond. Would definitely recommend and order again.

    Bao Bun Dim Sum Cake 5" and 7" two tier cake with Strawberry cake and cream cheese frosting, Hawaiian Mermaid, and Pog mini cupcakes
    Kourtney I.

    Melissa is the most professional, talented baker! She was such a delight to work with. She provided her expertise when needed to make sure our special cake came out just as we dreamed. It was a master piece and tasted delicious!

    I totally recommended the Frosted Mermaid for all the amazing flavor combinations and the cupcake presentation was beautiful !!!. I ordered the Coconut Milk Cake with Lillikoi Frosting, the Guava Cake with POG Frosting, the Ube Cake with Cream Cheese Frosting and Fruit tarts for a baby shower and talk about flavor explosion!!! The cupcakes lasted on the table for maybe two minutes before they were all gone .. The prices are reasonable and Melissa was so easy and friendly to work with .. She made everything perfect!! She was even willing to delivery them!! I will definitely be ordering from the Frosted Mermaid again for my next party...

    Amazing brownies

    See all

    2 years ago

    Business owner information

    Photo of Melissa H.

    Melissa H.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 1
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Sue S.
    1
    103
    109

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    1 year ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 months ago

    The cookies were absolutely incredible! Absolutely balanced and so yummy with the flaky sea salt on top. Definitely a gem of a bakery!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of JoAnne E.
    390
    29
    73

    5 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    2 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    5 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Frosted Mermaid

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Desserts 3,896 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Leoda's Kitchen and Pie Shop

    Leoda's Kitchen and Pie Shop

    4.5
    (4.3k reviews)
    13.0 km
    $$

    chocolate haupia pie ($11) - i dont usually like chocolate…read moreflavored dessert but i have to say this one changed my mind - it is one of my favorite dessert on this island AND i loved it so much this deserves a five star woooo - i really went in not expecting much from it but every bite was delectable from the cream on top to the chocolate and coconut layers - first, as a cream hater who usually scrapes off the cream, i actually ate and enjoyed it; it was light and fluffy not heavy at all - second, the chocolate layer wasnt too sweet and was super velvety smooth; it got enough chocolate content but not too much that it'd be too rich and dense - third, the coconut layer wasn't offensively strong but it actually balanced out the sweetness from the cream and chocolate; it was also a bit gelatinous which enhanced the texture of this dessert - lastly, the tart was crispy and crunchy; not too thick and it also added another layer to the texture, completing the whole dish rating: 5/5 - quick service and half self service; nothing much to note; the pies were already pre made so the server just gave it to us immediately - very casual dining spot; family friendly; ambiance is giving little cabin type restaurants you would find when you're on a road trip IG: @nom.noms.only

    Tried Yelpers suggestion and purchased Chocolate Mac Nut Pie and Apple Pie on the way to condo. If…read moreyou enjoy pudding consistency and thick whipped cream you may favor it. Expected more of a French silk chocolate. It was ok but I'd choose the not to be missed shaved ice down the road. We did enjoy however the two pot pies! Easy to reheat and a reasonable dinner at home meal. Beef pie is meaty and chicken had a good amount of vegetables and kale in it. Service at Leodas is good and friendly.

    Photos
    So cozy.
    So cozy.
    Apple Crumb Pie...smackin!
    Apple Crumb Pie...smackin!
    Just one of the many delicious pies.

    See all

    Just one of the many delicious pies.
    Island Cream Co

    Island Cream Co

    4.8
    (2k reviews)
    15.0 km
    $$
    Family-owned & operated
    Established in 2014

    The long line at Island Cream Co. tells you everything you need to know--it's absolutely worth the…read morewait! Once you get to the counter, you'll find an incredible selection of shaved ice and homemade ice cream, with endless combinations of flavors and toppings to create your perfect treat. Mixing your own flavors is half the fun, and everything we tried was fresh, delicious, and exactly what you want on a warm Maui afternoon. Beyond the amazing shaved ice and ice cream, what made this visit even more meaningful was seeing the energy returning to Lahaina. Every local business that's open represents another step in the community's recovery, and it's inspiring to see visitors and residents coming together to support them. If you're visiting Maui, make a point to stop by Island Cream Co.--you'll enjoy an incredible treat while also supporting the continued revitalization of one of Hawaii's most beloved towns. We'll definitely be back!

    I wish I had found this spot sooner! We passed by it several times during our trip and had no idea…read morewhat we were missing. I love Dole Whip, but this place serves their own version called Pineapple Cream, and in my opinion, it's a million times better. They even have a poster in the shop comparing the ingredients, and let's just say they're not shy about pointing out what's in Dole Whip versus their own product. Their Pineapple Cream is made with simple ingredients, and you can absolutely taste the difference. They offer a variety of island inspired flavors, which made it tough to choose because everything sounded delicious. Unfortunately, we didn't discover this place until our last night in Maui. Otherwise, I have no doubt we would have come back multiple times during our trip. If you're a fan of pineapple ice cream, this is a must-visit. Seating was limited outdoors and inside was full. Wish they'd have more outdoor seating.

    Photos
    Strawberry Shortcake in a handmade Chocolate Cone!
    Strawberry Shortcake in a handmade Chocolate Cone!
    Hand-Made Cream Sandwiches!
    Hand-Made Cream Sandwiches!
    Glacier Ice---The Ultimate Shave Ice Experience!

    See all

    Glacier Ice---The Ultimate Shave Ice Experience!
    Maui Pie

    Maui Pie

    4.5
    (802 reviews)
    18.5 km
    $$

    There are not many places to get a good slice of pie on Maui, but Maui Pie in Kihei is the real…read moredeal. I will drive from Wailuku to Kihei every time just for their peach cobbler. I had the peach cobbler warmed up and a la mode, and it was delicious. Crumble toppings on pie are my absolute favorite, that buttery, crumbly goodness you wish would never end. Hubby had the key lime pie a la mode, and it was the perfect balance of creamy sweetness and tart, but not too tart. Both slices came with a generous scoop of vanilla ice cream, which is the only way to do it. The service was friendly, too. The indoor seating was full, so we sat outside, which turned out to be lovely for people watching and enjoying the fresh air. If you have a sweet tooth and appreciate a proper slice of pie, Maui Pie is worth the trip. Highly recommend, and I'll see you there for more peach cobbler!

    ONE OF THE BEST PIES I'VE EVER HAD…read more ** But terrible customer service ** This place would easily be a 5 star if they had more polite people working there. My mom politely asked if they had any sugar-free pies available. The girl at the register stated " you need to ask for those a day in advance". So my mom asked if she could place an order now to pick up one tomorrow. The girl then looked up from the register with an annoyed look on her face and said, verbatim, " does it look like I'm the head baker? I only work the register. You need to leave the store and call us to order". We all looked at each other shocked. That was the most rude response I've heard in a while... like we are supposed to know who specifically ask to order a sugar free pie ... ... just a wild situation for such a fun place with great tasting pies. The good: - blackberry mango was probably my favorite pie - peach cobbler a close second place - loved the mountain berry as well The bad: - the girl working the register - you want a sugar free pie? Make sure to NEVER ask in person. You have to call in. - And they only offer whole pies and not slices for sugar free pies The verdict: - minus 2 stars for the rude girl who yelled at my mom - minus 1 star for only having whole pies and not slices for sugar free pies, even though they only have 3 flavors to choose from... Such a shame to have people like that working at a place that serves such a good product.

    Photos
    Seating area
    Seating area
    Banana cream
    Banana cream
    Lilikoi pie

    See all

    Lilikoi pie
    Sugar Beach Bake Shop

    Sugar Beach Bake Shop

    4.5
    (1k reviews)
    15.1 km
    $$

    Great malasadas. We preferred the ones made to order (we had ours rolled in li hing mui powder…read morewhich was so yummy) a little more than the pre-made filled ones (we tried lillikoi, ube and mango) but all were good and affordable. We also tried a keylime lilikoi pie and it was wonderful. Always a line, with great and friendly customer service. Right next to the Ulani shaved ice so you'll probably visit the location more than once a day!

    The Legendary Malasadas A true Portuguese-Hawaiian style…read moremalasada is a work of art, and Sugar Beach nails it. Unlike standard donuts, theirs are fried to a perfect golden crisp on the outside while staying unbelievably fluffy, light, and pillowy on the inside. The Passion Fruit (Lilikoi) Magic: Tasting that tart, bright, tropical lilikoi burst against the sugary, warm dough is unforgettable. It cuts right through the richness of the pastry perfectly. Freshness First: Because they open bright and early at 6:00 AM, getting them warm means you are catching them at peak texture--crisp, airy, and meltingly soft. Mouth-Watering Savories & Pies It's rare for a bakery to completely master both ends of the spectrum, but they strike an incredible balance between decadent sweetness and rich, savory comfort: The Quiche: Getting a morning slice with a perfectly flaky, buttery crust and a rich, velvety egg custard is the ultimate savory breakfast comfort. The Key Lime Pie: A masterclass in balance. The sharp, refreshing pucker of the lime curd pairs flawlessly with a thick, buttery graham cracker crust, making it the ultimate mid-day or post-beach treat. The Croissants: True to artisan form--shattered layers on the outside, a rich, tender, airy web of butter on the inside. The Ultimate Beachside Vibe What truly seals the memory is the pure sense of place. It's a quintessential "cute little bakery"--unassuming, warm, and hyper-focused on quality. Being located right across from the beach means your morning walk isn't just an errand; it's an experience. Holding a warm box of malasadas and a fresh coffee while looking out at the ocean is pretty much peak relaxation. Just remember the golden rule of the neighborhood to avoid heartbreak: they take Sundays off, making Monday mornings all the sweeter when those doors swing open at 6:00 AM again! Service was awesome . Staff was very attentive

    Photos
    Malasadas and the bake shop logo
    Malasadas and the bake shop logo
    Yummy malasadas
    Yummy malasadas
    Ube Stuffed Malasadas

    See all

    Ube Stuffed Malasadas
    Cinnamon Roll Place

    Cinnamon Roll Place

    4.4
    (1.1k reviews)
    22.1 km
    $$

    Highly recommend this place! The staff were incredibly friendly and efficient. The cinnamon rolls…read moreare fresh and hot. They make them fresh all day it looks like. There is going to be a line almost always because the shop is small. Icing is not included but it's only .85¢ to add and if you get 5 rolls the 6th is free. Drinks are good, but definitely not the star of the show. We will definitely go back! Update: we went back again on our vacay and tried the Hawaiian Head Sandwich. We got one on a bagel and one on a croissant, they were phenomenal!

    cinnamon roll - instantly felt sorrowful the moment my…read morefriend gnawed through the dry stale wheat; i could feel the texture just by seeing it with my own eyes - it was far from soft and pillowy but tasted as if it was left out for hours... perhaps that's why there was no line nor customers here - the glaze was crazily and unnecessarily sticky and sweet; i rather have a liquidy cream cheese glaze than a sticky almost hardened one - the exterior was a bit crunchy in an erroneous manner simply because it was over baked or something - this was everything gone wrong in a bun - i also didn't taste much cinnamon banana bread - loved this though! I got the bread with macadamia nuts because i love nuts and they drive me nuts - nuts were fresh enough, which added the crunchy texture to my soft moist bread - could be more moist but it was already satisfactory - i like how they sell smaller pieces rather than a whole loaf but also it was more pricey - not as fresh and as good as aunty sandy's but decent! rating: 3/5 - since this place focuses on cinnamon roll, the rating is heavily weighted towards the cinnamon, which did not meet the minimum expectations of what a basic cinnamon roll should be - if this place was called the banana bread place, id give it a 4/5 - quick service nothing much to note - very small store; grab and go vibes with some seats outside IG: @nom.noms.only

    Photos
    Store front
    Store front
    Breakfast Kalua wrap. Needs more meat.
    Breakfast Kalua wrap. Needs more meat.
    Classic Cinnamon Roll

    See all

    Classic Cinnamon Roll

    Frosted Mermaid - desserts - Updated July 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...