One of the most affordable liquor stores around. Pros: - You can find great deals on some of the most popular bottles of wine, whiskey, & tequila. - There are tastings pretty frequently to introduce some delicious spirits - They support some local businesses; we have to grab at least one bottle of Better Man Distillery's Lavender Gin every time we go Cons: - They don't sell mini bottles of any kind - They lack a bit of variety in the hard liquor section; I was looking for local moonshine which they said they don't carry as well as some of the newest trends like peanut butter whiskey Overall a great spot to grab some staples for the home. read more

I have been going to this store for years and I understand their no-return policy BUT I came home with a bottle of liquor that was not sealed shut. I brought it back the next day and they would not exchange it without a receipt. This was the first time I did not have a receipt but I did show it on my credit card ap. This was not sufficient. The manager had an attitude and said he would not take it back and if I wasn't happy he would be happy to drink some to show it was not tampered with! He said it SHOULD be fine. That is not good enough. VERY POOR CUSTOMER SERVICE. WILL NOT BE GOING BACK. read more

Great prices here. Went in yesterday for liquor for Christmas Day. Some bottles of liquor are $10 cheaper then a regular liquor store. Great wine selection too. You won't find everything but they have the staples. They have tastings often too. I enjoy trying new things before I purchase. Only downfall is the layout of the store. It's hard to maneuver your cart and get up and down the aisles. You make do though. I try not to go during peak time so I can browse easier. If you purchase cases they will carry to your car if you pull up after paying. read more

Hello liquor! Come let me buy you! This oddity is an extension of the Costco but requires no membership based on some law somewhere. Works for me. Snagged us a bottle of veuve cliquot rose for $49.99 and a Dom p for $154.90. Money saved on xmas gifts. Check. It can get a bit packed in this quaint little liquor store. There is a lot of vertical storage going on here (ikea would be proud) so keep your eyes ceiling bound for deals. The magnum bottles of wine can be a bit intimidating but are clearly a bargain. The 1.75L of jack Daniels is a must. Now I made the 20 minute drive here a few days before xmas expecting a zoo but they kept it orderly with a neat line of shoppers waiting for admission. I was kind of shocked to see they squeezed a tasting table in the corner. Didn't seem too efficient. Overall a great find. Can't wait to go back. read more

Ok ok I know I'm reviewing a liquor store but if I do say so myself... ITS A FREAKING AWESOME LIQUOR STORE!!! Cut to the chase... yeah it's attached to Costco & no you do not need a Costco membership to enter. But c'mon people it's 2014... everyone has a Costco membership these days! This liquor store as I previously stated is awesome. The prices are pretty darn good if I do say so myself. Service is usually right there asking if you need help and always happy to help. Even when I was here a couple of days before Christmas.. I had to wait outside for a minute or two because they were at full capacity but once inside I was in and out with my adult beverages. Also it's not huge but it's just the right size. Might I add super convenient because you can go to Costco get your bulk on and then head right next door and get your booze on or vice versa. Please wait until you arrive at home and unpack your bulk items and then enjoy your bevvies. So check it out. I promise you won't regret it. read more

Prices not that great! You have other better liquor stores that will match their price! Attitude of workers is absolutely awful!! Don't bring your kids because if they touch a bottle they will ask for your kids ID!! They will create such horrible scene! I have been a customer for years and buy a lot! read more

I overbought Fireball minis in a sealed bag. When I tried to return them, even just asking to exchange, I was told all sales final... only liquor store I ever heard of with this stupid policy. Last time I ever spend money there. read more

They are pretty well stocked and priced at this liquor store, always nice when I've been never had an issue, sorta sketchy area right there for some reason, but nothing crazy. read more

Best prices, can get very crowded holiday time... As other reviewers have said, they have the best prices because they buy in bulk. Merchandise moves fast and they always have specials. I took away one star because they sometimes don't have a big variety in certain hard liquors. They do have a large selection and variety of wines though, so it's worth the trip. They are right next to Costco, in the same building. read more

Love Love this place. It is adjacent to the Costco and its low prices (for the amount you receive) really puts this place on a different level than other liquor stores. It has a vast selection, really helpful staff who offer great suggestions and always has great specials and prices. If you sign up for their email list, they also let you know when they have tastings and sales. read more

Get that big shopping cart ready! They have some of the best discounted wines and hard liquer on LI! Opus One!!! Best price I have found. Anyone find better? I think this place has such good low cost wines they are turning me into an "alkie" 'just jokin' read more

Great variety and prices. My favorite spot to go to when need to refill my bar at home :)

IMO it should be dubbed Costco Liquors, since that's where it is...not Costco prices but not pricy, either. Decent selection and good service. read more

Best liquor store with the absolute best prices. I don't even buy from my local guys anymore because the prices at Holbrook Liquors are about $3-$6 less on everything in the store than other places. Even when the lines are long they move super fast because they have 2-3 registers open at a time. They have a great selection of everything. read more

Although the selection of wines is not too big, they have a good selection from all over the world and the prices are reasonable (better prices here than general prices online). Workers were friendly and very eager to help.. We came on a Monday and there was a small wine tasting of CA Chardonnay and Cabernet. read more

LOVE this place. Best prices around, great selection of both liquor and wine, and EXCELLENT, knowledgeable staff. Always very helpful, impressive wine suggestions. Can't go wrong here. But a warning to anyone who decides to come here to promote liquor through an outside vendor - a company called Think CMD will not only take over 6 months to pay you (after a lot of fighting), they will require you to spend money on their liquor, mixers and cups and take forever to reimburse you for that as well. read more

My favorite liquor store on Long Island. Spirits here are extremely cheaper than anywhere else nearby. Definitely worth a visit especially if you are stocking up for a party, holiday season, etc. They have a great selection of domestic and Long Island wines. They usually have samples on weekends. Staff is always happy to help and lines move quickly. read more

Was in town for an event and had to purchase the wine and liquor. Staff was extermely helpful and knowledgable. Great prices.

Absolutely cannot beat the prices here! The selection isn't always consistent so I recommend buying your favorite wines when you see them, until you get to know their more permanent selection. Highly recommend this place to anyone who likes a good deal on their wine and spirits! read more

Very broad selection of liquors. Very friendly staff. I have been going here for the past 10 years. recommended

best price always-when in stock-for my favorite tequila- Don Julio- in 1.75L , I

Monster selection with, BY FAR, the lowest prices around. I'm 2 towns over, but it is well worth the drive here for the savings. Don't be turned away if you see a large crowd - which is often - they have several registers and keep the line moving quickly. read more

The concept is exactly like Costco (buy in bulk and pass savings onto the customer). But it's technically not Costco and is completely separate. This is because supermarkets can't sell liquor in New York state. Personally, I think that for a small store this location does have a great selection and they ALWAYS have really good deals. read more