The food brings me "home" to south jersey. Hoagies and cheesesteaks are the best. The only thing bad is the parking lot and access from the street. read more

One of the best Philly Cheesesteaks I've had outside of Philly! I've never had a bad meal, sandwich, soup, salad, or CHEESECAKE!!! I try to eat there once a week at least. read more

Stopped by Gaetano's Subs, and unfortunately, we won't be coming back. The young woman working the counter (maybe 16-18 years old) was incredibly rude and seemed annoyed that a customer even came in. She barely communicated, didn't listen when we ordered, and looked like she'd rather be sitting in the front booth doing nothing than helping customers. She constantly rolled her eyes like having a paying customer was a huge inconvenience. Because she doesn't listen well, one of the subs was made wrong. Between the attitude, lack of effort, and sloppy order, it's pretty clear she doesn't want to be there -- and it shows. Definitely not the kind of service you expect when you're paying for lunch. read more

An amazing sub and sandwich restaurant, locally owned and operated! Quality food with excellent prices! Support a local business!!!!

All the food is made fresh and is delicious. There are numerous choices and food is ready quickly. The staff are friendly and make the food specific to your order. I wish i would have know about this great food sooner. The atmosphere is nice and you see alot of people you know and meet new ones. read more

Just looking for a good sandwich and this one had good reviews. The ladies are so friendly and helpful. I got a turkey and cheese that was pretty good. Bread was nice. Everything was fresh. Honestly I wish I would gotten The Godfather with all the good Italian meats. Next time! read more

Gaetano's Subs - Menu - Italian Near Me - Dunnellon, Florida

See all

What A Awesome Place This Is For The BEST Authentic Italian Subs! I've tried the cheese steaks too and they've pretty amazing too! My husband Paul goes for the pick up and said they are the nicest people in there too! It's A Great Place! read more

Best subs around! With friendly welcoming service. The cheese steak sub never disappoints!! And the cheesecake... yum read more

Usally love this place, tonight, no so much! Foot long steak and cheese and baked ziti was my order. No cheese on sub and barelt any sauce on ziti. New employee today so understood order wasnt right when I got there so waited for correction, but wasnt worth the wait! Fed to ziti to the dog! read more

Love this store. Hoagies are delicious. Well worth the price. Hours are not convenient for dinner.

Amazing food, love the variety of subs and always enjoy the soup of the day. Best soup they have hands down has to be the wedding soup.

The best sub job by in Dunnellon, old standbys and new items. Tough to get in and out, but worth the effort

The challenge of getting in the parking lot is worth it. We stop here regularly. The sandwiches are always great and I look forward to trying other items. We usually order during the busiest time of their day but they always have it ready when we arrive. Great service. Try their homemade cheesecake- you won't be disappointed. read more

BROUGHT A BAG OF CHIPS IN THAT THE BABY HAD HES TWO ! Bought 3 subs drink, said sorry no outside food had to throw my kids chips away !! buy a bag I understand an adult or a bag of food from another establishment but if it were baby puffs can my 2 year old not have his food ??! Athen dont know if its normal the food was worst than dog food :( maybe she was being rude tasted OLD AND DEFINITELY ROTTEN . THERE WAS NOT EVEN ALOT OF MEAT MY SON ATE HIS SAUD HE WAS NOT FEELING WELL:(!! would not recommend read more

Sandwiches were good and the customer service was great! I highly recommend trying this establishment out.

Great subs. Could have a little better control over the rolls getting hard. But usually good. The meat and veggies is always fresh. Yum

If you're in need of a quick bite, this is the place. Hole in the wall with BOMB Cuban and Philly cheesesteak. Service is always quick and friendly. Great prices too. read more

Thank You to Gaetano's for always providing top notch food to us for our events! Your subs are Awesome, but the whole lunch I kept hearing one compliment after another about your pasta salad and your potato salad! They are both so Amazing! Thanks for doing what you do so well!! read more

Brought my girls out for lunch here today, my youngest has really wanted a sub! The prices were high (around $9.00 for a sub with no extras) but I remember the subs being excellent years ago. I went to order ice waters and was told we had to purchase drinks. A bottle of water was almost $3.00! I asked if we could get our ice waters from the car and was told absolutely not by the rude front desk lady. My youngest got her kids meal which we thought would be a sub, but it was just a sandwich that we could have easily made at home. My sub had one tiny slice of pickle on it, so I asked for more and was told I would have to be charged! That was the final straw for me. The manager came out and was equally rude, telling me "the pickles come in slices". Sure they do, so place a few on a large sub please! Small business owners better wake up! This is why they are going out of business, and I assume it's only a matter of time for this place. GOOD customer service disappeared with COVID I guess. Next time, I'll go to an actual restaurant and get full meals for the same price. read more

Baked Ziti dinner: great blend of seasoning, large amount! Sweetest side salad ever. Lovely bit of bread on side, enough for 2-3. We loved every bite. read more

Oh My Goodness this Place..SO DELICIOUS!!! Fresh Fresh food, Delicious subs, Incredible cheesecakes, Fantastic staff!!!! This place is Definitely worth visiting...weekly!! read more

Fabulous subs!!, great prices!!, great people!!. I haven't had a sub this good in a very long time they blow subway out of the water. Everything is Homemade!!!!!. We eat there once a week if not more. The only negative thing is the entry to the parking lot. But well worth the hassle. read more

The phillys here are excellent! The service is excellent and omg the desert. On any given day there are a TON of super yummy cheesecakes in different and unique flavors. Honestly they have a big menu with a ton of different sandwiches but the philly is so good that I can't even branch out to try them. The next time I decide to try something new it will be a Cuban! Awesome little small town sandwich shop. You will not be disappointed! read more

Best Subs and Cheesecake in N. Florida . The Cuban is best I've ever had in Florida. (FYI I'm from the Miami area) Staff is super friendly and restaurant and bathroom is super clean. read more

Awesome subs and lovely ladies who work there. This is what a NY deli style sub is supposed to be! So good. Bread is warm and flaky. Loved it. Will come back to try more things! read more

Best submarine sandwich's in town. My favorite is the Italian. Very reasonable priced and they use Boars Head meat on some of there sandwiches. read more

This sub shop is horrible. The customer service is terrible and the food is nasty. I ordered a Cuban sandwich and it tasted like all kinds of food just not a Cuban sandwich. It seems that they have to clean their presser. The place is dirty and smelly and the lady behind the counter has dirty clothes on and is rude. The old lady that makes the sandwiches can hardly walk and is wiping her forehead with her arms. Just a nasty gross place to eat!!! I would never go back!!! Beware of this sub shop!!! read more

great sub shop perfect in every way . love this place for a little place it has awesome food

Hi I stopped by yesterday to buy a sub .a lot of people have been saying how super your subs are I am a cook and I know a lot of cooks in town and when we can find a good sub and love it I would love to tell you GOOD JOB. When someone does something good tell them .have a wonderful super day you made mine read more

Very unsophisticated, actually rude, ehhhh maybe food half decent, nothing better than Subway. At least Subway smile, these ladies are harsh and unpleasant and charge way more. Ive tried it 3 times, its not a one off opinion, they think because they are the only sub place in the small town people will put up with there lack of decency that they can get away with bs. Ive decided I can do much better read more

Absolutely fabulous. We ordered the cheese steak subs and they were some of the best we have had. This is our new go to place for subs. The parking lot is a little hard to get to but the food is worth the effort. read more

I work across Highway 41 from this place, and I stop in to grab a sub once or twice a week, easy. This place is always fantastic. Service is prompt (I've never had to wait more than ten minutes from order to my sub in my hand), the food is delicious - and in the hundred odd times I've ordered food from here, they've never once messed up my order. Cannot reccomend this little Italian eatery enough. read more

Tasty sandwiches and reasonably priced. I went here while visiting Dunnelion and next time I am in town I would go back.

Overpriced for what your getting. Sub shops all around but that's just too much money for a sandwhich. The staff is unpleasant also. Would say even downright rude. read more

Love this little place. We eat there at least once a week..Homemade food NOT prepackaged stuff from Cisco foods.

I recommend "The Godfather" sub. It's enough for a couple to share and only about 9 bucks tax and all. I don't know if the bread is home made or not and could care less. I don't make my own bread when I'm making a sandwich at home. Just sayin... Still the best sub around these parts that's for cotton pickin sure. We eat here at least every other week. Staff is real friendly and they make great cheesecakes and Canoli. Oh yeah, tiramisu good too. read more

Awesome food !! Great service !!! Did I mention absolutely amazing food ?!?! A++ We had the Cuban and the French dip ....both did not disappoint ! read more

Best cheese steaks good amount of meat never got one I didn't like.So what the parking is a little hard to get in ,its worth it.Everybody there has always been real nice no matter how busy. Cookies are good too!! read more

Unfriendly and chicken on sub was ice cold. Left most of the ingredients off sandwich!

They give you a lot of meat on thier sandwich. Unfortunately the bread appears to be from Sysco or someone. Not fresh baked for sure. The young girl that works the front is very nice. Beware the owner, she doesn't want to hear anything but good things. I once mention how hard it is to get in the parking lot and got a ear full. We go about once every six months or so after that. read more