Nine of us went here for an 8:30 dinner reservation on a Saturday in July. After a great experience at Gezellig's sister restaurant, Play, and after hearing all the hype about the other sister restaurant, Beckta, I was surprised this place wasn't busier.
Me and two guys at my end of the table made the obvious choice to split three appetizers and three main courses. We started with a delicious Pimm's mojito before leaning toward a bottle of white with dinner. Our server proactively offered us a few tastings before we settled on something completely different and slightly more local, a 2010 Tollgate Fumé blanc (Niagra), which made all of us happy.
For apps, we went with:
- Beef tartare with seven spice, fennel salad, finger chili, herbed aioli, crostini ($14)
- Grilled quail with merguez sausage & chickpea salad, almonds, pomegranate, baba ghanoush ($17)
- Seared scallops with pork belly, grilled romaine, spicy cashews, charred tomatoes, balsamic, parmesan polenta ($17)
The tartare lived up to its reputation; the crunch on the toasted baguette paired well with the texture of the tartare, but the quail was perhaps my favorite. The cook on the quail was perfect and the combination of the chickpea salad and the pomegranate made for a perfect marriage. As for the seared scallops, our server specifically told us that each order came with three scallops, which is why three of us decided to split one order. When the scallops only came out with two on each plate, our server overheard us complain. She informed us the chef decided to only give two since these scallops were bigger than normal. (Unless they usually serve those sad little bay scallops versus sea scallops, I didn't see how these scallops could possibly be considered bigger than normal.) To rectify the matter, our server brought us not one, but two extra complimentary scallop dishes. Great recovery. This is the difference between four star service and five star service.
For mains, we opted for:
- Grilled octopus tentacle with cumin-lime yogurt, mango chutney, cilantro oil, masala basmati ($29)
- Pacific line-caught halibut with lemongrass broth, grano, radish, snap peas, pickled carrots, pumpkinseed pesto, braising greens ($30)
- Boneless barbecue pork loin with barbecue demi, cheddar grits, smoked rib, collards ($27)
Everything about each of the entrees was phenomenal. As for the octopus, I swore it was wrapped in pulled pork since it had a notable BBQ taste and since it appeared to be actually wrapped in pulled pork. Others in my party disagreed. As for the halibut, the portion size was appropriate and I really liked the inclusion of the grano, which was near-identical to barley. As for the pork, though delicious, I thought the meat was overseasoned. A naturally salty meat, the pork loin was a bit too salty for my taste and I'm by no means sensitive to salt. At any rate, I'm glad we specifically requested the temperature to be medium, otherwise it would have come out medium-well and been overdone. And other than those paranoid about trichinosis, who wants overdone pork?
Too full from having tasted six different dishes at this point, I didn't order anything for dessert, but I got to try a bite of three different ones, including the:
- Cherry cheesecake with filo wrapped black cherry filling, liquid cheesecake, toasted
pistachio, rocher gelato ($9)
- "Butter finger," peanut butter, white, milk & dark chocolate, graham cookie, chocolate anglaise ($9).
- Assorted gelato ($7)
As for the cheesecake, this was essentially deep-fried and not at all what I was expecting. Good, but just not my style. As for the "butter finger," this thing was richer than Bill Gates and about the same size as an actual Butterfinger candy bar. The only problem I had with it was the need for a hacksaw to cut into the fudge. As for the gelato, there's no way this was anything but sorbet.
Overall, the appetizer and main rounds left a more lasting impression on me than the desserts. The service, however, probably left the most lasting impression on me, which in my view, is 1/3 of the battle in the restaurant business. The ambience, however, could use more consistent music. At one point it was off, then came on. But if I walk away with my biggest complaint being lack of music, you, Gezellig, are well-deserving of the highest rating possible. read more